Jock Young The Criminological Imagination Analysis

Great Essays
In The Criminological Imagination Jock Young’s main argument is meant to criticize the overly quantitative and positivist nature of modern criminology and point out the limited qualitative imagination within the discipline. Young considers his book a success if he can “create a moment of hesitation and contribute somewhat to the growing skepticism with regards to the widespread desire to quantify every aspect of the human condition” (p.ix). Young describes how criminal justice scholarship has lost touch with reality through an approach that is overly focused on complex statistics and analysis and less on the context in which events occur. The result of such a loss leads us to a state where “the tools of the trade become magically more important …show more content…
He mentions the extraordinary burgeoning of the criminal justice system. The operations of the criminal justice system require enormous budgets. Police, corrections, preventative techniques, and evidentiary procedures are expensive. This has increased the desire for evaluation research. Following in suit the university programs in criminal justice have grown extravagantly. The war on everything (drugs, terrorism, domestic violence) mentality has led some to believe that the answer to our crime problem lies in greater forces within law enforcement agencies. This mentality requires the use of hard evidence in the form of numbers more so than understanding the natural context of the war itself. The crime control industry has significant influence over research within …show more content…
The first is that male working class crime has been used to depict all criminality. The second is the depiction of crime in advanced industrial countries is used to describe crime in general. The book realizes, through an essay by Colin Summers, that traditional criminological generalizations are false when one looks at police behavior, crimes of the powerful, crimes of the poor and of political oppositionists in the context of global imperialism. The third is that criminology has become Americanized (p.79). It is important to realize that America is unusual when compared to other industrialized advanced countries. The factors that shaped America the way it is have a dramatic effect on its crime rate and the generation of criminological theory. It is doubtful that the United States has given us many theories that are applicable in the same way to vastly different countries. As criminology as an academic discipline grows worldwide cultural and critical criminology may be more appropriate in certain places than an American influence of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Sociology Explain how crime and criminal justice have been theorised? Criminology is now generally referred to as classical criminology which came into its own right 60/ 70 years ago, although it emerged around 130 years ago. It can be argued criminology emerged when the criminal justice system began to be questioned and the concern over identifying differences between criminals and non-offenders (Garland, 1994). There are various theories on criminology; those that will be discussed are theoretical explanations of crime and punishment, inspection and surveillance, criminal typing, and the normal and pathological. Systems of punishments in the 17th and 18th centuries were bloody and cruel because they were based on retribution or revenge.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyday more and more people are turning to small crime to make ends meet or just survive. This brings his discussion to the main point- how often overcriminalization occurs. He describes overcriminalization as convicting criminals who have committed nonviolent crimes in prison sentences that will damage the rest of their futures. He stresses that he realizes that any form of crime is still unacceptable but wants the readers to understand how unfair the judicial system can be. People who are committing these minute crimes would surely like to put it behind them and move their way back up in society, our incarceration system won't allow that to happen.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Edwin Sutherland was seen as the most important criminologists from the Chicago School (Cartwright, 2011, p.159). Influenced by Shaw and McKay, Sutherland established the differential association theory; which later influenced other criminologists and sociologists to introduce other theories (Cartwright, 2011, p.155). Sutherland, as well as others, explored white-collar criminality, and while investigating this, he came up with differential association theory (which later lead to social learning theory). His differential association theory is based off the idea all aspects of criminal behaviour are learnt (Cartwright, 2011, p.156).…

    • 1213 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Criminology, the “academic discipline that uses the scientific methods to study the nature, extent, cause and control of criminal justice (Siegel, 2013)” is a field that has been in existence since crime could be studied and tested. For years, researchers have been examining crime and coming up with theories in regard to criminal activities. These theories set to explain the possible reasons behind a person’s participation in criminal activities. There have been many theories that have been developed over the years regarding criminology and the purpose of this paper is to discuss certain popular criminological theories and to apply them to real-life scenarios. The theories that will be discussed in this paper are Robert Merton’s theory of Social…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Biological Positivism Case Study

    • 2092 Words
    • 9 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited

    1 Color Photograph, 1 Chart. Newburn, T (2007) Criminology. Cullompton: Willan Publishing.…

    • 2092 Words
    • 9 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Criminogenic Environment

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Introduction The purpose of this briefing is to explore the topic of Criminogenic…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this published book, Agnew provides the substructure of integration into just one cumulated position by assessing the ways of the postulations themselves, unlike anterior other criminologists that have failed or just didn’t get proximate enough to prove its subsisting function. Instead, Agnew takes a inversion approach in which organizing his book around theories, he organizes it around the key scopes of analysis, which are the definition of malefaction, free will or determinism, human nature, view of society and the nature of authenticity. Along each quantification Agnew endeavors to assess the contributions of each theoretical position to the rounded overall amalgamated theory. He is meticulous to include both mainstream and critical criminology’s…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this view the government could be said to have ‘tunnel vision’ as they only focused upon the idea of looking into how to make prisons cost less and not look at the negative affects it was having upon those incarcerated. The government look over the ‘bigger’ issues such as not having enough beds and not having enough police officers in prisons. With this in mind, Jock Young argues for the lack of the criminological imagination. He argues that criminology has become ‘Americanized.’…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1. Why does America have so much “nonsense” and “irrationality” in our criminal justice programs and policies? What is the role of public opinion, the media, social movements, political initiative, and science in America’s criminal justice policy-making process? Most crime control policies/programs within today’s criminal justice system are irrational; not all, but most crime control ideas are based on belief(s) rather than facts and data.…

    • 1598 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Repercussions Of Crimes

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This week’s readings introduced many aspects of crime that touch closer to home. Many students may be reading this same textbook, though I expect that we relate to these topics differently, some grasp our attention more and others, standing to be more significant to our lives and fears. This week we were introduced to the economic repercussions of crimes along with the fear of knowing that some serial murders are so cunning that they simply seem to disappear. The reason many types of physical crimes are more feared for some individuals is the simple fact that it takes work to earn the things they chose to purchase.…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Additionally, it pursues to ‘dissolve conventional understandings and accepted boundaries’ (Ferrell, Hayward and Young, 2008: 5), suggesting it challenges what is deemed as ‘normal’, unlike other criminological theories such as administrative criminology. Cultural criminology is overtly critical of administrative criminology for several reasons. Firstly, administrative criminology refutes and discards the significance of lived experience and culture in relation to crime, offering a ‘pseudo-scientific’ account of the behaviour of criminals (Presdee, 2004: 276). This directly contradicts what cultural criminologists signify, as this is the most important factor in the explanation of crime, and are heavily critical of the intense focus on scientific interpretations. Additionally, administrative criminology relies heavily on the use of statistics, which leads Presdee (2004: 276) to state that the Home Office Research Unit is a ‘fact factory’, making administrative criminology unable to explain crime and criminality, with theories lacking description.…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Summary Criminology studies the reasoning and factors as to why individuals engage in criminal activities. In classical criminology, social philosophers Cesare Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham developed a theory of crime that criminologist and theorist still use today (Akers 2017). In classical criminology, an individual commits a crime by making a rational decision. That decision is based off of whether the benefits that one might receive by offending outweighs the consequences such as being caught and cited or sentenced. Individuals base their decision to offend or not offend on what they have seen others suffer, their knowledge of what consequences they may endure and their own personal experiences.…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Society has made bounds of progress over the past century developing criminological theories to help explain criminality, deviance, and conformity. A good theory provides a foundational lens for one to interpret and understand why a crime is committed. These theories seek to uncover more than what researchers have discovered in the past in order to understand every aspect of why a crime occurs. This research paper will evaluate five different theories; social disorganization, anomie, general strain, cultural deviance and labeling theory, presenting the theorist(s), theory premise, strengths and weaknesses and an analysis of how each theory has played a part in making me the person I am today. Ancient Roman Philosopher, Marcus Aurelius…

    • 1771 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In this essay I will reflect on the few assumptions and understandings I had about crime and see how they have changed. Upon arriving at De Montfort University to study Criminology and Criminal Justice, I had average knowledge about crime and punishment i.e. insight into biological and psychological perspectives of crime having studied A-level Law and Psychology beforehand. However I did expect to delve so deep into the history and other aspects of Criminology during this first semester. During A-level Law I have read many case studies of murder, manslaughter, GBH, rape etc. I found the main reasons behind committing these crimes were usually motives for revenge, loss of control, hate, rage, and biological inheritance of 'criminal genes ' such as Monoamine oxidase A which makes individuals more prone to exert violence.…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Criminal behavior helps contrive summaries on the issue of social phenomenon on transnational to international crime. .Reichel (2013) stated “Similarly, because the phenomenon of transnational crime propels much of today’s multinational cooperation, it behooves comparative criminal justice to understand transnational crime and criminals” (p. 25). The studying of crime as a social phenomenon provides a better understanding by comparing countries through the years to pinpoint developed trends. The study of crime as a social behavior provides the knowledge of where and why crime began and where it…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays