Mark Traugott's Armies Of The Poor

Improved Essays
In his book, “Armies of the Poor,” Mark Traugott examines the motivations behind insurrection and loyalty amidst the June Days of France’s Second Republic. The June Days were preceded by the February Days in which the monarchy under Louis Philippe was overthrown by a popular uprising. The new moderate Republican government promised to create institutions that would alleviate unemployment in Paris. The most important of these institutions were the Mobile Guard and the National Workshops. Both organizations recruited the Parisian unemployed for their memberships. Unfortunately, these measures by the government were only somewhat effective, and eventually lead to a violent uprising by the Parisian workforce. Thus, Traugott argues that in the four …show more content…
The National Workshops, as they were known, were created to solve the same three problems that the Mobile Guard did. According to Traugott, membership in this new organization was expected to peak at 12,000, but enrollments eventually settled at 120,000 (Traugott 121). These numbers, while unexpected, did not change the structure of the National Workshops, but it caused issues later on. The rank and file were comprised of all sectors of the Parisian working class. Like the Mobile Guard, the National Workshops were organized in a military style structure with an officer corps. However, this officer corps was drawn only from students who attended the Ecole Centrale school in Paris. Thus, the officer corps was unified based on fraternal association from their time spent in school. The result of this organizational technique was an officer corps that reigned in the more radical workers, which ensured the loyalty of the National …show more content…
Therefore, I strongly agreed with his refutations of other hypothesis based on the evidence he provided. For example, he directly refuted Marx’s hypothesis with data that showed that the Mobile Guard did not overwhelmingly employ men who could be considered lumpenproletariat. Thus, Traugott justified his organizational hypothesis through refutation. However, Traugott did leave space for more research into the subject. For example, he did not discuss broader economic policy in the moderate Republic to better understand why the National Workshops were never able to employ more than 14,000 Parisians a day. Additional research in this area would strengthen Traugott’s argument if he were able to link economic policy to the decision to dissolve the National Workshops, which he argued was the tipping point in the Workshop’s political

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Terror was not simply the moment at which the French government unleashed its violence against its own people. The Terror, as it was seen during the Revolution itself, was rather a way by which one chose to think; it was, in essence, a rejection of monarchy and a willingness to proclaim full separation from the former rulers of the nation. This notion was perceived as an effort to intimidate the upper classes to enforce a new ideological era, not simply to employ physical violence against suspicious individuals. When Robespierre famously proclaimed that virtue and terror needed to be combined during the French Revolution, his message was not intended to be a justification of outright cruelty, but instead a compelling commentary on precisely how intimidation needed be used to threaten the royalist ideology. Indeed, while this was the valid historical use of the term, many abused its connotations and took it upon themselves to officiate a barbarous corporeal war against the French Republic’s supposed…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many citizens did not want to give up the monarchy French had. Other citizens rebelled against the “levee en masse”, a military draft in Vendee (Doc C). On top of the forced draft, the government also tried to abolish Christianity, upsetting French citizens even more (Doc C). These events caused the citizens to revolt against the local government (Doc A). Even though many citizens were against the revolution, they were innocent and did not deserve the Terror against them.…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Revolution greatly changed life for ordinary Americans in many ways. The author, Alfred F. Young, examined the story of George R.T. Hewes, and exemplified the ways in which his life coincided and contributed to the events of the Revolution. It is widely believed that the Revolution was mainly fought by people solely for their great pride in their freedom, and need for liberty. But, Young debunks this generalization, mainly by examining the reasons…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reign Of Terror Dbq

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages

    A time during the French Revolution, there came the Reign of terror, a one year period that saw countless scores of innocent citizens being guillotined. What exactly made a country that was running successful war crusades abroad degenerate into social terror, mass incarceration, and blatant executions unprecedented before? The economy was destitute, and the taxes were inflated. The poor do not have much liking for the rich, and in the French case, where the nobility was oppressive, an insurrection was therefore inevitable (Hunt, 33).…

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The great social theorist and philosopher, Isaiah Berlin once stated, “Injustice, poverty, slavery, ignorance - these may be cured by reform or revolution. But men do not live only by fighting evils. They live by positive goals, individual and collective, a vast variety of them, seldom predictable, at times incompatible.” In simpler terms, Berlin is saying that to cure injustice and poverty, men may use revolution and reform but they cannot “live only by fighting evils”, they must also live by positive goals that protect society’s interests as a whole and not become guided by their own ignorance. And it is for these reasons that Maximilien Robespierre’s Reign of Terror was not justified.…

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Burke and Orenstein I didn’t see that they tried to control the rise of industry but tried to control the workers, realization of how the sudden and fundamental changes the industrial revolution would change their lives not necessarily for the best. The government used many forms of propaganda to keep its patrons in line using religion to quote that it was their Christian duty to submit and be content as willed by a higher power. They limited education to basic needs as required for their factory work. They felt it was best to keep the population ignorant they had no freedom, no education and no options. There had been riots but the government clamped down using all sorts of propaganda from religious persons and poets to use words to…

    • 155 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The development of the French Revolution mirrors the development of egalitarian freedom to oppressive ideals, only emphasised through changed’ of government systems; what began as a fight for equality, soon deteriorated to oppressive tyranny and radicalised egalitarianism. Initially, a progressive society based on an obsolete government, the French Revolution epitomises the power of the people and the arbitrariness of revolution, echoed through the changes of governance systems’. b The impetus of the Revolution - socio-political and economic inequity against the bourgeoisie and proletariat, established the foundations of the revolution. The immensity of political unrest in France dominantly influenced the development of the Revolution through…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a time of dire change and the opportunity for revitalization, the American and French Revolution are key time periods that share very root similarities, but also branch out with individualistic differences. Both of these revolutions were rooted in subverting a monarchical government, overthrowing what each country believed to be unjust ways of ruling a nation. The American colonists found themselves deep in the British tyrannical rule, a key analogy to the weak peasants of France that were knee deep in the tyrannical rule of the French monarchy and nobleman. The two revolutions were a result of alarming economic crisis and conditions.…

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Annotated Bibliography Secondary Sources Andress, David. The French Revolution and the People. London: Hambledon and London, 2004. Andress?s publication provides the perspective of the people and the revolution.…

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It established a Civilian Conservation Corps, intended to take young men, who were out of work and not attending school, off the streets and put them somewhere where this youthful energy could be put to good use, rather than have them get into trouble. To critics, it seemed a paramilitary force was being created.…

    • 54 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There were already separations within the community between the ““worker members” [who] were interested in action, not ideology, [and] the students [who] were more inclined to theory than practice.” These rifts within the group did not cause many problems early on, since cells did not frequently meet with one another, and they were all fighting against the government and the social elite. Later in the 60’s, though, the internal issues became divisive as certain cells protested the extremely violent actions of other cells which eventually lead to the collapse of the FLQ. Pierre Vallières and Charles Gagnon “joined the FLQ informally in 1964” and were prominent in the promotion of a workers’ state and intensified bombing. They embraced harsher and more violent demonstrations (“more and bigger bombs” ) in hopes that it would encourage the workers to rise up and revolt. This was not the case, to the chagrin of the FLQ.…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many historians have found it difficult to precisely define a reason as to what caused ‘The Terror,’ this is due to it being a culmination of terrible events leading to tyranny. ‘The Terror’ can be defined as the period within 1793 and 1794, when the Robespierre subjugated Jacobian group executed, without remorse, any opposing citizens to their regime. Through the critical analysis of Maximilien Robespierre’s speech ‘On the moral and political principles of domestic policy’ in conjunction with Revolutionary France written by Furet Francois and other secondary sources, this essay will argue the differing perspectives provided by historians to discover a definitive cause to ‘The Terror’ through a common relationship that it holds with the theme of virtue. The context of this period being, the Industrial…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As the Revolution gained more power, its leaders became more paranoid. In 1793, Maximilien Robespierre, who had assumed most of the power in France, declared that a reign of terror would begin. During this period of time, the French government’s first priority was keeping the Revolution safe from people who wanted…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One question historians wonder about is, was Karl Marx’s call for the worker to upsurge in a revolution to seize power is justified. In the first half of the 1800’s, the workers were miserable, suffering low pay, poor work, and living conditions and they had no political power. The primary sources of The Berlin factory rules from the Foundry and Engineering Works of the Royal Overseas Trading Company, the Workers’ revolution was justified. In the latter half of the 1800’s the revolution was not justified.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Source A, a visual source titled, “1789- Burden of the Three Estates” depicts the three estates and the financial pressures put on the Third Estate. The depiction shows the struggles of the class imbalance between the three estates and the economic differences between the estates. Three figures are shown, representing each of the different estates and how they contribute to the burdens. The figure on the right represents the First Estate, known as the clergy. This can be seen through the crosier the man is holding and the mitre hat that is worn which represents a bishop.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays