Unplugged: The Myth Of Computers In The Classroom Analysis

Improved Essays
Since the early 1980’s, computers have proved to be a revolutionary advancement with regards to providing an efficient environment for the American educational system. However, one should note the use of the term efficient. Although computers provide a quick solution to many educational issues, they lack in providing an academic construct for students to build upon in the future. David Gelernter argues in his essay “Unplugged: The Myth of Computers in the Classroom” why computers will do more harm than good in educating todays tomorrow. Gelernter does not merely direct his argument toward teachers and professors, but he addresses parents and caregivers as well. The argument focuses upon providing the best possible educational experience for children today, and that can only be done by developing a technological independence from computers and the like. After Gelernter expresses his …show more content…
A main point of Gelernter’s follows the solution to disorganized history classes; he declares “Teaching children to understand the orderly unfolding of a plot of a logical argument is a crucial part of education.”(98). This not only summarizes all uses of ethos as well as the main argument, but also introduces an emotional appeal that draws the audience closer to his perspective. This use of pathos changes the direction of the article - the question of including computers in the classroom becomes secondary to the question of administering a proper learning environment for the young generation. To exemplify this shift, Gelernter states three rules concerning the use of computers in the classroom should it happen. Summarized, they are, computer programs must offer creative thinking, they should be used sparingly, and that teachers must still fulfill their duty in educating their students on a personal level. These rules tie a bow on Gelernter’s argument, leading into his final

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Sci/621 Research Paper

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages

    As teachers we have to equip our students to live in this kind of world. According to Sousa, “…children who spend their early years in front of screens will eventually have adult brains that are hardwired to process information at a frantic pace” (Sousa, 679). Technology has many positive aspects, but often gets a bad rap. According to Wedlock & Growe, “The problem is that technological innovations need to be transformed from tools of obsession into tools of education”…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article, “Why Laptops in Class Are Distracting America’s Future Workforce” was written by Timothy D. Snyder in 2010. His purpose in writing this article was to persuade professors against having laptops in the classroom because he feels they are a distraction. The arguments Snyder uses against laptops in classrooms are, they distract students’ attention, students miss out of the best part of American life, and he generalizes that this lack of attention will spill over into the workplace. Snyder discusses various online chatting forums such as Skype, Gchat, or iChat that students are engaged in on their laptops during class.…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Evolution of technology has created a significant transformation in the process of educating. It has become an essential part of society and the ability to communicate, learn and grow. The unlimited information has become a tool, in which students, teachers, and everyday workers use on a daily basis. Sherry Turkle, author of “Selections from Alone Together: Why We Expect More from Technology and Less from Each Other”, focuses primarily on the connection between progression of technology and the effects artificial intelligence have on society. In contrast, Cathy Davidson argues in her essay, “Project Classroom Makeover”, that a reformation of today’s education system is necessary.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The article explores a study conducted to see what teachers choose to do to conduct their classes when they have no restrictions and limits, specifically in terms of technology. The study showed that despite the freedom to choose the tool of choice, teachers stuck with power points, which are the most basic “old school” way of teaching a class. Savasci concludes after the study that teachers must increase their “ knowledge and skills about how to use those instructional technologies and help them develop positive attitudes toward information and communication technologies”. This illustrates Cahn and Cahn’s sub-claim that schools and their teachers should branch out to innovative technologies for their students. The intended audience seems to be the generation older than the millennials given the subject and context of the study is very factual, but can definitely be intended for millennials as well because the language used is not difficult relative to other academic studies conducted.…

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Freedman shared two narratives - the first one was used to illustrate “the exasperation of countless teachers and professors in the computer era” (Freedman, 2007, para 6) whenever their reminders to students not to use their digital devices in class fall on deaf ears while the second narrative was used to demonstrate that educators have given up on the war against technology because they feel they cannot outwit technology in capturing students’ attention. The effective use of the anecdotes enables the reader to understand the pain of teachers in classrooms because they are able to relate to these situations, thereby making his arguments more persuasive. In contrast, Britland’s article is more opinion-based as he brings in his arguments through rhetorical questions as evident from “So what is the future? Is it the iPad? No, I don’t think it is.”…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Technology has had an impact on students education. Anyone who can get on the internet can get access to the same amount of information and materials as everyone else. According to Ethan Bronner, eighth graders who “used computers for complex math had acquired more than one third of an academic year of education” (Bronner, 1998, Para. 5). Fourth graders who “used computers for math games, had a one tenth of an academic year of education increase” (Bronner, 1980, Para. 5). In 1984, for every 125 students there was a single computer and in 1996 there was a computer for every ten students.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It can be argued that where technology is central to the modern classroom environment, this form of education is contributing to the ‘blur’ between the real and digital world. However, this argument is widely criticised. For example, Piaget (1952), disagree with the very foundation of this argument. Cognitive constructivists argue that reality is subjective; humans create their own meaning of what is real in this world (Swan, 2005).…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the article “Can Students Have too Much Tech?” ,Susan Pinker cares about Barack Obama’s policy regarding students having too much technology. Pinker is a stakeholder who is involved in the controversy by being a Psychologist and Columnist. However Pinker is not the only stakeholder in this article. President Obama’s is also a stakeholder because he is the one making the agenda to promise to expand the internet. President Obama found out that the kids coming from struggling families with network devices will not shrink the class in education, they will actually widen the education.(par.2)…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Derek Bok saw that the use of laptops and iPads in class has become a very common thing in today's educational society. With that observation he saw that students taking notes on their iPad or laptop had more opportunities to distract themselves. Studies have shown that students who use technology in class damage their education (Bok,Derek). Regulating the use of technology in our everyday lives is a very important skill to have today. Without the regualtion When we don’t regulate the use of technology we end up becoming dependent on them and lose our intellectual independence.…

    • 1497 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Who is the intended audience? Young teenagers, but can also be adults to hear the opinion of the writer. State the father's argument in your own words.…

    • 1351 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Eliana Argument Analysis

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In response to the dogmatic opinion that the technology affects people negatively and the increasingly use of technology among American kids, Eliana argues that early use of technology does bring us benefits and people should embrace it. By virtue of employing tactical reasoning, providing convincing evidence, and using strongly persuasive elements, Eliana constructs a highly plausible argument. Eliana begins the essay with the facts that nowadays America kids are skilled at using technology, while most parents don’t think their kids are frequently allowed to use technology in schools, which leads the audience to the focus of the consequence of the exposure to technology on children’s early age. He then moves to discuss the outdated opinion that parents hold, “the less time spent with screens, the…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stulman On Computers

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Stulman’s essay argues that for college student’s computers are more of a distraction than a helping tool for leaning. Throughout Stulman’s essay he has a abundance of grammatical delivery errors which result in his essay being unsuccessful. Stulman’s essay is unsuccessful on how he delivered his argument such as he lacked factual evidence to back up his argument, broadly generalized his clams, as well as addressed numerous problems and did not provide any solutions to these problems. One of the primary reasons Stulman’s essay is unsuccessful is because he lacked factual evidence to back up his argument that computers are more of a distraction than an aid in learning for college students. This is shown in his example of how students are using…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the passage “ On Computers in Classrooms: Please Proceed with Caution!” The author’s claim is you should be very careful on deciding whether you really want to get a laptop for students, even though there is many good things about it, you should still be aware of the possible disadvantages of giving these students laptops. I strongly disagree with this author, and believe that students should be given laptops for school. The Internet is one of the biggest things trending world wide, Most parents/older people are less likely to understand the Internet because they didn’t grow up with it, they personally think the internet is bad for you but they think this because they feel like kids need to live life the hard way like they did at one time.…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We are in the digital age and we need to find clever ways of learning, experiencing and teaching related to technologic developments. From the printing press, we had not handled any special revolution except computer and internet. These two revolutionary tools would have been helping human history in every type of all fields, and of course in schools. The computer has recently been in schools. Before using computers, there were some kinds of methodologies used in classes.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction The use of technology is being practiced more frequently in education then the vintage hand writing. Today, schools are more and more likely to have assignments due online. People will usually consider that technology is undoubtedly been a more convenient way to do things; however, some claim that the practice of technology has actually been beneficial. The argument is that technology such as computers are more than just an alternative, but is actually more efficient while the person is able to use the most out of his or her resources.…

    • 1258 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics