Disadvantages Of Obedience

Superior Essays
According to Dictionary.com obedience is to comply “with an order, request or law or submission to another’s authority.” Obedience is a component in social behavior and everyday life. However, there are different forms of obedience such as blind obedience. This is where an individual follows direction without any question or moral perspective without knowing they are causing harm. Such form of obedience can be hostile and perilous to the people involved. This can be seen in the atrocious deaths of the Okinwa Residents, the brutal torturing at Abu Ghraib, and the dictatorship like power from the Milgrim and Zimbardo experiment. With such implications of obedience from the experiments and case studies, this paper depicts how human independency …show more content…
The objective of necessary obedience is based on moral values and aims for a better outcome of a society. This enables a society to stay on a good steady path without negatively affecting people in the environment. This form of obedience is not apparent in all cases discussed above. Interestingly, dangerous obedience or “extreme” obedience involves orders that cause more maltreatment to the individuals than good. This type of obedience can be considered immoral. Blind obedience which was mentioned earlier, is a form extreme obedience that is significant in the Okinawa case. The civilians in Okinawa were attempting suicide strictly because of the order and aims of the military. There was more harm than good. This is an example of how extreme obedience failed. Individuals who are underneath authority and follow commands without question also fall into this category of dangerous obedience. This concept helps understand military processes and its relation to Abu Ghraib. In military courses and drill training soldiers are taught to let go of their ego, and pride to follow direct orders from sergeants and higher military officials without question; blind obedience. Which helps explain why these horrific blood bath type events occurred at Abu Ghraib. The same is seen in the Milgrim and Zimbardo experiments, where the …show more content…
Threatening or harming others due to orders from a higher power does not mean one should necessarily follow them. In the Abu Ghraib situation, soldiers should be allowed to make decisions of their morals and values. This is what the Morality and Military Obedience article touched on. The goals of a society when regarding obedience should be for positive outcomes. It should be based from what we learned about necessary obedience. I will end this paper with providing a practical example using necessary obedience and extreme obedience. Lets imagine a soldier is called out from his general to arrest a gunman. The gunman has managed to kill many innocent civilians. Regarding obedience the soldier can either arrest the gunman as directed but risk the lives of more innocent civilians in the process or to instantly kill the gunman. Either way just because the general asked for a certain demand does not mean that it is the best for society. The point being made is that extreme obedience is not always the answer if it can cause great harm to a society. That if an individual has a choice like the soldier in the example above, to follow others or proclaim their individuality; they can make the decision

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Fromm alleges that too much obedience can end human history and evil will be able to control mass amounts of people to follow their deadly deeds. People will be too worried about earning national honor instead of themselves and the welfare of other people. Though the author believes too much obedience is a large flaw, he insinuates that disobeying is only acceptable when their is a good reason to deny authority power over oneself. Fromm shows this when he reasons “if a man can only obey and not disobey, he is a slave; if he can only disobey and not obey, he is a rebel (not a revolutionary); he acts out of anger, disappointment, resentment, yet not in the name of a conviction or a principle” (125). Fromm concludes his article by emphasizing that if obeying and disobeying isn’t in equilibrium mankind could find the end to…

    • 1616 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Many scientists such as Stanley Milgram, Erich Fromm, Lee Ross and Richard E. Nisbett have tested their theory of obedience to authority. Their findings might frighten people on how obedient people are and what the sick and twisted things people will do. An example of obedience to authority is the writing of this paper for Doctor Campbell, if not done properly with obedience the grade of the student will plummet. Another example of people listening to orders given by an authoritarian person that inflicted pain, suffering, and even death is the Holocaust; the Holocaust was set up by Adolf Hitler and Nazi officers in concentration camps. The Nazi officers were told to run these concentration camps filled with innocent people and to exterminate…

    • 1478 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To be obedient to authority means to “take directive orders from an authority figure, obedience is practiced to avoid punishment or other unpleasant outcomes due to ignorance of the order”. Usually obedience is done out of fear or respect. Obedience to authority was shown when Luke was made to dig the hole and fill it back up again. When he hadn’t done it fast enough the captain would hit him continuously. Luke begged and pleaded for them to stop abusing him and that he would do whatever they told him and that he will never disobey them ever again.…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the articles, “Just Do What the Pilot Tells You” by Theodore Dalrymple and “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem” by Erich Fromm, the authors possess differing opinions on the ideology of obedience versus disobedience, but are similar on demonstrating the impact on human relationships, explaining the key role of judgement in actions of conformity, and implementing facts based on scientific experiments. Ultimately, Dalrymple has a more superior argument providing further evidence of... to definitively conclude each point. Theodore Dalrymple states in the article, "Just Do What the Pilot Tells You," that obedience to power is no greater than disobedience. Dalrymple's motivation for writing this article was to define that the act of obedience to authority is needed for a society to remain in balance (Dalrymple 121) .…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Film A Few Good Men provides a lens through which to view the issues discussed in the articles "The Genocidal Killer in the Mirror" by Crispin Sartwell and "The My Lai Massacre: A Military Crime of Obedience" by Herbert C. Kelman and V. Lee Hamilton. The film depicts a classic struggle between moral correctness and militarized obedience. In "The Genocidal Killer in the Mirror," Sartwell describes that in certain situations and circumstances even the most moral people could be swayed into acts of wrongdoing. Kelman and Hamilton write about the My Lai Massacre, a bloody and atrocious annihilation of the city Son, Vietnam, during the Vietnam War. They tell the story of many, possibly normally moral people, turning into savage beasts, simply…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The natural response to such a violent environment is to behave in a way that portrays no weakness. If a soldier doesn’t show any sign of weakness, he finds it easier to trick himself into believing that survival is dependent on his strength. In claiming his self-control…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the movie, A Few Good Men, there is controversy about obedience to authority when two marines follow an order believed to be unethical. Privates Dawson and Downey, carry out a “code red”, or hazing, of another member of the unit, and were put on trial for the unintentional murder of Private Santiago. Stanley Milgram, Yale psychologist and author of “The Perils of Obedience” claims, “Some system of authority is a requirement of all communal living” (Milgram 78). Along with Milgram, Philip Zimbardo, and Erich Fromm also converse on the psychological issues regarding human behavior. Milgram’s test subjects were tricked into thinking they were electrically shocking someone if they answered a question wrong.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Obedience To Authority Obedience basically means compliance with an order, request, or law or submission to another's authority. Following the orders of authority blindly can have many negative effects. My Lai Massacre, Jonestown Massacre, Millgram Experiment and Nanking Massacre are some incidents that have caused negative consequences as a result of obedience to authority. My Lai Massacre took place in 1968.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Abu Ghraib, the American soldiers were ordered to detain and imprison Iraqis. Based on information provided from Zimbardo 's research, it is determined that the soldiers tortured and abused the prisoners because of the environment they were in, as it was believed that authorization for such brutal treatment came from high ranked military officials, even from the Secretary of Defense of the United States. The evidence found from Dr. Zimbardo 's experiment supports the idea that if placed in a certain environment that permits a certain kind of behavior, a person will do what is expected of them, and take on the role that is given to…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people in our society have been taught, starting in their early years of life, that they should be obedient to those older than them or those placed in a position of authority. Being taught from a young age that disobeying will lead to harsh consequences. But what if one is asked to do something that doesn’t aline with their personal morals? Why is it that most people in society seem to act under compulsion when faced with things they don’t care to do? What makes it so hard for them to disobey in that moment?…

    • 2072 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Platoon Film Analysis

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Vietnam War was a devastating war for both America and Vietnam. The Vietnam war was between Northern and Southern Vietnam due to the communist government in Northern Vietnam. The United States began the war simply sending aid to Southern Vietnam, but soon got much more involved. Many Americans opposed America’s involvement at all because they were not directly involved in the war, causing citizens and soldier to be unsure of their reason for fighting and not aware of the actual struggles and difficulties that came along with war. In the movie Platoon, directed by Vietnam War veteran Oliver Stone, the main character Chris Taylor, is a soldier in the Vietnam War and his experience symbolize the real experiences of a soldier in the Vietnam…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In a similar fashion, the experimenter in the Milgram experiment makes this idea concrete. Milgram states, “ [t]he essence of obedience is that a person comes to view himself as the instrument for carrying out another person’s wishes, and he therefore no longer regards himself as responsible for his actions” (87). By being obedient, a person can be taken advantage of by authority and in turn abandon their moral…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Visual Cliff Analysis

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The article that I read was “The Visual Cliff,” by Eleanor J. Gibson and Richard D. Walk. Based on what I read in the article, the intent of the paper was to investigate depth perception in babies, and in animals. The authors thought that a child would have common sense if they are places on a piece of glass that would have a depth to it, they would be able to notice the depth that is created. The hypothesis of this was to see if children and animals know depth perception. Depth perception can be described on how someone determines the distance of an area.…

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, not all disobedience is a virtue. Anyone who only obeys is a slave, while those who only disobey are rebels; they do not act for their own principles. Rebellion is the same as obedience if it is unquestionably followed; people must have a logical thought process behind their actions. Fromm says that obedience is wrong when we go against our logical and moral beliefs by obeying. We should never obey as an act of submission, only as an act of affirmation to our own logic and beliefs.…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is a characteristic of human beings in all societies: obedience of God, parents, teachers, managers and any person having an authority. This may seem tyrannical, but it is not. Believe it or not, obedience is a part of the foundation of society. Without obedience, nothing would exist except for chaos and rebellion. Without compliance, stability would diminish and the productivity of the citizens becomes non-existent (Leveillee, 2011, p.1).…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays