Peter Orner Illegal Immigration Analysis

Superior Essays
Peter Orner 's documentation of undocumented immigrants aims to validate the implications that the lives of these undocumented workers have had their basic human rights violated in some way. In Olga 's telling of her story about her daughter, Victoria experienced countless violations to her basic human rights while she was held in prison. As she was horribly subjected to inhumane treatment, her story now serves as a testament to the prison system, that any transgender person will not be subjected to the same treatment that Victoria faced. As a human, no one should be treated inhumanely, or denied any rights due to gender, citizenship, or even as a person who violated the law. Victoria is not a criminal and did not deserve to be treated or denied …show more content…
Vica had gotten booked and detained and sent to the county jail for failing to show up at her court hearing. She then wrote her mother and told her, that Immigration has come to see her, to detain her. She then transferred to the San Pedro Detention Center. Olga was dismayed by the whole turn of events. She was so worried about her daughter, and would send her as much money as she could. Vica’s main priority was to get her AIDS medicine for her treatment. “When Vica called me, she would tell me they treated her and the other transgender detainees very badly…. And she would call and tell me they wouldn’t give her medical care. She was scared because they weren’t giving her the medication she needed.” (Orner 111) Vica was horribly mistreated in the jail, not only by the other prisoners but the employees at the prison too. Her rights were taken away from her, and she could hardly do anything about it in her condition. The prison was trying to kill her. Many of her human rights were violated, including her right to receive proper care and medication. Article 8 states, Everyone has the right to an effective remedy by the competent national tribunals for acts violating the fundamental rights granted him by the constitution or by law. Vica got denied all of her rights because she identified as a transgendered

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Throughout human history there have been many theories developed in the attempt at understanding and explaining human behavior, no one theory is without flaws but each one provides a view on human interaction and society all together. The idea that society's parts work together to maintain a status and meet social needs is called functionalism, functionalism is about cooperation and interdependence. In sharp contrast to functionalism, conflict theory states that individuals are out to promote their own self-interest, and that conflict, not cooperation is what motivates society. Symbolic functionalism analyzes the way members of society communicate and the subjectivity of everything from religion to language. Each theory has its own problems,…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the novel, Araceli is presented as a character just is trying to help. She is saving the children from being taken away from their parents to foster care. For example, one of the L.A Times reporter named Stephanie Goldman- Arbegast, expresses her compassion by stating “ The Mexican woman who’d been briefly jailed for ‘the crime’ of trying to save two children who’d been abandoned by their parents” (Tobar 296). Goldman-Arbegast explains how unfairly Araceli is treated and punished for helping those parentless children.…

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The unjustifiable sufferings of migrant farm workers in the United States These days, even though we are fighting strongly for human rights issues such as human trafficking, racial equality, asylum seekers and refugees, child abuse and LGBTQ rights, we have to admit that not everyone is equal. We worked hard to ensure that the people around us have the rights they deserved, but we are ignorant to the suffering of others. In his book Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies: Migrant Farmworkers in the United States, Seth Holmes explores the lives of the Mexican workers who cross the border illegally to come to the U.S and provides an interesting idea on how “the fault lines of class, race, citizenship, gender, and sexuality” have shaped the experience of…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Diamond asserts she was raped repeatedly in the prisons of Georgia and was denied hormone treatments, to continue being who she was meant to be, or who she feels she is inside. The issues are that there are several transgendered women who are receiving treatments which total approximately $80 dollars a month in doses of estrogen and other treatments. The state claims that they may not disclose specifics due to medical privacy laws, but asserts that over 17 transgendered women are currently receiving the same treatments Diamond alleges she was denied. Two excerpts from Ashley’s account provide insight into the plight of her…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The objective of this research paper will be to examine three main ideas in regards to the undocumented immigrants. First, the social and economic stakes concerning the undocumented immigrants, particularly the ones who want to reach their American dream coming from Mexico and Latin America, in the American soil. When undocumented individuals migrate from their mother nation to live in the United States, they migrate uniformly across the country affecting their adopted new communities. We will also examine how these immigrants affect the communities they arrived. We label these individuals that migrate from foreign countries’ as “Undocumented Immigrants” because the United States does not have a national policy that addresses this labeling…

    • 166 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are critical dates in United States immigration. Initially, United States immigration law was the Naturalization Act of 1790. The Naturalization Act determined that "any outsider, being a free white individual, might be confessed to wind up a US citizen". In 1875, the Supreme Court decided that the Federal Government is in charge of managing US immigration. Then there was the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which barred certain laborers from immigrating to the United States.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tasha Robertson Professor R. Salter December 8, 2016 Healthcare Strategies Healthcare for Illegal Immigrants For many people around the world, immigration to the United States is just a dream and those who make it still have many obstacles that they have to face. Those who have already illegally immigrated to the United States have found the dream. Many illegal immigrants dislike the label but unfortunately that is what they are. When an immigrant enters the country without permission from the American government that immigrant is illegal.…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Normal Life Summary

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Dean Spade’s book Normal Life, healthcare justice and systemic issues regarding gendered treatment and access to healthcare are discussed in depth, with a focus specifically on the effects of injustice and inaccessibility to transgender and intersex individuals. Normal Life was extremely personal in terms of the subject matter, which made it difficult to read through; however, I found myself nodding along as he outlined and went into detail on the various mechanisms surrounding the discrimination of people like me. The actions being made currently by neoliberal social and political movements are not enough to achieve the goals that trans political activists strive for, nor do they make much progress in doing so. However, they are much more…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigration play a big roll in America's history. The united state has grown so much since the 1700s because of million of new immigrants who move to united states every year. There has been some differences where a different set of race is treated different because of the American's belief. For example, mu-slum where hated because of terrorism that has been going on. Just like what was going on with all the Isis issues in Europe.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrew Walker Professor Hernandez 10/07/2015 Writing 121 Immigration Immigration in America is an important topic when deciding whether or not to export those who are illegal and or to allow those with degrees to come and work. America is a country established and utilize by immigrants long ago, this means everyone in the country is an immigrant to it unless Native American. Exporting every illegal in America will allow more space and resources to receiving those with degrees and skills for work in this country. The process will be extremely difficult and will be a long process, could take years but, in the end it’ll open jobs to Americans that desperately needs them.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The authors of document 1 and document 2 are supporting the efforts to Americanize the immigrants. In the last three centuries, there have been settlements in the casts of Massachusetts and Virginia and the arrangements have been the basis for the American history. Americanism is not a matter of being born in America. Being an American is the matter of pursuing the American dream. It does not matter whether one is born in America or maybe one is born abroad, everyone in America should be assimilated to be an American.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    More than 11.4 million illegal immigrants currently reside in the United States that’s almost equivalent to how many people live in the entire state of Ohio. Most of these illegal immigrants are hardworking people that help the welfare of the economy and have a high impact on the culture of the United States. The proposition is that Illegal Immigrants who have paid their Tax’s and have resided for more than 10 years consecutively, in the United States should be given a way to get a legal residency. This residency would give them benefits like a social security which would let them get a good job, license, and, have basic human rights. Illegal immigrants deserve these rights because they create the most business, they create…

    • 1558 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How would a person feel and act if they had to pick up their belongings and move to a different country as an undocumented immigrant? These are three different stories with three different main characters, that are all going through or have gone through exactly that. The three following stories: “The Trip”, a fictional story by Laila Lalami, “Exile”, a poem written by Julia Alvarez, and finally “Outlaw: my Life as an Undocumented immigrant” by Jose Antonio Vargas all have three main characters that are going through similar struggles. These three stories are all about the struggles of an undocumented immigrant and those trying to get into a new country in order to provide themselves and their children with better, safer lives. “The Trip” is a fictional story about a man who decides that he wants a better life and goes on a trip to a new country.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Federalist’s Kaeyley Triller-a survivor of childhood rape-explains in her article, A Rape Survivor speaks out about Transgender Bathrooms, “I’d much rather risk hurting a smaller number of people’s feelings by asking transgender people to use a single-occupancy restroom that still offers safety than risk jeopardizing the safety of thousands of women and kids with a policy that gives would-be predators a free pass” (Triller, 2015). What Triller fails to realize is that this is not simply a matter of “hurt feelings” and damaged egos, but one of basic human rights. Triller has allowed her judgement to be clouded by a fear-one of the unknown, which she had so tragically had realized in the worst possible way... but this does not excuse infringement upon the personal liberties of others, regardless of her position. Sadly, in some areas transphobia has prevailed; fear has plowed through reason, albeit momentarily.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Healthcare discrimination is actually very prominent in the military itself, but it is also common in everyday life. ‘Health’ is a very holistic thing and it includes not only physical illness or impairment, but emotional and mental health as well. So, when using the term ‘health’ in conversation with transgender people, it is not just talking about the idea that these people need hormones or sex change surgeries, they are human too and could need therapy or some kind of prescription drugs for various mental illnesses. These issues related to healthcare for transgender people are not “adequately addressed by professionals” (3512) because they are not educated on how to care for these people, or do not care to learn. “It is difficult for a transgender person to get a good picture of what sexual health can be”, the reason being that schools teach sex education towards non-transgender people.…

    • 1728 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays