Arguments For The Articles Of Confederation

Superior Essays
Lauri Krause
November 12, 2016
HIS 131 01
The Articles of Confederation After the United States declared independence from Britain, members of the Continental Congress wanted to create a permanent national government with a written constitution. John Dickinson was given the task to draft the Articles of Confederation. This draft made it clear that Dickinson supported a strong central government, and thus the states debated and revised the Articles of Confederation for over a year creating a weak central government instead. The desire for a weak central government with most of the power given to the individual states stemmed from the tumultuous relationship the United States had with Britain under Britain’s rule. Eventually the Continental
…show more content…
The national government could conduct foreign affairs and did limit the states’ rights to do so under Article VI of the Articles of Confederation. However, this was difficult to enforce as proved by Georgia when they engaged in their own foreign policies and threatening war against the Spanish in response to Native American attacks and harboring slaves. Furthermore, the Articles prevented the national government from being able to enforce the Treaty of Paris of 1783, which the states ignored paying back pre-Revolutionary debts to Britain and in turn British forts remained occupied in the Great Lakes region.
The Northwest Ordinance of 1787 proved to be the most important provision under the Articles of Confederation. The Northwest Ordinance created a structure and process for territories to be admitted into the United States as a state. Slavery was prohibited in the Northwest territory, which southern states supported and food production took off in that region. The most significant part of the Northwest Ordinance was the protection and freedoms for eligible people through a bill of rights. These rights are found today under the Bill of Rights, which are the first 10 amendments of the United States
…show more content…
This convention had low attendance with only representatives from five states attending. This did not stop the members at this convention from discussing the flaws of the Articles of Confederation. Shay’s Rebellion was recently put down and fresh in everyone’s mind, and was a strong indicator to Congress that the Articles of Confederation needed to be amended. During the Annapolis Convention, Alexander Hamilton called for another convention to amend the Articles of Confederation due to its numerous defects. The Constitution Convention met in Philadelphia in May 1787 and it was there that Congress decided to create a new form of government that would be stronger under a completely new constitution, drafting the United States Constitution. The United States’ first attempt at government under the Articles of Confederation failed. However, without the countless flaws and headaches experienced under the Articles, the United States Constitution would not be as great as it is and the world’s oldest written constitution still in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The articles of confederation was the Untied States first attempt at creating a democratic government. Meaning instead of giving power to the central government they decided to divide it up with different states. But it all wasn't good, congress had trouble passing laws due to the fact that 9 of the 13 states had to agree before any laws could be passed (Doc 1). Congress did not have the power to collect the taxes needed to pay for the expense of the national government (Doc 2). Also the states refused to give the national government enough power to work correctly.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After the battle of the 13 colonies and a successful independence from the British monarchy, the Articles of Confederation became the great experiment to achieve freedom to all citizens of America. Establishing the first constitution was a call against monarchy or any privileged aristocrats who were looking for total dominance. Nevertheless, as every first experiment, the Articles of Confederation had critical defects such as a deficiency of central government to help or defend the well-being of its citizens. Monarchy was one of greatest fears to the early independent colonies. As a result, the Articles of Confederation created a constitution that was made to prevent the central government from tyrannical views thus give the power to the…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Articles of confederation was a disaster simply because it had no central power, it was all independence. In the Articles of Confederation the state government had all the power, like voting, which was unfair to the people because to get anything past you had to have a 9 out of 13 states to pass that particular law. Also under the Articles of Confederation there was no stable judiciary system, there was no National Court System, they only had Congress…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Neutrality was seen by Washington as the only way to prevent the United States from being harmed in a costly global war and preventing eventual instabilities that occur with war. The Pinckney Treaty was a treaty with Spain that secured United States rights to use the Spanish Port of New Orleans for economic trade from farmers in the Mississippi and Ohio River Valleys. The Pinckney Treaty largely helped farmers gain economic prosperity which help to stabilize the western states economically. In order to fix the problem of foreign and domestic debts and the north vs south destabilizing arguments on the issue, the Compromise of 1790 was reached between the Federalist of the north and Democrat-Republicans of the south. The Compromise of 1790 allowed the Federal government to assume the states’ debts, creation of the First National bank and national taxes, and the moving of the Federal Capital to a more southern location.…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Additionally, in “What You Should Know about the Articles of Confederation (Secondary Source)” by Martin Kelly, it articulates, “In 1786, Shays' Rebellion occurred in western Massachusetts as a protest to rising debt and economic chaos. However, the national government was unable to gather a combined military force amongst the states to help put down the rebellion.” Here, the Constitution would be a more efficient form of government because the national government would have the power to stop these riots. However, under the Articles, the national governors had no way of putting a stop to the…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The 1780’s were a tough time for the America’s. America had recently declared itself independent from the British and were ending the Revolutionary War in the early 1780’s. The Articles of Confederation was drafted and put into effect in 1781. The Articles of Confederation was created due to the war going on because they needed unity between all the states in order to fend off the foreign forces. Upon the creation of the Articles of Confederation, there were many upsides to it but there were struggles with this type of weak government that led to its failure and the creation of a new document that we are all familiar with today, the Constitution.…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Under the Articles of Confederation, the government was not completely effective because of the power imbalance, the nation's needs not being met, and financial struggles. Congress did not have strength over the people to enforce laws; the citizens desired a less powerful government after the harsh rule the British government enforced on them previously. They got a weaker government, but the Congress lost its authority to rule over the states. Citizens felt that the government lacked in stability and unable to deal with the nation's problems. A military was a basic need for the states, but because of the cost, congress struggled to pay for one.…

    • 209 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the United States had just declared their independence, it was clear that governmental structure needed to be established. In 1777, the Continental Congress adopted the Articles of Confederation, which all states would ratify by 1781. The Articles of Confederation would prove to be a weak constitution, giving too much power to the states and not having a strong enough central government. This realization led to several changes being made until a new framework was implemented. The Constitution established a better relationship between central and state governments, while making sure that no form of government would become too powerful.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, even though the Articles of Confederation seemed viable at the time, the Constitution was a much superior. Even though the US Constitution took away power from the state governments, it did not give all power to one specific hours. Instead it gave power to separate branches which all had the ability to check the powers of the other branches. This made…

    • 1582 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the Revolution came near the end, Americans decided there needed to be a set of laws in place, for the independence that will be gained if they win the war. The first set of rules to be drafted is known as the Articles of Confederation. Seeing that it was America’s first attempt at a government, it is quite obvious that there were many issues with the rules and provisions created, which caused problems in the new nation and stress among political leaders. The Articles of Confederation caused economic, legislative and leadership problems, along with unrest in the Anti-Federalist Party as shown in Documents A, spoken by Melancton Smith and Document B written by Brutus 1.…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Philadelphia Convention, better known as the Constitutional Convention, started in May of 1787 in “America’s largest and most sophisticated” city, Philadelphia. “Madison dreamt of a nation bound by ties among its people, not among its states. To achieve that goal, its founding document had to be ratified by the people through special conventions.” For Madison this goal was achievable thanks the unity of his fellow Virginian delegates, but unluckily for Hamilton “the New York delegation was sharply split between Hamilton, who…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Luke Stafford PS 110 7/21/15 States and Federal Government Rights Does the Federal government have too much control? Is the Federal Government oppressive to the people and States of America? Or are states’ rights well protected in the constitution and political practice? To answers any of these questions, we need to look back and see what the Constitution is and the path that was taken by the founders to where we ended up with the Constitution.…

    • 1401 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The articles of confederation were weak. They didn’t establish a proper form of government and no one liked them. The articles of confederation led to no money, a weak central government, quarrelling states, boundary and border disputes, and no military leadership. The articles of confederation accumulated all power in one assembly rather than distributing power. “...…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without Shays’ Rebellion, our nation's leaders would not have realized the problems The Articles of Confederation caused for the people. The leaders that realized this problem were George Washington, Alexander Hamilton and James Madison. They fixed this problem by starting the drafting of The Constitution at the Constitutional Convention in 1787. Shay’s Rebellion was an important conflict caused by the government’s weak economic policy and led to the actual rebellion which then resulted in the Constitutional Convention.…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays