Existential Crisis In Lia Lee

Great Essays
For Hmong who maintain their traditional beliefs in America, the scientific worldview and Western medicine, have challenged their entire means of understanding the world. Likewise, Hmong beliefs have done the same to Western medical practice. In the story of Lia Lee, her treatment via her doctors seemed to be none the same as her parents’ perception of illness, yet there lies two crucial ideas in common. Foremost, they both wanted to heal Lia. Secondly, each party was forced to understand an “existential crisis” like Lia Lee’s sickness. In these moments both Lia Lee’s parents and her pediatricians began questioning their cosmological systems and rituals. Both sides created chaos and needed to understand the cosmos in sickness and health while …show more content…
His theory provides a paradigmatic solution to an existential crisis. In the case of Lia Lee, it is not just that the Lee’s did not understand the words of the doctors. Their religion, and hence the way that they see the world, did not have the conceptual framework to understand Western medical practice. Just as non-religious man does not always understand religious man’s cosmology. Lia Lee’s family struggled to negotiate a balance between the demands of their traditional beliefs and modern medicine. Lia’s parents and her doctors wanted the best for her, but their central ideas of what caused her illness and how to treat it could not have been more different. To the Lees, Lia’s seizures were both terrifying medical emergencies but also signs of spiritual connections. This dichotomy created tension between the Lees’ concern for the safety of their daughter and the belief that her seizures would provide her with a life of honor and the possibility of becoming a shaman. Lia 's soul had fled her body and become lost. But, also we learn that the Lee’s were unfamiliar with Western terminology associated with illness when doctors said, “an electrochemical storm inside Lia’s head had been stirred up by the misfiring of aberrant brain cells,” and caused her seizures (Fadiman, page 28). Both cosmological systems were correct …show more content…
The hospital to the Lees was not a sacred space, rather a place where someone goes to die. Fadiman states that Foua Lee wonders if things would have been different in Laos (Fadiman, page 258). The administration of medicine to Lia was supposed to become “ritual.” But, this wasn’t the creation of sacred time through ritual and myth to the Lees; rather it was procedural clock work. Many things were missed during her time at the hospital. The therapeutic myth was never actualized and used by Lia’s doctors, only medical procedure. As seen by the Hmong, Lia Lee was sick from being out of balance and there was no one spiritually to re-orient her. This nostalgia was never recovered when myth was never applied. There was a sense of wholly unbalance as the therapeutic triangle was missing the crucial interaction between the healer (doctor) and the community (Lia’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “The Spirit Catches You And You Fall Down” is a story about a girl named Lia Lee who was diagnosed with epilepsy at a young age. There are multiple struggles in this book with cultural divide between the Hmong and the American medical systems. Lia and her parents, Foua Yang and Nao Kao Lee, were refugees that had immigrated to the United States. Foua and Nao were very religious, and lived by the Hmong culture. Shortly after moving to California they had learned that Lia had epilepsy, and other upper respiratory infections.…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lia’s seizure disorder along with cultural and language barriers ended with Lia not receiving the care she rightfully deserved. Firstly, Arthur Klienman suggests that ‘compliance’ should not be used. Compliance suggests cooperation, and “it’s a lousy term.” He states that colloquy will work better for the Lia Lee’s parents and medical personel, which is a conversational exchange.…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When asked to speak on the reasoning behind Lia Lee’s parents’ culture and opinion towards traditional medical practices, the California doctors stated that, “men think it is divine merely because they don’t understand it.” (Fadiman, 29) The doctors that cared for Lia believed that the scientific reasoning and diagnosis in Lia’s case was rational and therefore the answer to her problems, while ignoring any other worldviews. This outlook on the human condition diminishes the role of sacred space and the cosmic sense of nature’s ability to heal. Additionally, Eliade describes this thinking as, “the desacralization of the cosmos accomplished by scientific thought.”…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He not only created a beautiful memoir, but he showed how you can form a subtle, yet powerful life changing event. When Da Chen was young, he lived in southern communist China, 1962. In his childhood Da’s family was mistreated in many ways. But until one faithful day, he would have no idea about how his family was mistreated, or why his mother wouldn’t let him play outside. After this…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fadiman in her novel included an anecdote that reveals the secret to prevent the formation of a dichotomy of medical foreigncy, either be it the foreigncy of a doctor 's medical diagnosis or the foreigncy of a patient background. According to ethnographer Conquergood, who at the time was working at a refugee camp in Ban Vinai, “considered his relationship with the Hmong to be a form of barter and invigorating dialogue, with neither side dominating.” He stated that Western practitioners failed with foreign patients due to doctors believing they held all knowledge rather than viewing the relationship as mutual learning. I completely agree with Conquergood 's philosophy and the means of viewing the medical practice as a cultural compromise that requires an interactive exchange of information. Similar to the means that patients in Ban Vinai perhaps felt more confident and willing to conform to Western medicine with Conquergood’s presence, my own mother resonates with such an experience.…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Cultural Competence 101 The medical biographic novel” The spirit catches you and you fall down,” by Anne Fadiman is a magnificent time capsule of the experiences faced by the Hmong peoples during their migration to America. However amusing the novel was from a literary standpoint, the novel described many deeply discerning attributes of the American health care system and Social Work arena of that time period. Although this novel describes the journey of one peoples immigration to America this story really speaks to the experiences of many migrate populations to the United States.…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Spirit Catches You

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ethnocentrism, which is the belief that your culture or point of view is superior to others, is very essential and needs to be broken down. Fadiman significantly contributes and establishes a relationship with medical pluralism and cultural competence. Fadiman states that “to most of the doctors, the Hmong taboos against the basic tools of modern medicine such as: blood tests, spinal taps, surgery, anesthesia, and autopsies seemed like self-defeating ignorance. They had no way of knowing that a Hmong might regard these taboos as the sacred guardians of his identity” (Fadiman 2012,…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay On Hmong Culture

    • 2194 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The cultural clashes amongst the people of the Hmong and Westered based society of America about health care is a clash of ideologies and ethnocentrism. A refusal to find middle ground and a general misunderstanding of each other’s cultures. Each of these culture’s healing arts, be that biomedicine of America or the traditional healings of the Hmong, are working remedies that tackle the problems faced by healers and doctors with a unique understanding of one’s culture. Through the Hmong it is a spiritual and a truly holistic understanding of the body, while the American biomedicine divides things into parts, like a car. These two systems while approaching the same field with different understandings, can have similar results.…

    • 2194 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Foua Yang Reflection

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Foua Yang, Lia’s mother is an intricate character formed by the trials she has faced in her life and her rich culture. All of this attributed to the way she cares deeply for Lia and remains faithful to her Hmong culture. Our personalities are similar in many ways, so if I were to be the social worker of this case I feel as though I could relate and gain trust from Foua in order to better care for Lia and respect the Hmong culture in the process. Lia’s mom, Foua and I have a lot in common as far as what we are passionate about, but are very different in life experience.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The book, The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven, by Sherman Alexie is about a native tribe who go through a lot of difficult things but somehow manage to get through it all. They fight through it all and they preserve their culture. To them, family is the most important as well as their traditions. This book has a lot of interesting topics, such as, how spirituality plays an important role in the novel. They also explain how many of them have been destroyed by drinking and doing drugs at a young age.…

    • 2493 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down explores the relationship between the Hmong culture and the American culture; in particular the differences in medicine. Medicine has been a difficult subject to understand and master; moreover it becomes almost impossible if the person was raised in an entirely different culture than that of western medicine. This book discusses what it was like from both sides; the Hmong and those of the western doctors what it is like to deal with each other when it involves a common interest. That common interest being Lia Lee, an epileptic Hmong child. Both of the parties cared for Lia Lee; however their cultural differences were enough to distract from the real goal.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Movie Wit

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It is also important to explain the patient’s current state to them and include them in decisions so they feel as if they have some control over the situation. If all the decisions are made for them and a strong physician patient relationship fails to develop, the patient’s rate of survival is not only lower but their mental state is greatly effected. In order to have a successful practice, not only for the physician but also the patient, it is crucial to incorporate the themes of Wit into one’s everyday life and become familiar the dilemmas that are bound to occur in a health care profession. By using the story of Vivian Bearing and those who cared for her as a guide, we can create a health care system that not only works toward the interests of the patient but also the physician, resulting in a well rounded method of…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mayan Healing

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Blockages in the human body channels were thought to be the cause of illnesses and the result of evil doings or evil spirit. They believed that illnesses and physical and mental sickness were caused by supernatural forces and magic and religion were used to treat ill people. The Egyptian priest-physician Sekhmet had several important duties such as: discovering the nature of the illness and then attacking or destroying that entity. Magic in rituals, spells, incantations, talismans and amulets were commonly used throughout this process. Egyptian healers developed surgery and surgeons used basic surgical tools such as pincers, forceps, spoons, saws, hooks and knives.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anne Fadiman’s book The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, tells the story of the clashing of cultures between the Hmong culture and Western culture through the lens of medicine. Fadiman’s plot revolves around Lia, a Hmong girl born with severe epilepsy, and the tales of Hmong culture, allowing the reader to understand the actions of Lia and other Hmong, like her parents, as their culture heavily influences their beings. Thus I propose that this book remain a summer reading requirement as the book contains a unique correlation of culture and medicine, the themes are straightforward to analyze and provides a gradual preparation for the incoming year. The book itself consists of an interesting format, switching back and forth between plot…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Paradigms “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions” introduced Thomas Kuhn’s paradigm theory. Paradigms describe the scientific observations of a natural phenomenon or theory (Kuhn 2012, 41). Thomas Kuhn’s “Structure of Scientific Revolutions,” provides a philosophical look into the scientific process and an understanding of how theories change and progress over time. Paradigms help explain theories, concepts, and observations so they can be learned from (Kuhn 2012, 43).…

    • 1582 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics