Revolutionary Movement Analysis

Superior Essays
The history of revolutionary movements is one of interactions between the ideas of old and new: monarchy vs republicanism, and slavery vs freedom. This conflict of ideas and interests was not exclusive to one event or one revolution. Across the broader Atlantic world, this clash played out countless times in the American colonies, Haiti, Spanish America, and the Caribbean. To fully appreciate the interconnectedness of how the American Revolution also led to the Haitian Revolution, it is crucial to look at the period from a broad context which examines the content of arguments for freedom rather than focusing on nationalities and differences in achieving the end goal. Although revolutionaries in America and Haiti differed greatly in ethnic background, …show more content…
Both the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of Haiti formed a new government which had a clear and broad directive to use power in the public interest. Further, each document delineated the rights of citizens to equality and freedom, expressly forbid titles of nobility and privilege, and ensured that executive power was vested by the governed and not through inheritance. Each of these specific points highlight some of the most common grievances shared by colonists and the enslaved throughout the Atlantic world. However, the Haitian Constitution goes further by also implying direct equality, abolishing slavery in totality, establishing an elected monarch, and militarily administered regions. Again, this reflects that while American and Haitian revolutionaries shared the common goal of overthrowing the yoke of empire, demographic and economic realities drove how final outcomes were …show more content…
In both revolutions, decisions regarding political messaging, strategy, and diplomacy, were made with the realization that the rest of the world was watching. This not only reinforces the interconnectedness of the American and Haitian Revolutions, but also helps account for the complex network of alliances and political associations which largely defined success for both. After examining the political associations and rivalries which made American and Haitian independence possible, it becomes clear that imperial struggles evolved into imperial civil war, which ultimately became a global imperial war as European powers vied for dominance in trade and military power. The American Revolution, which began as a colonial revolt, gained legitimacy through this process, and eventually reignited the longstanding British/French rivalry. Due to this re-ignition of imperial rivalry, the American Colonies were able to incentivize French support, which ultimately helped tire the British and win the war. The Haitian Revolution followed a similar trajectory, but saw much more competition from Britain, Spain, and France than occurred during the American Revolution. This intense competition was due to San Domingue’s status as one of the wealthiest plantation colonies in the New

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Why Did The Creoles Lead The Fight? The creoles were said to have lead the revolution due to their power difference and how they did not belong with either group of people. The creoles had many reasons to start the revolution for their own causes and the causes of others. They were treated as both Americano and European and were trapped between the middle class and the upper class.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wim Klooster’s Revolutions in the Atlantic World: A Comparative History is a book that revolutionizes the connections between four major revolutions of the Atlantic World. Instead of examining strictly one revolution and comparing to another, Klooster utilizes both primary and secondary sources to compare and connect the four revolutions: “British North America (1775-1783), France (1789-1799), Saint-Domingue (1791-1804), and Spanish America (1810-1824).” Klooster’s work can be viewed at the most-updated perspective that historians hold towards the global impact of the American Revolution. A critical methodology used by Klooster in his research is the constant comparison of his own work to that of R. R. Palmer’s The Age of the Democratic Revolution.…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From the beginning of the revolutionary period and beyond, Colonial America would take its first steps to becoming the independent nation it is today. Many of the longstanding traditions can be traced to actions done by the people of that time. In order to explore the American Revolution, Jacksonian Democracy, and the events in between, this paper will begin with the French and Indian war. The French and Indian war began in 1754 due to frontier conflicts between France and Britain.…

    • 2244 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Out of Our Past: The Forces That Shaped Modern America” Carl Degler analyzes how the basis of the American Revolution which inspired multiple other revolutions globally was political and not economical. Degler wrote the Article to inform and persuade his audience that the American Revolution was politically driven by backing up his claim with credible evidence. The thesis of the Article is “This was no heedless, impetuous overthrow of an oppressor; rather it was a slowly germinating determination on the part of Americans to counter and thwart a change in their hitherto established and accepted ways of governing” (95). This expresses how the Revolution developed slowly as the colonies started to find themselves an there own entity politically and that it wasn’t directly related to the treatment they received from Britain economically including taxation,…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Haitian literature is posited around three codes of positive reference: indigenism, magical realism, and Marxism[3]. Essentially, these three references show how Haiti’s grim environment held a powerful presence in literature. The destructive nature of Haiti’s government towards its people can be seen in the titles of works of literature as well as the creativity of their respective authors. It can be noted that the titles of published works of literature held a double meaning for most. In French, it may be considered funny, but in Haiti, it was usually a local saying about the governments harsh reality towards its citizen.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Congress of Vienna addressed the disruption that Napoleon had caused in Europe, and placed orders in order to have Europe redistributed based on the lands that Napoleon conquered. The Haitian Revolution was truly changed after the revolt, due to the fact that they stayed true to their goals and freed the slaves who were still under the possession of their plantation owners. They also redistributed land which was much different from the American and French Revolutions considering the fact that the white property owning males were no longer at the top of the social…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Haiti and Latin America share many similarities including their revolutions. The Haitian and Mexican revolutions are moderately similar in that they fought for independence with multiple leaders, slavery was abolished in both; however, Haiti experienced debt and Mexico resulted in little social change. One of the main causes of both The Haitian and Mexican revolutions was independence. In both places there was slavery and an unequal social system. Many groups of people were treated unfairly.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The American Revolution was caused by much more than the simple concept of no taxation without representation; its roots can be found dozens of years prior, in 1763 and the years that followed, as well as back to the early history of colonial North America. Two authors and historians, Colin Calloway, who wrote The Scratch of a Pen: 1763 and the Transformation of North America, and Eric Foner, who authored Give Me Liberty! an American History, offer two comprehensive viewpoints into the origins of the American Revolution and a historical analysis of how the events and conflicts which took place during the time periods influenced the Revolution’s arrival. Colin Calloway’s The Scratch of a Pen begins in the year of 1763, with Calloway defining…

    • 1401 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Apush Dbq

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The movement for independence arose in the colonies as a desperate and defensive strategy to grab the reins of a young nation. The United States of America is not only improving the growth of democracy but also in its economic prosperity and the immensity of its later impact on the course of world history. Nations come into being in many ways, but this prosperous nation emerged from Thirteen little, fortunate colonies. That birth included civil strife, acts of heroism, acts of treachery, class conflict, disputes between the imperialist British Empire and the Thirteen Colonies. The ingredients of discontent seemed lacking — at least at the beginning because the colonies were not in a state of economic crisis; on the contrary, they were relatively…

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    American Revolution Dbq

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages

    By 1798 the Haitian have won their freedom. The revolt was a marvelous success because people came to together to fight for freedom and…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the late 1700s and early 1800s, revolutionary spirit was everywhere. The world was shocked at the success of the American Revolution, in which the oppressed colonies gained independence from Britain. This success, along with several other causes, motivated the oppressed lower class of France to have their own revolution. Shortly after the French Revolution, Haiti, a French colony, was inspired by the same ideals and had one of their own. The French Revolution and the Haitian Revolution are very similar in the ideals that drove them, the way they were carried out, and the things they achieved both through the revolutions themselves and their legacies today.…

    • 1432 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (Shen 1). The Haitian Revolution is looked at in this book as poetry and the author develops memories of Haiti’s leaders and how they are affected in maroons. As mentioned above, The Flight to Freedom helps readers understand that the Haitian Revolution created a huge impact for marronage and Robert explains in his book that Toussiant L’Ouverture had a great deal when he delivered his letter to the directory about the revolutionary force in 1791 about marronage. In the chapter “Sovereign Marronage and It’s Others”, Roberts lets us know that Toussaint's idea of freedom and marronage is the same as the Haitian Revolution. “Toussaint has been the singular figure often described as synonymous with the Haitian Revolution, and his idea of freedom is memorialized as the only one espoused by its revolutionaries” (Robert 255).…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Haiti was French colony and Latin America was spanish but independence was paramount in both and changed these areas forever. The outcomes of independence movements in Haiti and the Spanish Americas were similar because they both ended successfully and with independence from the colonizing nation, a difference however was that in Haiti the revolution ended with a complete social overhaul and the re-arrangement of social classes whereas in the Latin American revolutions it ended as mostly the same as before. Another difference is that Latin America ended up with a dictator under Simon Bolivar, whereas Haiti constructed a new government with the predominantly black population in office. Overall the outcomes of independence movement in Haiti and the Spanish Americas were more different than…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    December 18, 2014 Charles Hunter Day History 110 Final Paper Under imperial rule by the British, colonists in America were being smothered. Their basic human rights weren’t being met and they were forced to bow down to a government that ruled from across the Atlantic Ocean. The American Revolution gave the United States an opportunity to create a nation the likes of which had never been seen before. Through radical changes in the government, the citizens of the newly formed United States of America were able to become more free than they could have ever dreamed.…

    • 2672 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the eyes of the masters, the Haitian Revolution will harm the wealthy because the slave labor is the reason for their wealth. Their dependence on slaves to labor in the fields, build ships, and perform a horde of other subsidized labors is absolute. France uses the United States refusal to abandon its stance on slavery to do the same with its…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays