Seeing Is Believing Analysis

Superior Essays
Opening with David, the young protagonist, as he enters study of Professor Hobby, the blue fairy is nowhere to be found. Calling out in hopes of finding someone to help, David notices another boy, an exact copy of himself, reading a book. Moments pass as David is helplessly trying to comprehend how this child could be the “real” David when he is standing right there. Overwhelmed, David smashes the other boy to bits in a fit of hatred. This scene from A.I. leads me to wonder if John Keats is correct in saying that “nothing ever becomes real till it is experienced”. Before addressing the title, a few terms must first be clarified. It is important to recognize how even though real may refer to an individual’s beliefs, what the humans and David, …show more content…
Because of these terms and definitions, I agree with John Keats with some reservations; while being real is a direct result of experience, it is plain to see how imitation of this reality, due to learned or innate knowledge, could become just as easily accepted as true to the subject. It is often thought that “seeing is believing”, however, I believe sense perception is not necessarily required for belief and things are real even before we have seen them. This idea is arguably true through the two different types of knowledge; personal and shared knowledge. Personal knowledge is in reference to what we, as individuals, believe and know to be true through our feelings, beliefs, and memories, while shared knowledge is in reference to what we, as a society, know to be true, like scientific fact. Even though both types of knowledge can include sense perception, it is not required. For example, I know that the game of baseball is played with a baseball, a bat, and bases, however; I have never actually seen a baseball game. Despite never personally witnessing a game, I still know this information to be true because of shared knowledge. In A.I., David shows how this idea is true through his …show more content…
I believe that this way of knowing is required for belief, but more as an emotional reassurance of a belief from another person and this is true for David. In order for David to believe he is a real boy, he requires the feeling of unconditional, motherly love from Monica like she gives to Martin every day. This obsession with receiving that love even continues as far as to where David, lacking understanding, is swayed by Martin to cut off a lock of Monica’s hair, as well as other mischievous deeds, believing that only then will Monica love him. This emotional need is fulfilled at the end of the movie when David spends the whole day with Monica, as mother and child, receiving her undivided attention, until she dies. When this event occurs, David has essentially become a real boy, fulfilling his purpose and desire, and begins to cry next to Monica’s body. Conversely, there is some information that we believe to be true without any reference to emotion, but rather intuition and reasoning. An example of this within A.I., is when Martin has just come home from the hospital and is playing with David. Despite later performing the mischievous acts, when the idea of cutting Monica’s hair emerged, David initially used his intuition and reasoning to understand and deduce that Martin may be trying to trick him and that what the act entails will get him into trouble, which makes him

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    A Balance of Words & Pictures Among his revolutionary works, Scott McCloud’s graphic essay, “Show & Tell” emphasizes the effectiveness of combining words and pictures while addressing a general audience of various ages, consisting of cartoonists, writers, artists, and readers. The Show-and-Tell vignette, at the beginning of the essay, explains to the audience how a story can be difficult to understand when words and images are separated or used improperly. Throughout the graphic essay, the didactic tone teaches the reader the benefits of using words and pictures harmoniously, rather than following the traditional thinking of separating art and literature. McCloud was able to create such a tone by reflecting on a young child’s experience using words and images interchangeably and by using the dance metaphor to demonstrate the powerful relationship between words and image.…

    • 1414 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal Worldview Inventory According to Shelly & Miller (2016), the worldviews are the most fundamental and encompassing views of reality shared by a people in a culture. Furthermore, they can provide the cultural lenses that shape how we see the world, and they give meaning to life, both personally and humanity as a whole. Therefore, this author believes that her worldview has greatly influenced her upbringing, and everything around her impacts her decision and interpretation on what it is good or bad. In this paper, she will take a look at her personal worldview and discuss it as it is related to pluralism, scientism, postmodernism, and as well as the seven basic worldview questions by Sire.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Real, the Bad, and the Ugly by Cassie Heidecker is an interesting example of analyzing the reality TV epidemic and in addition to the people that view it. The author starts out by listing things that go into a reality TV production and things that happen in real life in order to state that these are two different things despite the idea that reality TV is supposed to be “real”. The mundanity of real life is emphasised here vs. the idea that reality TV is scripted and has a lot of extra work put into it to make reality TV more appealing to a broader audience. The author goes on to say that real life is boring which I thought was funny and a little ironic considering that later the author mentions that she is somebody who sets aside time…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The human brain is able to instinctively collect and recall information in a very particular way, however, some troubles seem to lie in how well the brain mismanages this information. In “Your Brain Lies to You,” Authors Dr. Samuel Wang and Dr. Sandra Aamodt, both established neuroscientists, use their knowledge to explain the specific ways the human brain stores memories and data. However, they also present their conclusion on how the brain can also mislead us to blindly believe information that could potentially hold no merit, without a second thought or inference. Wang and Aamodt claim that this is a result of source amnesia, a phenomenon where the human brain will subconsciously disconnect facts from their original source, making the credibility…

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Columnist Gregory Rodriguez has written about things such as immigration, political issues, as well as rumors. In “Truth is in the Ear of the Beholder” he discusses why people believe rumors for many reasons from trying to make themselves feel better, wanting it to be true and making sense of the world around them. Rumors can happen to anyone, including the President of the United States, usually very controversial, but that doesn’t prevent rumors from being told or believed. While he brings legitimate points to his argument to persuade readers there are also some fault in them as well. Rumors are processed differently as people hear them because of their own desires.…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his moving and inspirational memoir, Look Me in the Eye: My Life With Asperger’s, John Elder Robison depicts his struggles in life to readers. From a child, not comprehending why his understanding of “normal” was different than everyone else’s, to an adult, finally learning that he had Asperger’s, Robison conveys the inner workings of his mind. As a very personal topic, I imagine revealing one’s whole life would be very hard to write about. Robison includes all the tragedies, struggles, and successes in his life throughout this memoir. After reading, it is clear that Robison decided to share his life with Asperger’s to help others with the condition better understand the world and feel they’re not alone.…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humans are continuously working on researches that can make their life better. Technologies are the product of those researches. After many researchers’ dedications, technologies have become very advanced in modern days. From simply a cell phone to a complex satellite, humans’ lives are becoming more convenient because of the technologies. However, as the convenience that technologies have brought began to blend into humans’ lives, many negative effects also start to emerge.…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Things Aren't Always The Way They Seem In the story The Illustrated Man, Ray Bradbury explores the theme of how things aren't always the way they seem. Bradbury shows how easily it is for someone to mislead another being as a bad person based on the way they look. The illustrated man goes through his daily life knowing that he frightens other people and scares away little children and he knows that there is nothing he can do about it.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The effect of personal anecdotal evidence on confirmation bias. Confirmation bias is the common human tendency to notice or seek out information which confirms our already existing beliefs while ignoring evidence which conflicts our beliefs. It is particularly prevalent in cases where our beliefs are mere prejudice or based on superstition. Confirmation bias is the reason why many people believe in the supernatural such as ESP, lucky charms or the lunar effect: a claim that human behaviour is influenced by the position of the moon in its cycle. These kind of beliefs are usually backed up by evidence of personal experience.…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The Universe Next Door” by James Sire provides insight into the various opposing worldviews society faces today. Beginning with the Pre-Modern thoughts that believe in God’s existence, spanning to the Modern view placing matter in the center of reality, and concluding with the Postmodern thoughts which deny the existence of reality. Throughout the semester we have discussed several of these viewings of the world, noting some views appear to be more practical than others. With the use of Sire’s eight fundamental questions I would like to compare and contrast the Pre-Modern thoughts of the Christian Theistic worldview to the Modern thoughts of the Naturalistic worldview. Beginning with Sire’s first question “what is prime reality-the really…

    • 2051 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    After reading many books from some of greatest philosophers such as Descartes, Plato, Chuang Tzu, Thich Nhat Hanh, Wachowski Brothers the director of the Matrix and so forth, my mind is wondering with one big question that has been always rotating above my head during my philosophy and film class. That one big question is to define real, how do we define real? Is it merely real that we want to know about? How about the meaning of a true real? How do we know that we are really being in this world, sitting and reading my essay?…

    • 2462 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His purpose is to simply be the son of Monica and Henry Swinton. He does a good job of that, but he’s also smart enough to realize that the love he has for his mother Monica is not reciprocated. David also has trouble communicating with his mother, but the words he simply can’t get out are, “Dear Mummy, I hope you’re well just now. I love you…” (Aldiss 114).…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Many people agree that seeing is not believing. Many people would also, argue that seeing is believing but, there is much evidence that agrees to disagree. My three sources, The Courtship of Miles Standish, A Christmas Carol, and The People Could Fly support me with evidence to shut down any attempt of arguing that seeing is believing. Sure, people could argue that they have seen “god” or dreamed about something that actually happened but, it is all a trick of the mind.…

    • 107 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most intriguing and intellectual experiences of my life was searching for a senior quote. After much deliberation, I settled upon one by Albert Einstein, “Reality is merely an illusion, albeit a very persistent one.” This quote was one which provoked more thought and philosophical reasoning than any other I have encountered in my life. I began to realize that, in truth, objective reality is a figment of our imaginations. It is an unattainable ideal that humans will never reach.…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rationalism and Empiricism ; focussing on Rationalism When we do somethings whose results are known to us, like throwing an object in the air, so we know that it will fall back on the ground, How can we say this? Is it because we’ve seen things fall if we toss them up in the air or is it because of us learning some laws of physics ( the gravitation law ) The above example shows Empirisicm and Rationalism in the respective cases. This has been a famous argument in philosophy for a long time. There are two categories of people, the first are the empiricists that claim that our ideas or knowledge is based and gained from our own experiences and the information gained through our senses.…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays