Karen Partanen Gay Rights

Improved Essays
Over the past few decades, the movement for gay rights has been flourishing across the United States. From the first state legalization of same-sex marriage in Massachusetts in 2004, to the law protecting LGBTA rights in the workplace in 2007 (AGRM Timeline, Infoplease), the LGBTA community has finally began to get the basic rights and liberties they deserve. However, there are still many areas where their rights are lacking and inadequate. In many states across the country, the parental rights of LGBTA individuals are very limited. Karen Partanen, a member of the LGBTA community, has been fighting for the parental rights of her two children since 2014. Her children were both born by artificial insemination, however, by her former partner. Now that they’re separated, both mothers want custody of the children. Current law states that their biological mother receives automatic custody of the children simply for the fact that she gave birth to them. The legal problem: Partanen was unable to file for joint-custody due to the fact that she was not the children's’ birth or adoptive mother. Even though Partanen helped bring the children into the world and raised them, she was legally not eligible to file for custody (Randazzo, WSJ). Although this issue is not fully settled, progress is being made in various states across the nation. …show more content…
Unfortunately, there are many states that still do not protect LGBTA parents. For example, some states don’t allow for them to even visit their children if their “legal guardian” says they can’t see them. Moreover, other states don’t allow them to file for custody, but they allow them to be declared a “de-facto parent.” This is a legal position that provides them with visitation rights, however, they are not granted full parentage. Before Partanen brought her case to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court, the state followed the de-facto parent practice. The court ended up ruling that even though the Massachusetts paternity laws are written in gendered terms, they can be discussed in a gender mutual manner — meaning it can apply to a child is that is born to any two people — even if only one parent has biological ties to the child. Therefore, Partanen can now legally fight for joint-custody of her children. Although this is a big achievement for Partanen and the state of Massachusetts, this is only a stepping stone for LGBTA parental rights as a whole. Various states around the country have started to enact laws that protect same-sex partners that are looking for parental rights, but many states continue to be restrictive. Therefore, there is still progress to be made in the United States (Randazzo, WSJ). The biggest influence that shaped Partanen’s legal issue and slows the progression of this law are conservative, social-cultural views. Typical opponents of this issue are those that are against LGTBA rights in general. Their opposition may come from their religious beliefs, the way their parents raised them, or for other reasons. Other opponents argue “that expanding the definition of parent to be too broad can open courts up to bogus custody challenges and expose parents to legal battles with exes that aren’t in the best interests of children” (Randazzo, WSJ). Regardless of where their opposition stems from, the lack of parental rights for LGBTA individuals significantly alters a child’s life as it mean

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Maryland court of appeals ruled Wednesday that a lesbian woman once married to another woman had no right to visitation or custody of a young boy her former partner gave birth to before the couple wed. According to The Daily Record of Baltimore, the Court of Special Appeals upheld an earlier decision by the Washington County Circuit Court that ruled Michelle Conover does not have parental rights over Jaxon Conover. The child was born six months prior to Michelle Conover’s marriage to his birth mother, Brittany Conover and 17 months before their divorce. Judge Robert A. Zarnoch wrote in his opinion that current state law, governing the rights of same-sex couples is not clear and therefore distinguishes Michelle Conover as a “third party”…

    • 133 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people tend to not care about politics or anything of that nature. However E.J. Graff presents a very valid point. She states “No biggie, some people think: Just write a will and some health care proxies, appoint a guardian, and you're all set (4). However it is not that easy as may think. E.J. Graff thoroughly evaluated her claim and made a lot of valid points on the continuous revolving issue of the homosexuals and adoption rights.…

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “It’s a shame that qualified families are being rejected from the process because of irrelevant considerations, such as sexuality” - Shannon Corregan. Gay couples are being rejected from adoption just for their sexuality. Although some say children need a mother and a father, Gay couples should be allowed to adopt. Laws have been enforced to ban gay couples from legally adopting a child. Evidence from the article states “The Supreme Court's refusal to hear an appeal was a setback for the American Civil Liberties Union and gay rights group.”…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    If in a gay relationship where two men adopted a child then the legal parent gets to decide whether or not the second parent should have parental rights. In lesbian relationships this would be different, because one of the the women could have had a sperm cell placed in her to where now she is the biological mother. Also her and her spouse could have had the second parent 's eggs placed inside the first biological mother 's body, so that she is technically the biological mother also. This then would have to be resolved in the last option, which is a court appointed decision, but if the mothers just went through the steps of adoption; the legal parent will always have the decision to whether or not the second parent has any rights to the child. Just because people are fighting for gay adoption, doesn’t mean that every couple out there should adopt.…

    • 1838 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Breeding Nationalism

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Until last year, gays and lesbians were banned from getting married in most of the 50 states in the US. One of the primary arguments used to justify the bans against gay marriage, was that children would suffer. It was claimed that marriage had one purpose, to produce children. Here, the child is being used as a political tool. Children, as the innocent beings that they are, are used to rally people into a cause, even when the child has no reason to be mixed up in political affairs.…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Annotated Bibliography

    • 1422 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Relevant Literature Political attention toward same-sex couples and parenting in North America has increased considerably in the past three decades (Clunis and Green 2003; Epstein 2002; Warner 2002), largely coinciding with debates about the legal recognition of same-sex marriage and families (Warner 2002). A turn in sociocultural attitudes towards the LGBTQ community, cemented by the advancement of civil rights for gays and lesbians, and a “liberalization of legal constraints” (Johnson and O’Connor 2002, 3) has resulted in the increased willingness of gay and lesbian parents to be open about their sexuality. This shifting landscape and greater openness, in conjunction with the rise of extended families (Luxton 1997) and the legal recognition…

    • 1422 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Federal Information & News Dispatch comments, “Only seven states prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation in adoption, and only five explicitly ban discrimination in foster care. Louisiana, Mississippi and Michigan prohibit same-sex couples from jointly adopting, and Nebraska, Ohio, Kentucky and Kansas restrict same-sex couples from accessing second-parent adoption. ”(Congressional Documents and Publications). The times tides have been turning for LBGT couples due to the fact that only 7 states still having laws preventing the fostering or adoption of children. If America as a whole proceeds to looking forward, the barrier these states have create can be disbanded so that all LGBT couples in any region of the U.S. have equal rights to adopt and to foster children.…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gay marriage takes away one of the essential parental roles from the basic family structure. It is simply impossible for the gays in marriage to incorporate both the father and mother into the parental roles. Sure one can be tough and the other gentle but they are nonetheless both either male or female. According to the statistics earlier regarding a father and mother this is not a good predicament for the child.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Family law is an area of law that is concerned with family matters and domestic relations including marriage, civil unions and termination of relationships etc. The law’s success in family law is in the degree of justice achieved for all individuals involved and impacted. There are a range of contemporary issues concerning family law that affect the overall success of this part of the law and that includes recognition of same-sex marriage, care and protection of children and birth technologies and surrogacies. In relation to same-sex couples, the legal recognition of their marriage means more than the right to get married.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout this notion, a child needs the reassurance of both a mother and father figure. Once again, individuals who are ‘for’ gay marriage and parenting will possibly disagree and point out that a homosexual couples does not necessarily need to have children or the case that children will not be affected with same sex parents. As for the argument ‘against' this topic, that is not necessarily the case. In order to build upon this idea of children having both a mother and a father figure as apart of their lives, Jane Edwards’s article builds on Rod Benson’s claims in relation to arguments against same sex marriage laws. Rod Benson (2011, para 5) argues that “marriage has a place in the law because a relationship between a man and a woman is the kind of relationship that may produce children.…

    • 2734 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gay Home Research Paper

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Shmuley Boteach talking to a friend about Rosie O’Donnell adopting four children said, “When I told a religious friend about being inspired by Rosie’s adoption of four children, he said to me: ‘How sad that these kids are never going to have a father.’ Lost on him was the irony that without Rosie, they wouldn’t have a mother either.” Shmuley also brings about a challenge to people that are against same-sex adoption, by putting themselves on the list to adopt children instead. Also, he uses a comparison to “don’t ask, don’t tell” in the military. If you’re so against gay people serving in our armed forces, then why don’t you sign up for the job yourself.…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Destiny Quinonez English 102 October 28, 2016 Essay #4 There are millions of kids all over the world waiting to become part of a family and thousands of couples or families looking to adopt each year. The lack of acceptable straight couples, gay adoption can provide numerous kids with the loving home they need. Same sex couples or straight couples are a better alternative than the foster care system. So why not decrease the number of kids waiting to be apart of a family by allowing them to be raised by people who are making a big decision to cherish and love them through years that lie ahead of them? Adoption is the process of providing families with a child that can no longer be raised by their biological parents.…

    • 2082 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The fact is, there is a lack of new adoptive parents. Gay parents can already be foster parents for children, but adoption would confirm the legal rights of the gay couple. Since 1994, United States federal law has prohibited “denying prospective adoptive or foster parents the opportunity to adopt or foster children based on race, color or national origin” (HHC). However, no federal legislature stops the discrimination based on sexual preference of prospective adoptive parents. Determining the parenting rights is made on a "case-by-case basis" and it is judge's decision whether to grant the adoption petition (Human Rights Campaign).…

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A second-parent adoption may involve terminating an existing parent's relationship with the child” (Ritter 237). What this shows is that there are different ways for a couple of the same gender to adopt a child, however, because there are ways in which same-sex couples can adopt a child, Texas fears that problems can come…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These agencies don’t want to put children in “unsafe and rare” environments. Same sex parenting should be legalized everywhere because anyone who is able to meet the requirements of being a loving and caring parent deserves to become a parent, despite their sexual preferences. Many kids would be grateful just to have two loving parents. There are many families and households with same-sex parents and/or couples. “Studies estimate that between 1 and 9 million children in the United States have at least one parent who is lesbian or gay.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics