Ethical Dilemma In School Counseling

Improved Essays
This paper will be centered on an ethical dilemma involving a 7th grade boy named John who was suicidal, and was not given the proper care by his school counselor. To solve this ethical dilemma, the ethical decision making model will be used to apply it by going through six steps. First, to get to the root of the issue in this ethical dilemma, the problem needs to be identified and to see whether this is an ethical, legal, professional, or clinical issue. Since the ethical dilemma has something to do with school counseling, the ASCA ethical standards for school counselors will be used to see which codes the school counselor did not follow. The nature and dimensions of the dilemma will also be determined along with the moral principles and professional …show more content…
After talking with John for many sessions, the school counselor assess that John was at risk of committing suicide. The school counselor did do the right thing by contacting John’s parents letting them know what was going on but instead of helping John any further; the counselor printed a resource list for John’s parents that included community mental health counselors. After reviewing this dilemma, the problem that is presented was that the school counselor failed to continue to exercise the duty to protect John even though the counselor did assessed that he was at risk of suicide. What is also part of the problem is that the school counselor did not take the proper precautions by helping John any further such as coming up with an intervention plan on how to prevent him from committing suicide. Corey, Corey, Corey, & Callanan (2015) mentioned in the text that if a counselor determines that a client is at risk of suicide, then they should do everything as a professional to take the right steps to help that person and prevent them from harming themselves as well. The text also mentions that when a counselor assess the client is at risk of suicide, then they should make sure that their keeping a close eye on them since anything can go …show more content…
If John did not get the help that he properly needed from the school counselor, the counselor is held liable for whatever happens to him. This dilemma would be viewed as an ethical problem because the school counselor did not continue to work with John and referred him to other mental health counselors instead without providing proper care. It will also be a legal problem because if John was to commit suicide, then chances are a malpractice claim given to them since they have the legal duty to protect him. Not only the school counselor will be held liable for John being at risk of suicide, the problem is also related to the school which is also held liable given that maybe other staff members did not do enough to attend to John when he needed the proper care even though there was a teacher of his to rely

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Counselors are faced with many situations that test their moral and ethical beliefs. Although there are numerous guides for counselors to follow, none can offer absolute solutions to every scenario. Some situation, no matter the course of action, may have consequences that may harm the counseling relationship. However, “A practitioner’s guide to ethical decision making”, by the American Counseling Association (ACA) offers a seven step decision making model that will help counselors with the challenges of ethical dilemmas (Forester-Miller & Davis, 1996). This paper will use the decision making model to analyze scenario 2.…

    • 2130 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Comparing Codes of Ethics The very nature of the counseling profession places professional counselors in close proximity with people, information, and influence. Due to this, ethical dilemmas can arise throughout the course of this work. To help aid in the protection of counselors, and to provide a framework for ethical practice, ethical codes have been developed and instituted within the profession. As Beuchamp and Childress stated (as cited in Calley, 2009), “in the counseling profession, ethical standards are required to protect clients, guide professional behavior, ensure the autonomy of professionals, increase the status of the profession, enhance the client 's and the community 's trust in the profession, and articulate collegial conduct between professionals,” (p. 476).…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Counseling adolescents is very different then counseling adults and I would have liked to learn more on how to help them through the crisis of suicide. We all know that cyberbullying is a major factor to teenage and adolescent suicide due to all of the social media outlets. Dr. Wright (2011) did discuss with his readers on how to help individuals thinking of committing suicide. However, I wish that he would have touched on how to handle suicide and suicidal ideations when dealing with…

    • 2012 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kast went on to consult with another trained professional, the school’s psychologist. The psychologist expressed concerns for the situation of the opinion that Mrs. Kast should inform the principal. The principal instructed Mrs. Kast to not immediately call Child Protective Services. The principal then proposed an alternative: an after-school meeting with the counselor, the school psychologist, classroom teacher as well the principal to discuss the situation and take the appropriate measures. Mrs. Kast is now presented with two ethical dilemmas, breach client confidentiality and share information with the others or not calling authorities regarding Jane’s safety.…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After reading this case study, It seems prevalent that throughout case 7 that the theme that stemmed from Martin’s frustration. It was from there that his frusteration hampered his performance as a counselor. From a beginning counselor having the difficulty to find clients to the slippery slope situation from HealthCo and making questionable decisions, Martin has had enough with everything that was happening to him. That is why it was best for him to consult with other experienced counselors or peer consultation group that may have a similar situation in which Martin could vent his frustration. That way it would have helped by providing him with guidance and direction regarding of handling the situation in an ethical manner.…

    • 118 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    John's Parents Case Study

    • 138 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Following the action of calling Johns parents, providing referrals, creating a safety plan, and John leaving with his parents the counselor should document what occurred and the actions taken. The counselor should also discuss with colleagues what the next steps would be. The school counselor should schedule individual sessions with John for when he returns to school. These individual sessions with help build the therapeutic relationship back up. Ensure that John is able to keep up with schoolwork, create goals, and having positive coping skills.…

    • 138 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ethical Case Analysis Six In this scenario, my client, a self-employed plumber who reports that current business is slow for him, requests that I, as his counselor, allow him to provide me with plumbing services such as new fixtures and repairs in a home a recently purchased in exchange for approximately six month’s worth of session to address his adjustment disorder. This case brings up ethical concerns about fees and payment. Bartering counseling services for services/goods as payment from the client, when requested by the client, is an acceptable ethical practice. However, it is important that the exchange does not result in exploitation, particularly of the client, but of the counselor as well.…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ethical implications of a counselor expressing their values to a client Young, Scott, Craig, and Cashwell (2016) explain that it is often difficult for a person to exist and work in a manner that is value-neutral. According to Young, Scott, Craig, and Cashwell, 2016, value-neutral is a term in psychotherapy used to explain the goal of not changing the value of a client to match that of a professional, by assuming that the values of the professional are preferable. Although counselors often have their set of values, just like other people have, it is important that they understand that the goal of counseling is to ensure that a client examines his/her value systems and beliefs and make decisions accordingly. According to ACA code of ethics (2014), Section A.4.b., explains that counselors should refrain from imposing their values, behaviors, and beliefs.…

    • 1258 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    School psychologist focus on providing a healthy, safe, and equal opportunity environment for all children in her or her school(s). In order to guarantee that this is done in a practical manner, NASP and APA have established ethical standards. The reading suggests that having ethical guidelines assures that students receiving services from a school psychologist are valuable; thus, the community develops a confidence in these services. School psychologist must ensure that client information remains confidential, continuously adapt to new ideas, and only offer services that in which they have received training.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Counselors in the community and in the school setting will face ethical dilemmas throughout their time as counselors. Some ethical dilemmas can be simple to figure our by looking at the code of ethics and talking to colleagues. However there will be some during a counselor’s career that are not so simple such as when and how to break confidentiality with a client and who all needs to know when a client is experiencing suicidal ideation. The case that will be discussed throughout this paper involves a seventh grade student named John. A teacher referred John to the school counselor.…

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    STEP Solution Model

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Introduction The following is an ethical case study involving a school counselor, Agatha, and her student, Eustace. In solving this ethical dilemma, Agatha will apply the STEP solution model, created by the American Counseling Association (2001). The steps in which Agatha uses are as follows: 1.) Define the problem emotionally and intellectually, 2.)…

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Josh J Case Study

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Concepts In the period of early adolescence, youth face various concepts in development. In the case study, Josh J. has many protective factors that will aid him in making healthy decisions in later development. In this section, the concepts that were reviewed in relation to Josh J. are depression and suicide, sexual decision-making, substance use and abuse, bullying, and his relationship with school. Depression and suicide. Josh J. is beginning to express a need for autonomy from families and wanting to spend more time with friends.…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Suicide Analysis

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The final perspective included in this essay takes on suicide prevention as a public health problem rather than simply a mental health illness. In the article, "CDC Grand Rounds: Preventing Suicide Through a Comprehensive Public Health Approach," suicide is a manifestation of outside factors instead of solely being affected by mental health (894). It is manifested from multiple factors such as family history, environmental influences, along with the person's mental health. Specifically mentioned in this article is that increasing awareness of suicide is crucial in suicide prevention because it decreases the negative connotation given to suicide. This step is also outlined in great detail in Jason Healey's book, Suicide Prevention, where a procedure is detailed for individuals who believe they need to communicate suicide to a younger child who may notice their friend acting strange (35-36).…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics plays a vitally important role in any career counselling process and there are various different aspects that need to be taken into consideration to not only protect the client but also to protect the career counsellor themselves. In the case of Jennifer, the main areas relating to ethical practice focus around confidentiality, accredited use of assessments, informed consent as well as protection of personal information. In terms of confidentiality, all information obtained during the process of career counselling needs to remain confidential between the client themselves and the career counsellor. Only in exceptional circumstances such as a request from the court of law may this confidential information be divulged.…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Suicide is a really serious problem that impacts everyone, even the youth. “Suicide is the third leading cause of death for people between the ages of ten and twenty four “(Ashford). It results in approximately four thousand six hundred deaths each year, but even though mental health administrators suggested widespread screening for suicides and mental illness for students in 2003 (Freidman), “only less than two percent of schools have a mental health screening program” (Briggs). All schools should offer mental health screenings for its students as it can help professionals and parents in the early identification of teens at risk for depression and suicidal impulses because unless there is more awareness and prevention, suicide will carry on to take the lives of the young. All schools are in a significant position to…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays