The Lies Behind A Beautiful Mind

Great Essays
What Lies Behind a Beautiful Mind

The film industry has opened up new gates for mental illness in the past few years. Over time, society has grown as a whole with their acquired knowledge of mental illness. Through cinema, an audience can receive a better understanding of the attributes tied to the illness displayed. Silver Linings Playbook directed by David O. Russel, used a character with bi polar disorder, Pat Solatano, to show his life of living with this illness. He faced many difficulties and the audience watched Pat rebuild his life. Why did this trend begin? There is no real explanation of metal illness unless you have seen it first hand, the film industry has to recreate the stigma attached to mental illness and instead give a
…show more content…
The men that arrived there where not Soviets, they were from the psychiatric facility. Alicia becomes worried so she proceeds to the mail box where Nash has been mailing his reports only to find it is a broken mail box with all of his reports still remaining. Alicia confronts Nash about her findings where he then begins to look for the chip Parcher placed in his are, it is not there and he then believes that he has been hallucinating. John then learns Charles and Marcee are also illusions of his mind. He agrees to a series of painful insulin shots and won’t be released if he agreed to take antipsychotic medicine. But because of the side effects he experienced affected his relationship with his wife and his intellectual ability, Nash stopped taking the medicines and begins to relapse with his hallucinations. Alicia becomes aware of that John is bathing their infant son and he wanders off and she comes to find her baby in a bathtub full of water and John says Charles is watching him. Felicia then goes to call the psychiatric hospital and Parcher comes into the picture convincing John to kill his wife and after arguing with Parcher, John pushes …show more content…
Nash met a few good friends at Princeton, not one spoke of Charles or even talked about him and until the viewer became aware of Nash’s mental illness the connection was never made, they never knew of him. In relation when Nash met Marcee for the first time, she began to run around the pigeons, not one of the birds flew away as she was running through them. If the viewer is unaware of Marcee being a delusion they would never pick up on that scene. In relation when John was call to the Pentagon why was Parcher there? If this was a truth confidential meeting there would not be a “big brother” watching over. Also Parcher’s attire does not match with others are wearing at the Pentagon but because of his convincing personality John never question authority. The way this movie was scripted deceived the viewer. Seems leading up to the moment Johns reports are found the viewer is living in his world. Charles Marce and Parcher are seenin the viewer’s eyes just as John sees them. Due to this scrip,t making connection with this film is done

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The story takes off as John Nash, a Ph.D. Student at Princeton University, arrives as the co-recipient of the Carnegie Scholarship bent on finding a fresh equation that would stupefy the masses and fulfill his purpose of accomplishment. It is on his first arrival when his first Hallucinations begins to make himself apparent. Charles Herman, who in Johns' head is his roommate constantly reminds him of his basic needs for food, beer, society, and fun ultimately giving him companionship when he is lonely or incapable of coping with his body’s needs. The semester moves on, but Nash’s progress does not and after a great deal of time spent observing people, birds, and examining the work of others he found himself continually drowned in his own ideas…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On the other hand, when a mental illness is depicted in this outlandish way, the struggle of the person dealing with the mental illness is overshadowed by the comedy used to represent the disorder, and the behavior is more accurately related to a comedy act than it is to an actual representation of the disease. When the behaviors of people with mental disorders in film includes this type of nonsense, it is, unfortunately, perceived merely as bizarre behavior that is meant to be laughed…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    John Nash’s illness is presented in the film with visual hallucinations (Parcher, Charles, and Marcee), delusions (top secret code breaking in newspapers and magazines to uncover a Soviet operation), and paranoia (government officials following Nash). According to Halter, 2014, symptoms associated with Schizophrenia include Positive symptoms such as hallucinations, delusion, disorganized speech and bizarre behavior. Symptoms also include Negative symptoms which are blunted affect, poverty of thought, loss of motivation, and inability to experience pleasure. Nash exhibited several of both Negative and Positive symptoms of Schizophrenia, all which led to a decrease in his interpersonal relationships, ability to work, self- care abilities, social functioning, and quality of life (Halter, 2014). Nash experiences significant delusions in the film.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Addiction In Shameless

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages

    It has become a trend for screenwriters and movie producers to incorporate mental disorders throughout their works, whether it be for entertainment, thrill, or just to show society that their lives are not as screwed up as others. Coming across a movie or show with that incorporation is not a hard find; in fact, the majority of top cinematic works include some type of mental disorder. Some works, make the disorder apparent from the get-go, while others may make the viewer unaware until a turning point in the plot. Some mental disorders are portrayed as a part of every day life. The popular television show Shameless directed by a multitude of directors, including Mark Mylod, depicts many different kinds of mental disorders, the most persistent…

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The media has created a false stigma for those living with metal disorders, by regularly portraying characters with mental illness as problematic, uncontrollable and violent. Larger than life negative characters have been repeatedly displayed on the big screen with these stereotypical cliché behaviors, and used as the focal point, or “hero” of the movie. Silver Lining Playbook is not just another one of Hollywood’s inaccurate depictions of mental illness. However, discrepancies are inevitable when the story line plays a greater precedence over accuracy. Silver lining Playbook depicts the breaking point of a family unit, where a father and son struggle to accept the other, and a mother constantly seeks to find a resolution.…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There have been several example of movies that have provide a more compassionate view on mental illness and how anyone can be effected by mental illness such as depression or schizophrenia. There have been a couple of movies that have empathized with the ills of mental health such as A Beautiful Mind, Melancholy, while Disney’s movie Inside Out entertains us by having all of the emotions working together, as young Riley works thru her emotions on movie to San Francisco, but there are other movie that show a dark side of abnormal behavior or mental illness, movies such as The Talented Mr. Ripley or Silence of the Lambs, displays the mind of the sociopath or schizophrenia, these films portray the individuals as dangerous and unstable, with maniacal intentions. These two movies contribute to the publics stereotypes of the mentally ill, the movies present themselves as the true tell all of mental illness and how the mentally ill behave or respond.…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The film challenges social structures of young women coming of age and ideas about mental illness. Throughout the film, the lead female character fights to break stereotypes about being a young woman with a mental illness. Although, at the core, the film attempts to encompass women’s liberation, it perpetuates stereotypes of women who suffer from mental illness. Importantly, the film reinforces social stereotypes about mentally ill women behaving in hypersexual ways. The film, notably reports the lead characters promiscuous tendencies as one element of her mental illness.…

    • 1292 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The CMOP would state that Nash’s major issues come from his spirituality, not knowing what is real and what isn’t and not being able to make logical sense of his disorder. However, the PEOP would state the major issues come from components within his person and the environment around him. Nash began to suffer greatly when his cognitive, physiological, psychosocial, neurobehavioral, emotional, and spiritual factors became negatively impacted by his disorder. This in turn affected his interaction with the environment around him because he could no longer interact with his peers without his hallucinations appearing which caused him to stop going to work and school. Both models attempt to view a person holistically but focus on certain aspects of a person that may cause more harm if not treated or properly taken care of.…

    • 2010 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the Places Journal article “Landscape Is Our Sex”, writer David Heymann insists that designs informed by landscape and site do not equate to a building that is sympathetic to the landscape from which it was conceived. He also expresses his view that architects apply the ‘site as source’ rhetoric as means to deliver a convincing sales pitch, or to give licence to work within a preferred creative…

    • 69 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The lack of a diagnosis or treatment in Black Swan and, finally the dramatic, on-stage death of Nina brought to light the seriousness of a mental disorder that goes unrecognised and untreated. Black Swan was very effective in its cinematic illustration of the dark struggle of psychosis disorder; and through this it captured the attention of its audience and created a national conversation about mental…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The theory that dictates the premise of the movie is symbolic interactionism and the three components associated with that theory are: the social construct of reality, the stages of the mentally ill identity and the transition from civilian to mental health patient. The whole movie ties in the idea that our behaviors, personalities and actions feed off of the notion of what society deems or constructs to be normal or real. Society creates the stigma and our education of mental health comes from ideas that have been socially constructed and may not be true. Others interpretation of our opinions and actions are formed through their observation of our relationships and interactions but there are various factors to consider and not everyone should be evaluated the…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many studies show what personality traits can affect schizophrenia. John Forbes Nash Jr. showed an interesting personality trait that amplified his schizophrenic disorder. According to Capps (2004), his narcissism not only intensified his schizophrenia, but it helped in his recovery or repression of his schizophrenia. The movie, A Beautiful Mind, attempts to convey the life of Nash in a way that is understandable to all. The movie begins while he is in graduate school at Princeton University and it goes throughout his life, showing his falling in love with his wife, the birth of their first son, and his first admittance into a mental hospital.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Overall, Nash earns a privilege of teaching again and was honored to win the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economics for his revolutionary work on game theory. If I was to help Nash, I would certainly help being a therapist or a doctor. I think in order to help and really understand any type of disorder you would have to study a lot and have the knowledge to correctly assist a person with any type of disorder. If I was Nash’s friend I would not had the knowledge to help him, but I would try to find ways for example, finding the correct doctor or facility that helps with his mental disorders, encourage him to seek for help and most important try to understand his illness.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He meets Alicia, a student of his and eventual wife, when she approaches him about solving one of his problems that he posed in class. She asks him on a date, and that is the start of their romance. Fast forward some time again, and they eventually get married. One night following, Alicia and Nash’s marriage, Nash experiences the first massive delusion of his schizophrenia, which manifests as a high speed chase between Parcher and the Russians. In the hallucination, Parcher ends up killing the Russians.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He begins the long and never ending struggle of controlling these hallucinations without sacrificing the mind that makes him a brilliant mathematician. Nash is very clearly schizophrenic and displays many of the characteristic symptoms of the disease. One of the first scenes shows how his senses are heightened. When they are at the introductory luncheon at the middle, he follows the…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays