Natasha Rodriguez's Who Are You Calling Underprivileged?

Superior Essays
Underprivileged In Natasha Rodriguez’s essay, “Who Are You Calling Underprivileged?,” she argues that the word underprivileged shouldn’t be used based on someone’s ethnicity. The author then went on to explain that the definition of “underprivileged” didn’t fit who she is just because she’s of Latino/Hispanic background. Rodriguez also explained that researchers found that labeling these students as underprivileged can give them lower self-esteem, and that colleges should not automatically send out these brochures that are entitled, “Helping Underprivileged Students,” based on what ethnicity box they checked off during their application process. Instead, the author suggests that they use a different term other than underprivilege. In …show more content…
Just like the saying “don’t judge a book by its cover,” applies to this situation as well. Don’t automatically assume someone is underprivileged because of what they come from, maybe they need money, but that does not make them underprivileged.
The definition of underprivilege, according to Merriam-Webster.com, “deprived through social or economic condition of some of the fundamental rights of all members of a civilized society” (“underprivileged,” Merriam-Webster). Most kids who are called underprivilege don’t fit this definition. Students who go to college and are put under this category, are not being denied privileges of society because of their income. Rather, they are just in need of extra money to pay off for school, not saying they struggle in their own life financially. Secondly, labeling students underprivilege is wrong because it can cause problems in society. When we label individuals they most likely are brought up by assumptions. Typically, assumptions will eventually lead to being stereotypes, which will soon be put downs and turn in to bullying. Students will start to think that they are better than the students who are put under this category because of the definition of underprivilege, when these students just need help paying for
…show more content…
Just like Rodriguez stated in her article, it can cause people to have a lower self-esteem. (Rodriguez 207). When labeling individuals, a certain word that doesn’t fit who they are, it can have a long-term effect on their personality. Labeling can make people feel insecure in who they are by making them not want to apply to college, because of the brochures that get sent out to them. Labeling can also make them not want to associate with people who don’t have this label on, them because it can make them feel like an outcast.
It can also affect the way individuals feel in their life by making them lose motivation. They won’t be motivated to apply to colleges, go to college, or apply to any finance programs because they will have this label that they are underprivilege. Having to walk around with his label that they are considered underprivileged will make them lose all enthusiasm about accomplishments that they got for themselves. In Rodriguez’s article she states, “several colleges I was considering sent me material that made me feel worthless rather than excited about
Gouty

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Granfield’s research states that stigma holds one back from being able to be a “complete citizen” because they cannot fully enjoy and participate in their social life. On the outside, these students may seem normal and look like a typical rich student, but it actually only adds on more psychological stress (Granfield). It’s one thing to hide about their background verbally, but it’s different when they must try to hide it outside of school. As in if a working-class student was with his or her parents had happened to come across an upper-class student at the grocery…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    What benefits does privilege provide? Why do people seem to hate the word? Literary critic, Parul Sehgal, in her informative paper, “How ‘privilege’ became a provocation”, argues “Privilege blinds, because it’s in its nature to blind”(Sehgal 1). Sehgal explains how the definition for ‘privilege’ has changed over time and how it affects people today. People view privilege as an undeserved success; one simply attains privilege by birth or luck, rather than working for it.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I am frequently told that I am privileged because of the color of my skin. Then I’m told I’m underprivileged because of my gender and my income. Obviously, someone needs to make up their mind. This is the starting place of Natasha Rodriguez’s essay “Who Are You Calling Underprivileged?” She writes about her experiences dealing with labeling due to ethnicity and income while applying for college and financial aid.…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To better understand discrimination and everyday prejudice one must comprehend the importance of being privileged. In summarizing the Framework Essay “Experiencing Difference” highlights on the importance of master status. It emphasizes on age and the difference between the older and younger age generation. Explains that people who are younger see things in the world much differently.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Andrew Simmons

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The article "The Danger of Telling Poor Kids that College Is the Key to Social Mobility" by Andrew Simmons brings up a great idea of what the teachers and counselors are telling the underprivileged students the wrong thing. As Simmons brings up students should not be told that college is the only way to reduce economic hardship and that’s the only point to try attend college. He expresses that students should see a college education as a stepping stone to a great career and be able to give back to the community or be able to create their own company. He also expresses that students are taught differently as those “from wealthier backgrounds to be innovators and creators while the poor kids who do very well in school are taught to be educated, capable employees.” I personally agree with the points Simmons brings up about how students should not be “taught to be educated, capable employees” but rather “to be innovators and creators.”…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Our society runs rampant with all kinds of inequality. Racism, sexism, and xenophobia are just a few of the problems that plague our world. These problems all have the potential to hurt people socially and emotionally. However, there’s another type of inequality whose impacts go beyond social and emotional harms. Income inequality hurts people psychologically and economically, and its implications span a global scale.…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Hey Haleigh, I really enjoyed reading your post. I agree with Karl Marx, that society is determined by economic organization, particularly the ownership of property. In today's society, people think power is everything. People with power, think they can get alway with anything. In my opinion, it should not matter if you are rich or poor, everyone should be treated equally.…

    • 101 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fair is defined as free from bias, dishonesty, and injustice. It may seem like such a simple concept, but to this day, we have trouble determining what is fair. Fairness is rewarding those who try and work hard towards their goals, while encouraging those who don’t to give more effort. This has proved to be a large conflict in our modern-day world, as balancing accolades and incentives is a hard judgment. Nevertheless, it remains that being fair is not giving everyone equal treatment, but rather holding them responsible for their own actions.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As child, whenever we try something new, we get told something a long the lines of. „ You can do it“ or „You’ll be fine“. So if a black, first generation college attendant gets told, from beginning on, that she will not do well in a lecture, what does that do to her own self-esteem? I do believe, that by putting people in these little boxes, of what they can and can’t do, there is a strong discrimination, just a different one and probably the cause of inequality. From the beginning on, these people are getting denied of support and maybe even trust (believe).…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this memo I explain how privilege can cause large groups of people to receive unfair treatment due to their identity and background. It contains discussion how being part of a more privileged group in society gives me advantages while being part of a minority leaves people with significantly fewer resources. Areas in Which I am Privileged There are several reasons why I am privileged; being white, able-bodied, cisgender, receiving an education, and having a stable income are all examples.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Primary Positions The History of Mental Health Issues in the Black Community Mental illness among African-Americans has been present since Africans were first brought to the colonial south as slaves. In 1812, the father of American Psychiatry, Benjamin Rush, observed a disorder among Africans which caused them to become insane soon after entering slavery (Rush, 1812). He called this disorder Negritude. “The only cure,” he wrote in his journal Medical Inquiries and Observations Upon the Disease of the Mind, “was to become white,” (1812).…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Discrimination based on social class stops one’s individual progress socially, physically, and economically; which prevents them from realizing their full potential as a human. Discrimination based on social class stops one’s individual progress…

    • 1118 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Label Us Angry by Jeremiah Torres shows how difficult it is for oppressed people to breakout of the path or stereotype that society has created for them. Carlos and Jeremiah have very different triggers and coping mechanisms; any one decision can affect a person’s whole life. When we are taken in by a label, we are taken in by opinions and others’ beliefs. Labels categorize, are designed to make you feel like an outsider, become verbal abuse, narrow our perception of someone. Using any word as a label blinds a person’s true identity.…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Under affirmative action, the characteristic that earns blacks preferential treatment is implied inferiority. In integrated situations, blacks may be seen as intellectually inept since those around them view them as beneficiaries of affirmative action rather than merit. Since the effect of preferential treatment is the lowering of normal standards to increase representation, Steele argues that it places self-doubt within the minds of blacks which undermines their academic performance. This self-doubt in turn places them in a mental state of perpetual inferiority, impeding their potential for success and creates another obstacle in the development of blacks. The second liability of affirmative action is how it prompts blacks to capitalize on their past victimization as a source of power and privilege.…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Importance Of Free College Education

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited

    Students of high or upper middle class are more likely to attend a university because they have the means to afford it (Sander ). Students in the lower class, if they don’t have any source of funding, choose not to go to school because they just cannot afford to. This separation of classes seems to only benefit the higher levels of society because they can go to college without worrying about the loans, the defaults, the interest, and all the other factors that take part in student debt. While the lower class students who are unable to better their lives because they don’t think that college is a good enough investment to spend their time and money on. If college were to be free than class separation would not be relevant.…

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited
    Great Essays