Analysis Of The Video 'The Trillion Dollar Question'

Improved Essays
Reparations for Slavery The video called “The Trillion Dollar Question’’ talked about African American activists who believe the government should pay reparations for slavery. They want the government to pay the African Americans monetary compensation for the many years of slavery of their ancestors. In the video these activists were being interviewed and they declared African Americans are still being discriminated against. Stating they receive fewer benefits than others because of their past. The author of “Black Activists Call Senate Slavery Apology ‘Useless’; Say It Will Empower the Call for Reparations,” writes about an apology made by the senate towards all African Americans due to their ancestors suffrage. The author writes about the activists’ points of view, which is that the government is trying to prolong the reparations process. They also stated the senate should have given the apology a long time ago, and not now. The author of “Even If Millions Rally on the Mall, Reparations Won’t Heal Black America,” disagrees with reparations being paid to African Americans. They state that monetary compensation will not fix what slaves went through. The author mentions that no one who went through slavery is alive, therefore there are no living people who were directly affected by slavery to pay reparations to. It is also logistically impossible to provide reparations to African Americans Because it would also not fix what the black community feels on the issue of slavery. The author of “The Reparations Pipe Dream and The Tax Cut Reality” also disagrees with paying reparations.Some people disagree on giving a tax cut. They disagree because people believe the tax cut would only help the wealthy and harm the welfare programs. However they agree on paying reparations but will have the same outcome. Welfare programs will be harmed due to the large amount of money activists want. I believe that it is not be a good idea to pay reparations. …show more content…
I believe that with no living former slaves any reparation payments would only serve to give current African Americans a stronger feeling of entitlement.I am inagreement with the article that it is logistically impossible to pay for reparations. If reparations are paid some welfare programs will be affected, therefore people who live with the help of welfare programs will be affected as well.Ultimately this would cause a negative outcome to happen. Lowering the taxes for people who have ancestors who were affected by slavery would be appropriate. However I do not think anyone should apologize because the government was not involved in slavery. The southern states allowed slavery because it was a major part of the economy. People from today are not at fault for their ancestors who may or may not have owned slaves. …show more content…
The government has worked to achieveequal rights for everyone. They have established EEOC laws (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission) for employment. These laws affect not only African Americans but members of all nationalities as well as sexual orientation. I do not believe present day African Americans suffer because of slavery.Every American has equal rights. African Americans have the same opportunities as others to become a successful personin life. The government issues grants specifically to people with a minority background for college. With these funds African Americans, and others, are able to better themselves and prepare for a successful future. No other groups have been enslaved in the United States but Japanese Americans were put in concentration camps because the government believed they were spies for the Japanese during World War II. More than two thousand Japanese Americans were arrested for disloyalty. They were also forced to close down their businesses, getting detained illegally and being fired them from their jobs. They then went to concentration camps where they did not have any of their belongings because they could only take what they could carry with them. In the camps they were able to work, but were paid very little. In March 1946 concentration camps were closed down. Some Japanese Americans returned to their homes, but their homes were destroyed (Japanese Americans in Concentration Camps). While the Japanese Americans went through many hardships during World War II, they however later on were granted reparations. The government sent out

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In his essay, “The Case for Reparations,” Ta-Nehisi Coates confronts the permeation of racial discrimination throughout American history and examines its lasting legacy in modern times. Using primary accounts and historical examples, Coates traces the influence of racism from the foundation of American democracy, through the Civil War era, the inception of Jim Crow laws, the Great Migration, and continuing to modern times despite continued U.S. governmental efforts to create policy that promotes equality and eradicates racial discrimination. Coates emphasizes the discrimination, racism, and hatred African Americans have faced throughout the various periods in American history, eventually concluding that the social, economic, and political…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article The Case for Reparations by Ta-Nehisi Coates stresses the idea that reparations for historical African American discrimination should not be pay in money, but through acknowledgement by the American people. Coates begins his article with four subtitles stating the total years of slavery, Jim Crow laws, “separate but equal” era, and racist housing policy and finishes with a hook declaring, “Until we reckon with our compounding debts, America will never be whole.” He concedes that the US will never be a united nation until its people accept all parts of its history. He then opens up his essay with Clyde Ross’ life story and his helping hand in forming the Contract Buyers League, which filed a public case for reparations against Chicago…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That brings up another question, which is who should have to pay the reparations? Todays White Americans cant be forced to pay for what their ancestors did. They had no take in the act of enslaving African Americans over a century ago. There are still many other questions other than that which are yet to be answered.…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Case for Reparations I do believe that America must answer to its moral debt to African Americans, Latinos, Native Americans and other groups of color that have suffered due to institutional racism. I think Ta-Nehisi Coates is not demanding that a certain sum of tax dollars is giving to the African American people, instead he argues that the idea of reparations it’s what’s important. It seems as if Americans are unaware of the history and the role that white supremacy and oppression has played. He argues that we need to begin by asking the question, what the nation might owe it’s black population after everything that’s been done to them.…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “The Case for Reparations”, Ta-Nehisi Coates sets forth a powerful argument that the United States must find a way to atone for past injustices against black Americans. Rather than asking for money or anything of the sort, Coates basically argues that it’s the idea of reparations that counts. He believes that such is necessary for Americans to come to terms with the injustices that occurred, partially due to the belief in white supremacy, and to go through a spiritual renewal of some sort. Through various techniques, Coates supports the claim that paying reparations is both paying a moral debt and acknowledging past injustices.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Black Loyalists

    • 1931 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Even when most Blacks were skilled at what they did such as carpentry and blacksmithing after the war, “blacks earned as much as half of what a white tradesman could expect…” With the exception of fishing, no matter what the Blacks did, they would always be of lesser value than anybody. Now that the Blacks received their lower pay and worked countless hours a week, many of them could not provide for their families with such little pay. This then relates back to selling themselves as indentured servants and working again for someone. Now in reality some black did in fact receive their freedom. For example, on December 14th, 1775, “the said [Cato Hamanday] has hereby his Excellency Sir Guy Carleton 's Permission to go to Nova Scotia, or wherever else he may think proper.”…

    • 1931 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Well known essayist and writer, Ta-Nehisi Coates, wrote an essay, “The Case for Reparations,” that was published in The Atlantic, in 2014, in which the essay describes the hardships the black race has gone through and is still are going through. Coates’ purpose is to inform his readers of the struggle the black race has gone through each day and show why there is a need for reparations. He creates a compassionate tone to lead his readers to fully understand what it is like to grow up black in America. In “The Case for Reparation’s,” Coates uses a mixture of tone, diction, and historical imagery to create the readers to want to know and understand the struggle of being a black American.…

    • 1507 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Foner believes the Constitution is not clear because if the slaves who are returned to the south it doesn’t say who should be held accountable. The Fugitive Slave Act troubled the free black people in the North causing many black people to run to Canada free themselves from slavery. This slave law was made to stop the south from breaking away and instead helped influence the civil war. The Compromise of 1850, allowed the Fugitive Slave law to be modified and allowed the slave trade to be put to an end in Washington D.C.…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his article, The Case for Reparations, Ta-Nehisi Coates insists that “until Americans reckon with their compounding moral debts, America will never be whole”. He writes that after four hundred thirty-five years of racial injustice towards the African American community, the American government owes them. The slavery and slave-like conditions people were put in is something The United States should and will be ashamed of until the end of time. The horrific experiences and tragedies people endured are something that will hopefully never happen again. To think of the innocent who were lynched, raped, assaulted, and found guilty of crimes that they did not commit could make anyone’s stomach turn.…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since there are no living slaves at the moment it would be impossible to compensate the people who had been mistreated. In addition why would we pay African Americans in general using the theory that what American had done to the slaves has held them back in any sort of way? Blaming the economic problems someone has today because of something that happened over a century and a half ago is just ridiculous. But let’s consider the fact we end up paying reparations for whatever reason. Say someone like Barack Obama, he is of a mixed heritage.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    African American people were so mistreated, abused, politically deprived and denied their rights as citizens, manipulated and brutalized back into slavery in order for business to profit. There were laws that were created and enforced to create convicted felons that were for the most part innocent, who could then be leased and sold to companies and landowners to be used for hard labor. The cost of attaining these workers was very little and it was economically in their best interest to work them to death without concern; they were easily and inexpensively replaced. These practices were justified according to the 13th Amendment to the United States Constitution (1865) which declared that: "Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted; shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    American Dream Dbq

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The establishment of slavery in the United States was used to boost the economy, the wealth of white Americans, and capitalize off of the free profit from the forced free labor of African slaves. When slavery was abolished after the civil war in 1865, America continued to oppress Black Americans through the limiting of socioeconomic opportunities to improve, the mass incarceration of Black men through the fabricated war on drugs, and the crippling conditions created to halt the advancement of the poor. With the premise of the American Dream being that anyone can come to America and take advantage of the opportunities to advance themselves, Black people in America have lived a completely different story. Black Americans, who did not choose to come to America, purposely have been socially, economically, and politically oppressed for as long as they have been in this country. As Black Americans were trying to increase their wealth, socioeconomic statuses, and educate themselves after being enslaved for years, the white America that oppressed them used discrimination as a tactic to prevent the majority of Black Americans from reaching the same level of success and socioeconomic stability.…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analytical Essay on the Emancipation Proclamation The United States of America has had an aggrieved history of slavery about African Americans. African Americans at this contemporary are descendants of Africans who were force from their homeland and brought here in the United States as slaves. During the United States slavery era, slaves were consider properties of their master. At the United States’ constitution convention, it was very much explicit and adhered to by the founding fathers by accounting 3/5 of black persons to be equivalent three persons, that which denigrated black people as human beings. The southern states of the United States were deeply interested in slavery because of their labor on the southern plantations.…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The things that African Americans, Native Americans, and Asian Americans have in common would have to be being an oppressed population in the United States. Each of these groups have been judge and mistreated. European Americans saw something each of these racial groups had and wanted it and knew in order to get what they wanted all they had to do was take it. African Americans started out as slaves they were seen as objects and not humans. European Americans treated African Americans as if they never matter as long as they did what they were told.…

    • 1261 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Black Panthers Party Rise and Local Influence It was the 1960’s in America and racial segregation was unbearable. Black people were being terrorize, brutalize and murder by the police in their communities. There were high depression levels of unemployment in the Black community, people of color lived in poverty where 40% of men that lived in the ghetto were paid less than 60 dollars per week. Making it impossible to support their families or bring up their children in dignity. Health care was expensive and people of color had less job opportunities and those who did not have a job could not afford health care.…

    • 1747 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays