Compare And Contrast The Articles Of Confederation And The Virginia Plan

Improved Essays
James Madison, an American statesman and a political theorist, wrote the Virginia Plan in 1787.
The Virginia plan called for a strong central government with three branches known as executive, legislative, and judicial. The Virginia plan also called for a bicameral (two branches) congress. The bicameral Congress would have two houses (an upper and a lower house) and the two would meet separately and would have to agree upon a bill before it became a law. The two houses were known as the House of Representatives (elected by people) and Senate (elected by state legislature). House of Representatives and Senate were represented proportionally. Under the Virginia plan, the federal government would have power to lay taxes, raise revenue, and enforce
…show more content…
The New Jersey plan is the opposite of the Virginia plan and it was made to fix the faults in the Articles of Confederation. Unlike the Virginia plan, the New Jersey plan centered the federal government in a unicameral (one chamber) congress. The congress would be accountable for raising tariffs, negotiating with foreign powers, settlement of territories, and making war and peace. The New Jersey plan proposed that the seats in the congress would be represented equally among the states. So, smaller states such as New Jersey, New York, and Delaware benefited from the New Jersey plan because they had equal representation as larger states. The New Jersey plan also had the three branches known as the legislative, executive and judicial. The New Jersey plan preferred giving states the control over the federal government rather than the people. The New Jersey plan believed that the states should have more power than the National government. Under the New Jersey plan, the legislature had powers to make, change or revoke laws. The problem with the New Jersey plan was that it was not democratic enough. Smaller states could outvote larger states and the federal congress could heavily tax the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The lower house were picked by the people. The 2nd plan was the New Jersey Plan it was introduced by William Patterson and this plan helped the smaller states. This plan also had 3 branches the Executive, Legislative, and Judicial branches but…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Virginia Plan weakened this state powers and empower the Congress, maintaining the harmony of the nation and push the political system to upper level. In the paper of “New Jersey Plan” by Levy, Leonard W, William…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Virginia plan provided that the congress should compromised by two houses and the representation would be based on the population of states. However, New Jersey plan called for the equal representation. Finally, the government with three separate branches and two houses was included…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At a time when the nation was struggling to repay itʻs war debts as well as re-establishing itʻs trade market, the restrictions the Articles placed on itʻs governing body, impacted 3 vital areas of the economy: trade, currency, and taxes. Under the Articles of Confederation, the Continental Congress had no ability to regulate trade, except with Native Americans, as long as they did not impinge upon a stateʻs interests. Although Congress could negotiate treaties with foreign countries, which the states could not do, they could in no way influence trade deals, foreign or domestic. This led to each state having their own system of trade policies. (Brackemyre, n.d.)…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The New Jersey Plan Essay

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1) What type of representation did the New Jersey Plan call for? The type of representation the New Jersey Plan call for is the “equal representation” where even though the population of each states are different, they will still have the same number of representatives for their state. A federal government with only one legislative body which was based on the idea of equal representation that is having two senators despite the size of the state and its population. 2)…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He also suggested the idea of checks and balances. This is a great tool to use in America’s kind of government because it means no one section of government could become more powerful than the other, the government stays true to the equality values, and it avoids possible corruption. Madison also presented the Virginia Plan which recommended using three branches in our government, a legislative branch, an executive branch, and a judicial branch. This plan is now used as the basis of today’s…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    population that any attempt at disagreeing was pointless. Although initially reluctant, Washington eventually caved to the idea and participated in the Constitutional Convention. With Washington, the American epitome of a man, endorsing the convention, no state dared to miss it. Madison arrived in Philadelphia 3 weeks before the intended start date, intending to spend the preluding weeks preparing for the Convention.…

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This would give states representation based on proportionate population. They also considered the New Jersey Plan. This plan proposed a single house legislative where any state, regardless of size, would have the same representation. John P. Roche puts forth his thoughts that the founding Fathers were…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, the distribution of representation from the Virginia and New Jersey Plan widely differed. The Virginia Plan was highly represented by the more populous states within the federal government and the New Jersey Plan seemed to provide most of their representation through smaller states who wanted to prevent unbalancing the United…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Pros And Cons Of The New Constitution

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited

    Small states were in favour of New Jersey Plan, under which all states would have equal representation in the legislature. On the other hand, large states advocate the Virginia Plan to form a Bicameral (two-house) legislature in which representatives would be appointed according to population. The Great Compromise between the states gave rise to a bicameral Congress in which states were given equal representation in the Senate and proportional representation in the House of Representatives. Roger Sherman played a decisive role in success of Philadelphia Convention. He is remembered as the architect of the Connecticut Compromise.…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1787, the delegates to the Constitutional Convention meant to revise the Articles of Confederation. Instead they began a compromise to form a constitution. James Madison from Virginia proposed a plan that called for a three branch government: legislative, judicial, and executive. This was meant to separate the powers, assuring that not one group or individual could have too much authority. In this plan was also a system that allowed each branch to check the other.…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Edmund Randolph of Virginia proposed the number of representatives for a state would be determined by the population and the amount of finances the state provides the federal government. This became known as the Virginia plan. The smaller state opposed the Virginia plan feeling they would be under represented and taken over by the larger states. William Paterson purposed a new plan, referred to as the New Jersey plan, suggesting each state would have equal representation regardless of size. Both sides found it hard to find compromise.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the first issues that was faced in the convention was how the states would represented in the legislature. James Madison drafted the Virginia Plan as a proposal to address this. The Virginia Plan was put before the convention by Edmund Randolph and proposed the government to be made into three different branches: legislative, executive, and judicial. Of these branches, the people would vote in the members of the two legislative branches, and then the cabinet members of the legislative branches…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The author of the book A Brilliant Solution, Carol Berkin, a successful American historian that was born in 1942 in Alabama and was awarded the Bancroft Dissertation Award, from her college at Columbia University where she was awarded and an M.A. and a Ph.D. He has written many books In her book, she summarizes the key elements in the creation of our current government and constitution. She goes into detail factoring in people's beliefs and views to help generalize an individual's standpoint on an issue. In the book, Ms. Berkin is trying to argue that the creation of the constitution was not an easy process but was very tedious work. The book A Brilliant Solution is divided into many chapters but its best summarized in the parts starting…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays