Implications Of O Bannon Decision, By Matthew J. Parlow

Improved Essays
Matthew J. Parlow’s article “The Potential Unintended Consequences of the O’Bannon Decision” serves as a thorough exploration of the ramifications, both apparent and unforeseen, of Judge Claudia Wilken’s ruling in O’Bannon v. National College Athletic Association. Judge Wilken’s ruling in the case was truly monumental; it not only irreversibly altered the NCAA’s current student-athlete compensation policy but it also represented a defeat, or at the very least a non-victory, for an organization that had emerged victorious in all previous student-athlete compensation-related court cases. The implications of O’Bannon v. National College Athletic Association are certain for the present and near future – starting in the fall of 2016, universities …show more content…
National College Athletic Association; it is actually an examination of its potential ramifications. It is noted throughout the article that the Judge’s ruling only represents an incremental advancement for the cause of student-athletes. The author implies that the Judge believes that student-athletes should receive compensation but nevertheless only granted a meager amount of compensation to athletes in this case as an acknowledgement of the fact that full free-market compensation is unpractical in college athletics as presently construed. The incremental nature of the judge’s ruling means that student-athlete compensation is far from a settled …show more content…
National College Athletic Association that is discussed at length in the article is the effect that student-athlete compensation will have on parity in college sports. Some worry that in allowing for compensation of student-athletes, the divide between the haves and the have-nots in college sports will grow larger. There are currently three side to the aforementioned argument: those who belief that a growing divide will be unavoidable with the advent of student-athlete compensation, those who believe it can be avoided through negotiation of a collective bargaining agreement or something of that ilk, and those who believe that the divide between the haves and have-nots should be encouraged as it is part of what makes college sports great. Those who believe that student-athlete compensation will further the class divide in college are opposed to paying student-athletes because they believe it will effectively ruin college sports by making its results routine and predictable. On the other hand, there are some proponents of paying college athletes who believe that fears of a deepened class divide can be alleviated by pay caps and restrictions that come with a collectively bargained agreement between the colleges and the student-athletes. There are also some who believe that deep divide between the haves and the have-nots is part of what makes it so entertaining; if all teams were of equal caliber, the upsets that create so much of the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Due to NCAA rules, athletes have not been allowed compensation for their participation in college athletics. This rule has caused a great divide and debate within the collegiate sport world, especially with the recent exponential growth of college athletics. For instance, college sports critics Val Ackerman and Larry Scott argue “that college is ultimately about getting a degree and getting ready for life long after their playing days are over” supporting their claim that college athletes should not be paid (Ackerman and Scott). Opposing that view is the idea that college athletics offer exactly those benefits and more, which would be maximized with payment. As of right now, college athletes are being compensated through scholarships that average…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    by Reed Karaim shows how students have the right to unionize, along with class-action lawsuits demanding more compensation and better treatment for college athletes, has amplified debate over whether they should be paid. Reed Karaim discusses how the top of collegiate competition deserves greater compensation for their efforts rather than scholarships. Meaning these athlete’s deserve…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In terms of internal reforms, the NCAA now allows universities to offer unlimited meals and snacks to their athletes, and also provide additional benefits to scholarship athletes (Sanderson & Siegfried, 2015, p. 133). There have also been proposals to allow multiyear scholarships, and to also support athletes who want to further their education after their eligibility expires (Sanderson & Siegfried, 2015, p. 133). Regarding lawsuits, the authors discuss the O’Bannon v. NCAA case, the collective bargaining case by Northwestern University athletes, and the collection of similar cases that seek to attack the ceiling on grant-in-aid (Sanderson & Siegfried, 2015, p. 134). To conclude the article, Sanderson and Siegfried express their expectation regarding what will happen to collegiate athletics. They state that they expect an evolution in the labor market that will reduce, and even potentially eliminate the monopsony power of the NCAA, collegiate sports teams, and conferences (Sanderson & Siegfried, 2015,…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    within the attractiveness, the NCAA place the dollar quantity of Wilken’s injunction at “roughly $30,000 each over four years or $7,500 annually.” This quantity is predicated on the $5,000 cap that the judge printed in her ruling and also the gap of concerning $2,500 for an additional regular payment to hide the complete value of attending. The NCAA is relying heavily on the argument that judge Wilken erred by not applying a 1984 Supreme Court Ruling that the NCAA says protects conviction in college sports. The NCAA is additionally arguing that the O’Bannon plaintiffs lack antitrust injury as a result of the primary modification and Copyright Act.…

    • 1550 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the past couple decades, college athletics have increased their popularity tremendously. The increase in popularity has led to a surplus of revenue brought to each of the Universities and the National Collegiate Athletics Association (NCAA). Last year Oregon had a revenue of $196,030,398 and not a single player was compensated for the work they did on those sports teams (Berkowitz para. 1).…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Argumentative Research Paper Outline College athletes should not complain about not getting paid, they should be offered the option of a tuition or a salary. Not Both. People think that they should get paid because they are in college sports now. (Jones)…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The controversy of whether college athletes should be paid or not is a significant issue in the sports world, today. In this issue there are two different sides the NCAA and then their college athletes. The main reason the NCAA states they will not pay their college athletes is because they are ‘amateurs’. According to the NCAA, “Amateur competition is a bedrock principle of college athletics and the NCAA.…

    • 504 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Universities and Colleges recruit the athletes, imposing them to operate with a multi-billion-dollar industry regulating them and making a huge revenue of their exposers. The universities offer full-ride scholarships, and free education, which is a huge opportunity, and invaluable experience that many Americans are not able to afford. But looking at all the television revenue, tickets, jersey sales and other product sold, the comparison is incomparable. The athletes despite devoting 40 hours a week practicing, leaving them with little time to place towards academics, the division I athletes are not considered as employees, the source of income go to the NCAA and members that are involved in the business such as the coaches and the staff. Basically, the student athletes are exploited by the NCAA and universities for they athletics skills with no source of income, they are just given the opportunity to get free education, but do the amount of devotion towards their sport they cannot fully dedicate their time towards education.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In his memoir entitled Unsportsmanlike Conduct, the first full time executive director of the NCAA, Walter Byers, observed that "Amateurism is not a moral issue; it is an economic camouflage for monopoly practice."26 In arguing for college athletes to be paid, tennis legend and civil rights advocate Billie Jean King asserted that the NCAA’s concept of amateurism symbolized a power struggle between college sport officials and athletes.27 Part of that control is exercised through the manipulation of the language the NCAA uses to describe it.28 As Kevin Satterlee, vice president and legal counsel at Boise State University remarked at a conference examining the proper role of sports in higher education at the Santa Clara University Institute of…

    • 153 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    College Athletes Should Not Get Paid Outline Specific Purpose Statement: At the end of my speech the audience will agree that college athletes should not get paid. Thesis: College athletes should not receive any payment or compensation in college. Introduction: I. I would like everyone to raise their hand if they play a sport for Southeastern Community College.…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many court cases are beginning to arise due to former players realizing the NCAA unfair rules and guidelines, and it needs to be changed drastically. Two students on the Northwestern football team created a petition to be able to unionize and be compensated for their play, however, the National Labor Relation Board declined to give jurisdiction in the athletes’ case (Strauss) (this is another work from the same author). Although the board denied compensation for athletes, their reasoning was that college athletes are students first. They avoided the main point of the case which was William Goud, a former labor board chairman, thinks the student athletes have a good case by stating "The principle reason for that is their work -- they have…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction College athletes refer to the individuals who represent their learning institutions, particularly colleges and universities, in competitive sports such as athletics, soccer and ball games. Often the competition college students participate in is considered as non-professional since some international institutions such as Olympics Committee and IAAF do not approve them. However, the athletes participating in the college events tend to have an equal input in the sports as the professional athletes. This paper presents a case on why the college athletes ought to be paid.…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With over 170,000 athletes in the Division One segment. claims to why college athletes are not obligated to be paid money for their athletic efforts is because of their amature status. Today, many athletes can refute this claim due to the amount of money the NCAA makes off of the athlete. Many of these young aspiring men and women look for ways to profit off of their self image, the NCAA profits off of the athlete with all money going towards their institutions, and none to the athlete. A lot of these student athletes are struggling to support themselves, and excelled at a certain sport to improve not only their lives, but their families’ as well.…

    • 1877 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With events like the Northwestern ruling and other recent court rulings, it seems that college athletes will be given compensation in the very near future. There are many people who are uninformed on this important issue. In today 's society the benefits and detriments of compensation college athletes are numerous. The NCAA has come a long way since it was first created in 1906. Today it is fast approaching a billion dollar…

    • 1393 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Paid Persuasive Speech

    • 649 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Finally, there are the courts, which are also fighting over how much to pay athletes. When Judge Claudia Wilken decided the O’Bannon case in 2014, she ruled that the N.C.A.A. was in violation of antitrust laws and that players should receive money to bridge the full “cost of attendance” at college. (Under pressure from the so-called Power 5 conferences, the N.C.A.A. agreed to this a few months later.) She also said athletes should receive an additional $5,000, to be held in trust until they left school.…

    • 649 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays