Pencey Enterprises Case Study

Superior Essays
The issues at hand call in to question the protection of workers at Pencey Enterprises, as determined by Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act (hereinafter “the Act”). The two main parties in this case include Robert Ackley, a worker at Pencey Enterprises, and Spencer Antolini, a supervisor at Pencey Enterprises. The four main issues ask: Were the employees partaking in protected concerted activity? Was Ackley’s outburst towards his supervisor, Antolini, protected speech? Was Ackley provoked by Antolini? Did Ackley lose protection after spreading false information regarding employee wages relative to competitor wages?
1. Were the employees participating in protected concerted activity?
A.
One case that serves as precedent to this issue
…show more content…
In Sullair P.T.O., Inc., Terry Lee Boyle was discharged for directing profane comments at Plant Controller Douglas Sommers, including calling him a “fucking poor manager.” The Court found that, due to the comment being directed at management, Boyle lost his protection under the Act, even though he was undisputedly engaged in concerted activity. Despite the norm for profane language within the plant, Boyle’s comment was insubordination, and Boyle admitted to his insubordination being the reason for his discharge. Therefore, the Court held that Boyle’s speech was unprotected and his discharge was clearly justified. In the case at bar, Ackley was discharged for his outburst directed towards Antolini, where he called him a “fuckin’ liar” (p. 4, l. 25) and a “motherfuckin’ son of a bitch.” (p.5, l. 3). This comment was directed towards management, and it shows that Ackley was being insubordinate. Therefore, it should be held that Ackley lost his protection under the Act and his discharge should be considered …show more content…
Nonetheless, the discussion of wages started by Fouty was an “integral and important part of the movement to organize a union which began several weeks before Fouty’s discharge.” Although the statements were untrue, the Board holds, “Employees do not forfeit the protection of the Act if, in discussing a matter of such vital common concern as wages, they give currency to inaccurate or incomplete information.” In particular, it is important to note that inaccurate information can still be protected so long as it is not done with malice or intention to falsify the statements. Therefore, Fouty was still protected under the Act, despite his inaccurate statements regarding

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Over 3000 workers claimed that they were paid only for the time they were at their work stations and the production line was moving. c. The employee argued that the company violated the Employment Standards Act of 1938 and Iowa Wage Payment Collection law by not…

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Current state of wrongful dismissal in Employment Law and why we believe it needs to be changed. The current state of wrongful dismissal is that damages are awarded based on what notice of lieu an employer/employee receives (Richard A. Yates, 2011). Weakness for employee: • Not compensated for pain and suffering, only awarded difference of notice they should have received and benefits/pension they would have received (Richard A. Yates, 2011).…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the past decade, there were numerous cases pertaining the age discrimination with some still in the courts as they are unsettled while others were settled in either against the employee or the employer. One of the popular cases was the Kimel v. Florida board of regents Facts on Kimel v. Florida board of regents In the year 1994, two different associates’ professors initiated a suit against their state employer. In the month of December, the professors lately filed the suit in a federal district court claiming an abuse of the Age Discrimination in the Employment Act (ADEA) of the year 1967. The professors who were aged 58 and 57 years claimed that the university discriminated them according to their ages and retaliated…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The T-Shirt Offer and Picnic Photographs Case Study contained a few questionable actions by the union. This paper will summarize this case. Next, the paper will answer questions in regards to conduct, previous cases, outcome, and predict how the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) will rule. Case Summary…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Case Study 1: Lizardo versus Denny Inc. NDI Officers that were hired as security for Denny’s Restaurant escorted a complaining Asian American out of the restaurant and threatened to arrest him for disorderly conduct all because of a delay in seating (Curtis & McBride, 2011). A fight erupted outside and a group of African Americans that were waiting to be seated went outside to see what was going on (Curtis & McBride, 2011). One of them reentered the restaurant and was describing the commotion happening outside.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Relief Sought: Petitioner filed suit against the Western Line Consolidated School District seeking reinstatement because the nonrenewal of her contract violated her First and Fourteenth Amendments. Issues: Givhan v. Western Line Consolidated School District addressed a teacher’s right to free speech under the First and Fourteenth Amendments. Facts: Bessie Givhan, a teacher in Mississippi’s Western Line Consolidated School, went into the principal’s office and expressed her opinion concerning the school’s hiring practices and policies. She believed that the practices were racially prejudiced, and after expressing her opinions, the principal claimed that the teacher made unreasonable and hostile demands. After the school year, her teaching contract was not renewed.…

    • 491 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1. According to Ehrenreich, “no job is truly unskilled”. When the author states this, she is meaning to say how even minimum wage jobs require skills and skills are learned while on the job. 2.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ID THE CASE: Garcetti v. Ceballos 547 U.S. 410, 126 S.Ct. 1951 PARTIES TO THE CASE: PLAINTIFF = Richard Ceballos, calendar deputy for the District county attorney office DEFENDANT = Gil Garcetti, District Attorney RELEVANT AND MATERIAL FACTS (LIST JUST 5 OR LESS): 1.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Logan tells her boss, Diego, told her and five other women that they were his top employees, but none of them would be offered promotional opportunities with the company. When asked for an explanation, Diego told them that some of his traditional clients told him they would refuse to work with women, and if any of those clients decided to take their work to another vendor, he would suffer a significant economic loss. Issues 1. Could the client sue the company for sexual discrimination. 2.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Education Vs Loudmill

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Name of the Case: Cleveland Board of Education v. Loudermill 2. Citation: 470 U.S. 532 3. Date Decided: 1985 4. Facts: James Loudermill was hired in 1979 by the Cleveland Board of Education in the capacity of security guard after Loudermill had stated on his application that he had never been convicted of a felony offense. Later, it was determined by the Cleveland Board of education that Loudermill had indeed been convicted of a felony offense in 1968; therefore Loudermill was terminated for dishonesty regarding the submission of his application.…

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If the case were to go to court I believe that the school district would win. Philip is a student who goes to Harrison High School. Philip was a suspended for singing the Star Spangled Banner. The school would win because Philip was causing a disturbance in the class and he was being disrespectful to Ms. Narwin.…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the early 1900s employers hire people to spy on workers in unions and report back to them with information on what was going on. The Wagner act of 1935, also known as the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), was created by Senator Robert R. Wagner and signed into action by President Franklin Delano Roosevelt in July of 1935. President Roosevelt and the Wagner Act had an immense influence on the labor movement and the American work force we know today. Before the NLRH employers had monarch like power over their employees. These employers used any tactic they could think of to keep their workers under their control and to make sure they are the ones making the money.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Supreme Court decisions on sexual harassment, particularly in the Faragher case, have increased concerns about the nature of an acceptable policy and complaint mechanism. In that decision, issued on the same day, the Supreme Court ruled that, when there was no direct adverse job action involved, an affirmative defense against claims of supervisor harassment can be made. There is research relevant to the issues of effective policies, investigation processes, and what constitutes a reasonable or unreasonable failure to use an available complaint mechanism. However, further research, written in a way that makes it more accessible to lawyers and the courts, would be of…

    • 104 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the Gilded Age, the period that was glittering on the surface but corrupt underneath, the government attempted to settle the issues of this age by the reforms of the Progressive Era. The term “gilded” means something is beautiful on the surface but is really worthless underneath; however, it didn’t live up to its name. Although the reform of the Progressive Era attempted to resolve the issues of the Gilded Age; ultimately, it didn’t solve all the problems because there still were corruption in government, unethical business condition, and unequal distribution of wealth. During this Era, there were lots of issues and corruption in government was one of the biggest issue. The image from “Washington as Seen by the Trust” demonstrates that the government is corrupted and the white house is on top of Rockefeller’s hand, which means it is being controlled by Rockefeller (Doc. D).…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Analysis Of EEOC Vs. Federal Express

    • 2298 Words
    • 10 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited

    Federal Express (1995). A courier was harassed by a customer on her route. The customer made such comments as saying she looked better without any clothes on and repeatedly asked her out on dates. She brought this issue up with her supervisor who wrote to the customer asking him to refrain from ? any future conduct that could be perceived as offensive or intimidating?.…

    • 2298 Words
    • 10 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited
    Superior Essays