A & B & C. V Ireland Case Study

Improved Essays
Case Brief
Parties : A, B & C v Ireland

Facts : The three women in question in this case ( A,B & C ) each wanted to get an abortion in Ireland for different reasons. Each of these women had obtained an abortion abroad but had suffered complications after the procedure. A did not want to keep her baby as she had already had 4 children who were not in her custody and in foster care so she did not see herself capable of caring for another child, she had also suffered problems with alcoholism and depression. B had become pregnant after the morning after pill had failed to work. She was certain that she was unfit to look after the child at that time in her life. She had been informed that there was a risk she could have an ectopic pregnancy (which she did not ) and got an abortion. C had suffered from cancer and was advised that it was hard to predict the affect that the pregnancy would have on the cancer. She had unintentionally become pregnant when the cancer went into remission. It was only discovered she was pregnant during a series of check-ups for cancer. She was advised that the chemotherapy treatment would greatly danger the foetus in the first trimester. She had developed fear that her treatment would greatly danger the baby’s life or that the pregnancy would provide a huge risk to her life. C was the only one of the three applicants that was successful in this case as A and B’s claims were dismissed. Procedural History : First began as an application by A, B & C against Ireland in the European Human Rights Court under Article 34 of the Convention for Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. The application was then allocated to the Third Section of the Court. The Chamber relinquished their jurisdiction to the Grand Chamber on July 7th 2009. A hearing took place in the Human Rights Building, Strasbourg on December 9th 2009. Issue Presented : Whether the State of Ireland had breached Articles 2, 3, 8 and 14 of the European Convention of Human Rights in regards to applicants A, B and C ? Holding : No – In regards to A and B, the Court did not believe that there was any breach of the Articles in question and found the application inadmissible. Yes – The Court that the State had breached Article 8 of the Convention in relation to applicant C but subsequently no other Article of the Convention had been breached by the State in relation to applicant C. Rule of Law : With regards to applicant A and B no violation of Article 8 of the Convention had been found in their case as it was believed that a fair balance had been struck between the State and both applicants as they could lawfully travel abroad to obtain the abortion and post procedure they would have medical information
…show more content…
They presented the issue as they believed to be in this case in court that the right to life of the foetus can be balanced against the right to life of the mother and this would be the case in most European States under the consensus as [ the right to life of the mother and in some countries her well being would outweigh the right to life of the unborn foetus ]. This case, noted in the dissenting opinions was the first time the court had disregarded the existence of the European consensus due to the Irish people having profound moral views. These Six judges had strongly disagreed with the Courts decision to disregard the European consensus which is rare in the Courts case law as it had shifted the focus of the case away from the core issue. They argued that the consensus exists and that it gives a greater precedence to the life of the mother over the life of the foetus. The dissenting judges saw this disregard for the consensus as “a real and dangerous new departure in the Court’s case law”. Judges Lopez Guerra and Casadevall noted in their concurring opinions that the Court had failed to take into account the personal suffering of applicants A and B due to the restrictive abortion laws of the State

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In the majority opinion, it is written, “Men and women of good conscience can disagree…about the profound moral and spiritual implications of terminating a pregnancy, even in its earliest stage. Some of us as individuals find abortion offensive to our most basic principles of morality, but that cannot control our decision. Our obligation is to define the liberty of all, not to mandate our own moral…

    • 1496 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The factors limiting her choice were religious and legal, and it is important to consider her right to autonomy. These three factors are all present in the ongoing debate about the morality of abortion. The case study is interesting in the context of the abortion debate because it describes a horrible tragedy that many people would use to justify abortion. Because the child was the product of violent trauma, and a danger to the mental health of the mother, pro-choice people might argue that abortion is a good option in this situation.…

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion has been a controversial topic throughout the world for many years. Whether the support or lack of it is due to morals, religious beliefs, health concerns, and many other factors, there are split sides on this big decision. Is it considered murder? Is it a right women should have and should be able to decide themselves on without being criticized? Should abortion be legal or illegal, and whose rights is it interfering with?…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    What would happened if the Roe v. Wade reverse? Would you be against it or would you approve it? The roe v wade was a case decided in 1973 by the United States Supreme Court. This decision legalized abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy. The decision of the roe v wade was written by Justice Harry Blackmun and based on the residual right of privacy, which struck down dozens of state antiabortion statutes.…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    She presents the view that the right of the mother to her bodily integrity carries greater value than the right to life of the fetus. She presents very convincing cases in instances where the pregnancy is due to violence – through rape or abuse, and a somewhat weaker argument that applies to unwanted pregnancies that occur even though reasonable precautions had been…

    • 1880 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 1 Works Cited
    Brilliant Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Pro Life Vs Pro Choice

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Abortion is one of the most controversial and hotly debated topics of this day and age. The reason for this surrounds the idea of whether the induced expulsion of the fetus is murder or rather in the interest of the mother. Pro-life activists debate that all life in the instant of its conception is innocent and deserves a chance at life. God chooses its time of life and death, not the mother. Pro-choice followers often argue in favor of science and the United States Constitutional Ninth Amendment, which holds freedom of choice sacred.…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Flaws of Abortion The controversy continues to cause a divide between pro-life and pro-choice on the topic of abortion after the US Supreme Court’s decision in 1973 in the case of Roe v. Wade. Pro-choice believes that abortion should be a right with no limitations. They also believe that the rights installed in the Declaration of Independence cannot be claimed for an unborn child.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Title Abortion has been a well-versed debate for as long as anyone can remember. It has been a lengthy fight because no matter what, everyone is going to have his or her own opinions and views that are bound to clash with others’. The controversy of abortion has grown quite large over the years, and with this growth, an increase in violence and protests has tagged along for the ride. THESIS…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion is an extremely discussed topic in our contemporary country with many different opinions and reasoning. “Legal Abortion Can Be a Lifeline” is an argumentative article written by President of the National Organization for Women, Terry O’Neill. The subject of this article is that O’Neill believes that abortion can be a “lifeline”, meaning it can actually save or better the lives of many couples and women alone. “Legal Abortion Can Be a Lifeline” was published by U.S. News & World Report LP on the website www.usnews.com from the U.S News Debate Club on January 22, 2013. She claims that “legal abortion can be a lifeline,” and I have mixed feelings about it.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion Rights Essay

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Abortion Rights American society is divided over the issue of abortion, the induced termination of a pregnancy. The American people are split between the facts of whether or not the government has an obligation to protect unborn children. Two extremes define people’s stance on abortion: pro-life and pro-choice, the belief that women should not terminate pregnancies and that women have the rights to decide, respectively. This is an essential argument because individual rights are the foundation of American culture. Medical dangers, the origin of human life, and women’s rights all support individual choice; therefore, the American government has no responsibility, moral or legal, to condemn abortion.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    So the fetus has a right to life. No doubt the mother has a right to decide what shall happen in and to her body; everyone would grant that. But surely a person’s right to life is stronger and more stringent than the mother’s right to decide what happens in and to her body, and so outweighs it. So the fetus may not be killed; an abortion may not be performed.” The remainder of her paper is a series of analogies meant to challenge the basic argument mention above.…

    • 1953 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The case was in court for approximately 2 years, and finally a decision was made. The court was in favor of Jane Roe, with a 7-2 vote. The justices voted that taking away a woman’s right to have an abortion was a violation of the ninth and 14th amendments. But the practice of abortion was restricted during the third trimester of a pregnancy. As soon as this ruling was determined, an opposition was emerged.…

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I.Introduction The topic of abortion is currently one of the most controversial issues. The 1973 supreme court ruling of Roe v. Wade allowed for women to legally obtain abortions throughout their entire pregnancy, however, conditions were put into place that allowed for states to regulate abortions during the second and third trimesters of pregnancy. The right to have an abortion is protected under the constitution’s 14th amendment which protects the basic rights of citizens. This ruling has left our country divided in half by those who are for and against abortion. Those who oppose Roe v. Wade are referred to as pro-life and those in agreement are pro-choice.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1973, the case Roe v. Wade made a huge impact on the future of abortion. The Supreme Court made a historic decision and sanctioned a person’s right to choose whether they want to terminate an unwelcome pregnancy. Women were since allowed to make the decision of whether they wanted an abortion during the beginning of a pregnancy. If a woman waits till a later date, there are restrictions on abortion policies. During the…

    • 2242 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics is a systematic and critical analysis of morality, of the moral factors that guide human conduct in a particular society or practice and it plays a significant role in today’s society (Office of Director General, 2005). Different types of ethics can be applied to various issues to decide whether it is morally right or wrong. The focus of this report will be the ethical issue of abortion. The issue of abortion is an ongoing debate asking whether it is morally right to terminate a pregnancy; some think abortion is always wrong; whereas, others think that there is a range of circumstance in which abortion is morally acceptable. The issue will be considered from the philosophical framework of Situation Ethics.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays