Long Island Pesticide Case Study

Improved Essays
In the late 1960s and early 1970s research came forward that pesticides were harming fish, birds, and man, and a growing concern for pollution. Pesticides were previously controlled solely for consumers and farmers under the 1947 the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide Act. The Long Island Spray Trial that went through a number of phases in order to end the spraying of DDT and Kerosene oil to eradicate moths in the northeast United States, gained national interest when it made it to the supreme court. The DDT and Kerosene fight was lost in Supreme Court but it gained public attention because of the mootness of the case and having the President’s son as a plaintiff, Archibald b. Roosevelt. Aerial spraying over the state did have …show more content…
The pesticide control act on 1972 was introduced to the House of Representatives on Sept. 16 1971. They define protection of health and environment as control over any “substantial adverse effects on environmental value while taking into account the public interest, including benefits from the use of the pesticide.” William Poage introduced the bill and it was reported to the agriculture committee in the house, which Representative Poage was Chairman of. The committee searched for a balance that was beneficial to the agriculture industry as well as consumers. They commented on the public health benefit of pesticides eradicating pest driven diseases, as well as the efficiency it produces. The committee changed the language in the bill, the benefit risk concept in the bill, removed the “use by permit” category, and over all enabled the EPA and the state to regulate overuse and misuse of …show more content…
Poage, who introduced the bill to the House of Representatives, was a democrat from Texas and the chairman of the Committee on agriculture. He focused on helping rural farmers from his district. He thought the bill is a good compromise between regulation and allowing farmers fair usage. The House bill he introduced and the committee regulations he was chairman for lean towards less strict use for pesticides, and taking into account the importance of these industries. He had clear political goals that favor agriculturists opposed to strict regulations. Agriculture lobbyists, farmers, and the Nixon administration wanted the bill to control pesticides by giving out permits to users. Agriculturists lobby for farmers claimed it would be too big of a burden for them to produce crops with limited use of pesticides. EPA and the EPA congressional affairs director Howard A Cohen thought the new amendments were a reasonable advancement. Howard A. Cohen thinks the EPA should “under no circumstances attack the pesticide bill as being to weak” because they don’t want to cause problems for the president in farm states. Howard A. Cohen was fired from his position with the EPA shortly after that statement. Senator Allen Ellender served as the chairman of agriculture and Forestry for the Senate and also thought pesticide use is needed for agriculture and in turn national security. He was a democrat from Louisiana and was concerned with the reduction in the cost of producing

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Outline About Parathion

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I. Introduction a. Background information parathion and use of pesticides in the 1950-1960s b. Information about the environmental movement that happened after the book was published THESIS: In the excerpt from Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, she states that the use of spraying pesticides is not worth the damage done because of the poison's widespread damage to nature and farmers' ignorance to the dangerous effects parathion has on humans and their worker's lives. II. Body Paragraph 1 a. Carson describes parathion's widespread danger by presenting much of wildlife that was killed as a result of spraying the poison's damage as innocent and describing other deaths as an attempt to change the audience's view to have sympathy for these unintended deaths that do…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The answer is simple because why would senators and house members go against an industry that is providing them the funding they need to stay in office. The government doesn't want to cut out unnatural farming because pesticides and agribusinesses indirectly bribe these important senators in the agriculture section by giving them money to help fund their campaign and have success in the industry. Why would they want to shut down…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I think the pro of using pesticides is of course that it allows less crops being lost to insects, which yields more food. So, pesticides allow us to produce more food, which in turn then cuts the overall cost of the food. The big con of using pesticides is what else are these chemical affecting and what they might be doing to our bodies. The run off water from the agricultural farms can contaminate our groundwater, and the video showed the results of the infertility issues of workers from their various pesticide exposure. My son did a social studies project a few years ago that showed how it is believed that pesticides called neonicotinoids which are applied to crops seeds are killing honeybees, which is causing less pollination and therefore…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rachel Carson, a scientist and writer of "Silent Spring". She was very criticized by Chemical and Agriculture Industries and called as "hysterical woman who is unqualified as a scientist". In addition, politicians such as Tom Coburn announced his intention to block a proposed bill to honor Carson, he called her book a junk science and blame Carson for the Malaria Epidemic worldwide. Her suggestion about the indiscriminate uses of pesticides destroying the life and the ecosystem as well, was title as "Absurd ".…

    • 165 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rachel Carson’s “Obligation to Endure” is a well informative piece about the hazardous effects implemented by the careless distribution of pesticides in an uneducated society. She exposes the dark side of these chemicals with an overall goal to raise awareness and regulate control of the substances by the government. The first goal of Rachel is to make the citizens, pesticide companies, and government aware of this serious threat. Her second goal is to not ban these insecticides, but to persuade a regulation on what amount is reasonable. Carson uses her own credibility, along with logic, and statistics to create a strong and successful argument.…

    • 104 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As Chapter 7 mentions, nothing can “get in the way of the man with the spray gun,” as evidenced by the recent slaughter of buffalo on the Great Plains or the even more recent crusade of pesticides. However, not all humans are willing to watch this happen, as evidenced by conservationists and environmental experts that condemn unnecessary losses. These supporters of the environment and the government are often at war trying to prove or disprove the destruction of our Earth through pesticides. The chapter goes on to cite specific examples of the destructive nature of pesticides, such as the suffering of Sheldon, Illinois and its battle against the Japanese Beetle. By 1961, about 131,000 acres of land had been chemically treated with dieldrin.…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This method was adopted to many other farms because of its success, and was seen a lot along the Hudson River. In chapter eleven, of The World Without Us, Weisman discusses how the pesticides that humans use today is actually very harmful to the environment. It has destroyed much of the land we live on and has taken a toll…

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rachel Carson’s “The Obligation to Endure’’, Silent Spring (1962), she mentions, continued use of chemical pesticides will erase mankind if they are continued to be unregulated. She explains how it took millions of years to adapt to changes on earth, but chemicals are doing drastic damage to the world faster than it can adapt. She has one purpose, to inform the public on how our use of chemicals can destroy our planet and us. She is trying to create a relationship with the public in order to increase the public’s knowledge, making the last longer and better. Rachel Carson argues about the use of chemical pesticides are having an extremely negative effect on the Earth and its inhabitants.…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Agriculture is one of the main cornerstones of American history, from the Native Americans, to the tobacco fields of Jamestown, to our modern day lives. The United States agriculture system has gone through many changes, but few have been as important as the introduction of the Agricultural Adjustment Act of the New Deal and the later reversal of the act that came in the 1970s under the hand of Earl Butz, which remains in place today. The Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA) was put in place in 1933 to “rescue farmers from the disastrous effects of growing too much food” (Ganzel, Pollan 49). Butz’s plan, on the other hand, reversed the AAA and worked to drive down prices and increase the output of farmers (Pollan 52). The policies had both advantages and disadvantages, but it seemed as if everyone one benefited, more or less, from both.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This book has taught me a lot about how dangerous pesticides can be if you used in excess, or used inappropriately, I believe this book also informed…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ddt Research Paper

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Cases of malaria fell from 400,000 in 1946 to virtually none in 1950. DDT is still used today in South America, Africa, and Asia for this purpose. And also the year it was banned was 1972.DDT also is highly toxic toward a wide variety of insects as a contact poison that apparently exerts its effect by disorganizing the nervous. The reason it was banned was because it was discovered to be dangerous to wildlife and the environment and they…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Silent Spring written by Rachel Carson was the spark to a great controversy over the use of pesticide ever since it was published in 1962. This novel was a great influence over the abuse of chemical insecticides and succeeded in banning some dangerous chemicals such as DDT from the United States. Even though Silent Spring chastised the use of these chemicals, Carson never intended that all of the pesticides should be banned, instead the use of them should be controlled to prevent harm to the ecosystem. “‘It is not my contention that chemical insecticides should never be used,” she wrote. “I do contend that we have put poisonous and biologically potent chemicals indiscriminately into the hands of persons largely or wholly ignorant of their potential for harm...…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After World War II (DDT)

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages

    During the use of DDT, after World War II, crop yields increased greatly in the United States and overseas. This is because the pesticide killed many of the insects that consumed the essential crops. Author Lillian Forman states, “After the war, DDT helped ensure that starving Europeans, not bugs, ate the crops that farmers were once more able to plant. When the chemical was made available to the American public, it was welcomed as a means of boosting agricultural production, suppressing pests, and protecting shade trees, orchards, and gardens” (Forman). Due to the increase in crop production, there was a greater abundance of crops available for the citizens of the countries that used DDT as a pesticide.…

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    The first chapters of Silent Spring revolve around the introduction of a plethora of chemicals many of which are pesticides in the current society. The book points out those new pesticides…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, “The Obligation To Endure” by Rachel Carson the author focused on explaining the consequences of human behavior. She explains how much harm we have done to our environment by the use of pesticides specifically referring to DDT, a pesticide that is not only poisonous to insects but to our Ecosystem as a whole. These pesticides instead of helping humanity they are having the opposite effect and are altering our nature. She could not be more accurate, pesticides tend to settle into our soil, from there they are transferred to our water supply creating a chain reaction, therefore contaminating wild life, plant life, and our water, etc. Therefore, regardless of some of the benefits that DDT can have, such as the ability to prevent…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays