Toulmin Model

Great Essays
Pedagogical and instructional decisions are made using district curriculum maps that align with Common Core Standards. Bloom’s Taxonomy is referenced when crafting learning objectives and when structuring today’s lesson, which moves from a whole group discussion to small group collaborative learning, a theory by Kenneth Bruffee. The initial discussion is designed to increase comprehension of a text. This can be seen when students respond to questions about the plot (4:36), take notes (4:44), and annotate books (4:51). This lesson challenged students to use the Toulmin Model of Argumentation as they complete a graphic organizer to support claims, gather evidence, and develop warrants/analysis that assesses the guilt of specific characters. Collaborative …show more content…
Because several strategies and instructional approaches are used to master the content, students feel confident with the material and sharing ideas, which promotes speaking and listening skills (3:24). This is evident at 10:18 when one student mentioned an example in Chapter 7 and asked her group members a follow-up question. This conversation continued and at 10:59 two boys share evidence from the text, showing students examine this text from multiple perspectives. At the beginning of the period, finding evidence and applying it to a claim is modeled for them as we preview the assignment (2:24). Students are verbally encouraged to record page numbers on their graphic organizers before beginning the independent assignment (1:55, 4:36). During small group work, students used a common graphic organizer to record answers and demonstrate an understanding of major themes (6:11, 8:25). Students applied evidence from the text to claims, asked questions, and shared findings like when a student turns to another and identifies Tom’s motives for murdering Myrtle (5:51, 7:29). Starting with whole group (1:47) and moving to small group work allowed students to engage in rich conversations about the text (5:36). The class comes together to share claims, which reinforce engagement and understanding of …show more content…
Students were able to make specific references to evidence from the text and then apply these references to their claims (5:42). Claim statements will be used in tomorrow’s discussion and later in their papers to determine whether specific characters achieved happiness, success, and the American Dream, which is discussed at 12:44 and with the class at 13:55. Students were able to evaluate specific events from the text and determine the significance of them as they crafted their arguments and counterarguments for specific characters’ guilt or innocence of the manslaughter that occurs in Chapter 7 of The Great Gatsby. This can be seen when one student asks his group about evidence and another student provides him with page 120. Students were assigned characters and able to consider the evidence from multiple perspectives while developing support for claims, which is apparent at 11:48 when a group discusses their arguments. Today’s lesson will provide students with an understanding of how to craft a strong claim, substantiate a claim with evidence, and debate their positions, which is seen when a student finds a counterargument and relates it to his claim at 12:59. Students used listening and speaking skills to do this and will apply these skills to their writing and individual analysis of the characters in the text. Students will share

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Pt1420 Unit 4

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages

    • What evidence can a speaker use to support a claim? Learning Target(s) “I can statements” • I can summarize text in one or two sentences • I can use key points to summarize text . Essential Vocabulary Summary, key points, Resources and Materials Teacher Student Power Point Tone/Mood images Eleven (Holts Textbook) Activating Strategy/…

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    SEE-I: Toulmin Model

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The data is full of facts and important information. We base our argument off this information. Part two of the Toulmin Model is the claim. A statement that includes information that you involve into the argument and you ask the other side to accept. The third part of the Toulmin model is the warrant.…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1925 when F. Scott Fitzgerald first published the novel “The Great Gatsby” it sold a disappointing twenty one thousand copies. Today more than twenty five million copies of the have been sold world wide. Just like other American classics directors have taken their turn making timeless novels into major motion pictures. Forty nine years after the book was published Jack Clayton released the film “The Great Gatsby”. Now, American literature teachers are presented with the delim, weather or not watching the film would prove beneficial to students.…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Parallel Between F. Scott Fitzgerald and The Great Gatsby, a Coincidence? While researching texts and websites about Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald and his novel The Great Gatsby, it is noticed that there are parallels between Jay Gatsby and Fitzgerald’s life. Introducing enough background knowledge about Fitzgerald and The Great Gatsby will show the parallel between the authors and this fictional character. Information about the life of Fitzgerald; such as, early years, schooling, his wife, literature, and his death will show how he used his life experiences to make his writings come alive.…

    • 2291 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    REVELATIONS (2) 1. One event that I find to be important is when Gatsby avoids getting a ticket by the police by showing them a card from the police commissioner. This event gives us a better understanding of Gatsby’s character and power. He is evading the law by using his connections to a person in power, which shows that he is not afraid to use his power to break the law. It also shows how much power Gatsby truly has.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The classic American novel The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, contains one of the most complex story lines. It is a story of lying, cheating, and deception. In fact, if the novel was not explained in the first person point of view, the audience would have great difficulty discerning between falsehood and actuality. However, the realization of the amount of deceit displayed in the novel can also lead the audience to wonder about the integrity of the character relaying all the information, Nick. After analysis, it can be determined that the integrity of Nick does affect the reader’s understanding of events quite extensively because of his skirting of facts to suit his bias.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Fitzgerald’s novel climaxes and ultimately closes, there are numerous actions and events that take place: Tom’s discovery of Daisy and Gatsby’s affair as well as Gatsby’s business dealings, George’s discovery that his wife, Myrtle has a life outside of their marriage, the intense argument during the party at the Plaza, the death of Myrtle at the hands of Daisy who is behind the wheel of Gatsby’s car, and the death of Gatsby at the hands of George, who then kills himself. While these events are essential to the story itself, it is important to take note of Nick’s narration during the last third of the novel. During Chapter VII, the Buchanans, Gatsby, Nick, and Jordan have a party at the Plaza hotel, which quickly becomes as heated as the…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Epistemic and Axiological are two narratives amongst the four frequently used narratives. Although they both contribute to the story being told in The Great Gatsby, they possess a variety of differences regarding their specific contribution to the story. However, their differences blend together and help to achieve the author’s purpose for writing the story. Fitzgerald’s use of universal narrative technique achieves his purpose of discovering “Who is Gatsby?” by providing key flashbacks of Gatsby’s past, sharing Nick’s impression of Gatsby, and dichotomizing Nick and Gatsby. The Axiological narrative, which directly revolved around Gatsby, provided key flashbacks of Gatsby’s past.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Mr Hossack Observation

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I loved the way Mr. Hossack conducted this particular lesson because of the way the students took responsibility for their own learning! The way he guided them through a complex process was brilliant. Desired Results-- learning objectives: Mr. Hossack not only posted the class objectives on the board, he discussed them with the class and made sure they understood the vocabulary used in the objective as well as what learning outcome to expect. The students were clearly accustomed to discussing the objectives before beginning the activities. Assessment Evidence Mr. Hossack used both formal and informal methods of assessment.…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When reading The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, I was able to develop a greater cultural and contextual understand about the novel through hearing the interactive orals in class. Obtaining additional information on gangsters and the 1919 World Series, assisted my development of knowledge on the main character in the book, Gatsby. Through learning about prohibition, slang, and flappers I was able to achieve a greater understanding of the cultural and contextual aspects of the 1920s, the time period of the book, as well as acknowledging qualities of characters in the novel. Gangsters and additionally the world series played a huge part in the creation of Gatsby and the luxury surrounding his life.…

    • 172 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Dialogic Pedagogy

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Dialogic Pedagogy: Teaching the Grieving Process in the Classroom Essential Questions Does literature reflect different psychological aspects? Why should we read about grief and death? How can reading literature about the grieving process offer insight to our understanding? How does the grieving process relate to psychological criticism? How can readers use information in texts to provide a deeper understanding of the grieving process?…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The style of an author is something unique and creative to their person and their soul. The writing of F. Scott Fitzgerald is skilled, concise, and detailed. His novels are not only distinguishable by his incredible imagination but also his impressive articulation.…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The past and the present can often be at a constant struggle within individuals and lead to moral confusion and conflict with each other. As the past teaches one thing and the present another, the concept of right or wrong is broken and the idea that both must be embraced is not realized. The novel, The Great Gatsby, by F.Scott Fitzgerald, utilizes numerous elements and literary devices to portray many different themes and topics. Using these, he portrays the struggle between the past and the present. Specifically, Fitzgerald utilizes foreshadow to show us that certain events or conversations hold deeper meaning, relating a future event to a characters past and their struggle through their decisions.…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though the vast majority of people would prefer to deny it, one’s past changes our future or how it is perceived. As everyone has experienced at one point or another in our life, our past does not define our future, but it does affect it in a way. For example, in The Great Gatsby, Gatsby experiences several situations where his past affected his present and future gravely. In the beginning of the novel, although one perceives Gatsby as a mysterious rich character, the reader does not expect much depth to his character, at least not as much as there is in reality.…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Understanding The Great Gatsby is different for every reader according to the reader's-response theory. In this reflection I will examine how my critical reading, who the implied reader is, my past experiences, and the feminist lense have effect my interpretation of the novel. As a critical reader I have a read The Great Gatsby with an experiential approach. When I read a book, I start to envision the book almost like a movie, except I am the narrator.…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays