Thomas Nagel Meaning Of Life Analysis

Improved Essays
The meaning of life is a highly controversial topic among humans; one that has been debated for centuries. A particular philosopher, Thomas Nagel, has a certain idea about what the meaning of life. However, I do not agree with his position. Essentially, he believed that life has no meaning and that there is no rationale that could be given to it in order to make it meaningful. Nevertheless, even if everything we do in life will be forgotten, that does not mean humans cannot find meaning in their everyday life. Therefore, Nagel’s argument is flawed because there are several avenues in life that individuals can find meaningful. In order to fully understand Nagel’s belief in a meaningless life for humanity, we must first delve into his argument. …show more content…
The fact that what we do in the present may not have an impact on the future, does not mean our existence is meaningless. Personally, I tend to lean more towards the side of the Stoics in regard to the meaning of life. One aspect of meaning that the Stoics find is virtue. By virtue, they mean being excellent at your function. This tenant has the potential to be fulfilling to the person and bring them great joy. The competition aspect and always striving to become better at their function can give their life meaning. How one controls their mind will be who they become, so if they continue to strive forward they will avoid their doubts. Also, even if doubt arises, the joy and happiness they derive from their function may out way it. Nagel believes that once doubt arises, it can never be overcome. However, the Stoics believed differently; if one lets something harm the mind, you are letting it eat the divine inside you. Therefore, you should detach yourself in order to avoid harm to your divine spark. Everything happens for a reason, so use it to grow. With that being said, I believe this is one avenue humanity can give meaning to their

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Viktor Frankl’s Meaning Through Suffering For the duration of human existence, there have been shared characteristics that are innate to humans. These characteristics are centred around giving meaning to one’s life and questioning one’s existence. These questions of existence have been pondered by all of humanity, from some of the greatest thinkers to the average human being.…

    • 1914 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The question the “the meaning of life” is a vague question. Many interpret this question in different ways because the meaning of life for everyone is not the same. For some it may be to do as much good as they can, or it may be to live life like there is no tomorrow and have has much fun as they can or to gain as much knowledge as possible to make themselves happier. Many people interpret this question differently so there is no one answer for this question. No person can answer this question for someone else it is left up to the person himself to answer…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In her essay “Meaning in Life and Why It Matters,” Susan Wolf discusses the reasons that contribute to meaning in our lives and argues that we should “understand meaningfulness as an attribute lives can have that is not reducible to or subsumable under either happiness, as it is ordinarily understood, or morality” (3). In laying out her beliefs of how we can find meaning, she discusses different viewpoints and offers suggestions of how they should be altered and combined to make a more accurate theory she calls the ‘Fitting Fulfillment View.’ In this paper I will explain the details of the Fitting Fulfillment View as described by Wolf as well as why it is important to talk about meaning and how we can judge whether something is meaningful or not. Through looking at the example of education, I will prove that Wolf’s account is reasonable, versatile, and…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many different outlooks on life. Some believe that the world we exist in is meaningless and that nothing we do will be of importance. Others, however, have a much more lighthearted approach, focusing on enjoying their lives as much as possible and looking for enjoyable activities to partake in. This search for a purpose in life, or existentialism, shapes our realities and our ambitions.…

    • 1261 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Response to Question 1, Section 1: The Meaning of Life: Wolf vs. Taylor Both Richard Taylor and Susan Wolf understand the difficulty of answering the question, “What is the meaning of life?” Taylor begins his “The Meaning of Life” by saying that we do not even understand what the question means to then answer it, and Wolf claims in her own “The Meanings of Lives” that the question is embarrassing to ask because, as Taylor asserts, we really do not understand what is being asked here. Taylor proposes, then, the best way to answer this is to ask what makes for a meaningless life, and perhaps from this comparison, we can find some answers to the original question. Wolf appreciates Taylor’s approach as she also adopts his method, and even though…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because meaning is not just a human experience, it is subjective (as Wolf states, golfing might be meaningful to some but not to others), the realization of meaning in one’s life can be actively manipulated based on the vantage point that one chooses to have. I do not believe that only a self and a sub specie aeternitatis viewpoint exist. There are an infinite amount of viewpoints which we can choose to take, all of which imply different amounts of meaning depending on the conditions within that viewpoint. For example, for the viewpoint consisting of only an immediate family, a son or daughter can be viewed to be the most meaningful thing.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Susan Wolf’s paper “The Meanings of Lives,” she discusses the qualifications of and the innate human yearning for a meaningful and fulfilling life. The foundation for her argument lies in her three criterion for meaning which include involvement, purpose, and success. She then continues her argument by explaining the opposite of each of these criterion as a stereotypical person. However, Wolf’s assertion suffers from being overly general in that it makes the assumption that all humans have access to the same resources and opportunities to perform the tasks required to be considered meaningful by her standards.…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In The Absurd, Nagel (1971) observes that people seeking to escape from the absurdity of human life may resort to broader ultimate concerns, with religion and the glory of God constituting one of the larger enterprises pursued by people. However, Nagel (1971) is adamant that even the existence of God may be insufficient to give human life a purpose or meaning. A careful analysis of Nagel’s argument leads to agreement with his position, informed by his observations regarding the ability to cast doubt upon the larger purpose, which is God’s plan in the case. Nagel (1971) begins with the view that humans may try to escape the absurd position and supply their lives with meaning through fulfillment in the glory of God. The perception that God exists and that He has a plan for our lives constitutes one of the ways through which people seek to escape absurdity.…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nagel tends to point out that there is no meaning in life, but not much about what to do about this realization. Existentialists argue that life’s authentic existence has to start with the recognition of the nothingness that is life. This point is were they separate from Camus and Nagel, because existentialists from life, one is at complete liberty to make the free choices that will dictate and define the meaning of an individual life. Sartre importantly argues, that first, comes man’s existence, then (after), through life he defines himself. Sartre argues that nothing is a result of built in human nature, or nothing is predetermined for a person, essentially it is all up to what a person decides to make of his or her life.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Susan Wolfs “The Meaning in Life and Why It Matters” is a short book of Essays containing commentaries by Robert Adams and John Kothe, and Wolfs responses to their commentary. Throughout the book Wolf focuses on 3 views to talk about when thinking about life, and objectively why it matters for it to be important. Those 3 views are the Fulfillment view, the Larger-than-oneself view, and the Bipartite view. After explaining these views Wolf then gives her interpretation on her own crafted view called the Fitting Fulfillment view. After Wolf explains these views, Adams and Kothe set up counter arguments to her view and the other views.…

    • 1516 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Philosopher, Joseph P. Carter, in his opinion article, “The Universe Doesn’t Care About Your ‘Purpose’”, explains that our existence does not matter in the world. Carter’s purpose is to explain how people hold no importance at all to the universe, only towards each other. He adopts a thoughtful and sentimental tone in order to convince his studious readers. Carter argues that the universe sees no purpose in individuals.…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The environment changes, and therefore, so does fitness. All by chance. So this couldn’t possibly be the actual meaning of life. Also, the explanations by scientists as to “why” things actually work has always just answered “how” things work. They don’t actually…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas Nagel Volunteer

    • 1835 Words
    • 8 Pages

    If we were living a significantly purposeful life wouldn’t we wish for it to never end? Our natural human instincts for questioning reason and significance is one that is unavoidable. The point of view presented is not meant to be one of negative connotation, however, one to be taken with a grain of salt. One may also argue there is reason to live a life of despair supposing life is recognizably absurd. I also find this objection to be false.…

    • 1835 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Existentialism may answer questions about the meaning of our world by claiming that the world is simply a mess of random chance that happens to be what it is now, and say that “it is what it is,” matching their view of life. However, this topic is not often explored by existentialists, and opinions of the world may vary between them. This is because Existentialism is mostly centred around existence and life, rather than the world itself. If the core of existentialism is that people must choose the meaning of their own life, how can it then answer the question of the meaning of the world without using a separate…

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many different meanings to everyone, some enjoy the material things and others believe life revolves around the important things. Like I stated above, family and education. Before this topic was discussed and before I was in this philosophy course, I did not fully understand it, I did not give it much thought; it did not really matter to me. I did not think there was really any kind meaning to life, but after reading the materials given to us, it had me thinking of all the possibilities you could make happen. All the things going on in the world, bad and good, they all mean something to me and hopefully everyone.…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays