Students As Storytellers Analysis

Improved Essays
Review of Howard’s “Students as Storytellers: Teaching Rhetorical Strategies through Folktales” In the NCTE journal, Teaching English in the Two-Year College, PhD student Jeffrey Howard published a fascinating article titled “Students as Storytellers: Teaching Rhetorical Strategies through Folktales.” In the article, Howard explains how he was able to captivate students with an assignment that gave them the creative license to reinvent a popular fairytale, Little Red Riding Hood, all while asking students to explore and develop rhetorical strategies in their composition. The article shows the value of using literature in the composition classroom as well as how the practically universal texts of fairytales can reach students of almost …show more content…
He found that he also needed to find a way to use such a project to give contextualized and significant rhetoric instruction, and not just have a creative writing activity or a reflective writing assignment. Howard cites several prominent folklorists, including Lynn McNeill, as well as other teacher-scholars who have discussed both the benefits and difficulties with using literature in a composition classroom. With his research, he decides to ask students to implicitly add an “agenda” to their reinterpreted fairy tales. He gives students the agency to choose whichever version of the fairytale they are most familiar with, or to use one of the ones he provided. Howard gives a lesson on “agenda” and explains to students that it doesn’t have to have the negative connotations that it has in politics today; it simply needs to be a moral lesson or argument that is underlying and not expressly stated in their story. The article provides examples of the some of the best student writing that came from this project with Howard’s explanations of how those students succeeded in both the rewriting of the fairy tale and in putting an implicit argument that was identifiable in their story’s subtext. Students who were not as successful either made their agendas too explicit …show more content…
It is also clear that Howard has worked hard to make this project accessible and relevant for as many students as possible. Howard achieves this accessibility by giving students completely open options for which version of the “Little Red Riding Hood” fairy tale to reinterpret. He mentions many culturally diverse versions that students can choose from, but also gives students several options if they aren’t sure what they want to choose, including film depictions which would reach students who work better with visual or audio texts and multimodality. These are just some of the strengths of the article and the assignment, based on what readers can garner from the article. As a prospective GTA, I wish that Howard could have shown some examples of student work that fell short. Without necessarily showing a specific student’s work, the article would have benefited from having a clear example of writing that had too explicit of an argument or writing that was all creative with no argument at all. Giving the good samples was incredibly valuable, and it would have helped even further to demonstrate exactly which student writing didn’t meet expectations. These additional writing samples would have helped other teachers who want to know what they might expect if they recreated this assignment or

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Choose three popular characters. They can be cartoon characters (Ren from Ren and Stimpy, Michelangelo from TMNT), protagonists from plays or novels, (Bella from the Twilight series, Benvolio from Romeo and Juliet) or characters from movies or TV shows (William Wallace from "Braveheart", Jess from "New Girl"). Choose a popular fairy tale. (Snow White and the Seven Dwarves, Goldilocks and the Three Bears, Hansel and Gretel, etc.) Write three, one-paragraph summaries of your selected fairy tale using each of your chosen character's voices.…

    • 142 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The storyteller” is an article by Sandra Cisneros about her life journey beginning from post graduate school to a school teacher. In between she writes about her life in the point of views of a dependent, a growing writer, and a teacher, with short descriptions that gives the reader a glimpse of her mentality on each stage. All that is mixed up into the life of an average Hispanic woman from Chicago. Halfway through her article, during her “growing writer” stage, Cisneros writes a paragraph about what her and her friends do together.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Journal Response The chapter “Helping Writers Think Rhetorically” by John C. Bean describes how important it is to have students thinking about their audience and purpose before starting to write their compositions. Bean explains how thinking about a targeted audience will give the writers a better idea about their audiences´ thinking before reading their papers and the expectations after having read their works. In the study, Bean comments that most of the times students mistake by thinking of their teacher as their only audience for their composition project. Therefore, Bean highlights the need to have students practicing writing to imaginary audiences in order to develop their skills to target different mindsets using different rhetorical…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Francine Prose

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout her essay, Prose uses rhetorical devices such as ethos, rhetorical questions, and cause and effect to illustrate the negative relationship between culturally diverse literature in high school curriculums and the students being taught using them. Ultimately, Prose employs these devices to establish credibility, reiterate any ideas she made earlier in her writing and highlight the effects new curriculums have on high school…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    With the rhetorical situation, I gained a clear understanding of my topic, angle, and purpose which helped me decide which genre is most appropriate for my writing project. I can understand and analyze rhetorical situations which helps me contribute to strong, audience-focused, and organized writing.…

    • 45 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She discusses the common standards that fairytales have placed on females and how they have transferred their way into a way of life and thinking. Orenstein continues to point out the pressures Cinderella provides, but fails to acknowledge how girls now seem…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When choosing whether or not to include a specific text in the curriculum, an English teacher must consider many things to determine the story’s relevance, such as the content of the story and universal themes. Ishmael Beah’s memoir A Long Way Gone is appropriate for the Sterling High School English IV curriculum because of its use of complex ideas and universal themes that make this text a worthy champion for the curriculum. Beah’s extensive and sophisticated figurative language appeal to the reader and forces him to think beyond literal representation and think about the deeper meaning.…

    • 953 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An interview with Tiffany Burgess, a high school teacher who teaches theatre arts class and a director of school productions, was conducted to provide background information and her point of view on writing in the arts and humanities. I was also invited to watch some of her students perform their monologues as instructed. I took notes on her lecture and noted her perseverance to always do their best on their monologues. Because of her perspective on writing and her classroom working hard, Tiffany has received full credibility as a great primary source.…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Literacy Narrative I did a lot of writing while I was in the tenth grade. The English teacher I had at the time was the best when it came down to writing. I did not have too much interest in writing at the time but Mrs. Perez changed that, she gave me a new perception on writing and how it can change society. Mrs. Perez would always recommend really good books, one of which was a book called “His Dark Materials”. This story is about a young girl and her allies, fight for the discover of a dark substance called the “Dust”.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This assessment is intended for the lesson plan on The Cask of Amontillado which falls under the unit off exploring elements of a story and a sub-unit on How Writers scare readers. Students will learn throughout the school year about different elements in stories (fright/scare, suspense, heroes, etc. and more general elements like the protagonist, antagonist, climax/rising action/denouement, etcetera). The segment of this-how writers scare readers uses The Cask of Amontillado and other short stories, like Rappacini’s Daughter and Young Goodman Brown and The Fall of the House of Usher to explore these elements. The worksheets help track ideas students find in these stories. They are then asked to apply the findings to their own stories which…

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction I did not choose this path. I did not choose Accelerated English ¾. I did not choose to stay in this class. However, I did choose to excel in this situation. Sometimes, we are thrust on a path not of our choosing.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I don’t know why I say the things I say. They had no meaning it was just a joke the goal was a good laugh not to offend others. I felt ashamed. During my eighth grade year I had said something that in my mind was hilarious, but was very offensive to some. The Sun slowly climbed over the peaks of the mountains and shed it’s first light of day.…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fairy Tales are written with a purpose to entertain, mimic life situations, assist as a guide and to teach life lessons. However, in today’s modern society, original fairy tales are transformed into non-sequiturs in order to convey present day messages. In the original version of the Little Red Cap, the symbolism and messages are used to educate and be more direct towards children. The non-sequitur version of the Little Red Cap focuses more on modern problems people may face in today’s world. Though both stories teach and focus on different lessons, both convey and discuss meaningful messages that would benefit our society as a whole.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I was a great writer in middle school and I believe I still am, but I could always be better. My 7th grade English class consisted of my good friend Kris and two girls named Hailey and Reilly. Well, I really liked Reilly and decided to ask her out. I used to be a very nervous kid, especially around attractive girls, so I wrote a letter, asking her to go out with me.…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I have had many things happen in my life that should never happen to any high school student. First off, during my eighth grade year and freshman year I had just overcome a transition from being sent away from my mother to living with my father and his newly wed wife. On top of that awful circumstance, my father and step mom were both laid off from their jobs in Washington D.C. and were homeless. Luckily my dad cashed out his 401k and was able to live off that for a few months but it was still a struggle for me to get to school and had a lot of social problems going on at my new school and not having a permanent place to live yet. After running out of money, we ended up having a very odd situation and lived in my step-mom's ex husband's house…

    • 376 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays