Howl's Moving Castle Book Vs Movie Essay

Superior Essays
Most people who watch films and read stories would say that the movie adaptation is frequently different from the book. The fantasy novel, Howl’s Moving Castle, by British author Diana Wynne Jones, first published in 1986 by Greenwillow Books of New York, is no exception to this statement. Sophie, the main character, is the eldest of three daughters and “In the land of Ingary…it is quite a misfortune to be born the eldest,” (Jones 1). Early in the tale, she gets transformed into an old lady by a spell that is cast by the Witch of the Waste. The only way for her to rid herself of this awful spell would be to find an always-moving castle in the hill whose owner was the powerful wizard Howl. She forms a secret contract with Howl’s fire demon named Calsifer who says that if she would break the curse between him and Howl, then he would break her spell. Along the journey she faces the Witch of the Waste many times and learns more about the details between Howl’s and Calsifer’s contract. Because the antagonists in the novel is different in the movie, the characters transform both the plot and subplots of the narrative; several of the characters are drastically changed, and this causes a striking difference in the way the reader and viewer understand the story. The main antagonist in the book is the Witch of the Waste, a powerful and major character. She is an elegant woman who made a contract with a demon of greed in exchange for power, but this contract makes her self-absorbed, lonely, and unhappy. To ease her unhappy state, she breaks the hearts of innocent, young men. Eventually this stops easing her pain and she decides to create an ideal partner by combining the parts of several men. She captures two candidates she finds suitable and then decides to capture Howl. Because she isn’t able to capture Howl, (he realizes her true nature and runs away) she decides to try again and not stop until she obtained his head. Sophie, one of the main characters, by chance interacts with Howl early in the novel, and because of this interaction the witch casts a spell on her transforming her into an old woman. Throughout the whole novel Howl, Sophie, and a few other characters are hiding from this witch, and eventually face her. Without this major character, the reader would be very confused as to who the main characters in the story opposed. In contrast with the novel, in the movie version directed by Hayao Miyazaki, the Witch of the Waste is more of a minor and weaker character than in the novel. The new main antagonist of the movie is a royal sorceress named, Madam Suliman, who is a character that wasn’t originally in the novel. According to the screenplay, Madam Suliman used to apprentice the wizard Howl, until he makes a contract with the demon, Calsifer, and then decided to stop being an apprentice. The royal sorceress considers his contract with a demon unacceptable and dangerous, just like the Witch of the Waste’s demonic contract. Upon inviting the Witch of the Waste to the royal court, Madam Suliman corners the witch into …show more content…
During the climax, Sophie is the first to go face the witch at her magical castle, but was quickly overpowered and captured. Soon afterwards, Howl arrives at the scene and defeats the witch, but her demon tactfully hides in another vessel. Losing its human vessel, it hides in an inanimate object within Howl’s own castle and seeks to capture Howl’s body, by taking his heart. Howl’s heart is in possession with Calsifer because of the contract between them. The demon isn’t quick enough to capture Howl’s heart because Sophie quickly returns Howl’s heart back into his body using magic and thereby releasing Calsifer and Howl of their contract. With his heart returned Howl destroys the dead witch’s heart by using a powerful spell, and the evil demon is defeated. By having this type of climax the author allowed the reader to get a clear understanding to how the conflict of the story resolved. Upon the resolution of the novel, everything is resolved and the main characters get a happy

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Secret Life of Bees is a novel about a 14 year old girl, Lily, living in a time of segregation. She grows up in the time of the Civil Rights act. After reading The Secret Life of Bees book, we watched and compared it to the movie. A movie based on a book wouldn’t follow the exact plotline. There were key differences, but the movie followed a similar plotline.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Westing Game is an excellent novel as well as movie, however, they tell a somewhat different story. Sandy, Barney, Julian, and Sam are all different people right? This proves to be true in both the movie and the book. The Westing Game, written by Ellen Raskin, is a book about a 12 year old girl named Turtle, or Tabitha Ruth, who discovers who was responsible for the death of her dear Uncle Sam.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For decades, popular novels have been published and years later followed with a film. Although the movie tends to portray imagery, the course of events in the book tend to contrast to those of the film. This became abundantly clear when I read the book and watched the movie, The Natural. In both the novel and the film, we learn about the life of a baseball player named Roy Hobbs, who was born with a talent and was given the ability to pursue his goal of life. Although his mindset was determined to break all the records in the game, many obstacles stood in his path ultimately skewing his priorities and driving him towards a path only ending with failure.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Each day, every one of us wakes up and goes to our average, everyday high school. The normal day for Ender Wiggin was Battle school, hours of learning, and action packed encounters. The plot of Ender’s Game is about a boy who is placed in battle school at age 6 to train in the ways of a commander and lead an army in the war against the Buggers. After showing superior skill and knowledge, Ender is sent to command school where he defeats the Bugger race into extinction… Or so it is initially thought.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Imagine going into hiding for months or even years. Imagine having to be completely quiet most of the time because every little noise made could put everyone’s lives in danger. This was the life that many Jews had to live. In 1933, a man by the name of Adolf Hitler came to power in Germany and destroyed the lives of many innocent Jewish citizens. One of these people being a young girl named Anne Frank.…

    • 1536 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You may have seen the action-packed movie, but if you want something even better than the movie you really should read the book. Ender's Game was an intriguing story that is very exhilarating. You will read this book cover to cover over and over. In Ender's Game, the earth made contact with aliens and now the aliens took that the wrong way and started to attack earth.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Everyone has seen a movie? Read a book? Yes, of course. About a place that rains everyday? How would you feel?…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Madeline's Nonexistence

    • 565 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Another issue was all the noises Roderick heard, which he thought was Madeline escaping, but was only caused by the fierce storm outside the house. Roderick was so afraid that Madeline was still alive, his conscience ate him alive and made him believe that she was haunting…

    • 565 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Said to be one of Disney’s best films, Beauty and the Beast is based on a French fairy tale about a beautiful woman who falls in love with a beast. This film sends the message that “it’s what is inside that really matters”. Jeanne Marie- Leprince de Beaumont wrote the timeless tale of “The Beauty and the beast” which has been embraced by the hearts of many for decades.…

    • 1761 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I will be comparing Animal Farm by George Orwell and Lord Of The Flies by William Golding. In a Lord Of The Flies, young boys get stranded on a island after their plane crashes. After the plane crashed the boys try to make life livable on the island, but two boys Ralph and Jack fight over who gets to be the leader of the island. Eventually Ralph and Jack go head to head about who gets to be leader, and Jack wins because all of the younger boys go to his side. In Animal Farm, Mr. Jones the owner of the animals is always drunk and forgets to feed his animals so the animals chase him off of his own farm.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Most Dangerous Game book vs movie contrast In Richard Connell 's best-known work is the short story, first written in 1924, "The Most Dangerous Game. " The story starts when Sanger Rainsford, a celebrated hunter and army veteran from New York, falls off his boat and ends up in the shore of a mysterious island. Walking through the island he finds a mansion on the top of a cliff. When he goes to the mansion he is welcomed by General Zaroff and his frightening deaf-mute servant Ivan. Zaroff is an experienced hunter who has traveled the world looking for the most challenging animals to hunt.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the story, “The Lay of the Werewolf”, a faithful husband gets dishonored by his wife after the wife finds out that the husband is half werewolf. The story takes place in Ancient Greek, during the Medieval Times, where the Greeks wrote that people could be transformed into werewolves. The story really gives off a good example on how the people that you think you can trust with your life, especially in this case, can turn on you for the money, fame, power, etc. The three themes that are shown in “The Lay of the Werewolf” are betrayal, dishonor, and affection.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both the book Slumdog Millionaire (originally called Q&A) written by Vikas Swarup and the film adaptation of the same name directed by Danny Boyle received mostly positive reviews and critique, which cemented both of these works deep into the area they were apart of. The movie proved that you could make a successful movie using a traditional Bollywood recipe, and the book showed us how devastating and soul-crushing life in an Indian slum could be. The book also garnered an array of good feedback based on how it handled the different areas in India, and how the system was unfair in many of the different places. The book and the film adaptation have the same underlying pillars, but they differ a lot when it comes to plot and characters, and it is fairly unreasonable to say that the movie stays true to the source material of the book.…

    • 2140 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In both Crime and Punishment and Chronicle, it is obvious to draw parallels between the novel’s protagonist, Raskolnikov, and the movie’s protagonist, Andrew: both males are isolated by society, for which they are a contributing factor; both harbor a deep resentment against those around them; and both of them commit a violent act that ultimately marks their doom. The beginning exposition of both the novel and the movie spends a significant amount of time emphasizing the protagonists’ loneliness. The very first page of the novel describes Raskolnikov as someone who is “completely absorbed in himself, and isolated from his fellows;” in the same way, the movie begins in Andrew’s dingy room and shows him friendless as he gets bullied for his camera (Dostoevsky 1). As the storyline progresses, however, it is evident that these characters are not completely helpless victims;…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nowadays, if you ask a number of people if they prefer ‘books or movies’, it’s most certain that, there will be an extensive collection of different answers. For many centuries books have been the biggest source of stories that human kind has, but now, things are changing. Today’s way to get introduced to a new story is, to watch a movie. The demand for movies is constantly increasing, so, why do some people still read books? Why do a countless number of people like to watch movies?…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays