Moral Responsibility And Determinism

Improved Essays
The topic of moral responsibility is a popular debate among philosophers. Moral responsibility and free will are tightly intertwined, making the argument slightly more complicated. Free will is defined in two ways: 1. open choice, which states you choose x freely only if you could have done otherwise, or 2. voluntary choice, which states you act freely if and only if you act voluntarily, without coercion or constraint. Determinism is defined: past events and the laws of nature fully determine every fact of the future so that there is one way the future could be. There are theories to the existence of free will and determinism in our universe and they are defined in two main groups (Incompatibilists and Compatibilists) with sub-groupings in …show more content…
Although, moral responsibility does not include actions of the following: there was no control over the body, no ill-intent, the subject didn’t know of the action, there was a lack of control, or the subject couldn’t do otherwise. The final action in that list is one that Frankfurt believed could be false, depending on the person and what their views on a certain action are. Frankfurt argued against the principle of alternate possibilities with the Black and Jones case. Frankfurt created four different Jones cases, and his fourth Jones case is a counterexample to the principle of alternate possibilities regarding moral responsibility and free will. In the case, Black wants Jones to perform an action, but won’t intrude unless Jones decides to do something other than the action Black has in mind, granted, Jones doesn’t know of Black’s intentions to make Jones do a certain action regardless of Jones’s decision. Jones decides to follow through with the action Black intended for him to do without Black having to intervene. Therefore, as Frankfurt states, “If he (Jones) does it on his own, however, his moral responsibility is not affected by the fact that Black’s...intent …show more content…
He states, “ To make a negative moral judgment about one of your acts is to evaluate your taking one of the forks in the road of time, to characterize that fork as a worse choice than at least one of the other forks open to you,” (van Inwagen 254). I believe this statement to be false, as would Frankfurt. Determinism states that the laws of nature fully determine the events of the future, and there is only one path the universe can follow, even though the illusion of forks in the road are present. Since I agree with determinism, it is impossible to also agree with van Inwagen. For instance, in van Inwagen’s chapter “The Powers of Rational Beings: Freedom of the Will”, he gives an example of the rare chance that somehow God turned back time to see if history would repeat itself. If history repeated itself, determinism would be considered true, although, if history didn’t repeat itself, then determinism would be proven false, and forks in the road are not just mere illusions, but concrete actions that can be followed through. (van Inwagen 256) The issue I have is that if history didn’t repeat itself, then that must mean the laws of nature, which are known to be inherently true, must have been changed or proven false along the way, creating a massive butterfly effect on the universe. Laws of nature are something that

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The discussion of morals and moral responsibility is deep-seated in the classic philosophical repertoire. A closely related matter, and a frequent objection to moral responsibility, is determinism, the idea that given the initial state and laws of the universe, all future events and outcomes are completely determined. Over the course of this paper, I describe a particular theory for how moral responsibility can exist even in a deterministic universe. One prominent view in the realm of moral responsibility is the libertarian stance.…

    • 1647 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Determinism is a philosophical idea that attempts to place all events that occur as inevitable as they are predetermined by previous events and the laws of nature. However there are many who came to be known as indeterminists who reject the notion that free will is absent from the process that causes events to occur. Indeterminists believe that there are possible events that have different probabilities of occurring based on human beings free will. Then Chisholm’s view of the agent-casual theory presents humans as always going through a decision process when making an action that leads up to an event they work through their desires in first and second order volitions and then they act. These actions are free from previous events and cannot…

    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    What is the capacity in which things that are not under your control can affect the amount of moral responsibility that you face? For this topic, there are generally three main views that claim to answer this question, and they are each rather simple; first, there are those that think that people are only blameworthy for things that are under their control. Second, there are those who think that people are blameworthy for things that are not under their control, and lastly, there are those that restrict the second view, such that they can compromise between both views. In this paper, I will discuss the first two views only, providing arguments for the second view as well as possible counterarguments from those that think the first view is correct.…

    • 1287 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cahn's Argument Analysis

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The idea of moral responsibility is argued between determinists and libertarians, with the division being caused by the possibility of free will. Steven Cahn offers an explanation of the different views of free will with the three opinions being hard determinism, soft determinism, and libertarianism. In this writing, I am going to explain Cahn’s viewpoint, and his idea that freedom is not compatible with determinism. The setting for this argument begins with a criminal trial from the early twentieth century.…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Free will is the known as the capability to decide between different potential courses of action and is a highly questioned topic in the philosophical world. Free will, also closely accompanied to the views of moral responsibility, has some philosophers reason that only actions which are free willed are justified to accept the blame of the action while other philosophers oppose this view. Baron d’Holbach views free will under the idea of Determinism, which entails that only one sequence of actions is possible, which concludes that there is no such thing as free will or choice in the truly deterministic world. In contrast, Compatibilist theorists, like Stace, assert that free will exists and can be well-matched with Determinism.…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A cause is an event that makes a later event happen and once that event happens it must take place due to the laws of nature. With the belief that determinism is true, then a sequence of events exist that extends back in time. For example, a man decides to steal from a bank. Some preceding event, call c, caused that man to steal.…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    3. If determinism is true, then we could not have acted freely. To understand the argument, we must first know what “determinism” and “free will” are.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The argument goes as following. Premise One states “There’s nothing you can do to change the past” (Kane 23). Premise Two states ““There’s nothing you can do to change the laws of nature” (Kane 23). Premise Three which is a combination of Premise One and Two states “If determinism is true, then your current action is a necessary consequence of the past and natural laws” (Kane 24), therefore concluding that “If determinism is true, then there is nothing you can do to change your current action (Kane 24). There is an additional premise which connects the original argument for determinism to the concept of free will.…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The principle of alternate possibilities states that “one is morally responsible for an action only if one has alternate possibilities” (Frankfurt, 1969). David Copp writes about moral responsibility.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The debate about free will and causal determinism parallels, in many ways, another debate about free will, this one stemming from what is often called ‘theological determinism’. Some religious traditions hold that God is ultimately responsible for everything that happens. According to these traditions, God’s willing x is necessary and sufficient for x. But if He is ultimately responsible for everything in virtue of what He wills, then He is ultimately responsible for all the actions and volitions performed by agents. God’s willing that Allison take the dog for a walk is thus necessary and sufficient for Allison taking the dog for a walk. But if this is true, it is hard to see how Allison could have free…

    • 120 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Determinism says the doctrine that all events, including human action, are ultimately determined by causes external to the will. Some philosophers have taken determinism to imply that individual human beings have no free will and cannot be held morally responsible for their actions. Pereboom and Holbach are two of those philosophers. His first part of his argument is that we humans have no control over our birth or physiology.…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If We Have Free Will Essay

    • 1834 Words
    • 8 Pages

    If we live in a world where free will existed we would always be morally responsible for our actions because we always have options to do otherwise, this is known as the principle of alternate possibilities. For now let us assume that we live in a determinist world where our life events are predetermined would we be responsible for our actions even though we have no control over them? It is very hard to imagine how someone could possibly be responsible for actions they had no control over but beyond that we would have to accept that moral responsibility can coexist with determinism. Personally I feel even if we lived in a determinist world we would still be morally responsible for our actions for fact that you acted and your act caused consequences.…

    • 1834 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Free will is the power of acting without the constraint of necessity or fate; the ability to act at one 's own discretion. Some say that free will is how purposeful choices and intentions are made and that the environment does not have such a large affect that we think it does.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We, human beings, in the universe, all feel as though we are making decisions and using our free will each day. We are not forced to do things, we will them to be done. The higher power of God derives in us free will. Determinism is ultimately…

    • 2102 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Free Will and Determinism have been discussed by philosophers for many years. Free will is associated with moral responsibility, and alternative actions that “could have” been taken over the one chosen. Determinism is the opposite view, and is associated with universal causation, and a lack of free will. Determinists believe that a person’s actions are inevitable, they are dictated by a person’s experiences, they believe nurture, nature, and even a person’s genes determine their future actions. Because of this determinists believe people hold no moral responsibility for their actions.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics