Holbach And Atheism

Great Essays
The metaphysical position with which Holbach is most often associated is a negative one: atheism. Although indeed Holbach devotes the entire second volume of Système de la nature and all of Le Bon Sens to the defense of atheism and the criticism of particular claims about God, his views do not hold great philosophical interest. They emphasize well worn topics such as the problem of evil, the impossibility of discussing intelligibly what is unknowable, the suspect psychological origins of religious belief, and the confusion of traditional descriptions of God in terms that are simply the negation of genuine descriptive terms: for example, to say that God is infinite is just to deny that God is finite. None of these arguments is unique to Holbach …show more content…
Materialistic accounts of human nature are often thought to fail just because human beings seem to have properties, such as thought and freedom, that matter does not have. In making matter a genus of varied beings, Holbach creates a view flexible enough to accommodate an account of human nature more robust than that of many other materialists:

…Man is, as a whole, the result of a certain combination of matter, endowed with particular properties, competent to give, capable of receiving, certain impulses, the arrangement of which is called organization, of which the essence is, to feel, to think, to act, to move, after a manner distinguished from other beings with which he can be compared. Man, therefore, ranks in an order, in a system, in a class by himself, which differs from that of other animals, in whom we do not perceive those properties of which he is possessed. [ System of Nature 15]
Holbach's naturalism requires that human nature be understood in terms of laws and that human action be comprehended under universal determinism. But it allows that, in many ways, human beings may differ in kind from other bodies, even animals, and it allows that human beings may have many properties, notably thought, that have traditionally been denied to
…show more content…
Matter can to some extent be understood the ordinary sense of anything that has extention, figure, and so on. However, because matter also may or may not have any number of properties not ordinarily understood to belong to matter, such as thought, it is not entirely clear what may not be matter. Motion is likewise and for similar reasons a vague term in Holbach. Where matter is understood simply as extension and some other very simple properties, motion may be thought of in similarly simple terms, as a velocity, acceleration or, perhaps, as an impulse with a certain direction. Once matter is thought of, after the manner of Holbach, as something with properties which are perhaps best not understood in spatial terms, its motion may be much more difficult to define. Although he sometimes speaks of matter and motion in narrower senses, Holbach's tendency is simply to identify matter and motion with the general terms cause and effect. Holbach typically identifies bodies with causes and motions with effects, but he also allows that motions may be

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    And if man is a physical object, therefore man must act according to those necessary and immutable laws of nature, Holbach writes this to give foundation to future arguments supporting his position. Holbach is a staunch supporter of determinism, and his beliefs are in complete opposition to free will. In order to evaluate…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “On Human Nature” Refutation David Hull’s “On Human Nature” is an article written to oppose human nature. Specifically, it challenges human evolution as the cause of universality/commonality of human traits. The case made in the article utilizes the logic behind Charles Darwin’s theory of natural selection: evolutionary changes come via the generation of variation in each generation and differential survival of individuals with different combinations of these varying traits. The central thesis of “On Human Nature” is that any common set of traits that people share is due to chance as opposed to the inner workings of evolution.…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although many understand the concept of human nature loosely, as an abstract idea that may or may not define what is means to be a human being, C.S. Lewis in The Abolition of Man, treats human nature as something serious and necessary, yet at risk of being pushed to the back of everyone’s minds and ultimately forgotten. Lewis’ work, which at first seems to be a critique of modern education, reaches into the depths of the human soul and tries to make sense of it. By taking a simple flaw in one literature book, he ascertains the direction in which human nature is going, where it should go and the consequences derived from both paths––which are either the elimination of or the infiniteness of the true nature of man. In the first chapter, Lewis references an English schoolbook–The Green Book, as he calls it–written by authors he names Gaius and Titius.…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Scientists are aware of our body composition including the complexity of our body parts. How we in fact see, hear, and feel is all explainable via scientific discoveries regarding the human body. To think that our spiritual body or soul is still able to see and hear is quite astonishing. Perhaps this further strengthens the acceptance of a soul and that as created beings we are more than the sum of our physical body parts, much, much more.…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In their writings, Descartes and Berkeley argue the nature of sensible objects. Sensible objects are what are perceivable to the mind. The nature of how these objects are perceived and if, what the mind perceives exists is the foundation of both Descartes and Berkeley’s arguments. Are sensible objects distinctly external matter that are perceived by the mind, or are they created within the distinct mind and perceived directly. The arguments are related to Descartes and Berkeley’s different stances on rationalism and empiricism, or if our minds identify knowledge of sensible objects through experience or innate knowledge.…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What does it mean to be human? Being human and what it takes to be human is often taken for granted. This question is not something we question daily, monthly, or yearly. We often just accept that we are human and leave it at that. In both Alan Moore’s Watchmen and Franz Kafka’s…

    • 1659 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    To understand the notions put forward by Eduardo Kohn in ‘How Forests Think’, our anthropologic views must first be deconstructed. It is only after this that we begin to see ‘beyond the human’; as Kohn describes, it is a “kind of thinking that grows” (2013:27). Set out in six coherent chapters, Kohn begins by introducing familiar anthropological concepts. His exploration of semiotic dynamic, and how symbols and language are unique to humans, remind us of the well-known concept of homosapien dominance over other species. It is however, as we are introduced to various semiotic concepts within the sub-sections of each chapter, that these familiar notions slowly start to morph into more complex ideas.…

    • 1461 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Intellect:Mind over Matter, Mortimer Adler probes the relationship between the mind and the body. He describes the four main theories regarding this relationship and separates them into two categories: extreme and moderate. Among the four theories, Adler argues in favor of moderate immaterialism. His argument is easily the most convincing as it accounts for the essential difference between man and animal, our intellect, while acknowledging the congruity between the mind and body.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Galileo Galilei’s essay called “Corpuscularianism” from his book The Assayer offers an extensive argument supporting his belief that motion is the cause of heat. He describes the key role motion plays in creating heat through pointing out how motion affects the other senses such as taste and smell. However, Galilei’s stance does not come without opposition, as I will criticize his over-simplistic and contradictory explanation for how we sense the world around us. Galileo begins by differentiating between primary and secondary qualities. He states that objects necessarily have shape, size, place, motion, contact, and number (primary qualities,) but they do not necessarily have color, taste, sound, smell, or feel (secondary qualities.)…

    • 1395 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Endeavouring toward invulnerability, the beasts and brutes of this world have, in the whirling of the clock's hand, endured the voyage. To pardon from perils, one may see themself to countenancing in miscreant affairs so as their legacy reach the morrow. Love, to be enamoured with one; the handling to a continuance of the species. Dominion; admission to security. Power is such; a securing of a mate.…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Human is the most complex creature. Scientist Throughout the ages seek to know more about the human nature. They made lots of theories and hypotheses to know more about Human soul. In the human there are lots of conflicts, feelings, dreams, thoughts and moralities. One of the most famous scientists that cared about the human soul is Freud.…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Joseph Johnson Mason Tattersall History 103 Wednesday October 19th Condorcet’s versus Kierkegaard’s texts Through the historical study of human thought development, the aim of Condorcet was to point out the way towards the improvement of human condition. Condorcet was focused on the material and social wellbeing of a man, his writing consist of nine major epochs talking about the past and the 10th one which is focused on the future destiny of man. However, while his description of man and his progress has time dependence running it, with advances in human understanding and materialism, it is clear according to Condorcet that progress is uneven (Caritat and Marie Jean Antoine Nicolas 5). This is not a simple view of human conditions…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sometimes it is easier to blame other for our wrongdoings, than to admit to oneself and taking full responsibility for our own actions. In the book Existentialism and Human Emotions, the author, Jean-Paul Sartre address the statement, “existence precedes essence” and makes two logical conclusions such as freedom and responsibility that ties to the concepts of anguish, forlornness, and despair. The understanding of “existentialism precedes essence” is an awareness that there is no predefined pattern for human beings that we must fit into, therefore, every choice we make or do not make is composed by own our decision and judgement. Sartre claims implicates that we create our own meaning, and place our own values on our acts. Although admitting a truth about oneself and taking full responsibility of our own actions is sometimes a tough understanding to endure, it is still agreeable that existentialism is an optimistic philosophy due to the idea that we have still have this freedom to make our own decisions.…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hebrew Bible Thesis

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Brief Paper Senior Seminar in Interdisciplinary Studies Dr. Packer Eric G. Shuping March 23, 2015 Brief Paper The Hebrew Bible shows us the creation of Heaven and Earth created by God. Human nature proves to us the Hebrew Bible does not allow human beings to act independently or having the freedom to do so without answering to the Creator of heaven and earth.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The philosophical debate as to whether the human mind is a purely physical substance or a non-physical substance is an argument that has been around for centuries. Philosophers around the world have formulated a multitude of responses to the debacle, but none of the arguments have been universally accepted at this time. The debate has two main viewpoints. The first being the monistic view of the mind-body problem where the mind is a non-physical substance and the second being the dualism view of physicalism where the mind is a physical substance (Herrick). In this paper, I will favor and argue for the view that the mind is non-physical substance.…

    • 1122 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays