Why Was Dyfus Unfair

Great Essays
Could you believe that an innocent mans life was ruined just because of his religion?
The Dreyfus Affair was blatant anti-semitism. An innocent French soldier was convicted for a dreadful crime, just because he was Jewish. It is clear he was only imprisoned as a result of anti-semitism for countless reasons. Firstly, Dreyfus was the only Jew in the French Army. Secondly, there was a lot of anti-semitic statements coming out at this time, displaying that there was influx of anti-semitism in France at this time. Thirdly, another letter was found in the same handwriting as the one that was supposedly Dreyfus’, showing it was not him since he was in jail at the time. Fourthly, Emilie Zola stands up for him and is accused of saying a false statement and ruining reputations. Lastly, Dreyfus is called back into court and had all the evidence proving he was innocent, yet he was convicted and incarcerated for another ten years. Alfred Dreyfus was born to a wealthy, Jewish family on October 9, 1859 in Alsace, which was the border between Germany and France. At that point in time, Alsace was part of France. In 1870, post Franco-Prussian war, Alsace was returned to Germany, causing Alfred and his family to leave Alsace. They moved to Paris, France. One of the reasons why Dreyfus was convicted was because people said that he may not be loyal to France, since he was born in Germany. They thought his loyalties were with the country he was born in. Alfred served in the French military when they fought the Franco-Prussian war in 1870. In this war, France lost very badly against the Germans. After six months of fighting, the French army surrendered. It was a great embarrassment to the French. They kept on wondering why they had lost and could not believe what had happened. They wanted to find someone to pin this loss on, so they could have somebody to blame. They thought they had the strongest and most powerful army, yet they lost terribly. The French believed the only way they could have lost was if a spy was leaking all of their secrets to the Germans. Dreyfus, the only Jewish officer in the army, was arrested in 1894 and accused of passing the French military secrets over to the Germans. The evidence the court used to accuse Dreyfus of spying was a piece of paper that said he will tell the Germans all of the French military secrets. This piece of paper was found in a German military garbage. The only issue was that the experts were not completely sure that it was Alfred Dreyfus’ handwriting, so they did not convict him yet. But along came Colonel Henry, a French military intelligence agent, who testified in court that he knew for sure that Alfred Dreyfus was guilty due to additional information that he was exposed to, but could not reveal the additional information to the public due to the fact that it contained important military secrets. After Colonel Henry testified, Alfred Dreyfus was found guilty of spying on the French for the Germans and was sent to Devil’s Island, a political prison in French Guiana off the coast of South America, for the rest of his life. Most people supposed Dreyfus was going to die in jail and not be able to show he was uninvolved in the crime, yet he lived through the extremely tough conditions in Devil’s Island. He was eventually called back to France for a retrial. Alfred Dreyfus was the only Jewish officer in the French army. The French had to find an individual to pin the crime on and the only Jew in the French army
…show more content…
After the ceremony, the press called out to him, “You know well that you are not innocent. Vive la France! Dirty Jew!”. It is clear that throughout France, anti-semitism was becoming more common. Many people thought that Jews were not “normal” and therefore called them cruel names, such as “dirty Jew”. It would not be a surprise to the French if the Jew was the one that was passing France’s military secrets to Germany, which is why Dreyfus was framed for this crime. Convicting Dreyfus was an obvious act of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Martin Guerre Book Report

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The authors during the sixteenth century were more connected to the events of Martin Guerre and followed the story as the trial happened or closely after the trial ended. Most citizens were unable, however, to document the trial because it was closed to the public until the verdict was decided. Jean de Coras was one of the exceptions as one of the presiding judges of the Martin Guerre trial and a prominent legal writer. Even so, Davis argues that his accounts don’t line up completely with other documentation from Guillaume Le Sueur who published a pamphlet telling the “story from the arrival of the Guerres in Artigat to the execution of Arnaud du Tilh. No matter how few or many people witnessed the same event, there will be…

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    History shows the cruel and hideous habits and rulings of the people against other races. Races that deserved their freedom and earned the right to be treated equally. Two major events that proved this sickening mannerism was the relocation of the Japanese Americans and Nazi treatment of the European Jews. The Nazis were putting European Jews into death camps and taking their rights of a human being. The Japanese, like the Jews, were also put into camps but they were internment camps.…

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is there a justification to a persecution without being proven innocent or guilty? In the book Night by Elie Wiesel he tells the story of innocent people persecuted for being Jewish, a guilty sin. It is also a question of morality; who is brave enough to save humans from their suffering and who will turn away. Over the years pain has been inflicted by other humans, harsh weathers, and natural disasters. Imagine the feeling of a blanket of snow, the feeling of a slow and chilling warmth of the coldness.…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The news of the murder soon ignited anti-Semitic sentiments across Germany and, more specifically, propagated violent actions against the Jews of Konitz. In The Butcher’s Tale, H.W. Smith contended that anti-Semitism’s transformation from an ignorant belief…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Elie Wiesel was born on Sighet, Transylvania on September 30, 1928. He grew up with his three sisters, his mom, and his dad being taught all about Jewish religion. He lived here 15 years of his life. At the age of 15, when World War II was beginning, he and his entire family were raptured and taken to a concentration camp in Auschwitz. He lived many years in this concentration; he lived in horrible and inhumane conditions.…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The French government was taking away rights by abolishing worship and religious holidays. Undoubtedly, the threats were not enough to be justified and neither were the…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    World War 2 was the deadliest war in the world's history. It impacted many lives and changed the course of the world. However, one group was impacted more than any other. The Jewish people underwent the worst treatment. This cruel treatment, dehumanization, is talked about in the book Night.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    European Jews were treated terribly by Nazi Germany during WWII. They were faced with horrific circumstances and inevitable fates. Jews were dehumanised and treated as if they were a threat to Germany and if they were not disposed of, their supposedly evil and nefarious mannerisms would, ironically, soon destroy Germany as a race. According to the film, Schindler 's List, the discrimination of Jews and the actions the Nazis took to expose them was non-expectant and unpredictable.…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abraham Lincoln was our 16th president of the United States. Abraham Lincoln was an amusing president for what he did for our country. His life was not the funnest; he had a tough time. He did amazing things when he was in office.…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Injustice In Trifles

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Along with Glaspell’s work Trifles, other works during the time were also keying in on the issue of injustice to women within the legal system. “Kerfol” written by Edith Warton and another work by Susan Glaspell, the short story “A Jury of Her Peers”, were also attacking the inequality of fairness under the law for women. “Trifles depicts an unequal trial of strength between the male prosecution story and the female defence story, in which the female protagonists hide the emerging defence story to avoid incriminating the accused” (Wright 260). The lack of justice guaranteeing protection for these women under the law is what ultimately results in the decision they make to not incriminate Mrs. Wright. “No, Peters, it's all perfectly clear…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Jewish population was huge in the 1900’s and what happened was a terrible event that took place in certain spots in Europe most people liked Jews but some people despised them I do not know why but they just did. This one bad guy named Adolf Hitler did something about is so he was a leader a dictator and a king too some people and he took millions of Jewish lives and how did nobody know about this, a lot of people did but didn’t say anything Eli lost his faith when he was spilt up from his mom and sister and was with his dad, when the Nazis started rushing in and grabbing people and beating them nobody knew what was happening When he arrived at the camp, he was mortified looking at the Nazis throwing the dead bodies in the…

    • 194 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Society’s Stereotypes Women belong in the kitchen, and Jews are cheap. African Americans are criminals, and Asians are geeks. The poor, of course, are lazy. Media portrays people from all walks of life in many different ways, painting them in ways that are not always true to reality. When watching a movie, the majority of police are white men, and most women stay home raising their children.…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Adolf Hitler Outline

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Adolf Hitler AKA Trump Hitler is described as an idealist, Dictative, Radical, and persuasive person. Hitler was a very hopeful leader at the time. He was a great orator, but his ideals of what was right and what he thought was Germany's destiny were obviously misconstrued. He was very vengeful at the Jews (mother's death), and he was very Idealistic in the fact that he wanted to create a "Pure" Race, a "breed" of man that would be the ultimate in everything, he definitely brought Germany up from the ruins that it was in (one reason he became so powerful, because to most of the Germans, he was their hope, their "Savior")…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the harsh times of the Holocaust, many German soldiers were put in charge to harm Jews and rid of their existence. Some might consider this an act of evilness, but many do not recognize that many soldiers were forced into these positions and their environment had propagandized false accusations against the group of people, which filled them with…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dreyman was suspected in the first place because of curiosity driven by the Stasi. Due to his escape from the West, some attention is driven to him by by some officers more than others. He was “one of our only writers who has read in the West and is loyal to our government.” Despite this, the Stasi still believed that there was something wrong. The Stasi were quite stubborn towards considering him as a “possible suspect” as if they were keen that he was the only one that could have done such a…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays