Secondary Victim

Improved Essays
In Alcock, the House of Lords made it clear that there would be no liability to a secondary victim who is told about the incident through a third party (this includes newspaper coverage and television broadcasts). Lord Ackner left open the possibility that watching a live broadcast could ground a claim if it clear that the victim had died. He recognised that live broadcasts "gave rise to feelings of the deepest anxiety and distress". Unfortunately, he concluded that "in the circumstances of this case, the simultaneous TV broadcast of what occurred cannot be equated with the sight or hearing of the event or its immediate aftermath". We propose that the law adopts a less restrictive interpretation of what 'perception' means. This requirement …show more content…
which violently agitates the mind" as opposed to a continuous process of dealing with the incident. This rule is "arbitrary and unfair... simply designed to restrict recovery and avoid a flood of liability". Unlike the ruling in Alcock, the Lordships in the Walters case took a realistic approach and held that a mother was able to recover as a secondary victim, for the psychiatric harm she suffered as a result of the negligent treatment which lead to the death of her son. The court had established that such a shocking event should not be confined to a single moment in time, the thirty six hours before her sons dead was classed as a single horrifying event. This ruling is evidently in line with the opinion of Ward LJ who stressed the importance of examining the "totality of the circumstances" which surround the accident. In a recent negligence case, Michael Kent stated that witnessing the consequences of the negligent act does not equate to witnessing a shocking event. In relation to the experience undergone by the police officers at the Hillsborough disaster, Henry L.J argued that "the length of the exposure and the circumstances of the exposure was the trauma that caused the psychiatric injury, rather than any sudden and immediate shock"'. He added that it “is not...the trigger, but the fact and foreseeability of psychiatric damage, by whatever process”. Recent developments in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The cases listed in the notes section of the opinion demonstrate that prior court decisions, that lead to events very similar in this case, found the initial action of the defendant caused a chain reaction of events that inevitably lead to a victim’s death. In this case, had Cheeks not stabbed Joe Howell, to begin with, surgery would not have been necessary and the results of the surgery, that lead to Howell’s death, would never have…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Peter Donelly: How Stats Fool Juries In the lecture video, “Peter Donelly: How Stats Fool Juries,” Donelly explains how statistics are misrepresented and how they have fooled juries in past court cases. In the beginning of his lecture, Donelly compares and contrasts coin toss outcomes to genetic sequence combinations. What separates genetic combinations from that of a coin toss is that there are far more factors in genetics than there are in a simple head-tail coin toss.…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the court case The People of the State of Colorado v. Sandra L. Jacobson, Jacobson is convicted of homicide. The homicide resulted from her truck colliding with a taxi cab while she was driving under the influence. There were two passengers in the taxi at the time of the collision and both were killed. Jacobson appealed the court’s decision on the basis that the trial court did not allow her attorneys to gauge whether or not the jury had become biased due to mid-trial publicity that included inadmissible information. On the fourth day of the trial, the Court was made aware of the fact that a local television network would be covering the incident that led to this trial on its evening news program.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Polarising the nation, The Queen v Baden-Clay case demonstrates the extent to which the Australian media can adversely affect the success of legal proceedings. The Australian adversarial system enforces strict rules of procedure, which are imperative to achieve equality and adequate protection in society. Although it is deemed effective, imperfections are evident (Skwirk Online Education, Nd). The Gerald Baden-Clay case highlights the strengths and weaknesses of the criminal justice system through the efficiency of the standard of evidence, rights of the accused, precedent and appeal used within the relentless trial to prove an accused murderer guilty.…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The actuality of the case of State v. Stewart consist of a variety of mental, physical and emotional abuse in which Peggy Stewart had been “pushed” in her own mind to kill her husband to escape from his toxic and cruel behavior. As a result, the facts of the case are a wide variety that contributed to Peggy’s “imminent danger” state of mind when deciding whether her actions were truly self-defense. These include the abuse at hand, physiological trauma that Peggy experienced, and professional opinions about Peggy’s actions. An important factor of the case is Peggy Stewart’s significant abuse by her husband, Mike. Additionally, Mike’s abuse was not only to Peggy; but also to her daughter, Carla.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The impact caused the neighbor to fly 20 feet into an embankment causing her injuries and hurled Elizabeth under the defendant’s vehicle resulting in her death. The husband, Benjamin sustained injuries and ‘mental and emotional’ disturbances. Defendant filed an appeal. Procedural History: Multiple plaintiffs filed 3 different cases against defendant Graham.…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Each case is unique and has its own details as to how the alleged incident came into play. Therefore, each case needs to be analyzed in detail and reviewed before deciding who is at fault and to what degree they deserve to be punished. In the situation of “The Case of Jeanette M. and the Phone Call” adapted from chapter one of “Medical Law and Ethics” written by Bonnie Fremgen, it describes a medical situation that resulted in the death of an elderly women. The ethical and or legal issues in…

    • 1877 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    here are two recognised standards of proof in Scots law. The first is beyond reasonable doubt, which is usually in criminal cases. The second is on the balance of probabilities which arises mostly in the civil context. This would suggest that the law on the standard of proof is straightforward. However ambiguity arises in the argument that there is or that there should be a third standard.…

    • 1066 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Andrew Peryer Case Study

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Andrew Peryer Handed Over a Heavy Fine While Taking His Terminally-Ill Wife to Hospital A man has been fined heavily after not being able to take proper notice of a bus lane sign as he was driving his terminally-ill wife to an adjacent hospital. However; the person has accused the council of “underhand behavior”. It was two days ago that Andrew Peryer was sent a photograph and this happened after the death of his wife Wendy aged 53 years. In the photo, it was clearly shown that the couple was in the lane outside Queen Alexandra Hospital in Portsmouth.…

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a response to years of domination and human rights movement, the phrase “blaming the victim” was coined by William Ryan in the book he published in 1971 (Schoellkopf,2012). Many people have adopted the phrase including supporters of crime victims, specifically rape victims. In the Old Testament concerning tragic events, various instances of victim blaming can be found considering blaming the victim as sinners (Robinson as cited in Schoellkopf, 2012). Victim blaming is one of the unfortunate consequences of a belief in a just world. According to Schoellkopf (2012), it is an occurrence that has been recently recognized as a dynamic used in maintaining status quo and empowering criminals.…

    • 240 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The actus reus of murder in essence is the physical act of committing murder. It requires three elements. Causation, which means that something happens, and the result as for this is death. Causation itself can be split into legal causation and factual causation. The latter, follows the 'but for ' test, 'but for ' subject B being stabbed by subject…

    • 1560 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The unforeseen death of Princess Diana left the world in sorrow. Following her death, many public speeches and articles regarding this tragic event were released. Queen Elizabeth gave a televised speech, Earl Spencer gave a eulogy, the BBC broadcasted a report, and Wikipedia released an article. The BBC report and the eulogy were rhetorically effective, while Queen Elizabeth’s speech and the Wikipedia article were not.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Self-defence On the 4th of April, 2016, a matter was heard in the Supreme Court regarding Nicolas Blyton and the co-accused, Tim Cairns, charged with the murder of Blyton’s father. The key legal issue that was addressed during the trial was the commonly invoked ground for the use of defensive force, self-defence. The relevant provisions of the Criminal Code 1899 (QLD) (‘The Code’) establishes a defence of self-defence covering the relevant circumstances in which the use of force can be used. In regards to the case at hand, s271 stipulates the use of self-defence against an unprovoked assault.…

    • 1530 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    To undermine him the Pittston company used a case in 1899. where the Virginia Court system overturned a verdict of Claude Davis on the backing that he had suffered mental injury with no physical injury,” Mental suffering alone, and unaccompanied by other injury, cannot sustain in action for damages or be considered as an element of damages”(Stern,222). Pittston also used the 1945 case of Theresa Monteleone after she was awarded then stripped of her 5000$ reward due to the fact the courts decided that there was no correlation between the scars that the shattered glass made on her face and mental illness( Stern,223). Pittston…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A recent study has found that ‘One Punch Assaults’ have cost 90 Australian lives since 2000, most fuelled by drugs and alcohol abuse. Due to the increase in Youth Violence, Queensland’s Newman Government, as part of its Safe Night Out Legislation Amendment Act, 2014 has introduced the offence of ‘Unlawful Striking causing death.’ This recently developed law has a tougher penalty than manslaughter because it eliminates certain defences that are available under the charge of manslaughter. In the Criminal Code 1899, (QLD) Section 314A states that for the offence of Unlawful striking causing death, the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that the defendant unlawfully struck another person to the head or neck and caused the death…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays