The Book Of Salt And Exile According To Julia By Gisele Pineau

Great Essays
In exploring such a poignant topic as exile, one must first examine the group of people most likely to be subjected to exile. Often, this group tends to be the socially observed “other.” What an other is can change drastically depending on who is defining it, and to whom they’re assigning the term. As we’ve seen in both Book of Salt by Monique Truong, and Exile According to Julia by Gisele Pineau, the characters Bihn and Man Ya represent comparable, but fundamentally different ideas of the other in French society. They are used, in many situations, as representatives of their race as a whole, and the French ruling class is often depicted as categorizing these character’s acceptability in their country by previous notions of Bihn and Man Ya’s …show more content…
Another category that allows groups in power to determine who is classified as the other is language. Language serves as a central conflict in both Bihn and Man Ya’s narratives, because their native tongue doesn’t match the official spoken narrative of the French ruling class. The first example of this we’re introduced to in The Book of Salt manifests itself in the refusal for Bihn’s employers to learn to properly pronounce his name. Even after he’s repeated it for them multiple times, Gertrude Stein’s, Alice B Toklas’, and Sweet Sunday Man’s pronunciations fail to improve. In fact, Sweet Sunday man makes no attempt to even say Bihn’s full name, choosing instead to call him Bee, something that’s revealed to greatly trouble, and further isolate Bihn from the society around him. Furthermore, Bihn’s native Vietnamese and Man Ya’s native Creole are described as abrasive, unnatural, loud, and angry to those who naturally speak French, or English. In this way their native tongue serves as an indication of their worth, people denouncing them as lower because of their unnatural …show more content…
For Bihn, the only was he can possibly survive is by learning the language. He needs to have at least a basic understanding of it to know what his employers are saying to him, and needs to have a basic comprehension of how to respond in order to be deemed competent. The ability to speak the language is seen as a status symbol. Bleriot, a native French speaker, is said to have “placed great trust in the power of his language to elevate him from the fray, to keep his nose clean even when he was rooting in the dirt of someone else’s land (Truong 123).” Bihn cannot pass for a native speaker, though. Through the eyes of the French people, he’s merely a “little Indochinese, who can’t even speak proper French, who can’t even say more than a simple sentence (Truong 15)”, and because of that, he’s demoted to a life of service. If he can’t speak the language, his only use is to learn to understand it, learn to “swallow [foreign words]… the vocabulary of servitude (Truong 13).” In this way, Bihn’s imperfect French marks him as a foreigner, and by definition, an other. For Man Ya, the same understanding holds true. As accentuated through the education of her grandchildren, the path to success for black immigrants starts with literacy, and the acquisition of a proper French way of speaking. But unlike Bihn, she makes little attempt to learn a new language. Man Ya seems to put

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In chapter one, the author Martha Menchaca discusses the racial foundations and history of Mexican-American Indians, Whites, and Blacks. Menchaca begins her chapter discussing how archeologists and anthropologists in the past before the 1960s had little interest in recovering Mexican-American prehistory. It was not until the 1970s Mexican-American anthropologists began to recover their culture’s prehistory. Menchaca also shares that Mexican-American indigenous past is both in Mexico and the Southwest and have roots tracing back to Aztlán. She argues that Aztlán may not have been the true site of the origins of many Indians.…

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It would be fascinating to ken, for instance, Antilleans' views on the headscarf debate or African perspectives on the failure of French Republican sentiment to acknowledge its debt to former slaves. Does French gregarious policy guarantee the segregation of immigrants from each other? Do they all only orient themselves to the hegemonic cultural and political organizations, to the French conception of itself as a coalesced national culture? Beriss observes pointedly that Antilleans incline to optically discern themselves as a "culture group," not a race, which is in conformity with French gregarious scientific literature that evades discussion of race cognations. In this veneration, we could optically discern the cultural work of Créolité as a distinctively "French" practice.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her novel, A Medieval Life, Judith Bennett attempts to showcase the daily life of a peasant woman, Cecilia Penifader, as she lives on the English manor Brigstock in the mid-fourteenth century. During this time period Europe was full of thousands of rural communities including Brigstock. Brigstock was located in a very manorialized part of England which was the English midlands near London. Bennett works to redirect focus from the readers’ fairytale view of the middle ages to a more accurate view of how life really was. “Most medieval people were not knights, kings, churchmen, or merchants.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    NAME : ZIPPORAH NGARE-KARUA COURSE TITLE/NUMBER: HIST 1301 PROFESSOR’S NAME : MRS. RENEE CELESTE DATE : 11/29/2017 Celia, a Slave by Melton A. McLaurin, is an historiographical book that explains life events of slaves in the antebellum era in Missouri and politics that surrounded the ownership of slaves. McLaurin uses Celia, Robert Newson’s slave as the main character to propel us into the history of slavery and conquest in abolishing it. The country had disputes of free states versus slave states being legalized and national debates in Kansas caught up with Celia’s story.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Christine de Pizan’s Book of City of Ladies is often regarded as a response to misogynistic writings of women in many literary works done by influential men, in which they portray women as “vile creatures.” Paula Rieder, while never mentioning any of Christine’s work, discusses medieval women and misogyny; At first, medieval times were glorious for woman in the eyes of many scholars, but as time passes, many scholars started to notice trend of misogyny. Rieder produces detailed accounts from different historians and scholars of the lifestyle of women during the middle ages and its relation to the misogynistic works. She recounts Ruth Mazo Karras’ statement in which clerics failing to include women on important topics that affect them and referring…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Immigrants in Canada have a strong belief of “Land full of Opportunities” and a desired life that a developed country can give them. People from different parts of world move to Canada with a hope to live a better life. However, on immigration to a different place there are various obstacles that one has to face. Barriers like language, racism, culture etc hinder immigrant’s progress in a new place. In the following journal entry, I will be discussing in detail about various barriers, based in excerpts from stories by Mehri Yalfani, Himani Bannerji and Isabel Vincent.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Writings by white, male, upper-class individuals dominate the canon of Western History. While such a dominance does not negate their scholarship, the voices of the marginalized—women, the poor and ethnic minorities—are not represented in this limited historical viewpoint. Many mid-20th century historians felt that there was a need to counter this inequality of representation. For example, E.P. Thompson, Clifford Geertz and Natalie Zemon Davis each generated works that revealed the history of a previously marginalized group. Despite their different areas of expertise, the academics ' approaches are essentially compatible, insofar as they exhibit the same ultimate goal—giving a voice to the marginalized—and compensate for each other’s shortcomings.…

    • 1456 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the novel, characters of low social status…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the cultural narrative divides refugees from nativists and finds reasons to bar refugees from entry to countries, Mohsin Hamid not only reveals the refugee perspective, but also questions the idea of nativism itself as a legitimate reason for division. While Exit West follows the story of Nadia and Saeed, it also includes the many other refugees that the couple run into, and the doors present opportunities not only for refugees fleeing war and persecution, but also for everyday people that are looking for a new place to go. In the main plotline, the couple meet and live with other refugees, but the subplots in each chapter – which break from any known characters and jump into a new story entirely – include the magical realism of the doors,…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Throughout history there have been many cases of assimilation. However, almost every attempt has been unsuccessful. For example, after evangelizing native-Americans in the west, native culture continued to exist. The short story “The Lost Sister”, by Dorothy M. Johnson, explains the unsuccessful and negative effects of forced assimilation of the aboriginal people. The tragic consequences of assimilation are exhibited through the protagonist’s family’s ignorant ideas of Aunt Bessie before and after her arrival.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is a tremendous difference between dealing with the Hmong and dealing with anyone else. An infinite difference” (69). This cultural barrier prevented the Lees from keeping custody of Lia as they failed to comprehend the importance of providing Lia with her medication. The consequences of the barriers on the Lees enact the contemplation of one’s own privilege in knowing the most common language. Thus the emphasis on the significance of culture and the barriers it creates opens the mind of the reader, and provides a different education than that tested in…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With a close up of various regions of countries, one can see how everyone who speaks a language will not speak it the same way. Created in the 1980s, American Tongues is an informative documentary that illustrates the theme of dialectal variation in the United States. America has been considered a melting pot for multiple diverse people and cultures. In the past, settlers who traveled to and across the United States left their mark on various regions as they brought their accents, such as African languages molding dialects of the South and how French and English is intermingled by Cajuns in Louisiana. However, the documentary demonstrates and highlights how people tend to create stereotypes for people who do not speak the same way they do and how people may even change their accent to be accepted.…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Frantz Fanon’s The Wretched of the Earth is a powerful text concerning the struggle faced by colonized people on their journey against colonialism and towards liberation. Rooted not only in psychology but also in Marxism and critical theory, the book provides an analysis of number issues related to colonialism and decolonization. Fanon methodically examines a diverse range of issues including, but not limited to, racial identity formation, language, class, and the way in which they interact with the liberation struggle and alter the relationship between colonizer and colonized. The topic of violence however, is addressed repeatedly.…

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Edward Said once wrote that the concept of exile is “the unhealable rift forced between a human being and a native place.” While his general claim is that exile “can never be surmounted,” Said adds that it can potentially be an “enriching” ordeal. In the African tragedy, Things Fall Apart, author Chinua Achebe presents the impact of such a detrimental experience through his protagonist, Okonkwo. Throughout the novel, Okonkwo’s struggle to gain respect and improve his social status eventually consumes him when he is challenged by the cultural differences and the conflicting beliefs of masculinity. When Okonkwo endures the physical exile bestowed upon him in his motherland, Mbanta, he is also mentally exiled from the other tribe members.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The book entitled “Sophie’s World” was written by Jostein Gaarder, who was born in Oslo, Norway, in 1952. He was an intellectual author that teaches high school Philosophy. Gaarder often writes about Philosophy and its main Contribution to the society and oneself. He published his first book in year 1986 and one of his best-sellers is the Sophie’s world that was published in year 1991. Sophie’s world is a novel that talks about a girl named Sophie who explored through the History of Western Philosophy together with his teacher in Philosophy, Alberto Knox.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays