Mental Illness: A Comparative Analysis

Improved Essays
This article focuses on the families ' experiences of mental illness rather than the individual. Boschman explains that having an external party that has seen everything first hand is beneficial in the diagnosis process (2007). LeFrancois and Diamond would note that this actually delegitimizes the individual 's experiences as the individual cannot make sense of their experience for themselves because family members ' accounts are taken as truth (2014). This could also be because 'mentally ill ' individuals are often seen as not being able to take care of themselves. Both articles talk about the framework of performance, where a culturally dominant discourse that is biomedical is a produced effect that is shaped, formed, and reproduced within …show more content…
Authors noted that narrative is a powerful tool that can disrupt dominant discourses and can assist in constructing new discourses that are more inclusive and can work to better meet the needs of individuals (Fook, 2012). I have not done much previous personal research in the field of psychiatry, so this analysis has exposed me to the many problems that individuals face when experiencing mental health stress or trauma and are facing diagnosis. In the field of social work, practitioners and educators reinforce the importance of lived experience as it is unique to everyone and it creates the people that we are. Personal experience and narrative are such an important aspect of social work in that it helps with understanding circumstances, structural barriers, power relations, sites of oppression, and can help enforce appropriate measures for healing. I find it troubling that psychiatry silences this meaningful aspect of social science, and instead focuses on knowledge that was constructed by 'experts ', that further oppresses an individual who has been isolated from society. This comparative analysis has also shown me that when it comes to those who have been labelled as 'mentally ill ', writers are either very supportive of, or very against medication as a remedy. I think that the writers who are very supportive of medication have not been critical enough about when it is appropriate and inappropriate to be administering medication to individuals as some do not need it. There is also much confusion about what is being administered and why, and this needs to be changed (LeFrancois & Diamond, 2014). On the other side of things, writers who are very against medication have perhaps been too critical. Views that were brought forward were that because of so much resistance, the drugs must be doing horrible things to the individual. I side

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    77-85), the author talks about the effects mental illness had in his family. The author discusses the struggles and the changes in relationships that took place as both his sister and older brother became consumed by their mental illness. Early in life the author was very close to his brother but has his brothers illness progressed they became almost strangers. He discusses his sister’s strange behaviors and how he was scared of her. His parents had been keeping it a secret that this sister suffered from schizophrenia.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Medical care is a growing issue as time as progressed. How doctors care for their patients, and how patients react to the care received is sometime a great concern. Nowadays it is harder to perceive any type of care for patients with mental health issues, comparing to a few decades ago, where good medical care for any minority was hard to come by. The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks by Rebecca Skloot follows the life of Henrietta Lacks and her lack of medical care that caused her death, and how the medical world used her cells for success. On the other hand, It’s Kind of a Funny Story by Ned Vizzini highlights Craig Gilner’s time in a psychiatric ward after he checks himself in.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Stigma of mental ill health is 'worse than the illness”, Jeremy Lawrence talks about how people who are mentally ill are becoming discriminated against by ordinary people and that not a lot of people are helping or paying close attention to these people who are in desperate need of help. The mentally ill people are stigmatized because their illness. This author claims that people are deviant due to their irrational behaviors in treating the mentally ill people without care or sensitivity. They are deviant because they are making the situation worse by comparing them to celebs, abusing them, and increasing the rate of the illness. Mentally people are being criticized and discriminated in a wrong way, which can…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In her patients, Slater sees “pain pain pain the patient brings [her] back to… [their] arms [her] arms the wound is one” (Slater 14). Slater’s use of dramatic tone and rhetoric in describing her history of mental health issues creates a sense of dramatic importance and emphasis on the mental health issues themselves. Through this self-identification, Slater shows how her past experiences with mental illness shaped her own perception of the world around her. Throughout the piece, Slater continually references her past experiences, both with her mother and with mental health, and uses a tone that conveys her fear and fragility in the position she currently inhabits. If Slater were not so stubbornly convinced that she was cured, the institution would likely be a trigger for her mental illness that she could not overcome.…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Symptoms are sometimes expressed differently and mental health professionals therefore will diagnose differently, even on a cultural basis. But Hornstein stresses the point that there are alternatives to the medical model, including peer support groups like the Hearing Voices Network (UK) and Freedom Center (USA), which prove to be far more beneficial to mental health patients. There is a belief that mental illnesses are all incurable brain diseases that can only be managed with heavy drug doses. She warns that not every life problem is medical and therefore does not need to be treated with drugs. Before reading Agnes’s Jacket, I always assumed that the pills that are prescribed actually helped the patients and out of naivety I neglected the myriad of possible side effects.…

    • 972 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Megan Rotatori Case Study

    • 1020 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Many people who experience symptoms of mental health or who have been diagnosed with a mental illness have stated that they felt as though their symptoms are dismissed, or lessened (Itkowitz, 2016). As much as there has been progress with many shows changing the narratives of mental illness and online supports, there is still a definite stigma attached to being diagnosed with mental illness (Itkowitz, 2016). I decided to read Megan Rotatori’s survival story. I chose to read her story because I saw her picture and thought that she appears to be someone who many people would not believe to have a mental health diagnosis (Rotatori, 2014). The 20-year-old college student who is currently studying nursing at University of Vermont stated that she…

    • 1020 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pete Earley Reflection

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Reflection Paper: CRAZY A good book should cause you to think, a great book invites you to question your bias and a brilliant book shows you how necessary cultural change is (starting with oneself) and why it is so important. Pete Earley’s transparency in disclosing his family’s journey through mental illness and how America’s culture of indifference towards those who suffer with it, is an invitation to redirect how we approach social justice for those who are mentally ill. As Early begins to understand the long- term ramifications of having a loved one with mental illness in a system rife with problems, he recognizes the need to understand and explore why our approach to mental health is not meeting the needs of such a vulnerable population.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the book, Ethan Watters intents to show how over the last years, typically American conceptions of mental illness have been exported to the rest of the world. According to Watters, the DSM (the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders), also referred sometimes as the “bible” of the profession, and it has become the worldwide standard. In his book, Watters brings his argument with four different case studies that give an insight of the situation in other places around the world when it comes to different mental illness and how those places handle the situation. The first case study centers on the death of an atrophied 14-yeal old in Hong Kong, who fells to her death in 1994, in plain daylight.…

    • 1607 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With “Defining Mental Disability”, Margaret Price explores the complications with bringing order to the titles and beliefs used to define the realm of disabilities considered mental. For one, there is the issue of what terms are appropriate to label mental disorders. Price points out the trouble that comes from singularly identifying a very diverse group of conditions, as well as the differences in connotations found from region to region (298-299). Then there is the problem of how to perceive mental ailments. Are they something to cure, or are they a natural extension of a person that should not be seen as an enfreakment of sorts?…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In 335 BC Aristotle suggested that the heart was in fact where mental information was processed. Eventually it came to be known that mental functions were actually processed in the brain and also people were beginning to discover that the brain can mess up. Mental illness was seen as a problem in society. As a problem that became more and more prevalent, people began to look for a solution. The only issue with looking for a solution was that no one had known where to look.…

    • 1477 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We are the ones that are unnoticed and shamed for existing under the control of the ‘non-existent’ disease of mental disorders. A disease which effects one in seven Australians in their lifetime , though education systems continue to refute the significance of expressing mental illness. I was criticised in school for exploring the subject matter or mental illness and domestic violence in my artwork, where I was told that it is too “controversial” and “confronting” for people. My artwork comprised of an expressionistic self-portrait with a monochromatic colour scheme, engaging the audience through raising awareness on the stigma surrounding mental illness that it rarely addressed on a public scale.…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cultural Biases Paper

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Cultural Beliefs/Biases There is a stigma associated with mental illness and drug use due to the fact that mental illness is caused by a chemical imbalance in the brain, and the medication’s ability to reduce symptoms (Medication, 2016). The belief that the mentally ill are crazy also ties into this stigma with them needing to be medicated as well. There is a correlation that one of the first thought that comes into a persons mind when they are told the person next to them suffers from a mental illness is ‘are they crazy?’ (Kam, n.d.). The assumption that being medicated for mental illness and being ‘crazy’ because they have a mental illness is a result of social stratification.…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Mental Illness Viewpoints

    • 2024 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Generating the validity of mental illnesses as an actual genetic issue or something society controls has come to the surface for researchers. Those that self evaluate themselves by diagnosing a mental illness are ones that are the focus point for whether mental illness is actually an illness, or if societal opinion is corrupting their personal belief about their state of mind. An article that comes from Opposing Viewpoints-Overview of Mental Illness, gages the question of society being an aid to mental patients in order to obtain treatment. The article that is at hand describes the background of mental illness, gives examples of treatment, and the causes behind the diagnosis. An article that is comparative in rhetorical devices as well as…

    • 2024 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mental illness has become a serious issue affecting an abundance of people all across the United States. According to NAMI: National Alliance on Mental Illness, 43.8 million adults experience some type of mental illness, and 10 million adults experience a severe mental disorder affecting their day to day life. Mental disorders affect more than the individuals with the disease, but the friends and families taking care of them as well. Over the years, scientists have developed a variety of medications to help patients suffering with mental disorders.…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    According to the Canadian Association of Social Workers “mental health is the capacity of the individual, the group and the environment to interact with one another in ways that promote subjective well-being, the optimal development and use of mental abilities, achievement of individual and collective goals consistent with justice and the attainment and preservation of conditions of fundamental equality” (Regeher & Glancy, 2014, p. 2). This definition gives us a broad overview of what is perceived to be mental health, I will use this term to base what mental health is throughout this paper as I examine my own thoughts, feelings, attitudes and beliefs about what it means to live with mental illness. I will consider my own personal narratives…

    • 1449 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays