William F Shughart Turn Back The Clock On Daylight Savings Time Analysis

Improved Essays
In the article, “Turn Back the Clock on Daylight Savings Time” by William F. Shughart II, Shughart discusses the flaws of the concept of daylight savings. This article touches on daylights savings and what Shughart believes are its shortcomings. From the get-go, he states that daylight savings time is a scam. Shughart delves deeper into the subject of daylight savings and begins by detailing its origin. Benjamin Franklin first proposed the concept of daylight savings in 1784 as a method of conserving energy. Although first proposed in the 18th century, daylight savings time finally became the norm for life in the United States during the energy crises in the 1970s. It was hoped to serve as a way to save energy and resources. But Shughart then discusses how as a result of daylight savings time, there have now been prominent issues that have arisen as time as gone. Such as air conditioning coming into the picture, and now with hot summer days being an hour longer with daylight savings, they would be used even more and costing more in resources. He goes from issue to issue such as disrupting our flow and circadian rhythms, evidence of heart attack spikes in the weeks after starting and ending daylight savings time, people being less productive on the job as daylight savings time begins and even an increase in traffic accidents, most notably in the fall when drivers must adjust to commuting home in the dark. …show more content…
Shughart ends this article with a strong argument stating that it is ludicrous to think that daylight savings time makes an extra hour of natural light available to anyone as the sun will shine the same number of hours per day no matter where your clock’s hands point to. Some people seem to prefer having daylight savings time, while others prefer the opposition. The best option in Shughart’s opinion would be to pick one and stick to it. I find myself as a strong advocate of Shughart and his proposition of picking just one between standard time and daylight savings time. Shughart discusses how daylight savings time just results in people being less productive and the disruption of our circadian rhythms. I can vouch for this as every time daylights savings time is either starting or ending, I find myself struggling to adjust to the change. I will tend to be more tired in the mornings when daylight savings time begins and we skip an hour ahead, or I find myself staying up later than usual and having much trouble falling asleep on time. My daily cycle will tend to be out of its usual rhythm and flow, resulting in sluggish activity and not being as productive as I normally would be. I believe it would be much easier to just get rid of the outdated concept of daylight savings time and stick to just only standard time permanently. Shughart cites Arizona, Hawaii, and the territories of the U.S. as evidence that flip-flopping between daylights savings time and standard time is now redundant. Those locations do not “spring forward” and “fall back” with their clocks and they get along just fine. Shughart also discusses how daylight savings time was initially proposed as a method of saving energy and resources, especially by delaying the need for the use of lights. This is a very outdated reasoning for daylight savings time. Nowadays resources are being researched into how we can work on “being

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    If DST wasn't safe for the people why would such a great mind, encourage this topic. The citizens of United state have been proposing DST for over 200 years, If it was a threat for the us culture it would be stop along time ago. Furthermore, There have been many positive impact due to DST which are reducing crimes, saving electricity, and making it safer for the people while they are out for their businesses or school day.…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Daylight savings time negative effects that are associated with it. One of these problems with daylight savings time would be the way it effects sleep, daylight savings time turns the clock back an hour which effects the total amount of sleep during the night. The lack of sleep causes more work place injuries because of the 1-hour loss of sleep. there was not just more injury's, but they were also more severe then they usually are (Barnes, Christopher., Wagner, David. 2009). The interesting part about this article is when the daylight savings time was switched back to standard time which added an hour extra to sleep, "there was no significant differences in sleep, injury quantity, or injury severity".…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Daylight Savings

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages

    During the twentieth century, and World War I, the Germans started this concept called “Daylight Savings Time”, in hopes of saving a considerable amount of fuel. Being Americans, of course, we opted into trying out Daylight Savings, for we too wanted to save fuel and other resources. But, a majority of Americans were very unhappy with this, and the law was soon repealed due to its unpopularity. But, Daylight Savings came back just in time for the Second World War, where it continued to stick around, for years continuing to come. Though Daylight Savings was introduced and implemented in order to save fuel, there isn’t much fuel saving actually happening, leading me to agree with a majority of other Americans.…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Conceived by Benjamin Franklin over 200 years ago, the idea of Daylight Saving Time had its foundations in energy savings. It was implemented in the United States during both world wars and was later standardized by the Uniform Time Act in 1966. Nowadays, controversy surrounding the subject has supporters claiming that Daylight Savings Time conserves energy otherwise spent on artificial light; promotes outdoor activities in the evening, reduces traffic accidents, and is beneficial for businesses. This paper will present and explore the opposing view that changes in energy usage over the years have made Daylight Savings Time obsolete, as it no longer serves the goal for which it was developed. Actual energy savings are inconclusivein some cases…

    • 1307 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In our history, there have been countless historical periods, which have impacted our world in various ways. These historical periods involve any situations from political, social and economic events that have occurred. In this essay, I will be describing the economic, social, and political distinctions of three historical periods. The historical periods I will be discussing are The Antebellum Period, the Civil War and the Market Revolution. Furthermore, let us start by discussing the antebellum period and its political movements.…

    • 1882 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “Fast Time” add one hour to standard time to have more daylight so Americans could get more work done during the day so they would not have to turn on lights during the later hours. Most people did not like the concept of “Fast Time”, but some people like the idea of having more time to get there work done during the day. They also had heatless Sundays were they would all shut off there furnaces for 24 hours. A lot of people did not like this most people were not really for the whole no heat thing people like there heat especially in the colder parts of…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I am writing about Daylight Saving Time, and how we should abolish it. Daylight Saving Time is unnatural, ineffective, and detrimental. Daylight Saving Time gives farmers less time to farm during the day, and gets the cows off of their natural schedule. It is proven that Daylight Saving Time uses more energy, than before when we did not use it. When we set the clocks back, there is an increase of heart attacks and car wrecks, due to reduced sleeping time.…

    • 173 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The railroads being able to make different time zones in the U.S. so telling time on one side of the world would be easier while also thinking about the time on the other side of the world. Also, the robber barons were bad and some people like Thomas Vast tried their hardest to end the dishonest that ran rampant. In response to these changes the people turned to labor unions and political parties for advice and help. This Era paved the way for the time periods to come, The Progressive…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout centuries, the world has seen the need for a change in the time to accompany the change in daylight. Daylight Savings Time is an act twice a year where they change the clock an hour back or forward. It is practiced within the United States and some controversy regarding the usefulness of it. Some argue thought, that the complexity and usefulness of the Daylight Savings Time make it unwarranted. Thought another might argue that the small change of an hour gives many hidden benefits most can not visibly see.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How did mankind make the timetable to mirror the time inside the diverse societies? Acknowledged frameworks for the division of time into days, months, and years, schedules mirror a human push to quantify and arrange the expanded times without bounds. Researchers partition date-books into three general classes, for example, lunar, sunlight based, and lunisolar relying on whether their worldly divisions are chiefly in view of the developments of the moon or the sun or on a trade off between both. In the development of cash, it was simpler to make it so the general population can get to it a great deal less demanding.…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Daylight Saving Time-- created as a way to conserve daylight and save energy is a practice that dates back to the early 1900s. Most countries have adapted to the practice of turning the clocks ahead one hour in the spring, and then turning them back an hour in the fall. Yet, there’s a lack of knowledge of how and why Daylight Saving Time came about, which has caused a lot of debate over whether it should end once and for all. Daylight Saving Time should be abolished as it has no purpose and causes a great deal of confusion and aggravation, as well as having negative effects on our health.…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    During the Industrial Revolution people worked 11-12 hour days, witch for most was a rediculous ammount of time. No one understood the benifits of giving you workers a shorter day. What the shorter day did was enhance the workers rate of work, along with the raised profits of there companys. This is do to how a human works.…

    • 291 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Daylight Saving Time

    • 138 Words
    • 1 Pages

    People are saying that they want them to stop trying to force them to do this task twice a year. People who studied found in the spring losing hours of sleep can cause job injuries and heart attack. Alaska try to get rid of daylight saving time but the business seem to be following the daylight saving time. People are debating some want to stay daylight saving time zone samoe don,t. People say it is hard trying to book a flight because their…

    • 138 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is suggested that smartphones, bad bedroom environment, and light pollution are just a few things that pose a bigger threat to sleep deprivation than Daylight Saving Time (Sifferlin, 2015). Others say that in when in hour is gained in the Fall months that you gain an hour of sleep which is beneficial for your health. However, it was found that an average of only 12 extra minutes of sleep was gained during the Fall (Smith, 2014). Most arguments in favor of Daylight Saving Time appear weak, simply wanting to keep things the…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By shortening the work week the health of the American workers could be increased. A four day work week also has the potential to help soften the effects of the horrible economy that we are in. with implementing such a plan the carbon footprint that Americans are leaving has a chance to be decreased. Another problem the US is now facing is an increase in people who can’t stop working. And a simple decrease in the work week has the potential to help them become less…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays