Mandatory Military Rebuttal Analysis

Improved Essays
Rebuttal- Argument for Mandatory Military encourage equality
In the United States, the creation of an all-volunteer, professionalized army has led to a virtual separation between the political class which promotes and approves wars and the mostly poor white, Afro-American, and Hispanic men and women who fight them. Mandatory military service is one of most powerful means of nationalizing people, of producing an important, shared experience among members of different classes, social backgrounds, and regions.

Rebuttal- Argument that Voluntary military desensitize the political class and this country from war
Voluntary Military creates slanted selection pressures which makes the military far less diverse than a conscripted military. The political

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Although all young men were subject to the draft, most college students received deferments. The army was mostly composed of working-class whites and poor racial minorities. Blacks complained of having disproportionately higher casualty rates than white soldiers. And the military was not immune from domestic social and cultural changes. More and more soldiers wore peace and Black Power symbols, used drugs, refused orders, deserted, and assaulted and killed unpopular officers.…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prior to 1935 due to the rapid influx of immigrants, america was large assortment of different racial and ethnic communities living alongside each other. During this divided time, that many americans were not accepting of those of other religions, races, and ethnicities. It was this diverse nation that many saw their young men off to the military. At one point there was some 16 million american men were in the military- the modern equivalent would be 38 million more than 10x its current size. Many of these young men who were put into a uniform and forced to depend on fellow soldiers from very different backgrounds not only for daily companionship but also for protection in…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Black Like Me Book Review

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “…men in uniform…rarely descend to show discrimination, perhaps because of the integration of the armed forces”. The textbook talks about the Buffalo Soldiers who were African Americans who fought side by side with whites during war. Even though there was integration in the military there was still prejudice in the minds of some white soldiers and officers. They continued to stick to the old traditions of the south. “Many white officers refused to serve with black…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anti-War Dbq

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As Debs quotes "They have always taught and trained you to believe it to be your patriotic duty to go to war" meaning the government has taught one as a child to serve your country. As you go along in school one develops this mentality that as a citizen of this country one has to fulfill duties that will help the country like fighting in wars. For example, since the start of school a person is required to pledge allegiance to the flag. Students would get in trouble if they were to refuse pledging to the flag. Similar to the draft if one were to resist it, then they would not be for filling their so call duties as a citizen of the United States.…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Reconstruction Dbq

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages

    To prevent African Americans from joining, some states did not have draft boards and more specifically, white recruiting officers often neglected to send induction notices to black I-A registrants, which were recruits that were classified as available for military service. This blatant disregard for the men who wanted to fight for their country greatly contributed to the growing spirit of rejection that concentrated on the drafting and induction process for black soldiers. There was another form of rejection but it was more indirect where it concerned new recruits, seeing as this form of rejection dealt with the existing black soldiers. In the War Department’s Office of the Director of the Selective Service, there was a lack of black advisors,…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The 36 Peninsula Regiment

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The ironic existence of racial segregation and pseudo-democracy in the United States of America had a detracting effect on African Americans’ advancement in society. As a result, African Americans lived under Jim Crow’s subjugation regardless of their jobs, education, and talents. Even though many civil rights activists and organizations played an active role in bringing an end to racial segregation, the 369th regiment could be considered one of the primary proponents of racial equality. Thus, in this paper, I will analyze to what extent the 369th regiment undermined and changed the racist opinion of the United States Army.…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The military draft, or conscription, has been used four times in American history during times of national and international conflict. Some people feel that the American government should reinstate the military draft. We should not reinstate the military draft because there is currently no need for a draft, the draft requirements are unfair and inconsistent, and those who are unwillingly drafted would demoralize the overall military with their lack of commitment and cause a break down of comradery and teamwork between soldiers. The military draft has been used four times in American history: the Civil War, World War I, World War II, and the Cold War (including the Korean and Vietnam War).…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reconstruction is commonly known as the time of rebuilding the United States in a post Civil War America. When slavery was abolished and the Nation was divided President Andrew Johnson had to face the daunting task of bringing the South back into the Union, as well as redefining a culture that had drastically shifted in a few short years. The culture and economy of the Southern United States had been built around slavery, when the Emancipation Proclamation was enacted, freeing the slaves and ending the war, such a culture had to be redefined. The reforms in the Southern United States helped to industrialize the nation as well as forming what is commonly referred to as the New South.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Conscription is the compulsory enlistment of citizens for their country’s military service. This involves leaving any education, work and family behind in order to go to military training camps. World War Two was a time that saw unprecedented levels of damage and destruction. This put many countries in a state of economic and political desperation. During this period the Canadian government chose to introduce conscription in order to help the allied countries win the war.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Yeoman-Class In England

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages

    To recapitulate, a class of "yeomen", or richer peasants, evolved in England because some members of the English peasantry underwent comparatively short-term sacrifice for long-term gain. As with any sociological classification, the notion of a yeoman-class does traverse several economic definitions. But at least three important identities are useful. First, a proven and hard-working ploughman was often selected to farm his lord's private land as a capitalist tenant-at-will. Second, many serfs had commuted their obligation to work for several days each month under their lord, by 'swapping' to other forms of payment.…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    African Americans have served in the military for hundreds of years; in fact there has been no war that African Americans have not participated in. African Americans chose to fight in wars for various reasons including proving their loyalty to America. Despite all of the motives in joining the Armed Forces and fighting for America, blacks faced segregation in the military. African Americans played a vital role in integrating the military, but when segregation ended in the military blacks faced another problem: racism. The downgrading of blacks plays a role in racism, which was a major problem for African Americans in the military.…

    • 1493 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    African-American not only faced injustices in everyday society but also in the military. During the commencement of World War I, a large portion of the African-American community saw the war as a chance to demonstrate their patriotism and to take their place as equal citizen in the United States (Williams OL). Over a million African-Americans responded to the draft calls they received and an estimate of 370,000 were inducted into the army to fight during World War I, the war that would make the world safe for democracy (Williams OL). Even though the African-Americans were risking their lives to fight the war, their ultimate goal was to secure a democracy in the US in which African-Americans and whites were treated equally. However, racial tensions…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the year 1914 the U.S Army had another opportunity to highlight how important to the survival of our national diversity really is. The United States Army found itself locked into a deadly war with Germany and needed Soldiers. It was during this war that African American men saw an opportunity to prove their loyalty, patriotism, and worthiness for equal treatment in the United States. (HISTORY, 2015) The Army much in need of troops was eager to oblige.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Before a Citizen decides to join the U.S. Army they have a preconceived notion of what an Army soldier is, what an Army soldier represents, and how life as a United States Army Soldier will be like. They contemplate how their friends, family, and the public will perceive them when they wear the uniform. Past and present Army leaders have worked diligently to form and maintain an Army image of disciplined, well trained, and true professional soldiers. Over the past 15 years, this outstanding image of Army Soldiers has dwindled to an image of soft, undisciplined, and lazy soldiers who care more about themselves and less about what it means to wear the uniform. The Army has brought forth an idea to combat this growing problem with a campaign…

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Informative Presentation Outline Topic: The Army as a Profession Specific purpose: To inform the audience about the Army and the opportunities that it holds Thesis: The general public has a certain perception about the Army believing that all aspects of the Army are combat related and after being informed they make the military an option in there career choice Introduction I. Attention-getting device: A lot of individuals have the common perception the Army is kicking down doors and taking names, but what most people fail to realize is that the Army as a profession has a lot more opportunities then one might think. A. Credibility Statement: For the past eight years I have dealt with some type of military training rather it being the four…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays