Herskovits: The Ethical Definition Of Polygamous Culture

Improved Essays
Every culture has their own values and other cultures may view them as either good or bad. Each culture has different definitions of ethical concepts which is important to keep in mind when looking at polygamous and monogamous cultures. Every person is born into some form of culture. Having our culture being predetermined for us before we are even in this word, it shapes our views and beliefs. “We need to recognize “the validity of every set of norms for the people who have them” and respect other cultures” (Herskovits 1). Herskovits talks in depth about polygamy and monogamy. Polygamous people only know this form as marriage as the correct form. Based from their culture, it is their way of life and if one wants to carry their name on and have …show more content…
Some goods that come out of this type of lifestyle include: medical benefits, economic productiveness, the woman (wives) cooperate with one another, and all the children play together and get along. The children build an emotional bond with their half siblings. So by looking at the positives, it almost outweighs the negatives. Because in every culture there are always negative and positives so why when talking about polygamous does the human race focus on the negatives? When looking at the monogamous culture, we also notice the goods that come out of this, such as: marriage is constituted, the children have healthy relationships, and like before, we see the common good/benefit of economic productiveness and medical benefits. For both cultures, the medical benefits are brought up. For any culture and any woman who decides she wants to have children are told that spacing out when having children is “good” for your medical health. So even though we may not share all values and beliefs with different cultures, this is one item every woman and her spouse could agree to be …show more content…
For whatever reasons, he focuses on the point that one culture may believe that after death the souls of humans inhabit the bodies of cows. So you can most likely be eating your own grandma. Although this custom is different from someone else’s, they still may share the same values. They are just presented in different ways. Rachels mentions that this theory differs in our belief system and not values. We agree that we shouldn’t eat grandma; and we simply disagree about whether the cow can actually even be grandma. It is emphasized though that your values and beliefs work together to get your customs. For this example, one custom believes the human soul of grandma can be in a cow, so therefor, they do not eat cows. So their customs are what influence their beliefs as to if why they do or why they do not eat the cow also known to some as grandma. While another custom believes this not to be true (WHY). Rachels compares custom one as: eating cows= cows cannot be human and custom two states that: not eating cows= cows can actually be humans. But both customs value that eating human is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In polygamous culture, men typically have several wives and dozens of children, which makes for an extensive family tree. With several wives with differing personalities, there is bound to be problems and disagreements. According to The Meditteranean College of Social Sciences (2014), “the rivalry between the co- wives more often than not prove damaging to the children in polygamous families due to the pitting against each other and forcing to choose sides” (Thobejane, 2014, p.1059). While severe arguments do not occur in every polygamous family, or any family for that matter, they do happen. Polygamous children grow up with the value that they need to pick a side in order to be acceptable to society, which is not the truth.…

    • 344 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Polygamy Case

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Hodges, which states the right to freedom to marry, could be cited as a precedent for recognizing polygamous marriages. Writer Fredrik DeBoer argued the fact that in a polygamous marriage for instances in a regular two person marriage, a couple is called “husband” and “Wife”, but in a polygamous marriage you are replacing those words with “Spouse 1” and “Spouse 2”. I do agree with what cathy is saying because everyone was taught from young they would marry the opposite sex and had kids as it also states in the bible. She also had gotten a second opinion from the Slate columnist William Saletan he had argued that the key number is not ,two but one: “You commits to one person, and that person commits only to you”... The word “monogamy is derived from one not two”.…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article When Brothers Share a Wife Among Tibetans, the good life relegates many women to spinsterhood by Melvyn Goldstein states that many Tibetans follow their culture about brothers sharing the same wife. Two or more brothers sharing the same wife and have the same equal access to the wife is referred as fraternal polyandry (Goldstein 1). This type of marriage is basically arranged by parents with children. However, the Westerns do not see this as the right thing to do and they believe that this is structural violence because it harms them from preventing them from meeting their basic needs and therefore they also believe in structural relativism because they are judging them by their own personal perspective. Agency plays a part…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For my first presentation, I chose to go over polygamy courtship and marriage by Kiersten Warde. Polygamy varies from your typical relationship in that it is a marriage involving one man and multiple women, like stated in the presentation, polygamy in Greek translates to “often married”. While this practice is illegal in the United States, it is still practiced in other places around the world today. Although, even in places where polygamy is accepted the man is truly only married to his first wife, the others are only bonded spiritually. Having many children is important to this practice, it is believed that the more children a man fathers the closer he is to God, which is achieved by having multiple children with multiple wives.…

    • 1200 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Role Of Eve In Judaism

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages

    2. Eve is a very important figure for Judaism because she is the first women that was created. The Jewish understanding of her is slightly different than the Christian understanding, in that Jews do not see Eve as the source of original sin like Christians do. The negative and most common way of viewing Eve is that she is the cause of the fall of humanity and the expulsion of her and Adam from the perfect Garden of Eden is blamed on her. Many people see her as weak because she fell for the lies of the serpent.…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Ways We Lie Analysis

    • 1095 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In older times, men were allowed to have more than one wife. A lot of the times they had concubines or mistresses’. These same rules did not apply to women nor do they now in the future. Women were always expected to have just one man and remain faithful to him. Discussing male infidelity again, much of the time men are often praised for having more than one woman in today’s society.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nyimba Family Essay

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In a polygyny setting, it is one man to multiple women of whom are not related to each other usually. However, due to the lifestyle of the Nyimba, polyandry works best for them as the family’s inheritance is passed from brothers to brothers. Thus, ensuring the land and responsibilities to all the brothers of a family and their wife. In the instance of one particular…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With many parents in the equation, they all come from different backgrounds and offer different advice. Another benefit of polygamous relationships is the low rate of…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Of course, matrimonial ceremonies dutifully establish the convention rules between individuals involved, as the marriage, change in family dynamics and connections define the expected duties of men and women play in society. In Chinese culture, men have authority in the household, as An-Mei’s mother married a rich man “named Wu Tsing who already had a wife, two concubines and other bad children,” (35) The prominence of the male had of the household having several wives and children with these concubines and consorts while they had to remain faithful to him, establishes the privilege men have in several marriages and relationships while the women were just one of many to him. He is also free to take in as many wives and have as many children as he likes, going back and forth between them even though he has formed a marriage with each of them, reminding of his role in society as authoritative and domineering as an alpha…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Polygamy is considered taboo today just like same-sex marriage was several years ago, constantly being mocked about. Again I ask, is polygamy a serious problem today? All that comes out of polygamy are negatives especially toward the women in the families. You say that polygamous relationships offer kids a better support system. Giving kids more people to talk to when they have a problem.…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A marriage in African communities (including South Africa) was based on Polygamy and bridewealth. Polygamy is the custom of having more than one wife. Bridewealth is when the groom’s family gives the bride’s family livestock or some other form of wealth and in return the bride is to continue her productivity and bear children for her husband. Men typically go to work, and do what are considered “manly” duties around the home. (Women can have jobs but is not likely.)…

    • 1936 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    All throughout history people have been using polygamy to achieve our principal and most basic goal as a species: reproduction. Against the common belief, the word polygamy includes every kind of relations that involve more than one spouse, which includes the terms polygyny (many wives, one husband), polyandry (many husbands, one wife), and group marriages (many husbands and wives). Polygamy does not achieve perversion; polygamy is a way to connect with others and form special and unique bonds. Polygamy has been practiced all through history, in every continent, in every language, in every century, and in every culture, including modern times. Previous discoveries have shown that in ancient Greece, a civilization that lasted for thousands of years, a civilization considered one of the most important and distinguished ever, polygamy has been present in many ways.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Apart from polygamy being against my belief, I must insist that polygamy has more disadvantages than advantages. Those who do practice it do so for one reason or the other. Some, because their large farms that need a lot of manpower on; others, because they were the only children of their parents, and like my grandfather who ended up polygamous because of his fame and generosity to his society, he had wives as gifts. Most of the women were not enlightened like today and they saw it as a way of life then, and they coped quite well. I must say that there is a lot of preferential treatments in the family.…

    • 1379 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sexual Identity Reflection

    • 2228 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Completing the sexual intake, I noticed the shame that I have around certain sexual topics. I feel more comfortable answering the questions alone in a piece of paper than answering them to another person. If I were to answer these questions to another person, the validity of my answers would be questionable. I would refrain from mentioning or talking into depth about certain topics. This paper will reflect in my experience filling the sexual self-intake, my sexual identity exploration as I completed the intake, the cultural considerations that aroused during the intake, and the clinical considerations to improve as a therapist.…

    • 2228 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The dilemma presented in the textbook illustrates a case arguing over non-traditional forms of marriage, specifically, regarding the implications of allowing same-sex marriage. The question is; can one open up marriage relationships to other varieties of non-traditional forms of marriage such as gay marriage, and if so where do we draw the line, for example are polygamous relationships acceptable. In terms of ethical relativism, both personal and social relativism share the same notion when it comes to allowing non-traditional forms of marriage. As ethical relativism holds that there are no universally accepted ethical standards for individuals, there cannot be an objective standard that would be forced onto all of us.…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays