Use LEFT and RIGHT arrow keys to navigate between flashcards;
Use UP and DOWN arrow keys to flip the card;
H to show hint;
A reads text to speech;
43 Cards in this Set
- Front
- Back
Categories of character evidence
|
1. witness's propensity to lie 608(b) & 609
2. conduct by propensity 404(a) and 405(a) 3. character or reputation as elements 405(b) 4. other acts for non propensity purposes 404(b) |
|
Rule 405(b)
|
Proof of character or reputation as elements
|
|
Rule 405(b) stmt.
|
when a person's character or character trait is an essential element of a charge, claim or defense, the cahracter or trait may ALSO be proved by relevant specific instances of the person's conduct.
|
|
When is rule 405(b) available in a criminal case?
|
almost never, except for entrapment, where defendant must prove that she lacked a predisposition to commit the crime.
|
|
when is rule 405(b) available in a civil case?
|
defamation, negligent entrustment, child custody, amount of damages (loss of consortium, lost wages, pain suffering in wrongful death cases)
|
|
Proof of conduct by propensity uses which rules?
|
404(a) and 405(a)
|
|
Rule 404(a) Stmt
|
Generally, unless the D opens the door, 404(a) prohibits propensity type evidence.
|
|
evidence of a person's character or character trait is...
|
not admissible to prove that on a particular occasion the person acted in accordance with the character trait. 404(a)
|
|
Exceptions under rule 404(a)Defendant or victim in a criminal case
|
A DEFENDANT may offer evidence of the defendant's pertinent trait, and if the evidence is admitted the PROSECUTOR may offer evidence to REBUT it.
|
|
Rule 404 Title
|
Character Evidence; Crimes or Other Acts
|
|
Prohibited use of character evidence is?
|
not admissible to prove that on a particular occassion the person acted in accordance with that character or trait
|
|
Exceptions to the use of character evidence (criminial cases) #1 - defendants trait
|
defendant may offer evidence of the defendant's pertinent trait
|
|
if admitted
|
the prosecutor may offer evidence in rebuttal 404(a)(2)(A)
|
|
Exceptions to the use of character evidence (criminial cases) #2 Victims trait
|
a defendant may offer evidence of an alleged VICTIM's pertient trait
|
|
(i) offer evidence to rebut it
|
AND
|
|
Exceptions to the use of character evidence (criminial cases) #3 Homocide case
|
the prosecutor may offer evidence of alleged victims of peacefulness to rebut that the victim was the first aggressor.
|
|
Exceptions to the use of character evidence (witnesses character) #4
|
evidence of a witnesses character may be admitted under rules 607
|
|
Rule 404(b) Title
|
Crimes
|
|
prohibited uses under 404(b)(1)
|
evidence of a crime
|
|
permitted uses under 404(b)(2)
|
evidence may be admissible for another purpose such as:
|
|
to use evidence under 404(b)(2) you must? (2 things)
|
provide reasonable notice of the evidence the prosecutor intends to use AND
|
|
do so before trial
|
or during trial if the court excuses lack ot pretrial notice.
|
|
Rule for methods of proving character is?
|
Rule 405
|
|
Rule 405 Title
|
Methods of proving character
|
|
405(a)
|
By reputation or opinion- when character evidence is admissible...it may be proved by testimony about the person's reputation or by testimony in the form of an opinion.
|
|
405(b)
|
By specific instances of conduct- when a person's character or character trait is an ESSENTIAL ELEMENT OF A CHARGE
|
|
If defendant introduces evidence of his own good character...
|
then the prosecutor can introduce evidence of the defendant's bad character for the same character trait.
|
|
If defendant introduces evidence of the victim's bad character...
|
then the prosecutor can introduce evidence of the victim's good character for the same character trait AND introduce evidence of the defendant's bad character for the same character trait
|
|
If defendant introduces evidence that the victim in a homocide case was the first aggressor
|
then the prosecutor can introduce evidence of the victim's peaceful character.
|
|
406 Title
|
Habit; Routine Practice
|
|
406
|
evidence of a person's habit or an organizations routine practice may be admitted to prove that on that a particular occasion the person or organization acted in accordance with the habit or routine practice.
|
|
Rule 405(a) when evidence of a person's character or character trait is admissible, it may be proved by...
|
1. testimony about the person's REPUTATION or by testimony in the form of an OPINION.
|
|
On cross examination of a character witness, the court may allow...
|
an inquiry into RELEVANT specific instances of the person's conduct &* there must be a good faith belief that the specific instances occured.
|
|
Rule 404(b) Title
|
Proof of other acts for NON-PROPENSITY purposes
|
|
Rule 404(b) stmt.
|
evidence of a crime, wrong or other act is NOT admissible to prove a person's character in order to show that on a particular occasion the person acted in accordance with the character or trait. BUT, evidence of a crime or wrong, or other act is admissible FOR ANOTHER PURPOSE.
|
|
Other purposes under 404(b) are..
|
1. motive
2. opporutnity 3. INTENT 4. preparation 5. plan 6. knowledge 7. IDENTITY 8. absence of mistake 9. lack of accident |
|
other purpose 404(b) - motive example.
|
offer of proof that defendant's accumulated tax liablities as motive to burn his warehouse for insurance proceeds
|
|
other purpose 404(b) - opportunity example.
|
evidence that the defendant had access to a protected place or to special tools
|
|
other purpose 404(b) - intent example.
|
1. look for similarities in the between the crime charged and prior crime. AND
2. courts construe this broadly, often allowing evidence in, especially in drug cases |
|
other purpose 404(b) - knowledge example.
|
evidence of another crime that suggests defendant possessed knowledge of a particular fact that is an element of the crime charged
|
|
other purpose 404(b) - Identity example.
|
striking similarity doctrine: prosecution may offer evidence of other crimes by the defendnat that are virtually identical to the crime charged, and so distinctive/sophisticated/unusual to be almost like a SIGNATURE
|
|
other purpose 404(b) - lack of accident example.
|
Doctrine of chances: the chance of this/all of these things happening is very minimal ex. age discrimination cases where all people over a certain age were fired, child abuse cases wehre a parent repeatedly brought her child to the hospital with injuries
|
|
Proceedure for intoducing other acts for a non-propensity purpose
|
1. indentify a non-propensity purpose for the evidence.
2. establish that the other act actually occured 3. balance under rule 403 4. judge must give a LIMITING INSTRUCTION of the evidence is admitted. 5. On request by the defendant in a CRIMINAL CASE, the prosecutor MUST: 1. provide reasonable notice of the general nature of any such evidence that the prosecutor intends to offer at trial AND 2. do so before trial - or during trail if for good cause, excuses the lack of pretrail notice. |