Duplication. The Robot Reply is when the computer gains access to things like cameras, and can better detect the Chinese symbols it being fed. The idea is that if the robot could interact with the environment, then could it have thoughts. The answer is no because it’s just another way the robot can manipulate the syntax to come up with an accurate response but still lacks understanding. The System Reply is when the human working the machine doesn’t know Chinese but the system does. This still proves his point that computers don’t have mental states because the computer is only working with the syntax and creating an output based off the input. Stimulation Vs. Duplication is the idea that computers don’t have any feelings like feeling fear or pain, but it can generate a correct response based off the program that is made by someone who has felt real
Duplication. The Robot Reply is when the computer gains access to things like cameras, and can better detect the Chinese symbols it being fed. The idea is that if the robot could interact with the environment, then could it have thoughts. The answer is no because it’s just another way the robot can manipulate the syntax to come up with an accurate response but still lacks understanding. The System Reply is when the human working the machine doesn’t know Chinese but the system does. This still proves his point that computers don’t have mental states because the computer is only working with the syntax and creating an output based off the input. Stimulation Vs. Duplication is the idea that computers don’t have any feelings like feeling fear or pain, but it can generate a correct response based off the program that is made by someone who has felt real