Summary Of Hiv And The Criminalization Of Sickness By Trevor Hoppe

Improved Essays
Book Report #2: Punishing Disease, HIV and the Criminalization of Sickness by Trevor Hoppe
Introduction:
Trevor Hoppe in his novel Punishing Disease, HIV and the Criminalization of Sickness provides a narrative f or how public health has affected those living with HIV throughout HIV’s debut to the public in the 1980s to the present. Hoppe visits the history of how the public health handles disease outbreaks and relates that to how their tactics lead to the stigmatism of HIV and ultimately HIV’s criminalization. Once criminalized, it is dissected how the justice system has managed to criminalize a community of people through illusions of harm and invasion of their private lives. Its criminalization also reveals how race, sexuality, and gender
…show more content…
When analyzing the different methods of “coercion”, Hoppe highlights how those seen as more favorable in the eyes of the public are allowed better options of quarantine or safety methods when compared to those of poor favor, such as lower status individuals or persons’ of color. Hoppe explains this phenomenon through the stories of individuals throughout history, such as Mary Mallon, that became its unwilling participants after contracting a contagious disease. The stories of those who became victims to the public health’s methods without a diagnosis, such as alcoholics and prostitutes, are also discussed to support how public health is used to …show more content…
Lawyers and judges throughout cases used outdated information based upon stigmatism against HIV positive individuals with more force that was necessary for the case. Hoppe visits the information of several cases in which this occurred including the case of Brenda J. and Franklin C. The cases span before treatment had been discovered for those living with HIV and after. It is noted that even after treatment, HIV positive individuals still had the poorly informed stigmatism of HIV being a death sentence and false medical information used against them. Even with the discovery that those with an undetectable viral load, spitting, and biting have low percentage of passing it on, it was still used in court that they were intentionally spreading a “death sentence”. Now convicted, they face harsh punishments and long

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    R V Mabior Case Summary

    • 3451 Words
    • 14 Pages

    This case falls under the scope of criminal law, in which the respondent is accused of criminal conduct. Mabior was charged with a total of nine counts of aggravated sexual assault, based on failure to disclose his HIV-positive status before engaging in sexual relations. This case raises the issue whether an individual who is HIV-positive engaging in sexual relations without disclosure of his condition commits aggravated sexual assault. Mr. Mabior lived in Winnipeg, with a house known as a “party place”. On occasion, Mabior would engage in sexual relations with women who came to his house, including the nine complainants.…

    • 3451 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The health officials in New York were aware of other typhoid carriers, but did not quarantine all of them. Many of these typhoid carriers were out in the communities while Mary Mallon was quarantined on an island. (site article here). The health department did not show any empathy, compassionate or respect towards Mary Mallon’s situation. No one bother to communicate with Mary what it meant to be a carrier of this disease, in lieu she was offered to have her gallbladder removed.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the 1980s, the HIV was the apogee of a series of apocalyptical controversies that arose from the approach of the new Millennium. Kaposi’s sarcomas (KS) – along with other diseases – make up a list of conditions that serve as a guideline for the diagnosis of AIDS. In fact, its relation to AIDS is so remarkable that it became a label; in a society that is divided by pre-conceived ideas of morality, it became a visual representation of HIV as a punishment for homosexuality. In Angels in America: A Gay Fantasia on National Themes, Tony Kushner uses Kaposi’s sarcoma to symbolize the journey of marginalized individuals struggling to survive in an American society that refuses to embrace minorities.…

    • 119 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An interesting and thought-provoking section of the documentary is the programs that are in the communities who susceptible to drug use. The “Bluff” needle exchange program was a program that helped advocate aids and promoted a more hygienic approach to drug use. In turn, this helped combat the transmissions of HIV. Because the Drug Paraphernalia Law made it illegal for people to carry needles, it caused people to turn to shooting galleries instead. Instead of the law combating the use of drugs, the sharing of needles caused an increase in the spread of the disease.…

    • 214 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Working Cures Book Review

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The most common conflicts in society are due to misunderstandings, regardless of one’s cultural background. On the books Working Cures: Healing, Health, and Power on Southern Slave Plantations by Sharla M. Fett and Surviving HIV/AIDS in the Inner City: How Resourceful Latinas Beat the Odds by Sabrina Chase, the authors provide cases which reflect the failure of medical treatment provided by physicians due to the fact that it is not able to adjust to their patient’s needs. On the book Working cures, the slaves of plantations completely believed in “conjuration… also called ‘‘hoodoo’’ or ‘‘rootwork,’’ African American practice of healing, harming, and protection performed through the ritual harnessing of spiritual forces.’’ (Fett, p. 85)…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gaëton Dugas Summary

    • 1120 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the reading, Phil Tiemeyer, gives a unique spin off of the telltale story of the infamous Gaëton Dugas. A man who could arguably be called the Hitler of the AIDS epidemic. In fact, not only does Tiemeyer say that the things people have learned about Mr. Dugas was a fabricated myth, but he also defends Dugas, by saying he could not have even been patient zero. An audacious claim to make about the villain of the late 20th century, however, surprisingly Tiemeyer does not speak without compelling evidence. Phil Tiemeyer’s writing depicted two major aspects in the Dugas speculations and they were slanderous accusations of the media, and what was the truth of the matter.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although the diseases that threaten us today are HIV, Hanta, Ebola, Sabia, and Lyme Disease. “The social and public policy dilemma Mary Mallon’s story posed was addressed repeatedly in the 1980s, as writers tried to help people come to terms with new health dangers and dilemmas (Leavitt).” HIV was being spread rapidly without any way to treat it. People were not sure how to contain the spread of these diseases. “Early experience with HIV infection indicates that American public health has not yet moved very far away from some of the social insensitivities evident in Mallon’s day (Leavitt).”…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bacteriology has explained given concrete proof to the spreading of disease and therefore, any diseased immigrant is a huge threat in his mind. “If we remain indifferent simply because these diseases do not prove fatal to life, we evade our duty; for the health of the nation is imperiled while one man is diseased” (p.244, Powderly, document 3). Since the spreading of a disease now has scientific support, it makes sense that he sees the importance of one diseased immigrant. The important tone of this document is that the assumption that immigrants carried the threat of disease is even more emphasized after germ…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aids and Accusation Aids and Accusation, written by Paul Farmer, is a book that truly captures and describes the epidemiology and history of HIV/AIDS in Haiti. Farmer’s immergence into the Haitian community during his research, alongside his educational background as a medical anthropologist and physician, contributed greatly to his approach of providing a deeply holistic understanding of HIV/AIDS in Haiti to the public for the first time (Farmer 2006:253). Through ethnographical, epidemiological and historical data, Farmer shows how the effects of social inequalities, such as racism and poverty, were the main contributors of how the suffering, illness, disease, and violence effects of HIV/AIDS were distributed amongst people in Haiti, and…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The AIDS epidemic was a languid, merciless, killer that claimed the lives of millions in its wake. Often times, the people’s desperate search for a cure was referred to as “The War Against AIDS.” This War eventually was won in the sense that HIV no longer had the powerful to sentence so many people to death. However, it was still a sentence, but this time it was a sentence to a forced life style change. This struggle of AIDS and HIV was depicted in the autobiography Body Counts by Sean Strub.…

    • 1776 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Erving Goffman thesis on stigma was published in 1963, his work was titled, Stigma: management of a spoiled identity. The Greeks originated the term stigma to “refer to bodily signs designed to expose something unusual and bad about the moral status of the signifier.” (Goffman, 1963.) The Greeks cut or burned signs into the skin of a criminal or a traitor, to create a blemished person, this individual must be avoided at all costs, especially in public.…

    • 2289 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This HIV Policy Resource Bank category covers state and federal laws that protect the confidentiality of HIV-related information, the rights and obligations of people with HIV with respect to disclosure of their HIV status in various settings, the importance of privacy and confidentiality guarantees to health care and prevention programs, and possible legal actions when unauthorized disclosure of HIV-related information occurs. Basically, it says as it as today people living with HIV infection and AIDS should have the same basic rights and responsibilities as which try to every citizen. Confidentiality means that personal information is private, and may not be shared without your permission. The confidentiality of a person’s HIV status is important because people with HIV and AIDS face discrimination when other people find out they have HIV.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Safe Streets and Communities Act is an omnibus bill that consists of nine smaller bills that the conservatives failed to pass, which have now been put together to create Bill C-10. Bill C-10 includes the Increasing penalties for organized crime act, Protecting society from violent offenders act, Ending house arrest for property and other serious crimes act, Eliminating pardons for serious crimes act, Protecting children from sexual predators act, Increasing offender accountability act, International transfer of prisoners back to Canada act, Supporting victims of terrorism act, and the Protecting vulnerable foreign nationals against trafficking, abuse and exploitation act (Safe Streets and Community Act, 2012). The Safe Streets and Communities…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    'Acquired Immune Deficiency Virus (AIDS) is caused by a human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) that weakens the immune system , making the body susceptible to and unable to recover from op­portunistic diseases that lead to death' (USAID, 2010, pp.173). It is one of the major challenges for Pub­lic Health and it is the world's leading infectious killer. According to the WHO, 35 million people are living with HIV worldwide. In middle and low income countries is the majority of infec­ted people. In 2013, 2.1 million new infections occurred in low and middle income countries (WHO, 2013).…

    • 2493 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    "If you knew I was HIV positive would you still treat me as an equal, would you still be my friend, would you still touch me, would you still love me?” These are some of the thoughts that go through the minds of the millions of people worldwide who are currently living with HIV/AIDS. Despite the mass impact of the disease, many still remain ignorant to its definition, history, and effects, leading to the negative associations of those affected. I’m here to give you a brief enlightenment of HIV/AIDS in an effort to to lessen the misconceptions and stigma of HIV/ AIDS. First, we need to understand the basics.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays