Death Of A Salesman Dialectical Journal

Improved Essays
What were your first thoughts when you read this? And then? And then?
My first thoughts when I read this were the realization of where Willy’s stress and frustration stems from. He feels that his father and brother were so much more accomplished than him. Their successes in difficult environments in many ways appears to emasculate Willy. Although he has a great superiority complex when it comes to others, such as Charley when he comes to visit, when Willy speaks to his brother in a hallucination-like state, he acts completely submissive. It’s obvious that his brother and father have a strong, dominating hold over him postmortem. My second thought was the realization that this is why he is so hard on his children, especially Biff. He feels that
…show more content…
Throughout the play, music is played, majorly flute music. Although at first, such appears to be only a cinematic choice, the mention of Willy’s father’s flute playing makes it all the more symbolic. Like how the thoughts of his father are constantly plaguing Willy, music similar to what his father might have played haunts the play from beginning to end. The fact that Willy barely knew his father aside from stories from Ben and faint, blurry memories, makes this haunting presence interesting. Willy constantly longs for what his dad had, even though he doesn’t personally know what exactly his father attained. This only adds to the impossibility of Willy’s hopes and desires. He shoots for what he does not understand, and therefore his goals are not solid nor truly attainable. In the flashbacks it is also notable that many, like this one, are largely taken up by the presence of his brother, Ben. Although Willy would have minimally seen his brother who was generally in other places, such as Alaska and Africa, accumulating wealth, nearly all of Willy’s flashbacks center on Ben. Throughout them, Ben has a domineering hold over Willy. Ben’s monopoly over Willy’s memories and flashbacks shows that, even though he is dead, he still has a similar dominant hold over Willy’s conscious. This hold is maintained by Willy’s desire for what Ben has. Once again, it must be brought up that Willy has no means of fully understanding Ben’s life or what he has. He knew little aside from the stories of greatness on Ben’s occasional visits. Therefore Willy has, by constantly comparing himself to two uncomparable people, set himself up for misery and failure. Goals that are not solid cannot be achieved. It is like New Year’s Resolutions. If someone sets a specific goal, such as working out 4 times a week, that is potentially achievable;

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    o Willy recalls past memories of his sons o Biff tells his father that he borrowed a football from the locker room to practice with o Willy says that he will open a bigger business than Uncle Charley since he (willy) is “well-liked” o Charley sons, Bernard, tells Biff to come and study math with him o After Bernard left, Willy asks Biff is he’s liked, and Biff explains that he’s like but not well liked, which makes willy come to the conclusion that his sons will be more successful since they are “well liked” o Willy is still stuck daydreaming about fifteen years ago and tells Linda how he made $1200 o Linda takes out her notepad and calculates that he made over $200 commission; but later tells (without Linda even questioning) he grossed $200 and only made a commission of $70 o Willy feels discouraged and tells Linda that nobody likes him, he talks and jokes too much; Linda tells him that he is successful o Willy compares himself to Charles and says that he’s successful because he doesn’t talk and joke as much; Willy is jealous of…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This quote is significant because part of it shows Willy’s regret for not following his older brother and thinking of the success and money he could’ve had, the money that would help give his family the life he wanted to give them. Another reason to its significance is…

    • 186 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fred Ribkoff Guilt

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages

    By saying this, it displays how he feels extreme guilt for what he has done to not only Linda, but to his whole family, especially Biff. Biff witnessed what Willy wish he hadn't and that mistake has haunted him ever since. Willy battles with himself and it results in him killing himself. He is not able to handle the voices that…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Since he can not live out the life he desires, or provide for his family as he has expected himself to, he has grown used to creating his own fictional life in his mind. In fact, Willy often convinces himself that his delusions are an actual representation of his life and his family. After the audience becomes aware of this, they are able to better understand Willy as a whole and why he speaks contradictory to himself. The audience also realizes why there are broken relationships between him and the members of his family. Without this knowledge of Willy’s tendencies, the text becomes extremely confusing and seems disconnected to the…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mistakes Of Willy's Life

    • 1401 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Willy is one character who craves for the attention and is aided by the desire for success. In his daily interactions, he continually refers to his elder brother Ben that fortunately made it through diamond mining just because he represents all the things he desires (Kirszner and Mandell, 2012). Willy desires much more for himself as well as his children even though he does not put up measures to achieve the same things that the individuals he desires have managed to undergone. The entire play shows the character of Willy, with the plot demonstrating the role that he plays. Willy is unfaithful to his wife, after being fired from the company he contributed in the building he regrets he is regret and overwhelmed by thoughts (Kirszner and Mandell, 2012).…

    • 1401 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Gang Research Paper

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Blood running down cristian body while getting stabbed 40 times by local gang members with a machete, Christian an 18 year old boy trying to run away from a gang, because they were in search of killing him. Cristian was pulled into the woods by a young lady who promised him sex if he came into the woods, but little did he know it was all a plan three gang members came out of the bushes, hold him down and stabbed him repeatedly 40 times to make sure he was completely dead, Christian was killed for the reason of giving inside information to the cops, Their loyalty to the gang was too strong, because of the sense family they have for each other, they decided he must die, and protect their family formerly known as a gang to the outside world.…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Willy was disappointed with his life and the life he has provided for his family. After learning about how the interview went between Biff and his former employer, Willy was upset and argued with Biff about not living up to his expectations in the business world. Willy’s life was spiraling downhill. After all of his disappointments he thought he would be worth more dead than alive and that his…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Willy Loman Failure

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Willy becomes jealous of Charlie’s achievements, maybe because Willy never obtained the American Dream he desperately chased his whole life. Charlie appears to be a caring neighbor for Willy, even paying for Willy’s bills when he can no longer pay for his own. Willy refuses to show Charlie any respect despite his kindness towards Willy, until in the last parts of the play when he comes to the realization that Charlie might be his own real friend left. Charlie also acts as the character of commonsense and reason, even proposing a reasonable solution to Willy’s financial…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At first glance Willy Loman's ideal of the American dream is prospering in his chosen career of being a salesman in the United States. The tale goes on showing that throughout Willy's younger days he was more prosperous and self-confident which could be seen as to why throughout the play he revisits the past. One recurring person in Willy's daydreams of the past is his older brother, Ben, that he idealized till the very end. As his situation in life became worse Willy seems to over-idealize his deceased, older brother and his success as seen when he asks his brother for guidance, "Ben, am I right? Don't…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    American Dream Analysis

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages

    He dreamt and longed to be popular and well liked because why else would he lie to his family and Charley that he is popular. He told his boys that he had met the mayor and how the cops protected his car like their own, but he is wrong to go after this dream of popularity since in reality he is not liked at all. He told Linda that “people don’t seem to take”[pg.28] to him, they “laugh”[pg.28] at him and he is “not noticed”[pg.28]. The word ‘laugh’ insinuated the fact that people thought he was foolish and do not take him seriously. However Willy only revealed this self reflection for a few pages in the book, and then continued with his delusions.…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He further ends up betraying his son’s dreams because of his obsession with success, highlighted by his need to dictate the career paths they should take to be well off. All these points to the aforementioned statement; that Willy’s death is avoidable, that his suicide cannot be attributed…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His complexity comes from his unmoving characteristics with the opinions of others, the stubbornness and desperate nature that contradicts itself in his life. This can be seen with his interactions with Howard and his internal conflict of losing his job. As Willy attempts to reason with Howard his desperate nature emerges to simply, “set [his] table [with] fifty dollars a week,” which was a dramatic change from the sixty-five he was asking for a few lines before and more than the forty he asks for in later lines (Miller). As the lines continue Willy’s scene cues even come with notes such as, “desperately” and “desperation is on him now” (Miller). More of the stubborn side of his nature is revealed after Howard fires him and tells him to take, “a good long rest” (Miller).…

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    You can tell though that he is fighting to communicate over to his brother and doesn’t care about Charley, as he is questioning him but he doesn’t even care to answer his question. The appearance of Ben allowed for Willy to escape the situation he was in with Charley. The harassment he received from Charley was enough of a strain on Willy that he snapped and caused himself to move away into the illusion. The buildup of these situations causes further problems to his mental state. The problems reached an extent where his illusion started having its own sadistic thoughts and tempts Willy with the profits of suicide.…

    • 2132 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Death of a Salesman Essay

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When Willy dies this breed of gentleman passes. Sadly, Willy never realises the coming news. As a result he drifts slowly into obscurity throughout the play. Willy experiences the problems because of his debts. His perspective of his possessions goes down hill.…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although Willy loves his sons dearly, he is unable to get loved by them. When Biff calls Willy a “phony little fake” (Miller 121), Willy can not restrain that memory. He is not able to bear the fact that he is alone responsible for his son’s failure. “Depressed people have a tendency to blame themselves for the bad things that happen to them” (Silverstein 63). Willy is also in this state of guilt.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays