Adolescent Sexuality In Not Under My Roof By Amy Schalet

Superior Essays
The social view on adolescent sexuality varies across cultures, societies, communities, and families. It is a controversial topic because some individuals perceive sexuality as an important development of a teenager’s gender and identity, while others are opposed to the sexual interaction of adolescence. In the book Not Under My Roof, Amy Schalet demonstrates that in the Netherlands, society provides information and support about sexuality to teenagers. The normalization of sexual behavior in the Netherlands has allowed teenagers to develop a greater control over their sexual desires. In contrast, America’s perspective of adolescent sexuality makes the experience unenjoyable to young adults. The affiliation of sexual behavior with reciprocal …show more content…
“Part of the opposition to and discomfort with, adolescent sexuality is its association with high prevalence of unintended consequences, such as pregnancy, and sexually transmitted diseases” (Schalet, Pg. 4). Society belief that discussions about sexuality could affect teenager perspective on sexual activity. Instead, American adolescences would benefit from the acceptance of open discourse related to sexuality. According to Schalet, in the Netherlands a new perspective of sex has concluded in an increase in teenagers’ self-esteem and prevention of unintended consequences. In America the stigmatization of sex has discarded the open discussion of sexuality, gender and identity because of religion, upbringing, and institutional norms, which have implemented codes of conducts in society. Consequently, teenagers are prone to more risks because of their lack of sexual support and education. In the Netherlands there was ideological shift about adolescence sexuality. Schalet says that “adolescent sexuality has been considered a common part of growing up and experimenting. It’s discussible with adults in families, schools, and health care clinics.” (Schalet, Pg. 5). Such sexual revolution occurred because of a united contribution among religion, media, government, and policy makers. The normalization of sexual …show more content…
According to an excerpted quote from Talbot’s article, “even though young children are making that decision to become pregnant, they’ve also decided to take responsibility for their actions and decided to follow up with that and get married and raise this child”(Talbot, 2008). Pregnancy is a common situation in conservative Christian families. The pregnancy of the Republican candidate for Vice-President, Sarah Palin, struck the nation by surprise. However, the reaction from the “blue states” and “red states” demonstrates an unpredictable response. Blue states support sex education and are not against sexual intercourse before marriage, although these states seem to regard “a teen-age daughter’s pregnancy as devastating news” (Talbot, 2008). While the red states are untroubled by a teenager’s pregnancy “as long as she doesn’t choose to have an abortion” (Talbot, 2008), even though these states encourage abstinence. According to Talbot, Mark Regnerus, a sociologist and researcher at the University of Texas at Austin, explains that pregnancy is more acceptable by religious institutions because religion establishes different attitudes towards sex and pregnancy. Religions regards pregnancy as a gift from God, as a result pregnant teenagers tend to keep the baby and are more included into the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Deborah Tolman Summary

    • 371 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Deborah L. Tolman does an excellent job at examining three adolescent girls, each with distinct sexual preferences, discussing their individual experiences in regards to sexuality. Using Rochelle, Megan and Melissa, I will explain the struggles and strategies in regards to belonging and value within society. In the case of Rochelle, an African American, heterosexual, she claimed her sexuality is shaped, silenced, denigrated, and possible in relationships with young men. (Tolman, 101) Being a sophomore puts pressure on adolescent girls, as it stresses the need to be in a relationship, as well as become eager for sexual relationships.…

    • 371 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the short story, “Parents’ Night” by Barry Height, the main character, Karen, has to face the wrath of the conservative people around her because of one reason, her sexuality. Dealing with ignorant brats makes her even more anxious to deal with her parents reaction. Will they try to change her? Under circumstances, people rise from the dark to become powerful because of their new found confidence.…

    • 67 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abstinence v. Comprehensive An Analysis of the Respective Results Sex education has always been a controversial topic, especially to which it is taught. The Reagan administration passed the Adolescent Family Life Act for abstinence-only education, based on the presumption that talking about sex in school would promote sexual activities among teenagers. The President quietly passed the two-point act 1981, as the House of Representatives did not vote on it.…

    • 2328 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From a very young age we are taught the “sexual scripts” (pg. 313) that we are expected to follow and this largely dictates how we feel we should conduct our intimate relationships. Sexual scripts in many societies are largely “heteropatriarcical” meaning they are based on a system of heterosexual male dominance (pg. 354). Tight control over what is sexually acceptable can be harmful for the development of healthy intimate relationships especially for those who do not fall within the traditional heterosexual gender binary. A young American female receives mixed messages about her sexuality every day. In her article The Cult of Virginity author Jessica Valenti says that, “present-day American society- whether through pop culture, religion, or institutions –conflates sexuality and morality constantly” (pg. 336).…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Parents of teens often are faced with challenges during the developmental years of adolescences. One of the biggest challenges parents face during this time is sexual education. It is no surprise that the controversy surrounding sexual education still exists in today’s society. Some argue that children should acquire some form of sexual education in schools just as they do with other subjects. Recently President Barrack Obama cut all funding for abstinence-only sexual education curriculum due to studies finding them to be ineffective (Trehold et.…

    • 212 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At a young age media is exposing to sex in America; it is all over commercials, movies and social media. It is very hard to avoid and in a sense, it is a normal part of life but what age is too young to learn about sex? What should schools teach teens and who’s responsibility is it to teach the younger generations? Although there are many Americans who believe schools should teach some form of sex or sexuality education, there still are many who oppose it. (Source) Thesis: Knowledge of health and sexuality can help teens make better decisions when it comes to their sexual health and body which will lead to lowering teen pregnancy and STI rates as well as clearing misconceptions that are detrimental to student’s health, therefore all schools, private or public, should make teaching comprehensive sexual education a requirement in the United…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most women or girls who have sexual intercourse use contraceptives and still become pregnant due to malfunctions. About 85% of women who resort to abortion are not married, nevertheless, 51% of those women used the contraceptive method when they became pregnant. Moreover, only 8% of women who are sexually active have never used a form of birth control (U.S. Abortion Statistics). The reasons for these women not to keep their unborn child were: the child would interfere with school or work, they would not be able to afford the child, or they did not want to be a single parent (U.S. Abortion Statistics). Girls who become pregnant at an early age and most, if not all, of these reasons apply to them turn to abortion as a reasonable solution.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “ Teenage sex in America” Tennage sexual behavior are issues of concern in the world .In a society like the United states where the subject of sex is considerate as taboo in many families, Amy Schalet in her essay "the sleepover question" claims that parents should communicate more about sex to their kids, she suggest that it is still possible for families to stay connected when teenagers start having sex. While, many people agree with her that a better communication between parents and teens is necessary for a better understanding of sexual intercourse , others suggest like Joy Walker in his study “Parents and sex education-looking beyond the bird and the bees” that sex education from parents matter but, it is also important that the media, the schools get involved and play their roles to solve the problem of tennage sex and the consequences. Thus, a breakdown of Amy Schalet text is indispensable .How Amy Schalet introduces and establish her claim , how she appeals to her audience will be subject of examination in the following paragraphs.…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stanger-Hall, K. F., & Hall, D. W. (2011). Abstinence-Only Education and Teen Pregnancy Rates: Why We Need Comprehensive Sex Education in the U.S. PLoS ONE, 6(10). Principle Findings In this journal article, the author’s main goal is to analyze the effectiveness of abstinence-only education versus comprehensive sex education. The US ranks number one among developed nations in teen pregnancy and the rate of sexually transmitted diseases despite the US having similar cultural and socioeconomic patterns in teen pregnancy rates as other countries.…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Among the many myths out there on sex are oral sex and STDs, the pull-out method, sex on your period, not getting pregnant on your first sexual encounter, and the famous “everyone is doing it”. Our society has become more open to sex – as seen on TV, movies, and advertising. However, that does not mean teens are doing it more. Per MaryJo…

    • 1025 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this study it indicates how little things in life could bring about an impact of hazardous practices throughout your life in case you 're not cautious. As a child develops to being a youthful grown-up, their parents begin to play a vital part in their lives. In the article The Role of Parents in Early Adolescent Sexual Risk-Taking Behaviors show variables included were mother and father approval of premarital sex, guardian adolescent communication about sexuality, and parental social support (Bersamin et al. 2008). While scanning through articles I also discovered how distinctive religions could predict hazardous sex conduct. This study is mostly the greater part of the impacts of hazardous sex practices originate from homosexual men.…

    • 1622 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Teenagers are not exactly known for their restraint and maturity. It is no surprise that parents do not want their kids to have the kind of accountability that comes with being sexually active. In a survey done by the CDC (Center for Disease Control and Prevention), fewer than half of high schools and only…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The topic of sexual education has been one of debate for an extended amount of time, with opinions varying from accepting the idea of educating children on sexual topics, to the opposite.. Regardless of which opinions mattered more, there has undoubtedly been major societal changes in the views of sexual education, as well as opinions on what parents should consider “appropriate” for children; the Ontario sexual education curriculum has altered its way of educating, choosing to promote knowledge and acceptance of many human factors- including sexuality. Seeing as the sexual education curriculum had not had any major changes since 1998 (The Canadian Press, 2015), a plethora of updates can be seen throughout the curriculum. With this change,…

    • 1676 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author indicates that globally, teens are making up a high percent of the population. Sommer & Mmari (2015) assert, “In spite of the fact that youths have one of the most reduced rates of mortality internationally, various negative sexual and regenerative wellbeing results, for example, early pregnancy and contamination with HIV/AIDS and other sexually transmitted diseases (STIs), keep on threatening the wellbeing and prosperity of young people more than whatever other age bunch”. The author supports the main thesis through two case studies. Both case studies addresses structural and environmental influences and interventions. The key lesson is that one pathway is not a solution to adolescent sexual and reproductive health.…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sexual Education has been encouraged to be a part of public school education since the late 1800’s. It is a program that is supposed to help young adolescents understand their body, promote abstinence, types of contraception, the risks of engaging in sexual activities, and how to prevent diseases or pregnancy. However, many parents fight this program because of their beliefs that teens should stay abstinent till marriage, and learning about sex will increase their urge to have sex. Depending on what the state requires to be taught and what a school district wants, a student will either receive one of the two styles of sexual education. The two styles are comprehensive and abstinence only.…

    • 1798 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays