Batman And The Watchmen: A Comparative Analysis

Improved Essays
Batman and the Watchmen have revised the image of what a superhero is by being described as a vigilante. Superman works with the government and stay invisible and abides by their every rule. While Batman argues, “You gave them the power that should’ve been ours” (32). Batman is motivated to fight law breakers because of the death of his parents. Dressed in a costume he’d go looking for crime to stop. Though he is fighting crime for the greater good he is still breaking the law. All other superheroes before Batman were supported by the community and praised for all they have done but, in Batman’s case he is questioned by society if what he is doing is the “right” thing to really do. At one point Superman is sent to get rid of Batman, in all …show more content…
He does this by explaining that in questioning the superheroes humans should be really questioning themselves. That it’s not if humans can do and make the same ultimate decisions that the superheroes can make but, if the humans are prepared to take action into their own hands in a non-super way. If all humans would take the responsibility for justice they would not need someone to make those big decisions for them, if only humans were not so dependent on others. The humans wouldn’t have needed Ozymandias to make the decision to murder three million in order to restore and assure peace on earth. If from the beginning humans were watching and keeping a close eye out for any negativity those three million would not have needed to die. Because humans are acting immoral it is up to the superheroes to make the moral decisions humans couldn’t make. Unlike Superman, Batman and Watchmen are humans, unique humans? Yes, but humans none the less. Batman was a revenge filled vigilante that would avoid killing his advisories not because it was legal thing to do but because it was the right thing to do morally. Skoble argues, “He has refused to cross certain line” (33). Batman has stronger morals than the average human, he knows right from wrong behavior. Though he is not technically a law-abiding citizen of Gotham he knows how far to push his limits. He knew that when he first had the chance to kill

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Just like Macbeth did not want to kill King Duncan. Lady Macbeth tested his manhood to get him to kill the King. The same way Batman’s manhood is tested. Batman is tested by Bane, The Joker, and many other characters. Batman is known for not killing any of his enemies and so he has many opportunities to end their lives but, he is a better man than that so he has to decide to kill them or let them go.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    On the contrary, Batman represents the detective side of comics with stories of crime fought in plain and simple style. Superman had powers while Batman did not indicating fighting crime balancing the spirit of vengeance in their despair to justice. 8. A quote that Stan Lee coined and spotted in the Spiderman from Peter Parker is that “with great power, they must also come great responsibility. This quote symbolize each superheroes’ motive is to embrace a complex story that each one endure to preserve through one…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Boo Radley's Dichotomy

    • 2042 Words
    • 9 Pages

    On the other hand, Batman refuses to kill as he believes that in his own mind that to kill is to fall to the level of villains like the Joker and Bane. He learns from himself and indirectly from his former mentor Ra’s Al Ghul, that compassion is what separates and differentiates them from the villains and criminals of society. “I won't kill you, but I don't have to save you”(Batman Begins); were his final words to his former mentor and teacher Ra’s Al Ghul as he left the train before its explosion. Al Ghul was a genocidal terrorist that wishes to destroy civilization in order to rebuild it, Batman could not leave Al Ghul alive without risking serious consequences such as endangering the lives of many others, so given…

    • 2042 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In order to save the "dying" city of Gotham from the criminal underworld, poverty, and corruption within the police department, Bruce returns to the root of all his misery as a changed man; the identity of Batman was established to prevent anyone else from experiencing the pain and suffering he had endured as a child while the normal Bruce Wayne returns to his "throne" at Wayne Enterprises in order to gain the funding needed for new technology such as the bat-mobile and upgrading the suit as well as using his influence to support individuals such as Harvey Dent who had gained the title of the "White Knight" due to being able to achieve justice during the day without a mask. Despite his vigilantly approach towards establishing law and order, Batman is able to maintain his sanity by acknowledging a specific honor code that prevents him from using deadly force or resorting to killing criminals such as the Joker despite his ruthless and unpredictable nature to harm others for his own enjoyment. What makes Batman an ideal hero is his heart and courage because he refuses to be thanked or acknowledged for his role in justice. As a result, Bruce Wayne actually tries to distant himself from the caped crusader by essentially hiding in pain site and acting like the cocky "Billionaire Playboy" who…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ironman Hero's Journey

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The persona of Bruce is what protects the people he loves from becoming targets, but it is also what enables him to keep humanity. His humanity, the determination to never kill, is what separates him from a criminal. Bruce fully embraces the life of Batman, but also chooses to keep the like of Bruce…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Batman Good Vs Evil

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The line between what's good and what's evil seems a simple idea in itself, just a line dividing the two, right? However, what you don't think about are the footnotes that cross and cover the line with justifications and designated loopholes made by those who believe certain things must be accounted for when considering what is actually right and wrong. Supposing that Batman were on a side, he'd be one of those sticky notes teetering on the line that divides what he believes in, and what he is capable of. Page 149 revels in the fact that Batman and the Joker have found their opportunity to offer their final blows, Batman grasps at the Joker's head and is prepared to twist and turn, or press his fingers into his eye sockets. Anything that will…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the course of the story, the narrator continuously refers to the individual Superman. Superman symbolizes the ability to do no wrong. “ [The narrator] always liked the idea of superman because [he] always…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This quote relates well to Batman in the way that as a normal man, he has a side of insanity and immorality. Of course Batman has a positive side of him that only wants to do good for Gotham, but the other side shows someone who wants to hurt people and even enjoys doing the punishment. So why do we love the Batman stories? We love them for the same reason we love horror stories. The violence, blood, mystery, darkness, all of the deep, twisted traits presented in the comic or movie give people the opportunity to relieve their morbid thoughts and wicked fantasies, which many…

    • 1176 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In my opinion, Batman is morally justified in his reasoning for not committing murder due to the balance he has between Utilitarianism and Kantianism. To Batman, killing is an immoral act that hurts not only the victim but also the killer. Every murder is wrong because it removes one more person from the world and creates another murderer. It’s the consequences that Batman avoids, but he does so because of how he values human life. Many stories involve Batman convincing criminals out of committing murder; he would not have the same impact if he were known to kill his enemies.…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Okay, in that case, I have nothing to add. Again, the Bruce’s money is well invested. However, the intelligence could be the trickiest part. Although, knowing the fact Batman doesn’t possess true superpowers, his advantages are he’s smart, wise and brave and these virtues generally lead him to victory over his foes. All these advantages are the primary reasons Batman is often a leader of the Justice League and I have no doubts at all then he would be able to outsmart Superman in a variety of ways, who pretty often plays on the card his superpower advantages.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    " People can come together on their own, and combat things like stereotypes and injustices, without guns and bat suits. Everyone has the power to stand up for what they believe and to make their voice…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Becoming a criminal : Vigilantism and the Law In the movies, superheros are able try to fight crime and save the day. But some people try to replicate these heroes and become vigilantes. However these vigilantes are not fictional superheroes and end up causing trouble. For this reason, vigilantism is wrong for society because vigilantes are not above the law, there is always the authority to intervene, and since vigilantes are untrained and fueled by emotion, they are more likely to end up causing harm to themselves and others.…

    • 1233 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I agree because superman stands for the America dream, belief system, religious myths and the importance of immigration to America. Superman is so darned American because he is an immigrant from a different planet to earth, to the United States for that matter. He has many characteristics that are similar to that of other immigrants. In order to fit into the American society, he had to adjust to the norms and culture. His name was changed from Kal-el to an American name Clark Kent and he had to act just like every…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Batman the vigilante represents the shadow archetype. Being Batman allows for Bruce Wayne to fulfill his unconscious…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The term “vigilante justice” often invokes images of a fighter who uses his strength or power to take action at the expense of the common law. From the outside, these individuals seem to be wild and unpredictable, actively promoting disobedience to the established legal system. With this delicate relationship between the law and the citizens hanging in the balance, we must ask ourselves whether these lawbreakers can be considered heroes. Robin Hood, a self-proclaimed outlaw who “robs the rich to feed the poor” in the eponymous 1973 Disney film, is an example of one such individual who puts himself above the established law. In examining the social and cultural context behind his actions, however, we will see that he does not do so in a reckless…

    • 1896 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics