Meech Lake Accord Case Analysis

Great Essays
Ottawa’s efforts still did not lessen from Québec’s stubborn refusal. In 1987, PM Brian Mulroney attempted to accomplish Trudeau’s career-long wish: get Québec to sign the Constitution. These efforts took the name of the Meech Lake Accord. When Québec refused to sign the Constitution in 1981, it estranged itself from the Canadian “constitutional family”. During constitutional discussions, Québec made many proposals whose acceptance would have led to its addition to the Constitution. The accord recognized Québec as a distinct society within Canada. In order to become a law, the accord had to be ratified and Québec was one of the first to pass the resolution of approval. Saskatchewan and Alberta also ratified the Accord. Manitoba and New Brunswick created problems for the government by stating that they would need time to evaluate the agreement before passing it in their governments. …show more content…
Delays like this led to the failure of the Meech Lake Accord, but this did not end Mulroney’s determined fight to bring Québec into the Canadian constitutional family and still please all the other provinces. In 1992, he tried again. This time, it was the Charlottetown Accord through which the Prime Minister of Canada tried to get support for a new constitutional package. After several conferences, the English-speaking premiers, territorial leaders, Aboriginal leaders, and the Prime Minister agreed to the accord. The points of the accord were as follows: • “The Senate was to be reformed; senators were to be elected by proportional representation, and each province would have six seats. • Right to Aboriginal self-government was recognized. • Québec…would be recognized as a ‘distinct society’. • Provinces would gain power over tourism, forestry, housing, and culture. • Anglophones in Québec and Francophone communities outside of Québec would have their minority language rights protected. Canadians were asked to vote on the accord in a referendum. On October 26th, 1992, the majority of Canadians voted “NO”. It was doomed to the same fate as the one before it. Québec was given two chances to sign the Constitution and both of these efforts failed. The Charlottetown Accord was dead. On 15 June, 1991, a new federal political party was born with the name of Bloc Québecois. Initially, it started as a parliamentary movement after failure of the Meech Lake Accord. It consisted mainly of Québec MP’s who left the Conservatives and Liberals upon the failure of the Accord. Their objectives are to promote sovereignty and Québec interests in the House of Commons. In the 1995 referendum, to be discussed shortly, the Bloc Québecois played a significant role. They convinced Jacques Parizeau’s Parti Québecois to specify in the referendum question that a partnership offer would be made to the rest of Canada. The founder of Bloc Québecois, Lucien Bouchard, replaced Parizeau in the leadership of the “yes” campaign when it started facing difficulties. Bouchard was considered to be charismatic and reasonable, thus, …show more content…
It reappeared in 1995, but this time with more promising results. The ballot question was: “Do you agree that Québec should become sovereign, after having made a formal offer to Canada for a new economic and political partnership, within the scope of the bill respecting the future of Québec and the agreement signed on June 12, 1995?” There were many advantages to a “YES” vote. For instance, French language and culture would be maintained and money would be saved on maintaining two official languages (product labels, education, translations in parliament discussions, etc.). On the other hand, the disadvantages were that Québec would have to financially support itself and there would be many hardships for the people living in Québec who did not speak French. Premier Jacques Parizeau of the Parti Québecois led the referendum, fulfilling the promise he made when he was elected. Even though he worked very hard to promote his separatist views, the “NO” side was victorious by a narrow majority of 50.58%. Following the referendum, there was controversy relating to the counting of the ballots. There were complaints of spoiled ballots and the eligibility of voters along with other concerns. There seemed to be no end to Canada’s constitutional uncertainty. The day after the referendum, Jacques Parizeau resigned and was replaced by Bloc Québecois leader, Lucien Bouchard. Recently, when Bouchard was asked about

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Calder Case Summary

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Calder V. British Columbia Attorney General [1973] SCR 313 Calder case is a pacesetter for aboriginal jurisprudence in Canadian supreme court. It is the first to recognize that aboriginal title to land exist as a sui generis type of right in Canada at the time of time of the Royal Proclamation Order of 1763 and does not devolve from the colonial, Crown law, treaty or statute. The main issue for determination in this case was whether Crown authority lawfully extinguished the aboriginal title to the ancestral land occupied by the Nisga’a tribe that pre-existed at the time of the Royal Proclamation Order of 1763. The case was ended as a deadlock, the court split three to three in favor and against the appeal, while the seventh judge dismissed…

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The trial of Chief Oshkosh for the murder of Pawnee tribe member Okeguay due to a Menominee tradition of retaliation executions served less as an execution of justice and more as a drawn-out legal proceeding with no direct consequences and massive legal ramifications. This actual intention behind the trial becomes clear through the actions and statements of Judge James D. Doty. Baird records that upon his motion for final judgment in light of the conviction, “the Judge gave, at length, an opinion upon which facts states in the special verdict”. The Judge Doty proclaimed that “as the individual who had been killed by the accused was himself a Indian, and the accused was one of the nation amongst whom a custom existed, allowing the relation of…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The British laid siege on Quebec city and the British had finally conquered the capital but Montcalm's successor Chevalier de Lévis took command and fought the British and they laid siege but British ship came along and Chevalier de Lévis retreated to Montreal. The British troop attack Montreal but there was no reinforcement from the french so the french surrendered of the terms of their surrendered they gave up all their colonized land to Britain even New France. The British made the royal proclamation which made the french lose all its power and they had to live under British rule and there was no need to have the first nation as allies so they were treated…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    From 1933 to 1948 Newfoundlanders were faced with the possibility of joining the Confederation of Canada. Some historians speculate that Newfoundland was coerced into joining Canada by both Britain and Canada itself because of the financial issues that Newfoundland was facing at the time. Newfoundlanders were concerned about religion, education, and their children. Some Newfoundlanders were debating whether Britain could legally force them to join the Confederation. Newfoundlanders had both positive and negative reactions to the idea of joining Canada in 1948.…

    • 1889 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Maple syrup influences Canada. Similarly, Quebec influences Canada as well. To sum up, many politicians will use method to win whatever they want, but sometimes they may forget what do they citizens want. Some politicians want to get right for their people, but actually they win the benefit for themselves.…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the final minutes started approaching, the winning side seemed to be clear, however, the difference between the votes for yes compared to no would only differ by one percent. The referendum of 1995 would ask the citizens of Quebec if they wished for the province to claim national sovereignty and become a separate state, but however, with the condition of a political and…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Quebec has played a special role in French history of Canada. They spoke French in France, they feel that the way of living in France is still different from the North American mentality in Quebec. However, it doesn't mean that Quebec culture is exactly the different as the rest of Canada. I think it would be dangerous for them to do based on their history, traditionalism and their deep passion to do. Canada is at the reason why Quebec even existed.…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This movement later came to be known as the Quiet Revolution. After the election in 1962, the liberal party was chosen yet again to lead the province, this time with a different slogan, “Masters in our own house”. What they accomplish while in power was acquiring Quebec’s power source and turning it into a provincially owned power monopoly. Hydro-Quebec became one of the largest crown corporations in North America, further strengthening Quebec’s economy.…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Theorized system that produces outcomes through the interaction of a series of parts that transmit causal forces from X to Y” She concludes that the greatest mechanism is province building with a focus on immigration, with policies pushing provinces to see immigration as a resource and to embrace mobilization. Paquet builds her argument with provincial case studies, for instance Quebec’s 1991 Immigration Agreement, caused by Quebec’s nation building and mobilization which put pressure on the decentralization of the governments power of immigration. The agreement gave Quebec rights to a quasi-autonomous implementation of immigration policies, this unbalanced the pre-existing federal dominance and provincial avoidance by creating a situation where the government had to find a new way to interact with the provincial government. The government then extended similar offers to other provinces but few were interested, and after it was revealed that there would be no increase in funding to provinces there was no interest. Though the success from Quebec’s agreement meant that the federal government began to change its ideas on provincial involvement in immigration and integration, which led to the slow inclusion of provinces in immigration policy discussions therefore creating a type of provincial legitimacy in regards to immigration and integration…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    History Script: Since the early 17th century until the early 1900s, Aboriginal Peoples have signed treaties with the British and French, which the two countries then, turned into Canadians later on, after Confederation. Although, in the beginning, when the British first started to sign treaties with the Aboriginals, they wanted to encourage peace, yet, later on, the British and French looked at the treaties from a different perspective, then the Aboriginals and each country had different goals that they wanted to achieve from the treaties. Even though, the Aboriginals sacrificed a lot of their rights and freedom while signing the treaties, I strongly believe, each and every treaty that was signed with the Aboriginal Peoples was worthy and they were historically significant to Canadian history. In the early 17th century Aboriginal Peoples began to sign treaties with the French and British.…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Quebec has been viewed as an unique state compared to the rest of Canada for quite some time and by many individuals. Quebec 's separatist movement can be seen throughout Canadian history, from Justin Trudeau; the leader of the liberal party, saying ' ' Quebecers are better than the rest of Canada, because, you know, we’re Quebecers or whatever. ' ' during an interview, to the Quiet Revolution, Quebec views its self as its own country. It originally started with the Royal Proclamation of 1763, the first document that outlined how to govern the colony 's pre-Canada. It was unique wherein, the French lost New France to the English and yet, it protected the cultural integrity of what was to later become Quebec.…

    • 1360 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The new philosophy, called maître chez nous (masters in our house), was driven by desire for an equal partnership with English Canada. The most significant changes were that Québec became secular, the voting age was lowered from 21 to 18, the legal status of women was improved, the labour code was revised to provide protection for workers and unions, and a provincial pension plan was established for Quebecers (1964). The last change was a cause of discord between the French and the English because the latter participated in a federal pension plan and they wanted the French to do the same. The Quebecers chose to defy Ottawa in this and in many other ways as well. For instance, Québec formed its own embassies in other countries instead of being part of Canadian embassies.…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In 1978, the Canadian Government began to look to the North for economic expansion as a result of the vast resources of the North (Sinclair). The area is rich in gold and oil and the rest of the world also saw the economic potential in the North (Sinclair). In 1985, the United States of America began traveling through the Northwest Passage without the permission from Canada, lobbying the Northern waters to become international (Dickason and Newbigging 277). Canada saw the United States as a threat and acted swiftly to grant the Northerners their request for self-government. A political accord was signed by both parties in 1992 (Belanger, 222).…

    • 2048 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Quebec Sovereignty Essay

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages

    To the office of the Prime Minister, We are writing this paper to give you some advise your government on the appropriate way to handle the issue of Quebec sovereignty in response of the Parti Quebecois victory in the 1976 Quebec provincial election. The Parti Quebecois believes that Quebec is entitled to its own sovereignty, and favours holding a referendum to raise the issue of Quebec sovereignty. If Quebec votes to separate from Canada, this could greatly damage Canadian national unity and have a detrimental impact on our nations economy and social well-being. Canada must remain intact and united as one nation because Canada would face huge economic losses, and it is not certain that Quebec would be stable enough to survive on their…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Central to the separatist movement of the latter half of the twentieth century was the argument that Quebec needed to become an independent state in order to ensure the survival of the French language, uphold the integrity of Quebecois culture, and allow Quebec’s government to proficiently govern its own affairs. In the views of many, the fact that Quebec has managed to do these things in recent decades without sovereignty has diminished the need and legitimacy of calls for separation. In my opinion, these developments have indeed put to the lie the need for Quebec independence, for it is now apparent that independence is not a prerequisite of achieving these goals. That said, it does not necessarily put to the lie the legitimacy of independence, for the legitimacy of Quebec’s desire for independence is based on more than necessity alone. This essay will discuss how Quebec achieved each of the aforementioned feats without independence, in order…

    • 1725 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays