Compare And Contrast Plymouth Colony And Jamestown Colonies

Improved Essays
During the colonial era England strove to cash in on the riches being found and exported from the "new world." In an effort to do this, the Jamestowne and Plymouth colonies would be formed. Though these colonies were similar in some ways they were largely different.
Economically, Jamestowne was the most profitable of the two colonies even though
Jamestowne did not always return a profit to England. Because the Virginia Company thought the new world would contain an abundance of gold and silver, the majority of the crew on the
Jamestowne colonist ships were gold miners, jewelry smiths, and noble in nature. The
Jamestowne colonists were disappointed to find out there was a lack of gold and silver. These colonists would struggle to survive their first winter primarily as a result of these nobles feeling that they were of to high of stature to perform peasant work like building and farming. Though many of them brought their servants, and while some were of a working class, they did not make up for the vast amount of settlers that were unfit for the task at hand, leaving them unprepared for a harsh North American winter. This led to nearly half of the colonists dying that in the winter due as a result of cold and starvation. To the colonists, their chances seemed bleak, and they feared that they too would end up dying in this new land. In fact, in the next year many more would die from the same causes. Their saving grace came forth when John Rolfe traded to obtain a specific type of tobacco plant. The tobacco plants flourished in the soil around Jamestowne and would finally bring a profit to the struggling colony. In part this was due the increasing popularity with Englishmen who smoked it more recreationally; allowing tobacco to rise 3 pence a pound. For a short time it would make many colonists in Jamestowne wealthy, unfortunately, it would also bring about severe class divisions that would later impact the colony. Unlike the Jamestowne colony, the Plymouth colony was established primarily as a religious community allowing these colonists to practice the religion of their choice. The bulk of Plymouth's economy came from farming, hunting, and fishing. The men of the village would hunt and skin deer hides to use as clothing - trading both back in England and with the local native tribes. Plymouth colonists also traded corn, and far more with the local natives than did Jamestowne colonists. As a result of these positive trading experiences, the Plymouth colonists would invite the local natives to a celebration of both the success of their corps as well as the overall success of the colony in what would be eventually be termed the first Thanksgiving. The politics of Jamestowne is all over the place. When the colonists first landed they had harsh encounters with the natives, causing them to fight constantly. These relations did not much improve over the colonists' lifetime, as the Indians
…show more content…
The goal of the trade agreement was two-fold: not only would this help Jamestowne get trade items it needed, it also created a barrier between Jamestowne and the more aggressive Indian villages. One of the prominent colonist, Nathaniel Bacon, was unfortunately opposed to the trade agreement. Bacon believed that the only way of protecting the colony was to eliminate the local Indians with force or enslave them. Though Barkeley denied Bacon's request to do this, Bacon rallied an army of colonists and proceeded with his plan. After raiding
Indian village, Bacon would rally enough support to kick Barkeley out of control and become the new governor. This was coup was short lived due to Bacon's tragic early death, after which
Berkeley would again take control of the colony.
As opposed to the Jamestowne colony, the Plymouth colony developed a list of rules and rights beforelanding which would dictate how the colony would be set up and run. This set of rules and right, where named by the colonists the "Mayflower Compact." With the Mayflower
Compact in place, Plymouth was able to stay organized and had few governing problems.
Furthermore, Plymouth had much better relations with the local Indian tribes. Instead of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Even the local Indians living inside the colonies were losing the trust and were deemed enemies by…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    2. Compare the Indian uprising in Virginia in 1622 with Bacon's Rebellion in 1675. What were the consequences of each for Virginia's economic and social development? Upon reading all of the questions and trying to figure out which one that I would chose, I decided to go with the second question.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The colonists of Jamestown grew tired of having to obey a distant government that did not understand their needs. Although they were content at first to merely ignore the commands of the London Company, the tension between the colonists and the royal government was steadily increasing. Sir William Berkeley, the governor appointed by England, was despised by the colonists for making his fortune off of their hard work and refusing to cooperate with them. When Indians raided a part of the colony, Berkeley refused to give the colonists permission to counterattack. This was the last straw for the infuriated colonists.…

    • 154 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the 17th century, many English men and women were unhappy with the lives they were living in their home country. As a result, the people voyaged to the new world in search of religious freedom, glory and wealth. Early settlers chose to build their lives in different ways; two of the first colonies that arose in the new world were Plymouth and Chesapeake Bay. Plymouth and Chesapeake were alike in their forms of government, both used a representative approach that embodied the people. Both colonies relied heavily on slave labor to grow their economies.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bacon’s rebellion was a fortified fight that was known to eventually lead to the use of slaves instead of indentured servants. Two declarations were written by each man, arguing their side of the story and stating what would be done if the other did not submit. In the two passages, both men mention his Majesty, they were attempting to be in the Crown’s favor. By carefully examining Governor Berkley’s Declaration and Nathaniel Bacon’s declaration it is seen that Nathaniel Bacon throws many accusations at Gov. Berkeley, Gov. Berkeley responds with a list of reasons for his actions, and that behind the scenes both men are trying selfishly to grow their own wealth. First, Nathaniel Bacon immediately started throwing accusations at Governor Berkeley.…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Power of Poverty I, Walter Hind, a Catholic captive of the English as a result of the Wars of Three Kingdoms, arrived in the colony of Virginia as an Irish servant in 1660. I was ordered to work as an indentured servant for a certain Mrs. Hannah Aston for a period of six years. With the decline of the economic power of Virginia, the favoritism shown towards wealthy landowners and the elite, and the injustice shown towards indentured servants such as me by making us work more years or pay huge fines to the already wealthy, I argue that joining Mr. Nathaniel Bacon in his efforts to rebel against the economy, the colony 's security and the prejudice of race and religion . First of all, the economy faced a lot of situations…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nathaniel Bacon led one of the most memorable uprisings in history. As a 29-year-old, he led a thousand Virginians to rebel against Virginia Governor William Berkeley. There were many tensions that led to the rebellion, many people who were included in the rebellion, and a few long term consequences of the rebellion’s failure. During the 17th century, many new settlers and indentured servants came to Virginia, which eventually caused tension between white freed men, indentured servants, and the government.…

    • 657 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the mid 17th century, your status depended on the being Christian. Influence from Europeans formed the racist ideals of the British American colonies. During the beginning of slavery in the British American colonies, strict religious ideals were formed to determine legal status, as the colonies became more advanced and the need of slaves increased, ideals began to become based on race. Other Europeans formed this idea that your legal status is determined by your race. “Legal status was based increasingly upon skin color and physical appearance (Jacqueline Jones, Created Equal (excerpts) page 9).”…

    • 225 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It was one of the very first rebellions ever to take place following the English colonization of North America. A rebellion that would pave the way for shocking repercussions in the formation of our history as a country and a people: Bacon’s Rebellion. In this paper I will be explaining who Nathaniel Bacon was, what exactly he did, why Nathaniel did this, and most importantly the results of his actions. The story begins on January 2nd, 1647 at Friston Hall, in the small region of Suffolk, England.…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the institution of slavery grew, with the start of John Punch’s lifetime servitude, the dynamic of indentured servants to slavery changed drastically. Between 1640 and 1662, slave-owners started to demand for more legislation making lifelong servitude the common contract for all incoming Africans. In 1660, children born would take the legal status of their mother. Children born to slaves would be considered slaves, a condition slaves did not face in West Africa. Slowly, the differences between slavery in West Africa and Americas started to be more apparent and the treatment in Americas was far more hostile.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On the other hand, Jamestown and Plymouth had quite a bit of things that were different from each other for example, their reason to leave England, and the amount of people who came on each voyage. Nevertheless both contributed greatly to present American heritage of law, custom, government, religion, and heritage. Therefore Jamestown and Plymouth were very important to modern America, and we wouldn’t be where we are today without these two…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    William Bacon's Rebellion

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Pages

    There were many free, poor, landless, single men upset by the shortage of money, land, work ,and women. This caused Nathaniel Bacon to lead several thousand men that were effected by this in a rebellion against the harsh conditions. The people were indignant of William Berkeley, Virginia's governor, friendly policies towards the Indians. Nathaniel Bacon's men brutally attacked the Indian settlements after William Berkeley declined to counterattack for a series of bloodthirsty Indian attacks on the border. In the middle of all this, William Bacon suddenly died of disease.…

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So Bacon and his small army confronted the House Of Bugasses. When they were denied, they burned Jamestown to the ground. Then the government couldn't stand it and they have Bacon control. The public had many different clashing opinions based off of this rebellion.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jamestown Events

    • 1466 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The United States is known for its lengthy history and historical development as the country dealt with revolutions, wars, slavery, and other significant events. However, there are ten events that are truly significant to America’s history and development. The first event would be the creation of Jamestown. Jamestown was created in 1605 when two groups of merchants who had formed joint stock companies that combined the investments of small shareholders, petitioned King James I for the right to colonize Virginia. Jamestown became the first permanent English settlement in the New World and has then been celebrated as the “birthplace of America”.…

    • 1466 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By 1750, three main countries emerged as imperial powers in the New World: Spain, England, and France. As with most European countries, in the 15th Century, they had learned about the riches of Asia from the Crusades, in which soldiers journeyed to the Middle East to reclaim Jerusalem. The land road to Asia was generally dangerous and expensive, but the European desire for fine goods caused a race to find another route to that continent. Ships from Spain, England, and France sailed westward in search for the Northwest Passage, and though the Europeans were unable to expand their riches with trade, they were able to expand their riches through conquering civilizations in the Americas. Mercantilism was the dominating economic idea of the time,…

    • 1058 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays