The Pros And Cons Of The Endangered Species Act

Superior Essays
The Endangered Species Act of 1973 was passed when the U.S. Congress acknowledged that “various species of fish, wildlife, and plants in the United States have been rendered extinct as a consequence of economic growth and development” (“Endangered Species Act of 1973”). This congressional action has made the killing and eradication of any species illegal across the United States and its territories if said species is protected by the U.S. Federal Government. The Endangered Species Act has certainly been effective in the sense that it prevented many species from going extinct, but that does not mean it is above scrutiny or refinement. There are a few ethical flaws which are reflected in the limitations of protection status offered by the Endangered …show more content…
This includes the basic natural givens: air, soil, water, functioning ecosystems, hydrologic cycles and so on. These could previously be taken for granted. But now the right must be made explicit and defended. Note that is not any claim against or for nature itself; rather it is a claim made against other humans who might deprive us of such nature (Rolston 519-520)”
Many would take that quote and say it opens the door to environmental fascism. Protecting the natural world at all cost, regardless of what humans might want may seem extreme and possibly violate individual rights, but considering what has been allowed to occur in the past, that actually just seem like necessary precaution. Having the U.S. government create regulations so that it is illegal for citizens to essentially ruin the lives of future generations is by no means
…show more content…
Kant believes that “other animals are mere means, and may therefore be used for human purposes” (Korsgaard 97); while it may be true that animals are means from a Kantian perspective, humans cannot actually do whatever they want to them and still be ethical. Looking at the situation deeply, the impact you will have on the ecosystem by contributing to the removal a species will eventually causes problems for other humans, who you have an obligation not to treat as means. Although we have done much to separate human society from the natural world, the fate of our society has always been bound to the natural world:
Environmental quality is necessary for quality of human life. Humans dramatically rebuild their environments; still, their lives, filled with artifacts, are lived in a natural ecology where resources—soil, air, water, photosynthesis, climate—are matters of life and death. Culture and nature have entwined destinies, similar to (and related to) the way minds are inseparable from bodies. So ethics needs to be applied to the environment (Rolston

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Essay On De-Extinction

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Currently many animals are at risk of extinction due to pollution, overharvesting and habitat destruction. (Text 4) In text 3 it states “de -extinction tend to resurrect single charismatic species yet millions of species are at risk of extinction.” In other words there are many species at the brink of extinction yet scientists are concerned about the de-extinction of species. In addition it is believed that de-extinction will become a “moral hazard”.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Environmental fascism is an issue that most try to avoid when structuring a new environmental model. As well as it is also an issue that most try and avoid when trying to figure out how to solve an environmental dilemma because it shows favoritism. In this essay I will discuss why Aldo Leopold is accused of his Land-Ethic model falling into the category of the issue of environmental fascism, and how J. Baird Callicott tries to resolve the accusations. First lets begin with taking a look at what environmental fascism is.…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Augmenting people for the sake of scientific advancement is a topic, which can lead to excitement and hope for the future. Sonia Miller believes that “[b]y welcoming and adopting new technologies [...], the human condition can be redesigned, allowing for personal growth beyond the current biological limitations” (Miller, 61). Although, this type of augmentation also raises serious ethical and social concerns among the general population. The depiction of augmented humans in popular media has become a significant thematic topic, in which our real world discussions influence. Media, such as the popular videogame series Halo, consistently show how biologic and mechanical augmentations are beneficial, and necessary, for the human population’s advancement.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In my eyes, nature should maintain the feeling of freedom that it gives to people and we shouldn’t change the way of nature by excluding native people and set up fences in the means of “protecting”…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Restoration of natural places and respectful stewardship of nature is the only solution to the environmental problems we are…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    a. (EARTH) does have a case to challenge the FWS and NMFS decision not to list the shad. The Endangered Species Act (ESA) was made to stop species that are on the road to extinction, and put them on the path of recovery. The big mouthed shad is one of those species, which relies on Maine rivers for its lifecycle. The FWS and NMFS have completed a status review and have decided, against contrary data, that the fish should not be listed. Much like the spotted owl case (NORTHERN SPOTTED OWL v. HODEL), the agency (FWS, NMFS) did not make the determination based on “the best available scientific and commercial data available” as described in § 4 of the Endangered Species Act.…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After a three year old boy fell into the gorilla encloser at the Cincinnati Zoo, a gorilla grabbed ahold of the boy and dragged him through the water. The gorilla was shot by zoo keepers in order to rescue the boy who was not seriously injured. The gorilla, Harambe, was a western lowland gorilla which is a critically endangered species. Animal rights groups are pressing for an investigation of the zoo because they claim the zoo violated the Animal Welfare Act (Dodley). Was killing the gorilla to the save the boy’s life the right thing to do?…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humanity’s relationship with nature periodically shifts between symbiotic and parasitic. We feed off nature in order to survive, and in exchange, we carefully monitor how our behavior affects the environment and the organisms within it. Responsibility is the price we pay for dominance and sentience. To help fulfill this duty, the United States government established the Wilderness Act in 1954 with the intention of becoming passive “guardians” of nature instead of encroaching “gardeners.” Countless acres of wild lands, henceforth referred to as the “wilderness,” were declared off-limits to American industry and placed under federal oversight; the United States hoped that at least some small portion of nature could be free from the influence…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This week, the reading selections were quite interesting. We have these two authors, Taylor and Epstein, who truly approach the environmental topic in separate ways. On one hand, we have Paul Taylor defending our environment all the way in the article “The Ethics of Respect for Nature”. In this article, Taylor insists that we switch our current perspectives, regarding the environment, to ones that further zoom in on the sake of nature. In fact, Taylor states that “once we reject the claim that humans are superior either in merit or in worth to other living things, we are ready to adopt the attitude of respect” (330).…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Endangered Species Act, like many of the conservation acts, was put in place because people noticed something needed to be done. Although this act is very complex and can be confusing, it has been successful. Nonetheless, since many species are still listed or waiting to be assessed people criticize the act’s effectiveness. In 1966, congress passed the Endangered Species Preservation Act. This listed native animals as endangered and gave limited protection.…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We should respect and preserve as much as the natural world as possible, but use its resources to our…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Endangered Species Act

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Endangered Species Act is the most successful and important conservation act in the United States of America. More than 2,000 plants and animals are protected under this act and 93% of these species have remained stable since they became protected under the ESA. The Endangered Species Act is administered by two federal agencies, the United States Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. The ESA has helped prevent some of our most beloved creatures from extinction, including the Bald Eagle, Gray Wolf, the Florida Manatee, and the Atlantic Green Sea Turtle. Although the act has been tested by non-conservation supporting lawmakers, the act still remains successful due to its recovery rate and habitat…

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Great practice of U.S.A United States had passed an environment law called The Endangered Species Act of 1973 in the 1970s. It serves as the enacting legislation to carry out the provisions outlined in The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 2015). The ESA's primary goal is to prevent the extinction of imperiled plant and animal life, and secondly, to recover and maintain those populations by removing or lessening threats to their survival. And public notice is given through legal notices in newspapers, and communicated to state and county agencies within the species' area. Foreign nations may also receive notice of a listing.…

    • 172 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Kimberly Mund Environmental Ethics Essay # 3 Revised The beauty that surrounds us every day is breath-taking and unique. We look around us and see the artistic flowers to the beautiful birds that fly in the air. We are surrounded by nature’s beauty and in return we should respect what we are blessed with. The question comes down to, what attitude do we adopt when it comes to nature?…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Deciding how to interact and improve the world through ethics and moral reasoning is an ongoing contentious debate that has lasted for thousands of years. Two of the largest moral theories to develop in the twentieth century, that try to deal with the world around us, is environmentalism and animal liberation. Environmentalism is best summarized as the moral principle that biotic communities and the relationships within those communities are of the utmost importance to preserve. Animal Liberation represents the belief that sentience of a being qualifies that individual for moral consideration. If Leopold’s maxim is followed as the standard for land ethicism and the “when” in his maxim is read as a necessary condition then animal liberation…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays