The Tuskegee Syphilis Study: Ethical Implications

Improved Essays
Medical and scientific research have been the cornerstones of innovation and discovery for centuries. The development of anesthesia, surgical techniques, and the basic flu vaccination were conceived through decades of experimentation and research. There are always ethical implications concerning research, especially when involving human subjects. Though in our current time there are legal regulations enforced to ensure that trials are being conducted ethically, this was not always the case; the idea of what is ethical and unethical in medical research has also transformed. The Tuskegee Syphilis study is usually noted as the most unethical and inhumane use of unconsented experimentation on Black Americans in the nation’s medical history. However, …show more content…
James Marion Sims is renowned as the father of modern gynecology in the medical world. By 1850, Dr. Sims developed a surgical technique to repair vesicovaginal fistulas, a severe complication of obstructed childbirth, resulting in him becoming a pioneer of gynecological surgical advancement. His advancements, however, came at the cost of enslaved Black women who were subjected to inhumane and torturous surgical procedures, all without either consent or anesthesia. Discussed in grave detail throughout Harriet Washington’s book, Medical Apartheid, Sims acquired 11 slaves with fistulas and performed surgeries on their genitals repeatedly (65). He would also close their sutures and reopen them to perform the surgeries more than once. Male doctors initially held down the women during these horrific surgeries, but after being unable to bear the painful cries of the victims, the slaves were left to hold each other down when it was time for them to be experimented on again. Though this only scratches the surface of the disturbing procedures performed on these women without their permission, Dr. Sims is still hailed and commended as being a gynecological and surgical pioneer. Some have justified his actions by stating that he did the experiments for the greater good and that a few women had to suffer so that women for generations could be relieved of their pain. However, it’s important to note that he was performing these procedures specifically on Black slave women, not the White female patients who visited his medical office in Montgomery, Alabama. The choice of his victims demonstrates the view of Black bodies existing solely as bodies to be used for benefitting those in the dominant

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the early 1900’s, African Americans were faced with Jim Crow laws that created racial segregation in the United States, specifically the southern states. In The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks, by Rebecca Skloot, the protagonist, Henrietta was deprived of equal medical, legal, and educational services. The new historicism theory illustrates how African Americans were not given equal opportunities to medical attention, legal action and educational services needed as a result of Jim Crow laws. Henrietta is not given proper medical treatment because Jim Crow laws prevent her from receiving the treatment she needs. Henrietta noticed that she was unwell, and sought out her friends before seeking professional treatment, “‘I got a knot on…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In studying the essay “Racism and Research: The Case of the Tuskegee Syphilis Study” written by Allan M. Brandt, it is easy to conclude that the Tuskegee study was founded entirely off racism in the medical community and had no real relevance in the study of syphilis at the experiments’ conclusion. It became something much more useful to psychologists and sociologists to understand the “pathology of racism” rather than the “pathology of syphilis.” (Brandt, 1978, p. 21) The experiment led to the senseless death of dozens of people, hidden under the guise of research that became flimsier and flimsier as years passed and penicillin became widely available. Even after the experiment was finally terminated, the HEW Final Report completely ignored…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction This paper reviews the views of Samuel Hellman and Henry Beecher and their contrasting views on human experimentation. Hellman states that human experimentation is inherently wrong, while Beecher states that it was accidentally wrong. Hellman justifies his position from the perspective of patient-centered care, and against the notion of clinical equipoise. In contrast to Hellman, Beecher, justifies his position based upon past experiments, their flaws, and how to change procedures of experimentation to morally justify them.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Case Study

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Just as Skloot (2010) stated, “when black patients showed-up at white-only hospitals, the staff was likely to send them away, even if it meant they might die in the parking lot” (Skloot, 2010, p. 15). Furthermore, the structural healthcare disparities that Henrietta Lacks demonstrated included the facts that she was a female patient at the time when white men dominated the healthcare field, poverty, lack of education, and being black when whites were given privileges. All these factors have influenced the predatory behaviors of the medical professionals at the time. In fact, Skloot (2010) described that “for Henrietta, walking into Hopkins is like entering a foreign country where she didn’t speak the language” (p. 16) which speaks more about the lack of understanding related to the health services she was…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The video, The Deadly Deception, is a well-produced documentary on unethical behavior in government sponsored scientific research. The piece chronicles the forty year study of untreated syphilis in approximately 400 African-American men from Macon County, Alabama which began in 1932. The utilization of interviews with two survivors of the experiment, Herman Shaw and Charles Pollard, and experts in the fields of research, medicine, and civil rights, along with original film taken during the experiment, results in a believable and startling portrayal of the misuse of human subjects in scientific research. The documentary creatively infuses a play about the now infamous experiment entitled "Miss Evers' Boys" which helps the viewer to understand the lengths to which the United States Public Health Service (USPHS) went to keep…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the 1900s America violated loads of rules with African Americans with the Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment in such ways that you could not even imagine. "The U.S. Public Health Service discontinued a successful program to document and treat syphilis in rural African American populations" (Reverby). According to this citation the purpose of the experiments was to document and treat syphilis among African Americans. However later on in the trials when penicillin became the drug of choice to treat diseases such as syphilis, they were not given the option to be able to use it and still had to go through the rigorous experiments. "Even when penicillin became the drug of choice for syphilis in 1947, researchers did not offer it to the subjects"(Tuskegee Timeline).…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, this new medical development may not be in the hands of black women as there are greater benefits in keeping them out. In a few years, there might be an increased in the number of black women who can afford the high cost, however, the cost is just the first of many barriers to overcome. One such barrier is not in the control of the black woman. White couples’ desire to maintain purity in the race, the white genetic tie is greatly valued, while there is little to no value on the black genetic tie. There is no value in promoting the importance of this tie to black couples, however, there is great value in promising white couples that ‘blackness’ will not be allowed to contaminate the ‘whiteness’ of their children.…

    • 1484 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Allan M. Brandt wrote this article, “Racism and Research: The Case Study of the Tuskegee Syphilis Study” to assert the Tuskegee Study in a historical context and he wanted to relate it to the ethical implications that were seen in the twentieth century. The syphilis study that is being talked about was a study that included 400 syphilitic black men. There was also another 200 black men that were unaffected and served as a control. The issue that Brandt reveals is that when penicillin, the drug that treat syphilis, was revealed in the early 1950s, these 400 black men were not given the treatment. This study went from 1932 to 1972.…

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henrietta Lacks Racism

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Blacks wouldn’t question their doctors when they were told something was wrong because they thought doctors knew best. In the book, “The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks,” it says “Especially black patients in public wards. This was 1951 in Baltimore, segregation was a law and it was understood that black people didn’t question white people’s professional judgement. Many blacks patients were just too glad to be getting treatment since discrimination is hospital was widespread.” Not only was this true but back then blacks didn’t have any background knowledge on anything, so what other choice did blacks have except trusting white doctors and their resource .…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marlene Choi September 25, 2016 SOC 222: The Family Instructor: Naomi Gerstel TA: Yolanda Wiggins 9:05am-9:55am In the reading “Reproduction in Bondage,” from Killing the Black Body, by Dorothy Roberts, the author discusses the conditions black females had to endure during 1800s. During the 19th century, white men dominated the majority of Africans in slavery. Most importantly, black procreation helped sustain slavery and gave slave masters an economic motivation to govern black women’s reproductive lives.…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hartman’s utilization of the white abolitionist John Rankin’s admonishment of slavery through imagining himself and his family as enslaved demonstrates how it actually “inadvertently confirms the expectations and desires definitive of the relations of chattel slavery” (Hartman 19). Hartman recognizes Rankin’s intentions as well-meaning, but argues, “the effort the counteract the commonplace callousness to black suffering requires that the white body be positioned in the place of the black body…” (Hartman 19). This analysis of the “precariousness of empathy” acts as preparation for Hartman’s examination of how whites have often hijacked the black experience for pleasure, both as an instrument of empathy and with nefarious intentions. This…

    • 232 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Aviv uses professors and researchers to support. She goes into gives sources like Troug, the director of the Center of Bioethics at Harvard Medical School, who goes into depth of how social opinions impact medical treatment of others of certain color. Aviv uses Troug’s credibility to emphasize Jahi’s mistreatment at the hospital she originally was being held at. Aviv did a good job with letting the audience know the discrimination in hospitals an malpractice amongst racist doctors and nurses. But this was not the only problem Aviv exposes.…

    • 1488 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Tuskegee Syphilis Essay

    • 1747 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male Forty years ago, 600 of African Americans were horrifically involved in the Tuskegee syphilis experiments. In Macon County, Alabama illiterate black men were taken advantage of and were treated like objects instead of human beings. These victims were told they needed to be treated for having “bad blood”, including fatigue, anemia and syphilis.…

    • 1747 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, how and why it took place when it did must be closely analyzed to determine why it was unethical and to prevent it from reoccurring in the future. According to Allan M. Brandt, the study “revealed more about the pathology of racism than it did about the pathology of syphilis; more about the nature of scientific enquiry than the nature of the disease process.” At the time when the study began, racism was still very prominent throughout the United States, especially in the South. As such, the fact that doctors believed black people to be different and react in a dissimilar fashion to diseases in comparison to white people did not create uproar; instead, it was widely accepted in the medical sector. However, the ethical issues concerning this case go far and beyond the racist nature of the population at the time.…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Slavery has always been an awful thing. But It can be denied it play a major role in our history. For the purpose of this historiographical paper I will focus in slavery in the United States in colonial times. Focusing on African women something that many historian agree hasn’t been talk enough.…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics