Patient Autonomy: A Case Study

Decent Essays
agree one hundred percent that we must respect the patient autonomy even when he or she cannot longer make a medical decision. You are a future nurse and you have clear your role as a patient's advocate. However, in this case, I have to disagree with you in some points of the discussion. I was taught that if you have a code on the floor you are working and the family member says to you " he/ she doesn't want to be resuscitated" but there is no DNR, you have to continue CPR or whatever it is. I know is not the same because Brother F is in a mechanical ventilator and doctors state there is no possibility for him to regain consciousness, but the authority of someone acting without a proxy is more limited that someone who does have a health care

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The ethical dilemma here is that the patient is still lucid and not in a terminal state, should the medical staff ignore the DNR on a chart and hospitalize the patient with an intubation and ventilator or go with the patient's wishes? Since the patient is still lucid and understands the conditions, should the medical staff asks the patient's opinion if option if he/she will like to be hospitalized and incubated? Another ethical dilemma most common in the long-term care facility are the ethical dilemmas faced by the medical staff (nurses' aide, licensed practical nurses, registered nurses) in the use of restraints on dementia…

    • 105 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Staff of Life Care had an Ethical responsibility and the duty to speak up for their patients’ rights regardless of the conflict it may have cause them with colleagues or opposing authorities. Also, Provision four of the Code of Ethics for Nurses states that it is in the authority of the nurse to delegate tasks to promote optimum care for their patients (Brown 2015). This did not occur with these patients. Life Care staff passively allowed Memorial to make decision regarding the care of patient they were ultimately responsible for. The instead of being assertive and advocating they relinquished their power and…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This literature review will examine the pre-existing research undertaken on family presence during adult resuscitation (FPDAR) to determine health professional attitudes and experiences in critical care environments regarding FPDAR within Europe. The topic FPDAR was chosen due to the authors experience whilst in placement of a family member being refused permission to remain with their loved one during cardiopulmonary resuscitation. The reason the family member was refused permission to remain at the bedside was because there was no hospital policy that stated if a family member was or was not permitted to remain. The author wanted to understand why FPDAR was not being encouraged in practice as the role of a nurse is to provide patient with…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I believe that a patient has a right to this option under patient autonomy. Also, under this law the patient maintains their right to their life. They pick and choose when their limits are versus their only option being to push until they can’t be pushed anymore, ending with a possible outcome of surviving their disease. However in most of these cases they are terminal disease. I can see why this issue would be controversial because it’s going completely against the ethics of a caregiver, however in many cases like these the care giver can’t give effective treatment.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ethical principles are not laws, but guiding principles about what is good and what is bad, that should direct doctors and other health care professionals in their work and decision making. Issues arising over end-of-life care involving decisions that affect the nature and timing of an individual's death raise difficult ethical conflicts for all concerned and can be a source of discord between health professionals within a team, health professionals and family members, or between different family members. Ethical dilemmas arise when there is a perceived conflicting duty to the patient, such as a conflict between a duty to preserve life and a duty to act in a patient's best interests, or when an ethical principle such as respect for autonomy conflicts with a duty not to…

    • 3174 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The nurse may not always agree with their patient’s choices, but they can make sure they have all the information required to help them make the right decision for themselves. Respect does not always mean agreement, most Americans feel that their end of life choices should be theirs, and not the governments or medical professionals (Altmann, T & Collins,S., 2007). This fact leads me to believe that more states will follow in passing laws legalizing PAS and that means that nurses have to be up to date on what is going on in their states. They should ask themselves how they feel about PAS and if they could be involved in the…

    • 738 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Kevorkian Assisted Suicide

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A controversy in nursing I believe that is starting to come around to more people is the right to die law. There are many people that have been suffering in pain due to an incurable medical condition that comes to a point of not wanting to live. Since Kevorkian MD, there have been many people with medical conditions that are incurable. These people are those that are suffering in pain as their family watches. They feel helpless as there are currently no ways to help besides giving them more pain medicine to make them comfortable.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A potential ethical dilemma that I could face in my chosen advanced nurse practice role as a family nurse practitioner is a large family that disagrees amongst themselves over whether to continue their mothers care. The situation is this: A mother of five children, divorced for over fifteen years, enters the hospital after suffering a massive stroke, was found unresponsive yet breathing in her yard by a neighbor. EMS was called and she was brought into the hospital and placed on advanced life support. The primary ICU physician and neurosurgeon are in agreement that the patient will not regain a significant amount of brain function. It has been a catastrophic injury without hope of recovery.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Best practice recommendations are that patients be approached and asked about an advanced directive early, before they become critically ill. Education should be provided, including all treatment options. It is best that this be done in the presence of patient’s family to ensure that everyone is equally informed and involved in making this decision. Although unless the patient lacks decision making capacity it is ultimately their decision to make.…

    • 1249 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The only behavior and choices that one can control is one’s own (Haigh and Neville 3213). In health care, it is thought to be a fundamental ethical principle to respect a patient’s autonomy (Haigh and Neville 3213). When the principle of the right to autonomy conflicts with others, it should almost always come first and take precedence over other principles (Angell). One principle, or basis for a system of belief or behavior, that the right to autonomy could possibly come in conflict is the principle that all physicians and medical professionals should always care for the ill and keep them alive (Angell). Although nurses pledge to do no harm to their patients, it is ultimately the patient’s decision to decide what is best for them in the event that they may not have many other options (Angell).…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Autonomy and Ethical Principles of Care Gunnar Kupfer Grand Canyon University HLT-305 October 16th 2016 Ethics in health care could be life or death. Patients have a lot of rights when it comes to health care, yet patients don’t even know what they are. Basic consent forms truly don’t adequately inform patients of their rights. Consent forms are written in high levels and use words most wont understand. The average person simply cannot read a Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy consent form.…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The main issue here was whether a life support machine can ever be withdrawn from a patient who cannot give consent. In the concern of welfare principle and legal paternalism, it is improper and inappropriate to simply end a person’s life. This is an immoral conduct and must be prohibited by state due to public policy. Brooke LJ in made it clear in ReA that human life is sacred and inviolable, one should never end a person’s life by act or omission. [ ReA [2001] 2 WLR 480]…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In this case Gerald autonomy will be suppressed because he is confused and disorientated. He does not have the mental capacity to decide or to know that he is covered in faeces and the nurses wants to help him, at this point he is not able to give consent. Consent happens voluntarily when a person agrees to do something for another person (Griffith & Tengnah, 2012). By gaining consent from Gerald the nurses will be also covering themselves and the procedure to be performed. According to Kerridge, Lowe & Stewart (2013) for a person be be legal competent to give consent they should have a sufficient mind to interpret their condition and able to understand the consequences that can arise from their choices.…

    • 272 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many nurses are faced with ethical and legal dilemmas constantly in the health care setting. We as nurses need to understand the laws that pertain to our scope of practice and respect our patient’s decisions whether they interfere with our own personal views. Ethical dilemmas become more problematic when you take into consideration that each nurse has their own personal set of ethics depending on what they see as wrong and right. Nurses spend a lot of time with the patient and it allows them to have a deep connection which makes it hard to not get involved. We become our patients advocate so much that it can also be our greatest weakness because we do not know when to let go.…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this scenario, there is a living will that clearly specifies the patient does not want ventilator support or other artificial life support in the event of a permanent unconscious condition or terminal condition, and it has been determine by the primary physician that are condition is permanent. I will advise the husband that the condition is permanent and allow him time to grief the loss of the loved one, then I will put forward the desire of the healthcare organization to follow the instructions specified in the living will and withdraw the life support. Legal/Ethical issue 3 : Due to the present condition of the patient of not been able to care for herself, I will tell the husband that he is the only person who can honor the wish of the patient by withdrawing the life support. I will also tell him that by so doing, he respects the patient and helped her reduce the suffering she will go through in the process of been placed on ventilator.…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays