Greed And Grievance: A Diversary Argumentative Analysis

Superior Essays
Greed and Grievance – a complementary approach

While many scholars dealing with the academic or policy implication of this debate align themselves with either the greed or grievance camp, others believe that it is the combination of the two that has the biggest explanatory power when it comes to exploring the motives behind intra-state conflict. As highlighted by Murshed and Tadjoeddin (2007: 24), “grievances can be present without greed, but it is difficult to sustain greedy motives without some grievance. Although greed and grievance are regarded as competing views, they may be complimentary, as greed may lead to grievance and vice versa.” Those theorists that argue for the combination of both greed and grievance point out that sometimes
…show more content…
Private motivation is most often based on the economic factors surrounding one’s life. Thus, in some instances the economic factor of motivation towards violence can be seen as the overriding incentive. Seemingly in line with Collier and Hoeffler’s model, war offers opportunities of employment and loot-seeking benefits. War can give birth to shadow economies which provide the combatants and insurgencies with monetary proceeds from the illegal exploitation and trade of natural resources that flourishes in instances of conflict due to lack of regulation. The competition for resources in turn fuels the violence even more resulting in the prolonging of the conflict. A classic example of such economic motivation can be seen in the civil wars in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Sierra Leone, and Angola where ‘blood diamonds’ played an immense role in sustaining the conflict as profits from the illegal sale of these resources were used to purchase more arms (Beswick & Jackson 2011). Moreover, when one looks at the case of Afghanistan, it is apparent that the Taliban uses the illegal drug trade (mainly the opium export) as a route for profit. The group safeguards drug producers in return for protection fees and acts as a middleman in order to funnel the produce into the …show more content…
Often, after a nation had acquired independence only a single group or a faction of that group is able to gain power and in turn has the means to subjugate the other groups to their will while getting all the benefits of state power —''public employment, other public spending, and resource rents'' (Murshed and Tadjoeddin 2007: 29)—for themselves (see the cases of Burundi and Rwanda). Weak social contracts are also grounded in resource scarcity (especially in countries like Afghanistan, Somalia and Sudan), pre-colonial ethnic rivalries over territory, and the failure of these states to strengthen mechanisms of political representation. Hegre et al. (2001) highlight that greater state capacity could lower the risk of conflict in well established democracies and autocracies. The highest risk of conflict initiation happens during political transition deviating to or from democracy, and in imperfect democracies, or anocracies. It should also be noted that internal factors that lead to intra-state conflict often interact with external events, such as the Cold War, which supply the ruling elite and rebels with financial and ideological support. These processes result in the build up of grievances in the context of state favouritism and a failing social contract which ''would

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In his examination of security threats and violence in Africa, Mangala (2010:88) defines conflict as a ‘dispute or incompatibility between two or more opposing sides... It becomes a destructive force where the capacity to mediate incompatible interests breaks down and those interests are pursued through violence, either at a community, national, or international level’. One of the most prevalent forms of violent conflict in Africa affecting states and civilians are civil wars. Collier & Hoeffler (2004:565) define civil wars as ‘an internal conflict with at least 1,000 combat-related deaths per year’. The greed vs grievance debate examines factors within these categories which drive civil wars.…

    • 447 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    History has always prevailed itself by showing people fighting over territorial sanctions, ideas revolving around politics as well as the simplicity of faith itself. It’s these motions ad violence that affect us as humans. It greatly impacts the ideology of political and economical interest to society today, a pursuit that radicalizes a forth coming of how wars will leave a rationalized foot print in history to come. Through wars one is able to assert their dominance and through that one is able to force ideas and beliefs. To some, war represents a rational pursuit to gain economic interests, while for others it remains an irrational destruction of property and futures to others.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Prologue Our world is corrupt. People are slaughtered in their houses. People crowd the streets looking for food. People starve every day from food shortages, while the state hordes more than they can eat. This is the result of civil war.…

    • 186 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The continual sale of diamonds is what keeps the war in Sierra Leone going. The issue that Campbell identifies, is that “all those who have ever coveted this wealth- government regimes, smugglers, lovers, merchants -- have historically never cared where they found or under what conditions they were extracted so long as they could turn a profit” (Campbell, 12). If the mentality of both peoples and companies remains the same, then the profit will only continue to grow, and the inhumane treatment, mass murder and overall disregard to human life will not stop. A major part of the issue is the fact that the majority of people are unaware of the conditions in which the diamonds they buy are mined. Campbell mentions that this has only recently been brought to light for the public diamond consumers (Campbell, 13).…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Theoretically speaking, it could be that circumstances like Horizontal inequalities where the prevailing regime plot to keep resource-rich underdeveloped communities or regions marginalised; and that these same condition also create other domestic pressures – economic, socio-political, or increased tension of another nature – which result in heightened risk of conflict. Assuming the two events are causally linked, there is no reason why causality should run in only one direction. For example, just as resource dependence could create conflict; it may be that conflict leads to greater natural resource dependency (Ibid). Taking a longer outlook, there are several examples in history of countries which flourished as a result of natural resource exploitation, without suffering violent conflict (Namibia and South Africa etc), thus, posing more fundamental questions about the appropriateness of this type of quantitative analysis of conflict by the works of Collier & Hoeffler.…

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Robert H. Bates’ book “Prosperity and Violence: The Political Economy of Development” takes an in-depth look at how the two factors of either prosperity or violence work hand in hand in the development of the modern world. The different political structures of today have all come about because of prosperity and violence in different phases of each nation’s development taking it from the near egalitarian agricultural societies of the ancient world to the more modern nation-states that fill the earth on every coast. Bates does an excellent job of thoroughly covering the subject and frames his argument in a way that it is easy to read and understand his points. However one aspect that is not addressed at all is the almost inevitable transition…

    • 1696 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sophocles’ Antigone frames a central conflict between Antigone and Kreon, two characters who have differing loyalties. Antigone is most loyal to her family; in fact, it is the question of whether her brother deserves burial rights that drives the play. Kreon, on the other hand, believes that loyalty to one’s city should take priority over loyalty to one’s family. A modern equivalent to this ideological dispute is the debate about whether the United States federal government is ethically justified in intervening in both foreign and domestic affairs. Kreon would support any action that directly benefits his state, whereas Antigone would be more concerned with the people who would be affected by the intervention.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “State failure” means “the implosion of the state” according to Bates’ article State Failure. State failure is characterized by two major processes: First, “governmental predation” which means that those in power in the state abuse their position to exploit resources from others, who lake power rather then to provide security for them. Second, the state loses its monopoly of the means of force, which leads to a militarization of society. The author then addresses three contributing factors of state failures: economy, ethnicity and democracy.…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social Organized Crime Perspective CJA-325 Jamel Scott Most persons consider organized crime as expansive, multi-faceted and integrated within the societies in which it exists. While this is largely true, Tilly (1985) also reveals how organized crime arises in the same fashion as state-makers and its predecessor war-makers do. Accordingly, Manwaring’s (2007) contentions about organized crime as threats to national or transnational stability are valid. Yet, the ways that organized crime does this differs from the methods engaged by rebels or groups of disenchanted and disenfranchised people without access to protection from governments or justice through redress. Rather, organized crime groups form complex organizations mirroring…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Opium Brides Analysis

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages

    A short documentary “Opium Brides,” reported by Najibullah Quraishi in the PBS Frontline, analyses and describes the ongoing problems caused by opium in Afghanistan. This video with its source of interviewing Afghan people is describing the reality of an unfortunate disaster in that part of the world. Questions about how their problem started in the first place, causes made by it, and some other sad, unspoken problems that people are suffering about opium. People in Afghanistan because of their financial situation, start borrowing loans from drug traffickers. According to the interviewed people, the average money they get for a loan is twenty thousand dollars, and instead, “they start growing a crop of opium poppies to pay those people back.”…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Walter in “The Critical Barrier to Civil War Settlement” tries to explain why civil wars are never ended with a peaceful settlement and fought until one side beats the other. This is because there are problems of enforcement and vulnerability; both sides prefer to fight instead of cooperate because it leaves them vulnerable (Walter compares this exchange with the Prisoner’s Dilemma situation). Unlike interstate wars, making cheating not favorable is difficult; either side cannot withhold resources or build military defenses without triggering a response from the other side and there is no neutral force or government to enforce peace. According to Walter, there are two ways to solve this issue: design power-sharing institutions involving both…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Darfur Crisis Essay

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Darfur crisis was the first case of genocide in the twenty-first century. The killings of the Darfur crisis began in 2003, and it was carried out by a government-funded Arab Militias called the Janjaweed. The Janjaweed burned villages, murdered, raped, and tortured the civilians of Darfur. A total of 480,000 people were killed and over 2.8 million people were displaced. In 2004 the United States declared the Darfur crisis was an act of genocide.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Furthermore, a consequent result of these varied interests and international pressures mean that decisions on troop allowance for peacebuilding missions are decided mostly by selfish interest, rather than by what is actually needed in the relevant state. This can be seen in Sierra Leone, as initially developed countries did not supply any troops to the UNAMSIL mission, as the “financial and social burdens” appeared to high (Evoe, 2008, p86). This resulted in a largely “underequipped” UNAMSIL and ECOMOG force prior to British military intervention, which as Pickering explains consequently “failed to pose a credible threat to the RUF” (2009, p26). In the case of Sierra Leone, various forces were present to try and enforce peace on the increasing…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ‘The Banality of “Ethnic War”’ aims to debate the all against all theory of ethnic conflict. Within this piece, Mueller argues that ethnic war, in the sense of the Hobbesian theory, does not exist, and this generalized theory represents non-ethnic conflict (p.42). Mueller’s article provided several strengths, which makes the piece of literature a thorough yet interesting analysis of ethnic conflict. Mueller uses the cases of Yugoslavia and Rwanda to explore how ethnicity mobilizing device, played a role in the construction of the appropriate conditions, needed to conduct this particular form of violence (p.43). First, Mueller highlights another perspective by another analyst, Robert Kaplan.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Realism And The Cold War

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The idea that ‘states coexist in a competitive arena’ (Waltz 1995) is proved to be exceedingly accurate when regarding wars throughout history. The Cold War for example shows clearly a fight between states (the US and the USSR) to be the hegemon of the international community after the introduction of nuclear weapons threatened the balance of power. Arguably still this was a fight not just for physical security but for the security of ideals, in the eyes of the U.S if “commy” ideology spread then this would pose a threat not only to national security but to their sovereignty also. The Cold War however is viewed to be controversial between Liberalists and Realists. From a liberal perspective the fact that the Cold War ended through peaceful means without conflict proves that war is not inevitable and that diplomatic means and groups such as the UN can ensure peace.…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays