Saint Augustine's Response To The Pagans Analysis

Great Essays
The recent disasters in Rome in 410, is reflected in Saint Augustine works from the City of God. These works will be discussed and analysis in order to gain a clearer picture of Augustine’s response to the Pagans, who suggest that the Christian faith had caused the recent disasters in Rome. However, Augustine does not go into too much detail of the recent disaster itself, but he does use Rome’s disaster as an example of the sins committed by the Romans Empire from the past, in order to make his case against the Pagans.
Saint Augustine was born in the North Africa town of Thagate. When he got older, he was set to Cartage to study, there he got involved in with the Manichees. Eventually, Augustine went to Rome for work and met Ambrose, the bishop of Milan, where he found the beginnings of his Christian faith, he converted to Christianity not long after that. Once converted he returned to Africa to become the bishop of Hippo, not far from his own home town. In 410, Rome was captured by the Alaric the Gothic King, as a result the Pagans believed that the disasters that had occurred in Rome, was because of the Christians religion. They believed the Christian faith had weakened the Roman Empire, as before the Christians had arrived the Pagan Gods, had made the Roman Empire successful. Furthermore, it would never have fallen if the Romans had stayed true to their Pagan Gods. Augustine 's response to these accusations, in regard to the capture of Rome by trying to quell both the Pagans and Christians, who believe that if the one true God existed, then he should have protected Rome. Augustine against the Pagans is not something new, as like their predecessors, the pagan Celsus and the Christian Origin, both defending their rights to their religious beliefs and both accusing the other for any disasters in the Roman Empire. The only real difference this time is it was the first time; Rome has been captured, by a Christian. As a result, someone or something needs to be blamed for these disasters. When the barbarian King Alaric, who “was an Arian Christian” took control of Rome a “Catholic city” in “August 410.” The many Christians were “severely shaken in their faith” as they could not believe that the now “Christian Empire” could fall, as they were under God 's protection. Both the Christians and Pagans, were in shock, as neither Christians nor Pagans were spared from the disasters that had befallen them. The barbarians began to burn houses down and rape the women; they stole treasured sacred to the churches. Many believed that Rome’s destruction was caused by the Romans “forsaking their Gods under whose protection Rome had enjoyed such long prosperity.” As Rome had become more Christian orientated, they began to drift away from their Pagan Gods in favour of the Christian God and their views. A pagan named Volusianus questioned if the Christians were the ones that caused the disasters in Rome. A friend of Volusianus named Marcellinus, told St Augustine what Volusianus had said about the Christians causing the disaster and collapse of Rome. Therefore, St Augustine had no other recourse other than to send a letter to Volusianus in the hopes of alleviating his fears, but also as a way of defending the Christians against any wrong doings. Augustine
…show more content…
Although his writings in defense of the Christians religion would seem contradictory, to this, but he needed to make an example of Rome in his defense of the Christians. Furthermore, Augustine responds to the Pagans, was used as a means to justify his Christian faith, in addition to this, he further used his response as a way of soothing those Christians, who were starting to lose their faith in God.
He wanted to show the Pagans that their Gods were indeed the ones that caused the collapse of Rome. Furthermore, he needed to show that the Romans were no saints having caused atrocities against other nations and religions, that it is only natural that they should fall from grace. Augustine believes that the capture of Rome, began way before the Christians arrived, and he further believed that Rome had brought this on themselves, for worshipping false Gods. Furthermore, their fake Gods had brought evil into their

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Consequently, Christians were able to construct churches throughout the Roman Empire. All of a sudden, the religion that was basis for persecution has now become the official religion of the empire. The sudden acceptance of Christianity as the religion of the Roman Empire presented many challenges. The early Christians didn’t have a formal religious system, rather, they followed the teachings of Jesus in the form of Gospels.…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “God is always trying to give good things to us, but our hands are too full to receive them.” ― Augustine of Hippo, City of God Panegyric: Saint Augustine is the figure of the great Bishop of Hippo (the city of Bona). His book City of God became a monumental theology of history as Augustine’s analysis is timeless and universal. Paraphrastic: If our hands are full when God is trying to hand us blessings, our hands are probably full of things that we are addicted to.…

    • 380 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    First, Augustine draws a parallel between himself and a passage from the Old Testament in the chapter “Pear Theft”, in which Augustine is persuaded by his friends to steal pears from a local tree. The parallel between Augustine’s retelling and the story of Adam and Eve from the book of Genesis is both evident and purposeful. Adam is persuaded into taking the forbidden apple from Eve, leading to the eventual banishment from the Garden of Eden while Augustine is peer-pressured into stealing pears which signals his metaphorical banishment from enlightenment and acceptance of…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Two aspects of the Roman politics and culture change noticeably; the rise of Christianity, and the division of the empire which ended with an Eastern and a Western Roman Empire. Christianity altered the Roman lifestyle, while the decentralization of the Empire left Western Europe without a strong political system until the formation of the Holy Roman Empire. Although these changes marked the beginning of the Byzantine Empire, an important continuity shaped the Byzantine political attitude; the conservation of the Greco-Roman laws and ideas. When the Roman Empire split during the 3rd century, it was having both internal and external conflicts, unable to control its vast lands. The majority of the internal conflicts were caused by the shifting in religious practices and beliefs amongst the citizens, of which Christianity was a part of.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    He met the imposing figure of Ambrose, religious administrator of Milan. His incredible brains and searing sermons left a profound impact on Augustine. In Ambrose, Augustine discovered somebody who could impart at his own particular scholarly level, additionally affirming his dismissal of the Manichees and opening the path for his arrival to the Christian confidence. Ambrose and others in his circle were unequivocally impacted by the works of Plotinus an Egyptian conceived agnostic Greek rationalist who had been affected by Christian thoughts who started the philosophical custom of Neoplatonism which would impact Christianity for some eras to…

    • 98 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The emperors hated Christianity so much for one main reason. “The Romans tolerated the religions of other peoples unless these religions threatened public…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Monica became frustrated with God and contemplated his existence. After some more prayers Monica started to see change in Augustine when he started to enter college. Augustine began to build his faith and later on become a saint. This explains how Monica never gave up on her faith even when she thought God was ignoring her prayers. Who I believe that made the church catholic is Theodosius.…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This cause him to damage friendship and he becoming vanity, anger, and suspicion. Ch. 2 Augustine go and see a pagan theater shows that mirrors his plight.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Roman culture tolerated most religions expect for Christianity, which it sought to terminate through persecution. The reasons for persecuting Christians was to send a clear message of conformity in the name of patriotism, provide a diversion and as a form of entertainment. Roman authorities viewed the belief in one true God as dangerous, having the potential to ignite strong motivations towards challenging and undermining the self appointed divine rule of the Emperor and unmasking the unstable government. Christianity then became a scapegoat for all the problems of the Empire. As the Romans were being battered from several fronts by invading armies, placing the blame on Christians who were deemed nonconformists seemed like the best response…

    • 198 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Augustine’s Confessions demonstrates the conversion of a man from sin to piety. While Augustine credits God’s hand for his transformation, another man guides Augustine’s conversion as well. Though unknowingly, Alypius’ influence on the life of Augustine prompts him to better himself, inciting purpose in his search for truth which in turn leads to his conversion. Despite Augustine’s many claims of interactions and signals from God, Alypius’ youth and innocence, his more modest sin, and his dependence upon the teachings of Augustine generates the evolution in Augustine’s character from a state of doubt to one of faith.…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For Augustine, the sacred Scripture played a significant role in his conversion and acceptance of God’s grace in his life. After Augustine had been contemplating his poor life choices, he had opened the Bible and read the first passage that he saw, which told him to convert and Augustine immediately did so. After his conversion to Catholicism, he lost all the fears and doubt about God and the differences between good and evil that he had been harboring inside of…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Augustine The Aeneid

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Like most kids he did not care to study and he objected to all his classes and what his teacher was preaching. He acted out because he did like to learn but it was the fact that he was supposed to learn subjects that were not in his best interest. Augustine got the impression from his teachers that an education means you become rich and famous. This way of thinking did not sit well with Augustine because all he wanted to do was to have a deeper connection with God. Augustine reflected on this time period and found himself sinning because in a particular class he became overly attached to Dido a main character in the book Aeneid.…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In contrast, Augustine was born in Thagaste, a province of Numidia in North Africa. His Christian faith proved to play a major role in his philosophical teachings. While Plato’s worldview was more materialistic, Augustine’s worldview was…

    • 1091 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abelard and Augustine: Devout Sinners and Christians Abelard and St. Augustine felt compelled to write of their mistakes and misfortunes reflective of their lives. Despite the fact they did so in efforts to confess their sins, the two differ in a multitude of ways. Some of which include their approach for convincing people religion can provide them with salvation, or their attitudes towards religion in their earlier life. St. Augustine wrote within the first century where Christianity was a competitor when it came to religion. Up until this time, Roman Paganism was undoubtedly the main religion within Europe.…

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In light of Augustine 's constant challenges with the Biblical book of Genesis, the comprehension of the nature of time was important to protect the way of the God of Catholicism. This need to guard the sovereignty of the Supreme was also the primary reason for molding Augustine 's quest in this…

    • 2318 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays