Nick Bostrom And Rebecca Roache: Article Analysis

Great Essays
Only one thing is certain; humans are not perfect, no matter how much we try to enhance ourselves. Nevertheless, centuries have been spent on the pursuit of constructed divinity, a heavenly definition that is too ambiguous to consider plausible. As Nick Bostrom and Rebecca Roache explore in their article, Ethical Issues in Human Advancement, this topic is very complicated and nuanced. Therefore, during this relatively early implementation of human enhancement, it is important to make decisions on a case by case basis. In cases where people feel incapable of functioning every day or having a fulfilling life, enhancement is worth the risk. On the other hand, in cases where individuals seek human enhancement where there would be no direct and …show more content…
History should warn that quick fixes are not sustainable answers that lead to real satisfaction. Kenneth L. Garver and Bettylee Garver’s article on the history of negative eugenics is one example of how delicate the topic of human variation is. Counterarguments address what society deems as “normal.” Since there is discrepancy in that definition, it is nearly impossible to legitimize a rigid set of rules for everyone. Infact, many see any set of rules that hinders human enhancement to go against evolution. To rebut, is to recognize that every living person has the right to choose what kind of life they want to live so long as no harm will be done to others. Accordingly, human enhancement is powerful on an individual and societal level. If a greater understanding and appreciation of history is not applied to the decisions made, no innovation will be improvement. Therefore, as we move forward, human enhancement must be safeguarded as a influential yet dangerous tool that will undeniably change society for generations to come. So, extreme caution paired with controlled curiosity is the way to

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The author talks about how the conversation around eugenics is similar to the Pro-Choice movement in the 1960-70s. She explains how there is a stigma behind the word “eugenics” and questions whether it’s wrong to use new technology to improve the human race. She concludes the article by talking about the political opposition of eugenics. This article will be useful in the paper because it provides a different perspective of the ethics behind biotechnology.…

    • 74 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Eugenics: Argument FOR by May Slaughter Human genome editing enhances humans with desirable traits, either known as positive or negative eugenics, possible. Eugenics was coined by Sir Francis Galton, cousin of Darwin, in 1883. 19th century Britain looked down upon anyone, of the lower class. They had planned on sterilizing all of the following: mental illness, alcoholism, criminality, chronic poverty, blindness, deafness, feeble-mindedness, and prostitutes. Along with Galton, Hitler has also given people a bad opinion of eugenics.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Appeal to Pathos: Examples: “You will surely make your dear mother happy should you make her breakfast.” “When you finally leave for college, I will be the only child left. I’m sure I will find myself all alone far more often, all without a fleeting bit of hope left. The last one left, that’s me. ... College awaits, no?”…

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    SUMMARY/PRECIS Professor Ronald Green of Dartmouth University, in his article, Building Baby from Genes Up, addresses the topic of whether or not genetic engineering is a viable technological advancement for our society to pursue and argues that although there are many potential drawbacks, the overall benefits of genetic engineering outweigh its downfalls. He supports this claim by addressing the variety of benefits that genetic engineering can offer, then by categorically refuting counterarguments and finally by presenting his opinion for why each downfall of genetic engineering is surmountable. Green’s purpose is to shed light on both sides of the argument when it comes to genetic engineering, while posing the idea that genetic engineering…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Trying to curb intelligence of past and future generations by scientific modifications has been prevalent since the eugenics movement of the early 20th century. This movement seeked to create a “master race” by improving genetic traits of humans through sterilization and selective breeding. There were laws set in place which forced people that were deemed “feeble minded” to be sterilized. These laws are long gone now as a result of a ban on sterilization laws from the United Nations in 1948 (Greenblatt). However, the thought of trying to control intelligence in people, whether to increase or prevent “dim witted minds” still remains in current thought.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In chapter four of Michael Sandel’s book The Case against Perfection: Ethics in an age of Genetic Engineering, he brings up the notion of the controversial notion of eugenics. Sandel divides this chapter up into three types of eugenics- all of which he eventually finds unconvincing at the end of the chapter. Sandel begins this chapter by defining what eugenics is and its origins. However, as he does this, he also goes in to describing this notion as a shaky and righteous movement coined by Sir Francis Galton and others who thought like him.…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In contrast to Walter Glannon’s view that gene enhancement is morally objectionable, genetic enhancement, for the purposes of attaining a competitive advantage through increased potential in intelligence, athleticism, or attractiveness, etc. should not be viewed as morally illegitimate, because the consequences and intentions of gene enhancement can be morally justified through John Stuart Mill’s Principle of Utility and Emmanuel Kant’s Categorical Imperative. Walter Glannon argues four reasons as to why gene enhancement is “morally permissible if it is intended to ensure or restore normal functions, but is morally illegitimate if it is aimed at enhancing functions beyond normal.” However, gene enhancement is a simply one form of genetic alternation.…

    • 1327 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, society cannot be blinded by the glittering generalities of this modification process. Humans must be able to delve into the future, and analyze its greatest weaknesses and hindrances. They must analyze of the ways in which it will impact religious and moral values, how eventually we may stray away from the true goal of the process and how Aldous Huxley, in his novel Brave New World, demonstrates to the reader how dangerous genetic manipulation was to society. Due to these factors, genetic…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the beginning of the 20th century, the human mind was much more inclined to search for scientific answers to society’s problems by perfecting the human race by applying the laws of genetic heredity. In 1883, Sir Francis Galton, a respected British scientist, first used the term Eugenics, “the study of all agencies under human control which can improve or impair the racial quality of future generations.” He believed that the human race could help direct its future by selectively breeding individuals who have “desired” traits. This idea appealed to many people, who thought that there was a “natural" way to bring about a utopian society just as nature “weeds out the unfit" among animals, so too should human society “weed out" its unfit members. In creating a world where human beings would be kind, intelligent, brave and honest…

    • 1178 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the time period that Brave New World was written, Britain was undergoing an economic crisis. Amidst desperation, many revered eugenics as means of escape from the challenges society was facing. Many intellectuals, scientists, medical practitioners, and political figures agreed with the belief system of the eugenics movement. Of these people, Aldous Huxley was one who believed firmly but skeptically in eugenics. His brother, Julius Huxley, and many of his companions were also heavily involved in this movement.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The idea of consequentialism is that we need to consider the final consequences of the action, whether or not the act itself is morally good (Shakil, n.d.). This principle claims that the morality of an action, such as, genetic enhancement depends on the best actual or expected results. Therefore, someone like Savulescu will argue that if we fail to maximize good results through genetic enhancements then we are acting morally wrong, even if we had good intentions (Shafer-Landau, 126). Savulescu tried to defend his position from some common objections, however, this paper will argue that it is not the duty of the parents to genetically enhance their children and point out the concerns in Julian’s defenses of his…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The threat of dehumanization is a growing fear due to the result of scientific advancements in the biotechnology field (The President’s Council on Bioethics, 2003). While biotechnology is a growing area of science, there have been several concerns about the difference between generating new therapies vs. creating new enhancements. Enhancements are controversial because they go beyond restoring an individual to normal function (The President’s Council on Bioethics, 2003). This makes enhancements morally problematic because it seeks a new level of perfection that is not seen naturally in humans (Sandel, 2002). Questions about what defines humanity and how an enhancement affects human dignity are the focal point in the argument on biotechnological enhancements.…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The world of today is one of high performance. Everyone strives to be bigger, faster, stronger, and more efficient. However, this is not limited to humans. In man’s power hungry frenzy, unbelievable technological and scientific advances are made all the time. This can become dangerous as technology and biology are being integrated.…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The majority of individuals are familiar with the mundane task of choosing the ingredients on a Subway sandwich, numerous people have experienced the complex decision of electing the specifications for a computer, few have even encountered the remarkable undertaking of selecting a sperm donor, but what about ordering, through a catalog, the specific genes, abilities, and cosmetic characteristics for a child-to-be? Although the technology for human genetic engineering and cloning has yet to be fully developed, the idea of “designer children” (Sandel 2007, 7) can no longer be thought of as a science fiction, rather society must recognize it wholly as a science and more importantly as a reality (McKibben 2003, 67). Being at the cusp of these…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Transhumanism Essay

    • 2043 Words
    • 9 Pages

    We have reached a point in history where, the prospects of boosting our intellect, instincts, perceptual, and physical capacities through deliberate and ever growing direct human engineering. But at what cost? Transhumanists desire immortality. As (Rectenwald, 2015) states, “If technologically possible, why wouldn’t we want to transcend our species.” Transhumanism supporters should also ask themselves, post all these changes what’s next?…

    • 2043 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays