Discursive Negotiation Of Family Identity

Improved Essays
The main questions that I want to address are, “Why do adopted children not receive equal attention from their family and have a difficult time finding a sense of belonging as compared to those of birth children”? An example of a case study that I can use is United States families with adopted children from China. I found a case study called “Discursive Negotiation of Family Identity: A Study of U.S. Families with Adopted Children from China”. The bibliography information is below.
Suter, Elizabeth A. "Discursive Negotiation of Family Identity: A Study of U.S. Families with Adopted Children from China." Family Communication 8.2 (2008): 126-47. EBSCOHost. Web. 7 Oct. 2015.
It is a journal article. The author is an associate professor and the
…show more content…
The main argument seems to address the more difficult process in finding a sense of family identity of adopted children than those not adopted. It also gives feedback of parents of adoptees in how they perceive their adopted children as part of their own. There are many sources that support Suter’s research about the interactions between adoptees and their families. The most important source that is not scholarly is the participants in the study itself. The participants are a primary source to the topic that I am addressing.
Two sources are “Family Communication: Cohesion and Change, Ninth Edition” by Kathleen Galvin and “Discourse About Adoption in Adoptive Families” by Kenneth Kaye and Sarah Warren. Galvin is cited multiple times in this journal article. She seems to give an overview in a scholar’s terms and giving support to what Suter’s journal is saying. It is a good source for my
…show more content…
Brommel. Family Communication: Cohesion and Change. 9th ed. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman, 1986. Print.
This source is a book. Galvin has a Ph.D. in communication studies from Northwestern University and was an associate dean of the school of communication.
Kaye, Kenneth, and Sarah Warren. "Discourse about Adoption in Adoptive Families." Journal of Family Psychology 1.4 (1988): 406-33. EBSCOHost. Web. 7 Oct. 2015.
This source is a journal article. Kaye has a Ph.D. in virology from Harvard University and is currently an associate professor of medicine at Harvard

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Martin Rammo Mr. Brazzel ENG 102 – Final Essay MLA 30 April 2016 Open Adoption "You planted your garden; you have to live in it". Those were the words of Moriah Dialer, an unmarried 19 years old pregnant woman. She was a college dropout, working as a waitress in West Virginia. After getting pregnant, Moriah considered having an abortion. She didn't have any money, and her parents wouldn't pay for the procedure.…

    • 2336 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyone loves a heartwarming adoption story, but many people and our government believe that a family should be kept together at all costs. The United States spends millions of dollars each year on foster care, parenting classes, and legal costs to keep children with their biological parents or relatives. UNICEF also spends millions of dollars internationally to keep children in their home countries, even though those children may spend their childhoods in an orphanage until they age out of the system. People assume that domestic and international adoption are broken systems and sometimes they are. For example, people may adopt a child and be unprepared for the physical, psychological, medical, and social challenges that child may carry…

    • 1307 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Adoption implies an opportunity to be desired, adored, and appreciated despite the flaws you have, removing the misery of living alone and placing the blissful feelings of being surrounded by a family. Annually, thousands of children enter the foster care system and wait with anticipation for their chance of having a family again. According to UNICEF, the number of orphans globally in 2008 was approximated to be 132 million orphans. Hence for decreasing this enormous number, adoption should be encouraged and supported so orphans could find a better future and accumulate a better life. In other words, we should support different types of adoption like transracial, special needs children, and international adoption.…

    • 131 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In contrast, some people do not think adoption records should be open to the adoptee because birth parents may not want to be found. Birth parents have multiple considerations to make during the adoption process, especially choosing whether or not to keep their records open. For instance, it is possible a mother may desire a closed adoption if the pregnancy was unplanned, and the birth father decided to leave. The birth mother may not want the child to know the father left them. Miriam Reitz, a therapist with a PhD in Marriage and Family Counseling, stated, in the past, “The birth mother could go on with her life as though she never had given birth.…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Relative adoption is when an immediate family member adopts children placed in foster care. This includes, siblings, nieces, nephews and grandchildren. This process is less complicated than normal adoption procedures and termination of parental rights by birth parents is still required (Mintzer, Relative, 2003, 243). Also, with relative adoption, the adoptive parents have general knowledge about the birth parents and the situation which caused the children to be placed in a foster home or relative care. Birth parents may feel a sense of ease knowing that their children are placed with someone they know and trust (244).…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Adopting a child fulfills the need to adopt that child, and occasionally creates a trend for other people to follow. The author of these journals presents this information ever so well, “It brings unwanted and needy children to caring parents. It also fulfils the need of childless couples to accomplish the important stage of parenthood in their life. And adoption relieves the burden of communities to care for abandoned children. Nourished with attention and buffered against racism, children flourish in most circumstances, including transcultural or transracial adoptive homes” (Failinger p.529).…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Adoption Infertility

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Eventually, the couple comes to a conclusion that they just want to become parents, and it does not matter how. A great effect of adoption for the adoptive mother is the opportunity to observe and experience aspects of pregnancy. Birth parents choosing adoption before their child is born can select potential parents for their child, and the adoptive parents can follow the birth mother through her journey. Following the pregnancy can be a great experience for both the adoptive mother and birth mother. During this time, the adoptive couple is there supporting the birth mother, and the adoptive mother experiences pregnancy in a different aspect which is helpful because she doesn't go through the pregnancy herself.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dr. David Olson’s Circumplex Model (1999) defines the three dimensions in which a family functions: family cohesion, adaptability, and communication (p. 2). She balanced her busy work schedule with family time, creating a separated and connected relationship. Despite the unavoidable roles she inherited as a single parent, my mother made decisions carefully and consulted family or friends whenever she needed help. Finally, my mother was effective in stating and enforcing rules, as well as allowing effective communication from her children.…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Even a child who is separated at birth will carry feelings of abandonment which can lead to a low self-image-- self-worth, if not dealt with properly. Erik Erikson’s theory has been questioned as to how relevant it may be for people of all racial, cultural and ethnic backgrounds. This paper will look into the relevance of Erikson 's theory as it may pertain to adopted children and give insight into how being adopted can hinder developmental stages, especially during adolescence when they are developing a sense of identity. In this author 's experience, there is much to be learned about the difficulties of growing up as an adopted child.…

    • 2008 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1% of white women adopt black children, 5% of white women adopt children of other races, and 2% of women of other races adopt white children (Stolley). In adoptions worldwide parents look for potential children to help grow and teach, but in some cases they also help themselves to make themselves look better and have a better image. In Moyer, Griego and Callahan’s article, they state the perks of interracial adoption and some personal stories behind the process. In contrast, Cho and Yung argue against all ideas of interracial adoption. All together, interracial adoption is the concept of whether or not a parent is not only looking for physical features of their next potential child, but on what the parent will be viewed as, as well.…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Adoption Journey When a couple has an emotional journey trying to have their own biological children, but at the end they were unable to, they may consider adopting a child of their own. Although adopt a child may not be same as having their own biological child, they are still able to provide the same amount love and care to their adopted child as they would have given to their own biological child. By adopting they can give the child a better life; however, there are some up and down of adopting. When a couple makes the decision to adopt a child, the challenges affect both the adoptive parents and the adoptees, but the challenges are more impactful to the adoptee. Adoption has a long history.…

    • 1883 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, the debate whether adopted children should access their biological parents has raged. Proponents of the decision argue that the transferring of parental rights does not provide basis for denying children information crucial to tracing their parents. When children are perceived to be sufficiently mature to process such information, they should be informed of their origin. The implication is that there is room for reconciliation and cohesive bond creation among all parties. Considering the plethora of reasons why children are put up for adoption, children who are given the choice to access their parents or not are highly probable to be psychologically content and other accompanying benefits, for instance, cultural and social knowledge of one’s origin that makes individuals…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For decades in psychology one topic that has always sparked an interest with researchers are the inner workings of the family dynamic. As a result of that interest a significant amount of research has been done. From this research psychologists figured out the best interventions, which can be implemented in order to improve the life of…

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine growing up with another mother, father, or no one at all. Consider the thoughts of being aware that someone gave up a child. Today, there are numerous of children either living inside a foster home or with someone other than their biological family. The act of adoption gives an opportunity for these children to be placed with a family with open arms. Based on The Gale Encyclopedia of Children’s Health: Infancy through Adolescence, adoption serves to provide children under eighteen with a permanent, legal, or non-biological parent(s) after the child has been legally relinquished at birth, orphaned, or legally removed from the custody of an unsuitable parent(s).…

    • 1557 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Obviously, the more time spent on working, the less time is left for family (Hamilton and Denniss, 2005, p.18) Also, after a whole day work, the energy for the family is little (Hamilton and Denniss, 2005, p.18). The lack of communication with family, especially with children affects the relationship. Researchers are concerned that little communication between pairs has a close link with lower level of marital satisfaction and increasing divorce rate (Quick, Henley and Quick, 2005, p.31). Furthermore, as we all know, the communication with parents is important for children during the period of their growth.…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays