Analysis Of Sitting Bull And The Paradox Of Lakota Nationhood

Superior Essays
Gary C. Anderson wrote the biography Sitting Bull and the Paradox of Lakota Nationhood in an effort to tell the story, from Sitting Bull’s perspective, of how the Lakota nationhood were committed to defend their land as well as examine the goals and purposes of the American culture to dominate upon them. Despite the factionalisms, encouraged by the federal government, in the Lakota that led to the division of the nationhood, Sitting Bull is considered one of the most significant and influential Native Americans in history because he would always look out for the best interest of the Sioux tribe and the Lakota nation by standing up against the American army who was interested in the relocation of Indians and the creation of reservations.
It all started in the late 1800’s when the Americans began to invade the lands west to the Mississippi River because the federal government wanted to expand the U.S. territory. They believed that because they carried the dual banner of civilization and Christianity, they had the right to take the land (pg. 3). Americans saw the land as an unoccupied region, but the truth is that the land was the homeland of Sitting Bull and his Sioux people – the Lakota nation. Anderson explains that the Americans had made a wrong perception of the Indians, since they were viewed as savages (pg. 3). The Indians possessed a sophisticated culture and government. They were divided into seven tribes and each spoke their own language, which developed a sense of identity and nationalism between them and allowed them to organize political and social institutions that kept the order in the nation. The Lakota were able to form a unique economy that influenced their socio-political structure. They strongly relied on the buffalo hunt to provide for their food, clothing, shelter and religious purposes. One of the reasons they divided in tribes was to protect the Buffalo, since it was their main source of sustainability. The Lakota nation was very close and always looked out for one another. A clear example of this was Sitting Bull, who stood up for their nation against the American army. Sitting Bull was born around 1831 on the Grand River and since he was a young boy he showed potential as a leader. His father was Jumping Ball, a warrior and hunter, and his mother was Her Holy Door. As it was a tradition, he was raised by his uncles Four Horns and Looks-For-Him-In-A-Tent, who were the most important role models in his life. With them, he learned the arts of hunting and warfare and his intense training began after he was able to mount a horse. Some of the skills to learn were how to fire a weapon accurately from a fast-moving horse and how to act under the stresses of the buffalo
…show more content…
At first, the Sioux fought for their territory and were not willing to allow the Americans to stay but everything changed after they developed factions that caused major Indian divisions. Some Sioux believed that if they fought against the federal government, they would be outnumbered and lose everything they owned, while others, including Sitting Bull, were against the federal government and its army and believed they should fight against them. Anderson explains it better when he writes: “the more Sitting Bull and his followers sought to unify and define Lakota nationhood, and the more it seemed so distinctly different from what the Americans had to offer, the more the Lakota leadership faced factionalism and decay” (pg. …show more content…
Therefore, the government created The Fort Laramie Treaty that would limit the white settlers from entering those areas, but failed to follow it through. Because of the fights the Sioux were causing, the government created a “Great Sioux” reservation and suggested the Indians to relocate to this camp. After their attempt to purchase the Black Hills from the Indians, they mandated all Lakota to settle on the reservation by January 31, 1876. Many Indians lost their homes and food rations in the winter that they surrendered to the troops and went to the reservations. Sitting Bull and his tribe refused to be part of the reservations and be forced to leave their customs that they decided they would rather

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    It was said that President Andrew Jackson was looking in the best interest of U.S. citizens and moved the indians to help keep from conflicts that could possibly lead to war from arising yet again between the United States and the Native Americans or that some Native tribes were just too violent and were seen as a threat by U.S. citizens. It seemed like Americans and Native Americans could not blend and live together peacefully and that is also a said reason why the Trail of Tears…

    • 1950 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For many years the Arapaho and Cheyenne tribes tried desperately to adjust to sharing the land that was once theirs, with the troops and settlers that had moved in on top of them, killed off their game, and essentially made roadways through what hunting grounds remained. Despite all of the sit downs and treaties, relocating to reservations, and being stripped of their dignity as they were forced to rely on the distribution of government annuities, the end result was bloodshed. The Native Americans were not valued as human beings much less the rightful owners of the land in which US troops viciously killed…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Utley has truly written a thorough and informed book that enlightens the reader into knowing the true Sitting Bull. Utley begins his book by giving the reader an in depth look into the Lakota tribe’s culture and practices, in doing so…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sitting Bull Thesis

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages

    During Sitting Bull’s early years, he didn’t really interact or witness any white dominations or invasions. Sitting Bull didn’t come to contact with the white supremacy until about 1862 when the Sioux Indian tribes were beginning to be driven towards the West of the Great Plains. Once Sitting Bull witnessed how the whites demanded land and ran off the original owners and their families, he realized how cruel the whites were, he then decided to fight the white supremacy and never sign treaties with them especially if it included agreeing to move to a reservation. Sitting Bull,…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This sought to negotiate the exchange of Indian lands in the south for new lands in American territory (Lapanskey-Werner, et al page 254). The Jackson Administration urged many Native Americans to sell their land and move out of the southern territory which a ajority did; however, the Cherokee Indians refused to move and went to the Supreme Court (Lapanskey-Werner, et al page 253). The Supreme Court eventually ruled that the Cherokee Indians be allowed to remain on their land, but Jackson decided to force them out of the southern territory, along a Trail of Tears, that ended in Oklahoma (Lapanskey-Werner, et al page 254). Many people criticized Jackson for these actions, calling them inhumane and cruel, but Andrew Jackson’s focus was for the interest and welfare of the people of United States. Even…

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essentially, Jackson did not value the Indian ethnic groups as individuals of the country, forcing them to leave. He did not regard tribes as independent sovereign entities but rather as tenants of the government. Jackson believed that if the Indians wished to maintain their tribal government, they would have to expand into Western territory. The Cherokees rejected the treaty and were transported by military force to distant lands in what is known as the Trail of Tears. Jackson exclaims to Congress that the Indian Removal Act, “will relieve…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay On Black Hawk War

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages

    THE BLACK HAWK WAR? OR THE WAR FOR CHICAGO The Black Hawk War was one of the most vital parts of Chicago history. Chicago would not have happened if not for the Black Hawk war. Chicago was formed after the events of the Black Hawk War.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Treaty of Moultrie Creek (1823), the Treaty of Payne's Landing (1832), and many other meetings and discussions, US Indian Agents tried to get the Seminoles to sell off all of their livestock, “… return runaway slaves to their "rightful owners," and abandon their homes that have been in their family for generations to settle west of the Mississippi River to Arkansas Territory. Then in 1830, when Andrew Jackson became the president of the United States, the one thing he immediately tried to get the Indian Removal Act passed through Congress. Of course this meant that the government could remove the Indians at any time to make room for settlers, and it was all legal, and they could spend even more money to enforce that this new policy was carried out. Thus leading to the Second Seminole War (1835-42), when the Seminoles refused to be removed and held the U.S army at a standstill: forcing them to spend millions…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    By the time the 1830’s the government had forced the native tribes to move to the great plains . White settlers believed that the land they were on was to dry for planting crops , this is why the Treaty of fort laramie was put into place in 1851 not many agreed to it but they had no choice . In 1864 the Sand Creek Massacre happened when the militia set fire on a peaceful village , later the tribes responded with attacks on soldiers and settlements these attacks is the result of the Second Treaty of Fort Laramie . In 1874 people discovered that there was gold in the Black Hills of South Dakota miners came flooding into the Siouxland , Sitting Bull,Crazy horse and Two Sioux chiefs but then they later united to push back the intruders…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1928, Andrew Jackson was ironically granted the honor of becoming immortalized on the twenty dollar bill. He has become an important part of America’s history. Most of the younger generations automatically assume Andrew Jackson was a decent, honorable man. However, growing up around violence and death, Andrew Jackson grew to be unpredictable. “Here was an apparently unbalanced, excitable, insecure, and defensive boy coming of age in a culture of confrontation and violence.…

    • 676 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Sitting Bull: A Hero

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Sitting Bull was born sometime in 1831 in South Dakota and no one knows his birthday. When Sitting Bull was young, he looked up to his father and tried to to follow his footsteps but he lacked in his skills and was called slow. However, as Sitting Bull got older he got smarter and more capable. Sitting Bull is an important historical figure because he was a hero, he defended his land and he honoured his culture. Sitting Bull was a hero to his people.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States Government saw this as a problem. On January 31, 1876, the government urged the Sioux leader named Sitting Bull, and his people to give their land away to white settlers and move to a reservation. The Sioux decided not to leave, and that this was their land. At this point, the Sioux and the whites hated each other. Meanwhile, the United States Army was marching in to force the Sioux to move to a reservation.…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lakota Woman Essay

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Latinos incorporated more direct and diverse approaches. Another widely-used strategy, and one shared by these two groups, was the occupation of land to prove a point. In Lakota Woman, Crow Dog mentions participating in the famous siege of Wounded Knee in 1973. Members of the American Indian Movement, an advocacy group which promoted Indian rights, took control of the town on Pine Ridge Indian Reservation after the government failed to honor treaties. Lasting seventy-one days, members of the Oglala Lakota and…

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Territorial Expansion DBQ

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages

    During the harsh winter, the Cherokee walked through four different states (Doc D) to reach the American Indian Reservation in Oklahoma. This event illustrates another president creating his own policy as he disregards the government’s founding laws. Even though Jackson’s decision was mostly disliked, followers supported him by stating “the Cherokees have resisted, and successfully too, every effort to meliorate [improve] their situation, or to introduce among them the most common arts of life” (Doc C). The Indians “moral and their intellectual condition have been equally stationary” and…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While Blackmore goes on to speak about what life would be like without the Native Americans, Sitting Bull is more worried about their present situation and how they have to fight for their lives so they can see a better day. Although they have a completely different viewpoint on who has rightful ownership of the land, they do share one thing in common. They both criticized the other for their lifestyles while tarnishing their image. There was no capacity for a neutral approach in this case, instead both sides took a strong stance on the issue. Ultimately, a great deal of insults were employed by both figures in their attempt to discredit the other party and influence their target audiences to join the cause again…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays